← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 281773067

33 posts 14 images /a/
Anonymous No.281773067 >>281773111 >>281773345 >>281774007 >>281774074 >>281774184 >>281776764 >>281777888 >>281783963
Holy fuck this is so good. Why doesn't /a/ like it? Awesome historical backdrop, great characters, amazing animation, a fun story, a great blend of action, drama, and comedy, and a very strange pseudo science that is believable.

It's like the perfect anime ever made.
Anonymous No.281773106
the author is b/a/sed
Anonymous No.281773111 >>281788726
>>281773067 (OP)
the main girl is ugly and a terrible waifu
Anonymous No.281773159 >>281776684 >>281785118 >>281785185
Should i watch the original anime or the remake? Or should i just read the manga?
Anonymous No.281773196 >>281773236 >>281785185
I tried watching it but it just felt slow and soulless. Maybe the original was the same way but my standards are higher now.
Anonymous No.281773236 >>281774123
>>281773196
>slow and souless
neither of these words mean anything. If anything, this show is filled with soul. Especially season 2 when they reintroduce the chibi comedy
Anonymous No.281773345
>>281773067 (OP)
>demake slop
>shonenshit
Anonymous No.281774007
>>281773067 (OP)
>remake a 90s anime but make it cheaper and worse
Embarrassing.
Anonymous No.281774074 >>281774231 >>281775002
>>281773067 (OP)
I liked the 90s one, didn't gave a shit about the remake, you can't even claim that it is more faithful to the manga now since season 2 changed a lot of shit for seemingly no reason
Anonymous No.281774123
>>281773236
>chibi comedy
Cringe
Anonymous No.281774184 >>281781102
>>281773067 (OP)
I forgot all about the remake. I remember there was a thread for 1 episode then nothing else.
Anonymous No.281774231
>>281774074
Anonymous No.281775002 >>281776789
>>281774074
>you can't even claim that it is more faithful to the manga now since season 2 changed a lot of shit for seemingly no reason
it made things way more coherent.
Anonymous No.281776684 >>281779400
>>281773159
It's a bit complicated, but you're probably best off sticking with the manga, then seeing the Kyoto arc of the 90's anime and the first OVA as companion pieces. The first anime was fantastic in the Kyoto arc, but was really uneven before that and got sucked into filler hell without ever adapting the last arc. The remake was better overall in its first season, but had some really dull direction and it took a few episodes to find itself. And the second season was pretty disappointing due to the weird liberties they took.
Anonymous No.281776764 >>281782590
>>281773067 (OP)
Japanese historical stuff is a real turn off for me
Anonymous No.281776789 >>281776866 >>281783569
>>281775002
Aoshi just somehow showing up on the Rengoku at the end and Shishio and Sojiro doing nothing about Sanosuke sinking his fancy boat was far from more coherent, and the rest of the subplots added nothing to it. In the new version the people of Kyoto fail to stop the fire from starting, but then it's put out two scenes later with no damage being done anyway.

I'd need to rewatch it, but although I remember some stuff with Shingetsu Village getting a few decent changes, overall the way they handled it was messy as hell. And I'm just now remembering that they inserted a story about Kenshin using the sakabato for the first time at a really awkward moment, and the story wasn't even nearly as interesting as the one with the doctor that they inserted into the first season.
Anonymous No.281776866 >>281777212
>>281776789
Aoshi joining Shishio on the ship made way more sense than him staying at the temple. He wants to find kenshin and knows kenshin is going to the ship. Makes perfect sense. It's a theme Sanosuke is underestimated. And both kenshin and saito were there. They couldn't turn their backs towards the other two. It was made clear.

Did you watch the show? They put it our until the bat guy dropped bombs, which he stopped because of the policeman. The additional scenes cleared up a lot of criticisms from the original.
Anonymous No.281777212 >>281777664
>>281776866
Aoshi shouldn't have known about the damn boat to begin with. Nobody would have told him, and he doesn't know or care about Shishio enough to be able to "predict his actions" the way Kenshin did. Kamatari didn't know about the thing.

And I'm not trying to be facetious when I say I have no idea what criticisms the remake was supposed to be addressing. There not being a big fight on the Rengoku didn't matter in the manga/90's anime because the final battles started three chapters/two episodes later, as opposed to the year-long gap the remake's had. Everyone managing to stop the fire from starting in the original was important because the heroes had been consistently losing since the start of the arc, and by turning it around and humiliating Shishio's forces it shows the heroes' growth before starting the final series of battles. In the remake, Misao can't get a single goddamn win and continues to look completely incompetent right before she's to be put in charge of defending the Aoiya.

But now I DO have complaints. Why were there more scenes with Cho, including one where Kamatari talks about him "not caring about morality," only for him to still not do anything? I thought they were building up to Cho helping that police captain to fight off henya and Kamatari, but instead that just sort of sputtered out. Kenshin and Aoshi's actual fight at Mt. Hiei will now have to be completely rewritten since Kenshin will now know going in that he can't just talk him to death. I'm willing to chalk it all up to "well, the season was set to end in an awkward spot and they tried to make it a decent climax," and stick around for the next season, but I've got a lot less optimism than I did going into the last two seasons.
Anonymous No.281777664
>>281777212
how dumb would an elite ninja spy have to be to not know about the boat when Shishio outright says it?
Anonymous No.281777888
>>281773067 (OP)
Because it's taking 3 slow, boring padded seasons to get to the part anyone even cares about that was already adapted 30 years ago and 5 seasons to get to the next part anyone cares about that hasn't already been adapted.
Anonymous No.281779400
>>281776684
>And the second season was pretty disappointing due to the weird liberties they took.
Such as? I dont remember anything different from the manga, qlthough I read it like 5 years ago.
Anonymous No.281781102
>>281774184
We had threads every single week. You just missed out.
Anonymous No.281781150 >>281781978
any news on the next season? I'm surprised they got to pump out 48 episodes in 2 years
Anonymous No.281781978
>>281781150
Nope. It will take some time since season 3 will be non-stop battles. Even if it's only 13 episodes, it will be heavier on animation than the previous 2 seasons.

But they started reairing all episodes so we should be getting some news in the next couple of months.
Anonymous No.281782590
>>281776764
American moment
Anonymous No.281783569
>>281776789
>Kenshin using the sakabato for the first time at a really awkward moment
That's literally where Watsuki placed it.
Anonymous No.281783963 >>281785197
>>281773067 (OP)
Is he in?
Anonymous No.281785118 >>281785519 >>281786959
>>281773159
Just watch the live action trilogy
Anonymous No.281785185
>>281773159
>>281773196
the first arc is genuinely bad, just throwing random ideas with no focus whatsoever
Anonymous No.281785197
>>281783963
Soon.
Anonymous No.281785519
>>281785118
this but unironically
the films are not groundbreaking kino, but they are pretty good either way
Anonymous No.281786959
>>281785118
It's a pentalogy.
Anonymous No.281788726
>>281773111
You are a faggot, that you are.