← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 283111516

111 posts 46 images /a/
Anonymous No.283111516 [Report] >>283111589 >>283111651 >>283111706 >>283111724 >>283111780 >>283111917 >>283111963 >>283113762 >>283114559 >>283114670 >>283115258 >>283115442 >>283115838 >>283118853 >>283122760 >>283122865 >>283124060 >>283126580 >>283129399
> nobody cares
Is it THE biggest fall from grace and relevancy in recent years?
Anonymous No.283111566 [Report] >>283114203
>no good animation for the IP who got famous because of the good animation
who was responsible for this?
Anonymous No.283111589 [Report] >>283111628
>>283111516 (OP)
Hype status?
Anonymous No.283111621 [Report] >>283114433
It's been a decade anon, time to move on.
Anonymous No.283111628 [Report] >>283120249 >>283121289
>>283111589
None.
Although Buki is cute in this season.
Anonymous No.283111651 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
Blue Lock was even worse
Anonymous No.283111706 [Report] >>283131461 >>283133418
>>283111516 (OP)
The story came to a reasonable emotional conclusion in the season 1 anime. The only reason for further material to exist is so I can fap to Tatsumaki and Fubuki. The story is like how everyone's always waiting for Goku, but worse, because all these wacky characters just exist to exist.
Anonymous No.283111724 [Report] >>283111750 >>283114156
>>283111516 (OP)
>kill all goodwill you have with animefags by selling out to a shit studio that cant do action
>kill all goodwill with manga fans by rewriting a long and highly anticipated arc into torturous fanficslop over the course of 4 years
It's the most deserved fall from grace and relevancy in recent years.
Anonymous No.283111750 [Report] >>283111924 >>283111955 >>283112103
>>283111724
How many rewrites of stuff did he do? I feel like it was at least four separate times.
Anonymous No.283111780 [Report] >>283111864 >>283112016
>>283111516 (OP)
everybody read the manga already and the arc is pure shit so what would there be to be hype about?
Anonymous No.283111794 [Report] >>283120249
I need Fubuki ass
Anonymous No.283111841 [Report] >>283113805
God even the promo art is low effort shit
Anonymous No.283111842 [Report]
I am more hyped for the new Mogudan art that this will motivate over the anime to be honest,famsempai
Anonymous No.283111860 [Report]
Did you hear? One Hurricane is alive!
Anonymous No.283111864 [Report] >>283112016
>>283111780
This. Even if it somehow had S1 animation, it would be in service of bringing pure shit to life. It was over long before it could have begun.
Anonymous No.283111917 [Report] >>283114575
>>283111516 (OP)
>CSM anime
>AoT ending
>MHA ending
I would OPMs fall off was tame in comparison
Anonymous No.283111924 [Report] >>283112016 >>283112103 >>283114325 >>283119274 >>283120218 >>283129358
>>283111750
I lost track long ago but plebbit has a list of retconned chapters
https://cubari.moe/read/gist/Z2lzdC9mdW5reWhpcHBvL2RkMTlkNjU3NjhjOGJlMTk3MTFmZTllMjAwNDVkOGY1L3Jhdy9vcG0tc2NyYXBwZWQuanNvbg/
If I remember right, anything listed before chapter 103 were just minor refinements to art or story, with a few exceptions like chapter 99/100. They were redrawn like 3 times for the first reason in 2018, the after picrel mindbroke Murata and the fanbase, the were redrawn again in like 2021, completely scrapping one of the most entertaining fights in the series and turning it to shit along with almost every chapter listed afterwards. After the garou arc finished I dropped the manga, but I heard what little came after also got redrawn

It's at the point where I genuinely do not actually know what to expect in season 3 despite reading the manga because the current state of the manga is so far divorced from what I actually read.
Anonymous No.283111955 [Report] >>283114325
>>283111750
Big ones were Phoenixman, Do-S, Orochi, and Saitama vs Garou. Either because of the sheer amount of time wasted on the redraws, or because of how much characters and events changed between versions.
Anonymous No.283111963 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
>Is it THE biggest fall from grace and relevancy in recent years?
Shingeki no Kyojin went down from the top of manga prestige in a ball of fire.
Anonymous No.283112016 [Report] >>283112103 >>283112129
>>283111780
>>283111864
>>283111924
I'm honestly of the opinion that an anime-original Season 3 might be a good course of action. I cannot see how JC Staff will adapt the second half of the MA Arc in a single season. If manga fans actively liked the manga changes, they shouldn't have any problem swallowing any anime changes.
Anonymous No.283112068 [Report] >>283122972
I can’t stop lusting for Fubuki
Anonymous No.283112103 [Report] >>283112803
>>283111750
>>283111924
Forgot to mention the redraws came in batches too. We might get a year of original chapters, only for the next 6 months to be spent redrawing the chapters expected to be released in the next upcoming volume, obviously leading to strange nonsequitur storytelling for lengthy periods
>>283112016
Problem is a blueprint for a good arc already exists in the webcomic, but if the anime decides to pivot in that direction, it would be too hard to justify pivoting back afterwards. And I dont trust JC staff to come up with an alternative story that will be much better than the manga's shit. But I dont care, id rather the series crash and burn with season 3 anyways knowing that everything that's happened was all for nothing anyways.
Anonymous No.283112129 [Report]
>>283112016
Nah, obviously, the best course of action is an anime-original Phoenix Man fight. Nothing can go wrong with that!
Anonymous No.283112803 [Report] >>283122889
>>283112103
>if
ALL you have to do is follow the webcomic. murata broke you...
Anonymous No.283113668 [Report] >>283120249 >>283123130
Will they ever...?
Anonymous No.283113733 [Report]
Post kusoga
Anonymous No.283113762 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
It's definitely one of the bigger falls. If the Murata manga still had its hype from those days, it could have sustained things but they've been pissing people off with its decisions lately
Anonymous No.283113805 [Report] >>283114503
>>283111841
Why are you lying?
Anonymous No.283114156 [Report] >>283114325 >>283115272
>>283111724
>4 years
Murata's Monster Association arc went on for 10 years.
Anonymous No.283114203 [Report] >>283114808 >>283121182 >>283122888 >>283122902 >>283123815
>>283111566
First season set an expectation that they never had any chance of ever reaching again
Anonymous No.283114325 [Report] >>283114767 >>283120848
>>283111924
>>283111955
>>283114156
I'm glad I only followed OPM as a casual fan watching the anime and not as a diehard fan, cannot imagine the mess that must be discussing the manga and the comparissons with the webcomic.
Anonymous No.283114388 [Report]
The situation surrounding OPM is just surreal. Nowadays every fucking battle manga adaption manages to have good animation, even steaming trash nobody cares about like Kaiju No.8 is handled by a high profile studio. But OPM, arguably one of the biggest anime in the world at one point, can't afford anything better than a embarrassing JC Staff slideshow? Just how far can incompetence go?
Anonymous No.283114433 [Report]
>>283111621
It's been how long?
Anonymous No.283114503 [Report]
>>283113805
cool preview movie
Anonymous No.283114526 [Report] >>283120249 >>283129415
Is Saitama gay?
Anonymous No.283114559 [Report] >>283114677
>>283111516 (OP)
> nobody cares
Anonymous No.283114575 [Report]
>>283111917
Except everyone cared about all of that and are constantly posting about them even now.
Anonymous No.283114670 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
>A third season

For what purpose? The second one didn't need to exist, the third one really doesn't either. This anime was one and done, always was.
Anonymous No.283114677 [Report]
>>283114559
it used to sell 400k week 1 lol, more than half of the readers gave up
Anonymous No.283114689 [Report]
saitama is for shortflat angry women
Anonymous No.283114767 [Report] >>283115272
>>283114325
Believe it or not the discussion wasn't that bad all things considered.
Anonymous No.283114808 [Report]
>>283114203
Garbage like kimetsu no yaiba has better animation
This is just producers being lazy
Anonymous No.283115115 [Report]
Anonymous No.283115258 [Report] >>283116020 >>283131380
>>283111516 (OP)
Ok so what is going on with Murata and ONE?
Is it just that Murata draws sexy women?
That is a good explanation for me Murata does draw really sexy women
Anonymous No.283115272 [Report] >>283117012 >>283131359
>>283114156
Unless youre one of the spergs who hated the tournament arc, the manga MA arc was only dogshit during it's last 4 years.
>>283114767
Lol. Lmao.
Anonymous No.283115442 [Report] >>283115797
>>283111516 (OP)
but the fanmade animation has 12m view...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7Oo18gECmg
Anonymous No.283115797 [Report]
>>283115442
>the shitty fanfic fight.
Even if lost of people has seen it, its still don't make it good. The worst thing Murata has even done to this series after the redraw hell.
Anonymous No.283115838 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
The drop in animation quality was more detrimental the story was still interesting but nothing explains that level of fucking drop off
Anonymous No.283116020 [Report] >>283116824 >>283121134
>>283115258
You got it. Murata is a coomer virtuoso. Left to his own devices, he will obsessively redraw to the point of redirecting completed arcs to accommodate his harem. ONE could hypothetically wrangle him, and basically be the writer + storyboard artist, allowing Murata's talent to thrive in the proper role. But ONE is a webcomic guy, and considers the rest of the franchise as spinoffs and cash-ins.
Anonymous No.283116824 [Report] >>283118750
>>283116020
Anonymous No.283117012 [Report]
>>283115272
The tournament arc was dogshit.
Anonymous No.283117120 [Report]
japs probably got upset it became too popular in the west and sabotaged it.
Anonymous No.283118750 [Report]
>>283116824
Genos will put her hips to good use
Anonymous No.283118853 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
Season 2 already did it.
Anonymous No.283119274 [Report]
>>283111924
This redraw was good though, waifus are for loving, not being guroed by some self loathing monster fag
Anonymous No.283120218 [Report] >>283123656
>>283111924
you idiot, Season 3 is animating the webcomic not the manga.
Anonymous No.283120249 [Report] >>283120500 >>283123130
>>283111628
>>283111794
>>283113668
>>283114526
Is her entire character purpose really is being an endgame girl for Saitama?
Anonymous No.283120500 [Report]
>>283120249
Genos will take her.
Anonymous No.283120671 [Report] >>283129673
What's the problem with Genos shippers? Why do they latch onto a literally dickless character who's obsessed with another man and doesn't care about anyone else?
Anonymous No.283120848 [Report]
>>283114325
The best but also the most convoluted way to read OPM is to read the volume releases of the manga up until the start of the MA raid, then switch to the pre-redraw online version of the manga, and after Saitama kills Orochi switch to the webcomic chapter where Tatsumaki first confronts Psykos.
Anonymous No.283121134 [Report] >>283121378
>>283116020
I mean One wasn’t a lazy slacker there would be no need for redraws
Anonymous No.283121182 [Report] >>283121356
>>283114203
They have Aoki so that’s no excuse
Anonymous No.283121289 [Report]
>>283111628
Total Buki Love
Anonymous No.283121356 [Report]
>>283121182
Oh wow, they have one (1) good animator! Surely he can do the season all by himself
Anonymous No.283121378 [Report] >>283122552
>>283121134
the MA arc in the webcomic was already complete by the time murata was drawing the martial arts tournament in the manga
he did not need to take so many years redrawing it
Anonymous No.283122552 [Report]
>>283121378
The issue with the MA raid is that the webcomic changed massively during it. The first 7 webcomic chapters of the MA raid were adapted into 6 and a half volumes in the manga, and this makes sense because the manga arc leading into the MA raid changed things a bit and some bits were turned into full blown sequences which is how the manga had been adapting the webcomic in the first place. Somewhat drawn out but expected.

But the thing is, most of the MA raid arc in the webcomic is already fleshed out and slower paced just like the manga. There's no real need to add more characters and sequences because it messes with the very deliberate pacing of the surface battle. Early webcomic gave Murata more room to interpret the action and fill gaps when desired but as MA raid progresses that's no longer possible. Everything becomes more defined and directed, more recognisably ONE if adapted faithfully. Aspects that would previously be dictated by Murata wrestled back by ONE's very intentional storytelling. To me it seems like Murata made a conscious decision to deviate from the webcomic when he could no longer stick to it without giving up his creative freedom. That's where shit like Murata's Blast comes from, it's like his self-insert for his sense of authorship over the manga, granted he IS the author even if it's based on someone else's ideas.
Anonymous No.283122556 [Report] >>283123224
The redraws are One ideas btw
Anonymous No.283122712 [Report] >>283122740
> marry and reproduce finale
Your reaction to this ending?
Anonymous No.283122740 [Report] >>283122793
>>283122712
Why should Saitama get with a cunt like her
Anonymous No.283122760 [Report] >>283122774 >>283122842
>>283111516 (OP)
I blame Murata for butchering Garou's arc.
Anonymous No.283122774 [Report] >>283122797
>>283122760
What was changed?
Anonymous No.283122793 [Report]
>>283122740
She cute.
Anonymous No.283122797 [Report] >>283123707
>>283122774
Enough for all the passionate freelancers who worked on S1 to jump ship.
Anonymous No.283122822 [Report]
>animation this animation that
These reddit muratard copes seems to forget why S1 had good animation in the first place.
Nobody besides murata want to polish shit like the official fan fiction called manga.
Anonymous No.283122842 [Report]
>>283122760
Didn't the initial draft for the manga version of the Garou fight have Monster Garou and Saitama chilling in some destroyed shack to discuss their opposing philosophies before Murata rewrote it to some time travelling sharkjump?
Anonymous No.283122865 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
It is not even the biggest fall from grace and relevancy in OPM
Anonymous No.283122888 [Report]
>>283114203
Why do you think they never gave it a good staff again? Do you think execs enjoy their shit flopping? They just saw the source material (dogshit) and concluded it wasn't worth spending much on after fanfic murata took over, it's that simple.
Anonymous No.283122889 [Report] >>283130745
>>283112803
>don't say other words, you cuck
What are you even criticizing about his post?
Anonymous No.283122902 [Report]
>>283114203
>"S1 was too greats they can never match the hype!!!"
meanwhile mob100 delivered on literally all fronts. 3 seasons in a row, with some crazy production timing too
OPM is just a pathetic failure
Anonymous No.283122972 [Report]
>>283112068
She's the best.
Anonymous No.283123037 [Report]
It will never capture the pure hype and fire of the first season. Even the theme songs will never be as good as the first seasons intro.
Anonymous No.283123130 [Report]
>>283113668
God, I hope so.
>>283120249
In the webcomic, she seems to be more of her own person with her own arc and doesn't seem to be that romantically interested in Saitama (or anyone). In the manga and anime, however, she definitely seems more what you described. I just wonder if they'll follow through with it or not. I guess we'll be waiting on Murata to decide that.
Anonymous No.283123224 [Report]
>>283122556
yeah bro ackshually the opposite of what you think is going on is whats happening got it thanks for the insight lol shut the fuck up you fucking mutt.
Anonymous No.283123260 [Report]
i watched the episode and i don't remember anything anymore
yes animeonly but it has been a long time
Anonymous No.283123656 [Report]
>>283120218
What makes you say that? They animated loads of manga exclusive chapters already.
Anonymous No.283123658 [Report] >>283126413
I hope the webcomic gets an anime adaption before I die
Anonymous No.283123707 [Report]
>>283122797
That fact that you didnt explain it in this post shows me you probably don't actually know
Anonymous No.283123815 [Report] >>283130808
>>283114203
Does Madhouse not care about money?
Anonymous No.283124060 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
>third season airs fucking six years later and its already a decade old anime
>its irrelevant to the current anime market
it should have been a one off thing maybe even gotten an anime original ending with 25 episodes
Anonymous No.283126413 [Report]
>>283123658
It's not getting one. Even the manga getting animated is already a question mark at this point.
Anonymous No.283126580 [Report] >>283127295
>>283111516 (OP)
Season 1 was so mainstream people thought it would pull a Kimetsu before Kimetsu.
Anonymous No.283127295 [Report] >>283128181
>>283126580
Kimetsu manga already had a solid conclusion so it’s easy for the producers to pour everything into a new anime season without worrying about their investments going to waste because some mangaka butchered the source material with his redraw autism.
Anonymous No.283128181 [Report]
>>283127295
The volumes don't get redrawn, I don't think the suits care about the free online release, the audience are the paying customers. Also, we were very yet to meet redraw hell when S2 was greenlit.
Anonymous No.283128262 [Report]
Once I learned about the BL books as reference a ton makes sense about the way Murata draws guys in OPM.
Anonymous No.283129358 [Report]
>>283111924
>94-120
Hey, that's around the time I dropped it. Now I know why it was so boring.
Anonymous No.283129399 [Report]
>>283111516 (OP)
It's because the studio working on is sucks. Season two looked like shit.
Anonymous No.283129415 [Report]
>>283114526
Nah, just dead inside.
Anonymous No.283129673 [Report]
>>283120671
I don't ship it but Genos and Fubuki have shipping fuel in the manga. Saitama couldn't care less about her
Anonymous No.283130455 [Report]
I love Fubuki so much it hurts
Anonymous No.283130745 [Report]
>>283122889
All they have to do if they want a story is follow the webcomic. Instead you start going,
>but what if yadda yadda and [other issues that don't matter but you make everyone listen anyway]
There's no ifs. Everything you said ignore the simple fact. If they want follow the version in manga, they're free to butcher their work, I'm sure they will, but if they don't, the script is in the webcomic and they have a story by following it.
Anonymous No.283130808 [Report]
>>283123815
It's been J.C. Staff since S2, dude...
Anonymous No.283131359 [Report] >>283132647
Kind of amazing how enduring the lie of Murata writing the manga has become
>>283115272
Not as amazing as those spergs still existing though
Anonymous No.283131380 [Report]
>>283115258
ONE is on record saying he can go ahead and make characters more "alluring" when he isn't the one drawing so it's like 50-50
Anonymous No.283131461 [Report] >>283131504 >>283131725
>>283111706
Yeah you can only take the central gag of "Goku/Superman is having his midlife crisis" so far. It's a joke you can only tell once per "story" and season 1 served as a pretty coherent single narrative that escalated from street level chumps to fighting a space god who could blow up planets. There's nowhere left to escalate after that.
Anonymous No.283131504 [Report] >>283131540
>>283131461
Why limit yourself to only 1 gag?
Anonymous No.283131540 [Report]
>>283131504
When it's the entire premise of the story you by default limited it to that. Everything else in the story by definition revolves around it. If you try to excise it, it takes the whole story with it. Some stories just aren't meant to last forever and there's nothing wrong with that.
Anonymous No.283131725 [Report]
>>283131461
Good thing OPM stopped being that over a decade ago, this critcism doesn't hold any water lol

OPM has for 98% of its existence been a straightforward battlemanga and its best moments in both the manga and webcomic work because its being played entirely straight
Anonymous No.283131859 [Report]
When does Fubuki get naked?
Anonymous No.283132647 [Report]
>>283131359
>the lie of Murata writing
著者 : 村田 雄介
Anonymous No.283132930 [Report]
It's pretty funny how the best MMV creator of OPM, Durzo, also stopped doing MMVs right at the Phoenix Man vs Child Emperor fight. Sure, the main reason was because his MMVs kept being taken down on youtube, but it's also funny how he also stopped making them during the Phoenix Man fight that is according to many where the manga mainly fell off.
Anonymous No.283133418 [Report]
>>283111706
This. We passed season 1 wanting to see if someone could give Saitama a great battle and Boros was the hype for it but then the great conclusion and joke is in fact no one can defeat him.
Then season 2 and monster arc in general is season 1 again but much longer and without the emotional appealing(at least I cant feel nothing for Garou). It does have good things like King and fanservice but that's it.