Thread 283161385

>>283161385 (OP)
... on opposite day

>>283161385 (OP)
What did she win?

>be cool onee-san
>confess first
>win
Biggest plot twist seo has ever done.

>>283161385 (OP)
The spoilers are fake, Ami won

>>283163508
>Schizo in denial.

If the spoilers are true this is one of the most anticlimatic wins of all time, we didn’t see a confession and the mc can’t even explain why he likes her

>>283163596
he doesn't love her. he just pick randomly and postfactum barely explained it
hayato NEVER shown real feelings for his harem girls since first chapter to the last one, true CHAD

>>283163702
>true CHAD
More like a true MARICÓN.

I'll believe it when I see it

The reasoning actually made sense to me, as small as it may seem. Especially since girls who confess first tend to get screwed.

who did she avenge

>>283165637
Ichika

>>283161385 (OP)
Spoilers where? Or is it just from the result of the polls?

>>283163702
Nah, he kissed Riho of his own accord.

>>283165715
Who the fuck is Ichika

>>283163596
Link to the spoilers?
>If the spoilers are true this is one of the most anticlimatic wins of all time
So this was truly Seo's mild ride till the end.

>>283165770
The least popular quint, by far.
She stepped on Mikufags toes but even without that she's still shit

>>283165770
A cute snek that didn't need avenging.

>>283165847
Kanokari thread

>>283165855
>The least popular quint, by far.
She's third place, Yots and the fat one were at the bottom of the polls by the end

>>283165992
The fat one is fairly popular because she actually looks feminine + first girl

>>283161385 (OP)
Congrats to the 3 people that like her

>>283166036
she also had the best character development

>>283161385 (OP)
>people still read this guy's garbage
When will they learn.

>>283166036
>The fat one is fairly popular
lmao, the highest place she got was 3rd at the first poll and it was all downhill for her after that

>>283166062
???????????????????????????

>>283166076
>gets no screentime and is treated as a fat joke
>still more popular than half the quints

>>283165914
Danke
>Kiku became his sister-in-law
Kek

>>283166134
She had plenty of screentime when that poll happened, she started getting shafted soon after

>>283166036
Itsuki is specifically popular with seasonal slop watchers on MAL and plebbit, among actual fans not so much.

>>283166216
What poll? The first one after 40 chapters? Half the cast weren't fleshed out That's basically a first impressions poll who the fuck cares

Reminder that we finally got nipples

>>283166076
That's fine, the fat one is just for me.

>>283166038
You know she is the most popular girl/character, right?

>>283166248
Nice. I like the shading outside the frames.

>>283166219
Cope

>>283166318
I feel like people started liking her the most and then moved on to the other girls. At least here. I don't go to other sites.

>>283166219
Makes sense, "fans" like the crazy menhera batshit bitches while the fairly stable ones are ignored, aren't you glad?

As a day 1 Ninofag I'm glad she won, while I'd prefer Riho, Akane is nice.

>>283166382
So Shiragiku will keep trying to make babies with him either way.

>>283166582
Also, I forgot. Did she never tell him they met as children? She could have pulled that card to say she's actually the first one to promise to marry him or something.

This shit is so mid the entire thread is about a completely different manga, kek.

>>283166353
iirc there have been 5 popularity polls. Shiragiku won the first one and Ouka the last one and Akane won the other three and besides the first one, she has been in the top 3. So yeah, maybe here she is not that popular, but everywhere else she has been the fan favorite.

>>283167724
>fan favorite.
Lol no

The ending is gonna flop even harder than Amagami's nothing burger routeslop did, unless there's an epic tweest to wow everyone.

>I don't dislike any of you and I don't particularly like any of you more than the others, and I can't possibly have a harem end so I'll just pick whoever asked first as that would take the least effort
Kek

Don't get my hopes up you assholes

>>283167724
Akane won the first one though

>>283167854
Wrong

I think it was a fine justification for Hayato.

>>283167818
I don't even know where to begin poking fun at

>>283167888
So he just chose whoever won the popularity polls. Makes sense since he said he wanted it to be a girl fans liked.
But also means it's just pure slop where the story doesn't matter at all.

>>283167888
Amybros?????

>>283168143
Jap fans got mad that she dared to talk about having dreams other than being a cocksleeve.

>>283168167
I'd be mad too, fucking whore

>>283167801
Is there only one more chapter after this one? What are the chances Seo adds a twist?

>>283168216
The twist is isekai truck-kun

>>283168124
Seo stated that the winner would be chosen based on the pulls. At that time everyone though it was bs, but it seems he said the truth.

>>283168216
>Hayato is impotent
>on paper he is married but he's with all the girls
>daughter is adopted

>>283168034
It isn't, there isn't a single man in the world who would chose "whoever asked first" in that situation, it's nonsensical. Unless you don't like any of them and just want to get it over with.

>>283168167
Don't they all have dreams?
Akane wants her group to become famous.
Rihi wants to be a famous actress.
Ouka wants to make her haute couture brand.
Kiku wants to be a 3 star michellin cook.

>>283168314
I mean if you don't particularly care, you would pick the girl with the richest family.
Ami is no go, Kiku's dad doesn't seem particularly rich.
Now Ouka and Riho's families are somewhat wealthy but Akane's family is Japanese Yakuza. There's no comparison.

>>283168330
>Don't they all have dreams?
Yes, Amikeks are just having a melty

>>283168465
Based hayacchi get himself rich oujou

>>283168465
Hayato was all about money from ch1

If there are flashbacks of Akane in the background while he explains why he likes her i might buy it

*bows out

>>283168629
kek not after reading this

what wrong with marrying the most wealthiest woman in the roster? dating in HS may be fueled by love but in adult life money is the most important component.

You know an endgame sucks when even the fans of the winning girl only arguments are "well she's rich!! She's was first !!"

>>283169563
What other reason can there be? Did he pick up one name from a hat?

>>283166434
Same. She's a fine girl even if I prefer Riho a lot more.

>>283169563
She's hot, proactive, and high-tier wife material. I like heroines who make moves and aren't shy about admitting their feelings and fighting for what they want, and Akane has been that since the start. She's the one I always wanted to win. Though I would have been fine with Ami if she weren't developmentally disabled and were given some actual romantic development with Hayato.

>>283169563
akane and ami were the only good choices

I hope Seo doesn't write a sequel where their children start dying.

>>283169793
>Amy
Kill yourself

Do we know the source or why people are saying she won?

>>283169652
Close enough to "she was first"

>>283169898
>>283161416

>>283169756
And she had a toilet scene. Did anyone else have a toilet scene?

>>283169826
I hope Seo writes a sequel where their granddaughters fight for his grandson.

>>283169652
They obviously threw a dart at a board

>>283169652
Hayato saw the polls.

STOP THE COUNT
harem bros there's one chapter left we can still win

>>283169980
So nothing confirmed yet then?

>>283166248
>>283166382
WHERE ARE THESE FROM?!

>>283161385 (OP)
As a NinoChad, I'm glad my favorite won
Get fucked Amifags

>>283169986
Two toilet scenes, as a matter of fact.

>>283170232
As a Nino, Akane, AND Ami enjoyer, I would have won either way.

>>283170313
As a Nino, Akane, Riho and Ouka enjoyers, I condemn your enjoyment of Ami

Honestly, I'd be extremely disillusioned with the manga if he doesn't end up with Kiku. Hear me out first, i know she's not your typical super well-developed character, but she's at least endearing, likeable, kinky, and extremely hot.

You may chalk it up to "personal bias" because i find short black haired demure himecut girls irresistible.

>>283170313
>>283170333
Stop lying, no one likes Ami, the polls prove it

>>283170360
Nobody cares you retarded subhuman nigger, she's even worse than Ami

Shitposting aside, did you enjoy the ride, anon?

>>283170391
You cared enough to respond to me, bitch.

>>283170367
Everybody thought she'd win so they deliberately didn't vote for her.

>>283161385 (OP)

kinda rank Riho above her but Akane is acceptable.
Ouka win would have been fine too.

>>283170441
>Ouka win would have been fine too.
based

Love all the Riho and Ouka love in the thread.

So, what happened?, considering there was zero romance in this story it could've keep going forever, did Seo got bored of it?

>>283170611
Seo wanted the guy to tell all these bitches to go take a hike, but his editor just barely restrained him.

>>283170394
Eh, I've been on and off on this.
Tune in to Midnight Heart > Amagami >= Cafe Terrace
I might change my mind depending on who wins in midnight tune

>>283170765
Mayotuna is so underrated. I don't get why Japan doesn't like it.

>>283170803
Not him, but while all the girls but Iko have been developing decently, the actual mystery lost its luster for me.

>>283170913
Nothing advances the mystery towards one girl for long. Just like with Cafe. For me the end goal is Bucky fulfilling the goals of all the girls.
Iko's time will come, the author just has fun bullying her.

>>283170360
kiku wasn't even in the race
she fell over at the starting line

>>283170360
Should have taken it up to eleven when they figured out her sluttiness was calculated and not from getting drunk.
Instead she only took it up to a 6 maybe a 7.

>>283170598
Riho has a lot of mesugaki energy despite her age, it's makes sense a lot of people here like her

>>283171160
Seo didn't know how to use her so her character development was mostly reverted. Just like Meeku.

>>283170803
MC is too much of a walking joke and the four girls playing the straight man to him gets old quickly, the mystery has been handled terribly so it's only real appeal is the girls designs but even then they all have almost the same body so it all comes down to whether you like their trope and hairstyle, no character there is strong enough to carry the manga either, I'd say rather than being underrated is just as popular as it deserves to be

>>283161385 (OP)
Better than no one winning.

Ouka sisters... Don't believe the spoilers, stay strong...

>>283172108
we all lose so... win I guess?

>>283172389
we don't accept this ending and will be considering manga on indefinite hiatus like friren

>>283170220
Volume 21

>>283168167
Really? Amifans pissed off? Where? Like on 2ch and twitter? Cause I’d love to read that.

>>283172389
Seo wanted Ouka to win but the editor forced Akane, you can tell by how shitty he handled the ending that he hates Akane

>>283172389
Meh. It is what it is.

>>283170394
Yes, at some point it became clear that the status quo wasn't going to change, so i stopped expecting any developments and just enjoyed the ride

ninibros...

Akane's grandma was the only one in love with Hayato's grandpa. She advices Akane on how not to lose.

I was saying "I am fine with anyone but Ami" last week. Now that I got anyone but Ami this week I'm still mad.

>>283166248
>>283166382
Nice, I saw the poll he held on his Twitter account and voted for the nipples. He also included the Shiragiku option.

>>283173802
How was Ami even in the running? She's basically retarded

>>283165754
That's true.

>>283166330
Why? What's good about it?

>>283173962
The yotsuba thing spooked people for good reason, but it seems to be a one-off thing thankfully.
Anyone can see how Negi tanked his career after, no one is interested in torpedoing themselves just for the sake of being contrarian.

>>283174075
Yotsuba was the only one making Fuutarou happy. He was just tolerating Miku and Nino. Itsuki was never in it and Ichika gave him the ick.

>>283174351
What kind of retarded fever dream is this post supposed to be. Disgusting.

>>283173962
Ami was the least popular which mean her winning would make the most people mad and there's a group of retards who only read harems in the hopes of seeing people get mad

>>283161385 (OP)
>draw a bishounen
>call it a girl
LOL

>>283174397
It's just OnK fags wanting everyone to suffer as they do.

>>283171251
Mesugaki harem when?

Ouka love

>>she won

>Confession is skipped
>Wedding is skipped
>No kiss
>The other girls are still clinging to her husband as if she wasn't even there

What did she win exactly ?? An undercooked ending ?

>>283174770
She won, you lost

Amikeks.. not like this...

While Ami win would make the most narrative sense, I understand why Seo didn't go that way and went for a simple popularity win

>>283175126
Bruh sticking "narrative" in the same sentence as your joke character doesn't make her not a joke. It didn't for Yotsuba and it didn't for Ami.

>>283175202
Let him have this.

>>283175126
>went for a simple popularity win
Sure, just like Negi went for the safest option, right? lmao

>>283175126
With the others sneaking into his bed, she should have been successful once without the others finding out, whether she won or lost.

>>283175303
Yotsuba was #2 in the poll and was widely well regarded among fans. She only became a lightning rod for hate after she won.

>>283175317
Ami never liked him that way and he daughterzoned her hard

>>283172727
But why did it have so many volumes without any?

>>283175431
If Hayato gave a fuck about Akane's feelings she would have won 2 years ago. She's asked him to marry her multiple times.

>>283175431
There's no reason to let that stop it.

What if we see the future again and then the daugther brings all her little sisters, daugthers of all the other girls?

>>283175506
He explained that already, he didn't wanted to keep her or anyone else tied to the cafe instead of following their dreams

>>283175407
Imagine having a girl everyone feels at least a little bit of sympathy for and is a lot of people's "yeah, I'll be fine if she gets in over my fave" pick, and the contrarian fanbase pretends they never said any of that when she actually does get picked

>>283175693
>feels
Felt.

Because Yotsuba, who was basically a non-character and invisible for 90 chapters is a different person in the flashback.
And she gets even worse after it.

>>283175585
That's BS, they can follow their dreams and still marry the owner of a cafe
For Kiku it's especially favorable since he also owns a restaurant and she could make it her own. Maybe for Riho it's a little unfavorable but even that is a stretch since she's an actress not an idol.

Real hot take here
Hayato acts likes he is not interested in any one of them.

>>283175884
That's people women aren't real humans.

>>283175303
The safest option was ANYONE but Ichika or Yotsuba, Negi went for the full retard option

>>283175505
We may never know

>>283161385 (OP)
dykecoded

Any harem manga is first and foremost concerned with dragging the tension out for as long as possible. Why is Hayato here honestly considering touching up Giku despite being in love with Akane? Why is he letting Ami sleep in the same bed as him? Why are they faking out who the mother is with the cats death last chapter? It's all in service of that.

This manga was never that serious.

Hayato should have just killed himself

>>283176400
>Yotsuba
>not a safe option
I can see how you'd think that if you weren't there.
She was the safest. She was most people's #2 and was also the 2nd most favorite one after Miku. People thought Yotsuba winning would be the least offensive outcome at the time. Nino was the most divisive and everyone gave up on Ichika. Mikufags held out some hope but they were mostly reddit and twitterfags.

>>283175506
That's why the whole 'the was the first to confess' sounds terrible.
She was first, she even proposed, that's what made him fall for her apparently yet he still kept the other girls around for years, refusing Akane advances for reasons ?
And he also said that he didn't want to interfer with the girls career but Akane has been telling since the start that she was 'greedy' and wanted both so this reason for stalling is now completely bs

>>283176660
People were "fine with Yotsuba" winning because they thought she would lose. Genki girls at that time never won so they votre for her because they didn't think she had a chance. And when she won, they all got angry

>>283176859
If any choice had to be made, it should have been which got to be the official wife while deciding to keep the rest as part of a harem.

>>283166382
I want to fuck Shiragiku

>>283176400
This.
Nino and Miku were the fan favorites and the ones with the most sexual tension w/ Futaro.
Shitsuturd was asspulled bc Hackaruba wanted to be a chad wannabe and be with his preggo wife so bad he went scorched earth over his manga

>"Dude, everyone hated Yotsuba winning"
>Yotsuba winning
The only people who hated it was fags who can't let go of a manga that ended 5 years ago. /a/ was jubilant.

>Nino
Mostly hated but she had powerful autists behind her.
>Miku
Only if you were the biggest normalfag

The only reception that matters is the Japs'.

>>283177331
>Only if you were the biggest normalfag
Like shipjumping yotsufags?

>>283177428
Those were mostly ninifags

>>283161385 (OP)
Kind of anti-climatic.

>>283177331
>cherry picked screencaps
How is that supposed to prove anything other than that you're a biased Yotsubaschizo? Literally go to anywhere discussing 5toubun and people will clown on the ending and winner.

>>283177513
It feels very mild

the only girls i would be mad for winning is riho and ouka