Thread 283660695

why is lucky star popular to this day compared to haruhi?

I'd say is the other way around, also most new watchers wouldn't get most Lucky Star references as they are kinda dated.

>>283660820
Then why do I see so many people with Konata pfps?

>>283660695 (OP)
It really isn't.

>>283660695 (OP)
haruhi is shit. lucky star is goat

haruhi has aged like milk

TTGL won

>>283660695 (OP)
Because the Lucky Star girls are super breedable.

>>283662146
>implying haruhi isnt breedable

>>283661995
Unfathomably based

Konata is a timeless masterpiss

>>283661614
Same reason you see kimi to kanojo to kanojo no koi pfps.

Bumping this because I have something long to say

>>283660695 (OP)
It's because Lucky Star, unlike Haruhi, offers an experience that, to this day, is almost wholly unique to itself. Haruhi, aside from being 2000s-styled and KyoAnimated, is truthfully nothing but a school drama with a charismatic hot girl and a supernatural twist. We've seen dozens of those emerge within the subsequent decade. But Lucky Star is something genuinely revolutionary: A chibi-styled candy-colored fluff show that revolves around a cute and relatable comedy duo consisting of a Dionysian tomweeb and an Apollonian tsundere, and KyoAni made sure to give it most powerful design, directing, art, animation, music, voice-acting, etc, that it could at the time. Haruhi may be a classic of sorts, but Lucky Star is the moe equivalent of crack.

I don't get the impression that one is noticeably more popular than the other.
But I'm not on tiktok or other bullshit like that, so I wouldn't really have any idea what is 'popular' either so I could be wrong.

>>283661783
>>283661964
braindead

>>283660695 (OP)
Because it was a massive success at the time (around 2007 or so if I remember right). Similar to Death Note.

>>283660695 (OP)
Because it was a massive success at the time (around 2007 or so if I remember right). Its artstyle, appealing interesting characters and argumental arcs, etc. It resulted innovative.
Similar to Death Note.

>>283660695 (OP)
Zoomers watch it ironically like the do everything.

>>283666356
>>283666356
>ZOOMERS I HATE ZOOMERS DO YOU KNOW ZOOMERS WHY DO ZOOMERS DO THING ZOOM ZOOM ZOOM ZOOM
Get a personality beyond internet buzzwords you soulless hylic

>>283666356
Is it ironic if they enjoy it
I never fully understood the "ironic watching" thing

>>283666433
They start watching it ironically, but that tricks their easily influenced brains to authentically like it.

>>283660695 (OP)
I think it has to do with anons relating to the characters more,Lucky star just attracts more autism but that just little girls doing cute things shows in general

>>283666623
see
>>283666431

>>283666431
>>283667088
Fuck off.

>>283667148
Maybe you should fuck off and stop being a buzzword spouting nigger

Lucky Star, while dated, is actually funny. Haruhi on the other hand, is dated and honestly really fucking boring.

>lucky star
full of cute likeable girls
>haruhi
far fewer cute girls; revolves around a narcissistic BPDemon

>>283661995
I started rewatching it in 2022, and it took me 3 years to actually get through it because I found it really boring and just stopped watching in the middle a few times. I thought it was cool the first time, but it was 15+ years ago and I was a kid. Not that I mind wacky anime these days but something about TTGL feels like nothing is real or matters and Imaishi is just autofellating the whole time.

Lucky Star is Japanese Family Guy.

Haruhi has aged poorly.

>>283667645
its not that, its that they never actually finished it despite being basically one of the anime poster series of back then, so no one is going to bother getting into a series without an ending

>>283661614
Really just boils down to her making a lot of meme faces like >>283667645.

>>283667645
Very strange reading this post, whenever Lucky Star would come up a few years ago the prevailing opinion was the exact opposite. I'm in the camp that says Lucky Star is mostly unfunny (though I didn't dislike it) and Haruhi is a masterpiece.

>>283660695 (OP)
Haruhi was an event you had to be there for and requires a lot of context to appreciate; Lucky Star, while mired in references, still has solid silly and sometimes emotional moments that keeps it entertaining without needing to rely on referential humor.

That said, it's not necessarily that Haruhi is BAD. It's just a bit of a slog to get through. "You had to be there" is in full effect when it comes to Haruhi - unless you rewatch the whole thing in both orders with your pals it's not gonna be the same.

>>283667836
I mean yeah, it doesn't have a good ending, but it's also boring. I watched it again recently and I realized the most fun I had back in the day watching Haruhi were the threads here about it. The actual show just isn't that interesting, not to mention Endless 8.

>>283667921
You're insane. What you're saying applies to the time loop arc exclusively. The rest of the series stands on its own perfectly well. Are zoomers too socially inept to comprehend good character writing?

Haruni failed for not being yuri

>>283668077
Like I said, it's not bad, good even - it's just a pain because of all the expectations people place on one watching it due to all the order bullshit.

>>283667927
yeah I get that, It was fun back then, but its not something I would rewatch,I still like it, but I've been re-downloading all of my 2tb anime HDD with newer encodes and better res and yeah, I have no desire to re-archive Haruhi lol,

>>283667755
>Imaishi is just autofellating the whole time.
Why do you think that?

>>283662557
Why do you see them?

>>283666356
>>283666431
>>283666433
>>283666623
I'm old, and I just want to say back in the 2000s 'hipsters' also consumed/watched/read/listened and even drank stuff like shitty beer 'ironically'.
Most of it was just a facade to actually enjoy things, but have a shield in case someone criticized their taste.
It's funny how things don't really change.

>>283667645
Having fun with Konata sounds fun

>>283661614
Newfags like all those Brazilian tweens that got into Azudai last year

>>283670662
Why brazilians specifically

>>283661995
it was and it always will be overrated coomer anime

>>283667927
Endless 8 (and Haruhi in general) is a pleb filter, you have to go back.

>>283673501
Fuck off. I watched all eight episodes of Endless 8 as they were airing.

>>283673520
and you loved every second of it

>>283673529
No, I was actually annoyed because the threads were going to be super shitty. KyoAni making Disappearance into a movie and dragging out E8 to eight actual episodes was a huge mistake. As much as I enjoyed Disappearance I think it was the wrong decision to fuck over S2 like that.

>>283662211
She isn't.

>>283673596
it's avant-garde, you wouldn't understand

>>283673717
FUCK Haruhi

Didnt Moot actually customized music and stuff on /a/ back when the S2 dropped in surprise?
man, back then we would actually get hyped for stuff, and here we are

>>283673827
The announcement of P&S season 2 got a sticky and plenty of hype.

>>283673873
Fair, I admit I was not on /a/ at the time, I came back recently after a looong time
Got sick back then from all the LN spoilerfags

>>283673717
I would show her how much of a faggot I am by lifting that short skirt and start raping the shit out of her

>>283670384
trolling her on the intern3t gamez and making fun of her dead mother sounds funner-er

>>283674230
Has that happened to an anime character?