← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 281596315

164 posts 40 images /a/
Anonymous No.281596315 >>281596469 >>281596613 >>281596990 >>281596991 >>281597422 >>281598059 >>281598216 >>281598459 >>281599949 >>281603799 >>281603995 >>281604202 >>281604455 >>281604790 >>281604953 >>281605431 >>281608414 >>281610112 >>281610159 >>281610188 >>281610398 >>281610545 >>281610624 >>281612017 >>281613619 >>281613857 >>281615870 >>281624950 >>281626105 >>281627974 >>281628047 >>281629312 >>281629565
Serious Question: How do people enjoy power fantasy anime without feeling embarrassed?
>Imagine you are the most superpowerful good looking cool guy ever
>Imagine every threat is easily overpowered by your inherent genius and muscles and every dirty normie villager can only gawk at how godly you are compared to them
>Imagine every bodacious fantasy babe thinks you're the coolest guy ever and wants to bone you
>Imagine you don't have to put any work into making these relationships last because your harem of babes is happy just basking in your awesomeness and will never challenge you in any way
>Imagine you work your way up to a position of power and can make drastic lasting changes to the kingdom's political structure
>Imagine these ideas all being genius and you create the perfect society way better than any irl politician ever could because you played sims city
>Imagine just being perfect in every way without even having to try
>Also imagine that every bully or person you don't like has been reduced to a blubbering humiliated pissbaby that gets raped to death
I was out with some friends recently, and we all came to the same consensus that if any of us seriously tried to get into anime like this, it would make us all feel...well, sorry, there's no better way to say it, like losers. There's just something so deeply pathetic about it. How does anyone engage with this type of storytelling and feel good about themselves when they look in the mirror? How do you think that there's a good admirable person looking back at you? I can't wrap my head around it.
Anonymous No.281596469 >>281597230
>>281596315 (OP)
a power fantasy of the degree you describe can only work as a comedy for me, make it as ridiculous as possible and stuffs like that
Anonymous No.281596595 >>281601744
Why would enjoying a story of any kind make me feel bad about myself? I can't comprehend what would make you think this.
Anonymous No.281596613 >>281598191
>>281596315 (OP)
your post is a huge wall-of-text of fantasies where you orgasmically btfo somebody in your head. now just imagine your post. but in a comic, book or anime. that's a power fantasy.
Anonymous No.281596990 >>281601020 >>281609739
>>281596315 (OP)
You'll understand after your 16th birthday.
Anonymous No.281596991
>>281596315 (OP)
this is simultaneously one of the funniest and most fucked up images I have seen
Anonymous No.281597013 >>281601779
>retarded thread
>OP writes out his thoughts in the subject field like he's on reddit
Name a more iconic combination
Anonymous No.281597140
>normalfag tourist from X post number 9213145
Anonymous No.281597230
>>281596469
fippybippy
Anonymous No.281597422 >>281597750
>>281596315 (OP)
>I was out with some friends recently, and we all came to the same consensus that if any of us seriously tried to get into anime like this, it would make us all feel...well, sorry, there's no better way to say it, like losers.
And then everybody clapped and a bunch of bodacious babes commented on your good looks, making your girlfriend jealous and thus that night she was even more active in riding you above-average-sized cock
Anonymous No.281597750 >>281610623 >>281610824 >>281611440
>>281597422
Lol, I'm single bro. One of the friends I was talking to at lunch did recently get a girlfriend though. Which shocked us, since he's easily the nerdiest of the bunch. Unironic sheldon-but-in-real-life type guy in real life.
Anonymous No.281598059 >>281598164 >>281610936
>>281596315 (OP)
They aren't for you. They're for people who have been bullied, abused, or mistreated their entire lives.
Anonymous No.281598164 >>281598331 >>281598391 >>281612512 >>281614181 >>281622261 >>281622501 >>281622852
>>281598059
Why wouldn't knowing what it was like to be mistreated and abused make you want to be more compassionate and empathetic to others though?
Anonymous No.281598191
>>281596613
I'm not the OP but personally I think if someone is so far gone they don't instinctively cringe out of their skin reading narou-kei that there's nothing I can possibly do to hold their face to the fire and make them see reason.
Their perception is autistic and skewed. You can't argue with that. Not really, not in a way that would make them intuitively get it.
Anonymous No.281598216 >>281599839
>>281596315 (OP)
Why do people who watch romcoms want to eat babies? How can they live with themselves knowing that their dark hunger can only be sated by the flesh of the innocent? How do they sleep at night when every time they close their eyes they see the tiny brutalised remains of those they wish to devour?
Anonymous No.281598331 >>281603206
>>281598164
No, people with childhood trauma grow up fucked up in the head compared to the average population because their brain was nurtured to be wired completely differently during the peak neurplasticity years for interpersonal relationships and the understanding of one's own ego interaction with the outside world.
It's not a just world: people who suffered don't think
>I ws abused, thus I rationally understand that abuse causes suffering and don't want to perpetuate the cycle of hate
They think something like
>AAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaaaaIwantdodieIwanttofuckingdieAA
And just mask it well
Anonymous No.281598391 >>281603206
>>281598164
At the superego level yes.
At the id level you're fucked up and likely to perpetuate abuse yourself.
Anonymous No.281598401 >>281598457 >>281598461
It’s an East vs West, or white vs non-white thing. For us, the essential power fantasy is overcoming all adversity and becoming the strongest. For them, it’s about BEING the strongest. Also, we want the best women, and they want sex toys. That’s why Westerns like the basic concept of the isekai as a power fantasy, but get turned off by the execution.
Anonymous No.281598457 >>281598573
>>281598401
You're a fucking retard, every hero in Western folklore was born better and did heroic things because they were just superior by birth. The hero who becomes good by training (the underdog story) has less than a century of relevance
Anonymous No.281598459
>>281596315 (OP)
Well these stories are based off video games. It doesn't make sense to play a game poorly. Like if you watch someone play Super Mario Bros and they miss jumps and don't run fast it feels awful and dirty. You just want to take the controller away from them and ban them from ever playing again.
Anonymous No.281598461 >>281598528
>>281598401
There are western analogs for isekai though in the old stranger in a strange land pulp stories.
For example the Tarzan novels are really rooted in "Yeah well if I were transported to shithole Africa I'd basically be a god no fucking problems". Like literally Tarzan gets seen as a deity by the local niggers in the book.
Anonymous No.281598528
>>281598461
Western media is really targeted though. Last thing I watched was Walking Dead like 15 years ago and for an entire episode it was just some old lady talking to the audience as if it we were her husband. It was creepy as fuck in an evil and sadistic way.
Anonymous No.281598573 >>281598666
>>281598457
That’s the hero’s journey you stupid trash I specifically said “power fantasy” which is what this very thread is ABOUT.
Anonymous No.281598666 >>281598747 >>281599328
>>281598573
What do you think romcoms are if not power fantasy?
Anonymous No.281598747
>>281598666
shut up Satan
Anonymous No.281599328
>>281598666
>romcoms are power fantasy
There are no words that can capture how staggeringly baffling this statement is. This is absolutely bizarre. Where do you even start to make sense of this? I have to to assume you just want to win an argument and typed something you didn't think about in the slightest.
Anonymous No.281599839
>>281598216
nigga whut?
Anonymous No.281599949 >>281600050 >>281600149 >>281601012
>>281596315 (OP)
Do you have to constantly self insert as the main character in everything you are watching? That is peak midwit delsuion and misuse of your modest brain matter.
Anonymous No.281600050 >>281601632
>>281599949
That just makes it worse. Power fantasy has no tension to begin with. If you take out the fantasy there's nothing left.
Anonymous No.281600149 >>281626675
>>281599949
No, but it's kind of hard to ignore how blatantly self-inserty something is intended to be when the writing amounts to the author going "this is how perfect the world would be if I were in charge of everything" and the fan discussion consists of bitter schizos agreeing that the mc is a based alpha fuehrer chad.
Anonymous No.281601012 >>281601655 >>281608502
>>281599949
Ok. Let's assume people generally don't self-insert as generic, OP protagonists. Watching a guy with no personality, in the world's least imaginative fantasy setting, get a lot of pussy and crush his enemies without trying is still boring and pointless. Explain the appeal.
Anonymous No.281601020 >>281601632 >>281601655
>>281596990
But aren’t angsty teenagers more likely to love power fantasy heroes that give a middle finger to the world than adults?
Anonymous No.281601632 >>281601655
>>281600050
>>281601020
Reminds me of how /a/nons kept bragging about how raped healer was "a huge success with women" but then ratings tanked after the first episode/the post-nut clarity kicked in, because every femgooner that rubbed one out to the rosebudded psycho twink got bored and left.
Anonymous No.281601655
>>281601632
>>281601020
shit, meant to reply to >>281601012
Anonymous No.281601744 >>281602495
>>281596595
Yeah, the type of media you consume says nothing about your character, uh huh
Anonymous No.281601779
>>281597013
you could just move along and go join your ilk in those 1-2 word coomer threads
but nah, you just have to bitch
Anonymous No.281602495
>>281601744
no questions, only consoom
Anonymous No.281603206 >>281603840
>>281598331
>>281598391
The fact that OP and his like-minded faggots are still going after these two very salient responses should give you an idea of how much they actually care about this topic. They just want to punish others.
Anonymous No.281603799
>>281596315 (OP)
The only one I liked was Eminence in shadow because it was being ironic.
Anonymous No.281603840 >>281603917 >>281604636
>>281603206
>punish others
It's called tough love. A wake up call. Being treated like shit doesn't give you the right to treat others like shit. That's toddler mentality. Grow up.
Anonymous No.281603917
>>281603840
You continue to fail to give a valid response to their posts when we are talking about fiction, you subhuman.
Anonymous No.281603995
>>281596315 (OP)
read better power fantasy
Anonymous No.281604202 >>281604545 >>281605350
>>281596315 (OP)
This bait thread is relevant enough to my question
I unfortunately missed the last Penguin Classics thread. What Isekai would be most appropriate for this image?
Anonymous No.281604455
>>281596315 (OP)
It's easy when you're super cool and powerful in irl. They're literally you.
Anonymous No.281604545
>>281604202
Boku no Pico
Anonymous No.281604636
>>281603840
These abused people try to get help for their childhood trauma, but no one ever gives it to them. So they isolate themselves from the world.
Anonymous No.281604790
>>281596315 (OP)
any power fantasy feels good with enough eye candy action scenes and carthartic overkill finale where mc completely overpowers and destroys pure evil
the worst power fantasies are the ones where mc hides his power for the whole fucking show and only clowns on D-tier bullies
Anonymous No.281604953 >>281606966
>>281596315 (OP)
Your wall of text isn't any different from teenagers making fan fiction with mary sue self inserts.
Anonymous No.281605350
>>281604202
Konosuba
Anonymous No.281605431
>>281596315 (OP)
kek is this based off the weekly Chinese mass elementary school killings?
Anonymous No.281606966 >>281608294
>>281604953
>Your wall of text isn't any different from teenagers making fan fiction with mary sue self inserts.
But that's worthy of ridicule though, contrarian-kun
Anonymous No.281608294
>>281606966
What's with that
Anonymous No.281608414
>>281596315 (OP)
I love watching giant robot anime because I've been crippled with chronic pain and mental illness my whole life. I dont even leave my bed. I think the last thing I felt was a power fantasy that I watched was Eureka Seven because theh went through so much shit like killing all those innocent people and taking care of those kids. I just wish I could take care of someone like Ico and Yorha. Or someone could take care of me or I could have a real family and raise them so they dont need to watch absolute fucking shit like you described because they'd have a family too. There's nothing more freeing in an anime than seeing people fly. I just want to fly on a goddamn flying surfboard.

I love Ico so much man. You never know how much you miss holding hands until you've spent like decades alone.

I dont think this answered your question at all though. I just like robots and am not bitter.
Anonymous No.281608502 >>281608948 >>281609576
>>281601012
There's a pretty huge difference between, "This story is dull because it lacks tension," and "The tea leaves tell me that people who like this genre all all evil" or whatever nonsense you've imagined.
The appeal is that some of them are enjoyable. Some have interesting protagonists and worlds. Some make the character's power a side show to exploration, romance, or whatever else. As in any genre some are just bad.
Anonymous No.281608948 >>281609494
>>281608502
>everyone who likes this genre is evil
Pretty sure the OP just called these people pathetic, not evil. Not every loser becomes a school shooter, most are just annoying and sad but ultimately harmless.
Anonymous No.281609494 >>281610024
>>281608948
It wouldn't make any difference if he called them diabetic. The point is that it's complete nonsense and that insulting people who like a thing is entirely different from just not liking the thing.
Anonymous No.281609576 >>281609616
>>281608502
Interesting protagonist and world, aye? And these would be?
Anonymous No.281609608 >>281611403
What I don't get is the displacement of adventure and fantasy, in their most literal meanings. Officially sanctioned agencies that are "guilds", state-funded magical academies, predictable game-adjacent rulesets. Elves and dwarves and nekos that aren't even distinct enough to be considered different nationalities. Most of shitty stories aren't some autistic exploration of those ideas like "Hero, Dragon, Courier", and rarely an honest slice-of-life in a fantastical setting. Just incredibly sanitized worlds bereft of any real need for heroes. And so the heroes that arise in such dire times are anemic cowards, no different from the regular japanese high school student.
While is*kai is a subject of common mockery, the key problem is how the protagonist of such pulpy stories has largely stopped being a man of action. I do think "things just sorta happen around the hero" is an easier way to write a gorillion-volume-long ranobe. But pursuing a clear tangible goal is like the definition of "quest", you can't get away from that when everything else is so stuck in the trappings of fantasy. It's not as if shonen isn't full of teens rising up to the cruel and violent occasion.

>tl;dr
Go read "Monster Collection" I guess. It's short and sweet and perfect.
Anonymous No.281609616 >>281609657
>>281609576
>>>/wsr/
Anonymous No.281609657 >>281609679
>>281609616
This isn't a request, it's skepticism
Anonymous No.281609679 >>281609726
>>281609657
>requesting a list of good shows isn't a request
Be less retarded.
Anonymous No.281609726 >>281609777
>>281609679
My intentions were very clear, you autist. Unless you're being intentionally obtuse. In which case, stop being a word twisting faggot. How about that.
Anonymous No.281609739
>>281596990
More like you'll stop understanding after your 16th birthday, lol.
Anonymous No.281609777
>>281609726
Your intentions don't stop it being a request.
Anonymous No.281610024 >>281611118
>>281609494
since when is being nice and accepting and shit the default attitude, in this place no less? it is man's prerogative to make judgments, and "indulgent power fantasies appeal the most to aimless and pathetic people" is hardly unknown or untrue
if you wanna be pedantic, feel free to post "not all X are Y", but remember that real world is not about contrapositive proofs
Anonymous No.281610112 >>281610175
>>281596315 (OP)
ZOMG YOU JUST CANT ENJOY POWER FANTASY THATS HECKIN CHUD AND SEXIST DORKY AND NERDY... YOU HAVE TO BE A RETARDED GÖYSLAVE AND BE A TOUGH KEK, BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT BEING A MAN IS.
Anonymous No.281610159 >>281610175
>>281596315 (OP)
Holy shit, you need to feel good and intellectual even in the comfort of your room, because the invisible sissy friends are always judging your intellectualism when you don't spent your night reading shitty books. What a sad existence, you don’t live for yourself, you live for a constructed image that the normogroids built for you.
Anonymous No.281610175 >>281610245 >>281610398
>>281610112
>>281610159
Don't you have a year's worth of revenge cocks to take in the ass? Or an open sex window to nest on for 10 years at least?
Anonymous No.281610188
>>281596315 (OP)
>How do people enjoy power fantasy anime without feeling embarrassed?
I don't self insert like you, that way I can watch stuff you would consider based and also things you would consider cringe.
Anonymous No.281610227
Super power fantasy is not that bad if the mc is not strongest alone.
That's why something like solo levelling is despised so much but something like one piece is still accepted. The former is the mc strongest alone while the later the mc has friends to achieve being the strongest.
Anonymous No.281610245
>>281610175
You decide to shit on power fantasy anything because you are a retarded göyslave who will accept anything
You could watch anything else that catters your gay nigger sensibilities, but no, power fantasy has to be shat on because it reminds you are cück who most likely has fake friends, a non-virgin girlfriend and a slave condition (being employed)
In other words, I have more respect for escapist manchildren and extremists who wish to escape this system than I do for people like you
Anonymous No.281610398 >>281610433 >>281610477 >>281610667 >>281617059
>>281596315 (OP)
>>281610175
You are so deep into the irony opium addiction that you don't have a personality anymore, you have a status-symbol persona you protect from societal bullying by agreeing with the consensus. You can and will suddenly turn on something you used to love and trash it until you actually start hating it, just for that sweet whiff of crack known as "dopamine from being accepted by other normogroids."
Don't know why you are afraid of feeling like a "loser" when you already have Manchildren syndrome mixed with superiority complex. Your irony armor to shield yourself from criticism is basing your entire personality on the top-rated shit from MAL or pseudo-cult shit 3x3 to jerk off together with your friends, while shitting on people enjoying the things they like just because they know how to separate public self from private hobbies instead of fabricating a miserable, invisible persona profile in the comfort of their room.
I know you got destroyed, so feel free to reply with a random buzzword or ignore this post entirely.
Anonymous No.281610433 >>281610471
>>281610398
>I know you got destroyed
Holy kek, this is like adding fpbp or /thread to your own post. Me thinks you aren't as secure in yourself as you claim to be, my samefagging friend.
Anonymous No.281610471
>>281610433
>>"feel free to reply with a random buzzword"
>holy kek
>fpbp
>/thread
>samefagging
I will say one too
I accept your concession.
Anonymous No.281610477 >>281610495 >>281610672
>>281610398
Mald.
Anonymous No.281610495 >>281610504 >>281610672
>>281610477
Göyslave. Your friends are fake and your girlfriend is not a virgin
Anonymous No.281610504 >>281610535 >>281610672
>>281610495
Cope.
Anonymous No.281610535 >>281610550
>>281610504
Göyslaves love using words whose meaning they don't understand
Anonymous No.281610545
>>281596315 (OP)
It depends on what kind of isekai story it is.
I genuinely love overpowered characters and power fantasies, because they are relatable to me.
I am IRL a genius with 150 IQ and insane creativity and I am literally getting paid for solving problems only I can solve and constantly praised. Also people often praise me to heaven, saying things which are not humble at all.
I still watch anime sometimes when I have time or I am tired.

Characters I can totally relate to are Shiba Tatsuya or Monika the silent witch.
Because genuinely I too am a genius magician. Their story does not need to deal with them struggling to gain recognition or against obstacles, because it is a given that they will win.
Their struggle is with how they square having all that competence and status and yet they are actually still just human. No one really understands them despite all their success.
That I find totally relatable.

Then there are the slow life protagonists, to them I can not really relate because they have no drive and no passion.

Probably the worst offender you all are talking about is another world with my smartphone.
The protagonist just wins constantly and is successful and is rewarded for his efforts. It gets boring at some point but I don’t find it offensive at all.
Sure he is successful because of cheat skills given by God. But how does that change anything?
But let’s be real here, all my intelligence, my creativity, my capacity for hard work, my passion - those are all things that were given to me by God. They are products of circumstance, of nature and nurture. I added nothing to them.
So why should I look down on characters who have different inherent or given traits that make them powerful?
What is unrealistic and unrelatable is when the protagonist refuses to use them or when he is constantly holding back or it’s some kind of behe oh no I am cheating.
But the protagonist just winning constantly because he has the skills?
That is totally fine
Anonymous No.281610550 >>281610559 >>281610672
>>281610535
Sneethe.
Anonymous No.281610559 >>281610644 >>281610672
>>281610550
Ah yes /tv/queer references, power fantasy fiction owns you slave
Anonymous No.281610623
>>281597750
It's so fucking over for you. literally sub-5 male status. You will never breed so why shit on stories like this
Anonymous No.281610624
>>281596315 (OP)
So why don't you get off this forum of friendless "losers" and go hang out with your friends then, Norm? You must surely have better things to do.
Anonymous No.281610644
>>281610559
Yikes.
Anonymous No.281610667 >>281610753
>>281610398
>consensus
>accepted by other normogroids
>jerk off together with your friends
kinda weird approach to take considering seasonal garbage bins are full of stereotypes from OP, those are considered worthy of an adaptation for the masses
how is being a normalfag complaining about anime power fantasies different from being a weeaboo complaining about dearth of pantyshots? all this talk of irony and personas, as if every low powerlevel anime watcher merely pretends to like popular things how do you think shit gets popular in the first place?
Anonymous No.281610672 >>281610687
>>281610477
>>281610495
>>281610504
>>281610550
>>281610559
This isn't /pol/ or /v/ you fucking retards, and for that matter it isn't fucking 2019 anymore this cringe->cope->seethe->dilate soijak duel nonsense is old as fuck. Stop shitposting and go back.
Anonymous No.281610687 >>281610715 >>281610785
>>281610672
He literally asked for it. And now he's mad about it.
Anonymous No.281610715 >>281610736
>>281610687
I don't care who started it you fucking child.
Anonymous No.281610736
>>281610715
Ok boomer.
Anonymous No.281610753 >>281610846
>>281610667
>how do you think shit gets popular in the first place?
When you obtain the knowledge that 80% of the population are retarded, easily manipulated, and have no opinion of their own, just like cattle, you can see why Marvel movies sell millions, why dogshit modern music has billions of listens, etc.
Anonymous No.281610785
>>281610687
>And now he's mad about it.
I only made one reply after that post and it was not for your "Mald." tho
Anonymous No.281610824
>>281597750
Holy fucking over
Anonymous No.281610846 >>281610935
>>281610753
Are people who listen to Merzbow and watch film festival fare "intelligent" and "free-thinking"?
Anonymous No.281610931 >>281610953
4cuck is shit for unintelligent göyniggers
>durr hurr why are you here
Every other imageshitboard is dead and this amerinigger site is still alive
Anonymous No.281610935 >>281610941
>>281610846
If it’s something they enjoy and not something like
>yooh, this shit is popular frfr, let’s see the hype, must be good, I think it's shit though but it's popular so I will turn my brain off
or
>look how cult and highly rated this thing is. my friends say it’s good, but I think it’s shit, still gonna say it’s good tho
then yeah
Anonymous No.281610936 >>281610941 >>281611444 >>281612512
>>281598059
More like they’re for narcissists and social retards with victim complexes who think they’ve been abused and mistreated.
Anonymous No.281610941
>>281610935
>>281610936
Durr hurrr hurr durr, but also being a goyslave
Anonymous No.281610953
>>281610931
I am not going to use the /a/ on (defec)8, they added IDs.
Anonymous No.281611118 >>281612461
>>281610024
And yet you want people to blindly accept your faggotry without questioning it?
>indulgent power fantasies appeal the most to aimless and pathetic people
Total bullshit. They appeal to most people, which of course includes the aimless and pathetic. You have no evidence whatever for your claim, just a woefully misplaced sense of superiority.
Anonymous No.281611274
Highly entertaining by the very clear line between this thread somehow managing to stay relatively sane, and real schizo hours starting
Anonymous No.281611403 >>281611417
>>281609608
if you want an isekai that has that try:
dungeon keeper ami
otome survival
Living Loving Maid.
All of these have clear and obvious goals that the characters are invested in following
Anonymous No.281611417 >>281611444
>>281611403
Why are you recommending him anything
Anonymous No.281611440
>>281597750
Ngmi
Anonymous No.281611444 >>281612218 >>281612618
>>281610936
>um ackshully you where never bullied.
lmao
>>281611417
because jannys made it illegal to make a thread to discuss OC i like. Naturally if such a thread adjacent to it exists I will happily rec such good content without being asked.
Anonymous No.281612017
>>281596315 (OP)
If you said "male power fantasy" you'd make just as much sense and sound just as much like a tranny.
Anonymous No.281612218
>>281611444
If your avatarfaggotry is any indication, the bullying was entirely justified, and apparently did not go far enough.
Anonymous No.281612311 >>281612515
>talk about isekai
>NOOO DONT POST CUTE GIRLS IN VILLAINESS DRESSES THATS AVATARFAGGOTRY
Anonymous No.281612461 >>281613672
>>281611118
>no evidence
you need some mean opinion scores on anime so you can correlate them with the amount of self-attested bullying?
if you want to dismiss "people most invested in indulgent stories are the ones who lack that thing irl" as a baseless assumption, then be sure to follow up with proofs as to how exactly power fantasies "appeal to most people", since common wisdom ain't shit you do understand that "appeal the most to" doesn't contradict fantasies being appealing in general? it's a measure of quantity
oh and also average harem protag is an oblivious and indecisive doormat just because it's such a compelling archetype to follow, and not because it's easier to project into a character with no personality
Anonymous No.281612512
>>281598164
Most people who abuse children were themselves abused as a child.
>>281610936
So painfully obvious this poster is a woman it hurts
Anonymous No.281612515 >>281612575
>>281612311
>doesn't have the guts to reply like an honest shitposter
If you really aren't the autist who posts THOSE cute """girls""", and aren't just hiding behind plausible deniability, then sorry for friendly fire.
Anonymous No.281612575 >>281612704
>>281612515
frisk and chara are both female so I don't know why you are putting their gender in triple quotes
Anonymous No.281612618
>>281611444
>um ackshully you where never bullied.

correct
Anonymous No.281612704 >>281613042
>>281612575
>stopped attaching his pics as to not be so obvious
>still had to assert his headcanon
It's funny how often you hide being "anybody could post these pics, I am totally not obsessed" while bluntly insisting on a point nobody but you cares to argue about.
Anonymous No.281613042
>>281612704
>stopped attaching pictures!!!!
make up your mind
>anybody could be posting these images? phfff!
Considering I got every one of these images from someone posting them on this website.
Yes.jpg
Anonymous No.281613619
>>281596315 (OP)
Sounds like you're the shitty person here.
Anonymous No.281613672 >>281615274
>>281612461
I need something even slightly more substantial than some faggot saying "I reckon". Some actual line of reasoning at least.
And harem fags are oblivious and indecisive because that's how the author keeps their serialised fiction in perpetual status quo and thus publication. Almost no one is "projecting into" characters of any kind. It's not a normal way to appreciate fiction.
Anonymous No.281613775
When you constantly talk about how you don’t like “wish fulfillment power fantasies”, it’s not making everyone think that you’re powerful and your wishes are fulfilled and you’re so very validated; it just makes them think you prefer sob story powerlessness fantasies. Which easily describes cuckold porn.
Anonymous No.281613857 >>281614230
>>281596315 (OP)
Writting is not hard, but writting something good is.
Anonymous No.281614181
>>281598164
Because being mistreated and abused mostly just teaches you that mistreating and abusing others is how you get ahead in the world.
Anonymous No.281614230
>>281613857
>good writing means having subtext that I agree with
Anonymous No.281615274 >>281615837
>>281613672
reasoning is gravely simple: people seek catharsis they cannot obtain in reality through fiction
this extends to everyone and ideas that appeal specifically to them, which means some people are more suspectible than others
so a story of an aimless nobody rising up in status and power is more appealing to those who don't believe they can get any of it irl

>no one is "projecting into"
that is false
not strictly in the sense HE'S LITERALLY ME (though it does genuinely come up, believe it or not), it's just way more simple for a man to emphasize with his fellow man, which means your regular kirito possesses SOMETHING appealingly familiar, lest you would see more john carters
you can grandstand about your appreciation for characters as some vague fictional abstraction, but i am talking about an extension of "attractive characters are better" maxim
everyman protagonist is a staple of popular culture precisely because they are familiar to the common man, arguing against that is arguing against marketing psychologists, which is as close to "actual evidence" as you're gonna get
>but i don't self insert and enjoy all that nonsense for other reasons
good for you, but can you say the same for everybody? videogames and silent protagonists is probably the biggest wrench in that logic, but you could argue that it's different and doesn't count
Anonymous No.281615837 >>281616856
>>281615274
>people seek catharsis they cannot obtain in reality through fiction
But anime power fantasies feature things literally no-one can obtain in reality. And most others are things available for very few. So even accepting your premise the target demographic isn't total losers, it's anyone with less than three yachts.
>it's just way more simple for a man to emphasize with his fellow man
That's a hell of a long way from projecting into a character who is "literally me". I'm not claiming to enjoy characters as some sort of abstraction, but as imaginary people who aren't me. That I'm more likely to like someone (imaginary or not) similar to me does not make them me, and does not make me confuse them for me.
>videogames and silent protagonists
I would indeed say that's quite different because of the element of control. You're not merely experiencing the story but affecting it, often from a first person perspective. That does afford identifying with the protagonist directly. Though at least in my experience mostly in a physical sense rather than an emotional one: I'll lean away from projectiles, but not be upset if "my" friend dies, for instance.
Anonymous No.281615870
>>281596315 (OP)
>it would make us all feel...well, sorry, there's no better way to say it, like losers
>How does anyone engage with this type of storytelling and feel good about themselves when they look in the mirror

Because they are already losers? Duh?
Anonymous No.281616856 >>281618606
>>281615837
>target demographic
>relatability
>identifying with the protagonist directly
feel like we are getting into the vague technicalities of storytelling, so i'll just circle back to my very first reply and general sentiment
as a man, you are entitled to judging everything and anyone with speed and prejudice, tastes in anime included
what is exactly unfair or unusual about making harsh assumptions about strangers?
when i see a mushoku tensei thread, tell its residents how retarded it is that after a cross-continental adventure the main guy still goes to fucking school, and then get images of the 3 harem broads in reply; it's so easy to dismiss people who hold completely different priorities
i am not so arrogant as to say junkfood romcoms / battle harems / sfw fetish porn have no appeal nor merit, and everybody who ever enjoyed them is just a love-starved loner; but if that's primo shit in your opinion, then i am gonna extrapolate some very uncharitable things from that
Anonymous No.281617059
>>281610398
TRVTH NVKE
Anonymous No.281618289
I'd say OP hit the nail on the head with how defensive some of these anons are getting
Anonymous No.281618501 >>281620251
is this just another isekai complaint thread?
We've had four of them now.
Anonymous No.281618606
>>281616856
Vague technicalities? Isn't "identifying with the protagonist directly" precisely the crux of your argument?
And what's unfair or unusual about me judging you as a faggot looking for a reason to feel superior to others?
If you judge everything by the responses you get from 4chan threads then everything will look like retarded trash for losers. Never mind that you're basically going, "ure shit sux" and trying to pick a fight. You sound like far more of a petty little shithead from your story than those with the audacity to post images on an image board.
Anonymous No.281620251
>>281618501
Isekai may be the worst offender, but there are cringe revenge-complex power fantasies in other genres too.
Anonymous No.281622261
>>281598164
it can, and i've met many compassionate people who have been through abusive situations. however, the other anons are right that it can turn you into an abuser. it probably depends on the abused person having positive influences in their life that help them maintain their humanity through the abuse.
Anonymous No.281622501 >>281623784 >>281627187
>>281598164
Some people get abused and resolve to never hurt other people the way they did.
Some people get abused and resolve to make as many other people suffer like themselves as possible.

And it basically all just comes down to genetics. We're all slaves to circumstances beyond our control or perception.
Anonymous No.281622852
>>281598164
Anonymous No.281623784
>>281622501
Yeah, it's like how some people who are born lucky and attractive and stuff become solid guys while others become arrogant assholes. On some level, you were always going to be a bad egg, regardless of whether you are bullied or not.
Anonymous No.281624950 >>281625605
>>281596315 (OP)
Conan the Barbarian is a power fantasy without being anything like what you described.
In the end isekai, power fantasy, wish fulfillment, none of these are bad, what you are seeing is just a bunch of poorly written stories taking advantage of a fad.
Anonymous No.281625605 >>281628609
>>281624950
If this thread has shown me anything, it's that power fantasy as a term is surprisingly broad and can mean any number of things to different people.
Anonymous No.281626105 >>281626675
>>281596315 (OP)
Why are you self inserting? Just watch the show faggot.
Anonymous No.281626675 >>281626982
>>281626105
Did you not see >>281600149 ?
Anonymous No.281626982 >>281627435
>>281626675
Why would I bother reading what is a shitpost at a glance?
Anonymous No.281627187
>>281622501
>all genetics
I'd be careful with that. I don't think the research is conclusive yet.
Anonymous No.281627435 >>281627462
>>281626982
Not everything you disagree with is a shitpost, Retard
Anonymous No.281627462 >>281627763
>>281627435
I don't read posts that look like shitposts. You should do the same. Also stop being a self insert faggot.
Anonymous No.281627763 >>281627778
>>281627462
>hurp derp maybe if I say the retarded thing enough times it'll magically be true
That's what you look like gigafaggot
Anonymous No.281627778 >>281627872
>>281627763
See that's what a shitpost looks like, not reading it.
Anonymous No.281627872 >>281627925
>>281627778
I'm not sure what show you're trying stand for the honor of with this behavior, but i can guarantee it's dogshit.
Anonymous No.281627925 >>281628067
>>281627872
Self insert faggots? If you look at my first post, you can see I'm telling OP not to be a self insert faggot. Just watch the fucking show.
Anonymous No.281627974
>>281596315 (OP)
Damn, I hadn't seen that image in ages.
Anonymous No.281628047 >>281631040
>>281596315 (OP)
I wonder if part of it is just standards getting higher as more stories get churned out. It isn't enough to just be the hero who slays the dragon and gets the princess anymore. People hate it when MC's struggle and/or show weakness, they just want their self insert to be competent and strong from the beginning. The hero just getting with a single princess is "boring and bland" now, they want a harem bare minimum, full of powerful exotic women like Dragongirls, Elven Queens, Sword Masters, etc. The hero can't have the spotlight shining off him for even a minute, so every side character has to be either incompetent or a scapegoat villain designed to make the MC look like a moral paragon by comparison. And even then, the crazy part is that all of this is just a drop in the bucket compared to gacha games, which take all these tricks and amp them up tenfold to convince players to gamble on them.
Anonymous No.281628067 >>281628190
>>281627925
Tell me then, which one of these obviously self-inserty shows for people who desperately crave escapism magically becomes worthwhile by just tricking yourself into thinking it's not a self-insert show while watching it?
Anonymous No.281628190 >>281628322 >>281628470
>>281628067
Sounds like you may have some more important things to work on if you can't watch a show without self inserting. Just watch the fucking show and don't self insert like a faggot, it's that simple.
Anonymous No.281628322
>>281628190
Unfortunately the main character is literally me so I have to self insert, shikata ga nai.
Anonymous No.281628470 >>281628509
>>281628190
>not every hentai is made to be jerked off to. You're weird for thinking that. Just stop jerking off and watch the hentai
Anonymous No.281628509 >>281628620
>>281628470
You have to self insert to jerk off?
Anonymous No.281628609 >>281630723
>>281625605
It is a broad term just like how an extraterrestrial film can range from a friendly ET that befriends children to world conquering advanced extra terrestrials but also animalistic aliens that predate humans.
Anonymous No.281628620 >>281628666
>>281628509
Not even remotely what I said, but fuck it. You clearly have intention of arguing I good faith.
Anonymous No.281628666 >>281628881
>>281628620
Why are you responding to a post with something that nothing to do with that post then. The subject is why are you being an insufferable self insert faggot when you can just watch the show like a normal person. No one was talking about hentai.
Anonymous No.281628881 >>281629176
>>281628666
How in the fuck does a normal person watch one of these insipid ppwerfantasy shows then? If you're not self inserting, then they're fucking boring. THAT is what I'm trying to say. These shows are fucking boring and dogshit! and the only possible way I can even imagine someone enjoying them is if they're arrogant enough to imagine themselves as the perfect and idyllic mc because otherwise they offer nothing of actual substance.
Have I spoon fed this enough for you, you mind-boggling retarded Neanderthal?
Anonymous No.281629176 >>281629272
>>281628881
You can enjoy something without self inserting. Most of these series the cute girls are the entire reason to watch anyways.
Anonymous No.281629272
>>281629176
Fine, sure, whatever. Personally I think there are better sources of cute anime girl content, but fuck it. That's not something I feel like arguing. If you're willing to put up with shitty power fantasy writing purely for the cute anime girls, that's your prerogative.
Anonymous No.281629312
>>281596315 (OP)
They're called Chinese people, and they're not embarrassed that this is their sole form of entertainment in manhua
Anonymous No.281629565
>>281596315 (OP)
Fantasy?
Anonymous No.281629805 >>281630217
I wonder what makes a self insert story compelling. What does a story need to rise above the competing slop? It can't just be money and advertising.
Anonymous No.281630217
>>281629805
I've heard someone argue before that video games in general are self inserts, since you're directly controlling the character. I'm not sure i agree with this thought process though; I never imagined I was literally Mario afterall.
Anonymous No.281630723
>>281628609
Behold! A power fantasy!
Anonymous No.281631040
>>281628047
I've noticed this change in attitude too. I blame social media.