← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 283665539

220 posts 158 images /a/
Anonymous No.283665539 [Report] >>283665677 >>283665733 >>283665771 >>283666658 >>283666679 >>283667099 >>283667228 >>283667316 >>283667477 >>283668765 >>283669388 >>283670617
Wait, The cardcaptor girl isn't a magical girl?
Anonymous No.283665584 [Report] >>283665744 >>283669058
she is my wife
Anonymous No.283665588 [Report] >>283665744 >>283674731
Who?
Anonymous No.283665621 [Report] >>283665744 >>283665783 >>283668818 >>283668950
She's a GIRL that captures cards so that she can use MAGIC
She isn't using them to play children's card games, she's using them to cast REAL magic because she's a MAGICAL GIRL
Anonymous No.283665626 [Report] >>283665744
Tell me more about THEE Sakura Kinomoto
Anonymous No.283665677 [Report] >>283665744
>>283665539 (OP)
That's my wife.
Anonymous No.283665733 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
Many see "Magical Girl" as being like Sailor Moon and the like, with transformations and all.
Anonymous No.283665744 [Report] >>283665883 >>283665928 >>283666324 >>283667651 >>283668765
>>283665584
>>283665588
>>283665621
>>283665626
>>283665677
I think this drama is originating from the recent youtube essay about magical girls? Does anyone know about this video?
Anonymous No.283665771 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
>Twitter screencap thread
Let me guess, tourists who think Magical Girl is when Sailor Moon Clone?
Anonymous No.283665783 [Report] >>283666008 >>283666025 >>283666658
>>283665621
So, is this a magical girl?
Anonymous No.283665797 [Report] >>283666968 >>283667000
Magical Girl is a specific genre, the female version of Super Sentai.
Anonymous No.283665883 [Report]
>>283665744
But that last one is a duck.
Boco !sCZ24qY6KY No.283665905 [Report] >>283666539
She's the first one, she doesn't have to follow every rule because some of them didn't exist yet.
Anonymous No.283665928 [Report]
>>283665744
I hate normalfags so fucking much.
Anonymous No.283666008 [Report] >>283668583 >>283670932 >>283671418 >>283671630 >>283671888
>>283665783
Actually let me end this thread. Does the "magical girl" have a transformation sequence? If no then that's not a mahou shojo.
Anonymous No.283666025 [Report]
>>283665783
I never realized how defined and muscular her legs were in this picture. N-not that there's anything wrong with that! I guess this was right after the grape stomping village story.
Anonymous No.283666033 [Report] >>283667348 >>283669349
Secondaries are making fool of themselves. She does have a transformation sequence, the one where she transforms her key into a staff or when she uses cards to cast magic.
Anonymous No.283666324 [Report] >>283666406 >>283666796 >>283666945 >>283667766 >>283667902 >>283668783 >>283669061 >>283669148 >>283669558 >>283670165 >>283670574 >>283671874
>>283665744
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2YSHwSvRUg
I think its this one. She's pissed a lot of people off
Anonymous No.283666406 [Report]
>>283666324
Thx. reading this comment section is going to be great.
Anonymous No.283666539 [Report] >>283667418
>>283665905
Sakura is not even close to the first magical girl
Anonymous No.283666558 [Report] >>283666717 >>283669959
Anonymous No.283666632 [Report] >>283666833
Precure killed the genre anyway
Anonymous No.283666658 [Report] >>283667538
>>283665783
>>283665539 (OP)
Someone should make a chart with witches and magical girls on two sides and characters that overlap with both in the middle.
I think Sakura herself while firmly on the magical girl side is fairly close to the middle.
Anonymous No.283666676 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666679 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
Why is she so rapeable? I would kiss her eight there and I wouldn't stop no matter what
Anonymous No.283666717 [Report] >>283666815
>>283666558
Her first few leotard costumes were god tier
Anonymous No.283666719 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666756 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666781 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666796 [Report] >>283666921
>>283666324
Summarize what she said.
Anonymous No.283666803 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666815 [Report]
>>283666717
Anonymous No.283666824 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666833 [Report]
>>283666632
Man shut the fuck
Anonymous No.283666874 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666899 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666921 [Report] >>283667094 >>283667322
>>283666796
Magical girls is for the male gaze unless its Revolutionary Girl Utena. She did not mention cardcaptor or Pretty Cure.
Best moment was when she bitched that there was no girl anime in the most watched as apothecary diaries scrolled past by
Anonymous No.283666922 [Report] >>283667750
Her nails are certainly magical
Anonymous No.283666930 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666945 [Report] >>283667804 >>283668278
>>283666324
The fact PreCure was not mentioned says so fucking much of how big of a tourist she is.
Anonymous No.283666955 [Report] >>283667750
She's such a brat omg.
Anonymous No.283666958 [Report]
Anonymous No.283666968 [Report]
>>283665797
>the female version of Super Sentai
You better hope you never run into pic related in a dark alley after saying shit like that.
Anonymous No.283666988 [Report] >>283667750
Anonymous No.283667000 [Report] >>283667304
>>283665797
>the female version of Super Sentai.
How to expose yourself as another faggot whose only understanding of magical girl is fucking Sailor Moon.
Anonymous No.283667026 [Report] >>283667750
Anonymous No.283667034 [Report] >>283667750
Anonymous No.283667070 [Report] >>283667750
Anonymous No.283667091 [Report] >>283667750
Anonymous No.283667094 [Report] >>283667126
>>283666921
So it's not the video these twitter folks are talking about? I'm more confused
Anonymous No.283667099 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
>twitter screencap
Go back.
Anonymous No.283667126 [Report] >>283667186
>>283667094
No it is I belive unless some other retard has a dogshit take
Anonymous No.283667173 [Report] >>283667210 >>283667750
Anonymous No.283667186 [Report] >>283667612
>>283667126
These posts were from yesterday and the video is from October so i'm not sure
Anonymous No.283667210 [Report]
>>283667173
>No spamming or flooding of any kind. No intentionally evading spam or post filters.
Anonymous No.283667228 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
No one gives a damn about what some nigger on twitter thinks.
Anonymous No.283667304 [Report] >>283668484
>>283667000
Sailor Moon is one of the only good ones.
Anonymous No.283667316 [Report] >>283667348
>>283665539 (OP)
No transformation sequence
Not a magical girl
Simple as
Anonymous No.283667322 [Report]
>>283666921
Did she actually not mention CCS at all? She seems like a hardcore CLAMP fan.
Anonymous No.283667348 [Report] >>283667542
>>283667316
Like clockwork lmao>>283666033
Boco !sCZ24qY6KY No.283667418 [Report] >>283667686 >>283668257 >>283672184
>>283666539

Who is?
Anonymous No.283667477 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
>twitter screencap
mods do your job
Anonymous No.283667538 [Report]
>>283666658
Number autism is telling me to somehow make it into a 3 parts Venn diagram. Witches, magical girls and either superheroiness or more general henshin heroes to cover the all three bases.
Anonymous No.283667542 [Report] >>283667559
>>283667348
>Her appearance doesn't change
Good you agree to her not transforming
Anonymous No.283667559 [Report]
>>283667542
retard
Anonymous No.283667612 [Report] >>283667730
>>283667186
Most of the comments are from the past day so I think it's getting attention now even though it was made last month.
Anonymous No.283667651 [Report] >>283667688 >>283668683
>>283665744
This is the ultima list of what you should watch. Period.
Anonymous No.283667686 [Report] >>283674515
>>283667418
I'm not going to spoonfeed you. It's easy to search up the history of mahou shoujo. But I will point out the absurdity of thinking CCS is the first magical girl when even Sailor Moon predates it.
Boco !sCZ24qY6KY No.283667688 [Report] >>283667737
>>283667651

Hey, wheres Puni Puni Poemi?
Anonymous No.283667730 [Report]
>>283667612
Fair
Anonymous No.283667737 [Report]
>>283667688
in the honorable mentions like tweeny witches and nymphogear.
Anonymous No.283667750 [Report] >>283667783 >>283669238
>>283666922
>>283666955
>>283666988
>>283667026
>>283667034
>>283667070
>>283667091
>>283667173
you can do better
Anonymous No.283667766 [Report] >>283669151
>>283666324
>The [X]fication of [Y]
>literal troon
pass
Boco !sCZ24qY6KY No.283667783 [Report]
>>283667750

Hey, don't lewd her.
Anonymous No.283667804 [Report] >>283669576
>>283666945
Now that you mention I've been wanting to at least watch one or two Precure. Which ones would you say are the are the "must watch"?
Anonymous No.283667902 [Report] >>283668025
>>283666324
>How did iconic shows like Sailor Moon tailored toward women turn into a site of male fantasy like Cutie Honey.
How can you say this when cutie honey is 20 years older and you show the date (The date is incorrect based on the version of Cutie honey that is on screen but whatever)
Anime are less segmented into demographics due to just being on TV while manga are mostly in magazines that feature more than just manga, they have celeb gossip, model photos and interviews that more targeted towards those certain demographics. (Josei isn't pronounced that way)
Hot take but the idea that Cutie Honey is a mahou shoujo maybe should be pushed back on. She is completely in line with other transforming superhero stories both from western comics, other Go Nagai stuff like Devilman and super sentai Japanese media. (She is a robot and not magic in anyway too)
Creamy Mami isn't an innuendo, weird thing to say.
Reused animation is in no way a mahou shoujo thing, it is just an animation thing. (Not how you Pronounce Go Nagai)
Why not bring up the director of Utena and the fact he directed a bunch of Sailor moon? Why not bring up that he is a giant fag?
I skipped a bunch of boring bullshit.
She jumped from Cutie Honey (1973) to Creamy Mami (1983) to Sailor Moon (1992) to Utena (1997) to Madoka (2011) and assumed those 5 shows summed up an entire genre.

TLDR: Bad video premise and worse research.
Anonymous No.283668025 [Report]
>>283667902
post it on the comment section of the video
Anonymous No.283668067 [Report] >>283668230 >>283668438 >>283674779
Honestly, I find the sheer disrespect of the lack of attention to Mahou Tsukai Sally and Himetsu no Akko-chan, despite both basically kicking off the magical girl genre.
Anonymous No.283668221 [Report]
Fuck this bitch for not liking Dragon Half.
Anonymous No.283668230 [Report] >>283668271
>>283668067
>The 60s anime
Probably because it's ancient. How many people mention Anpanman or Astro boy these days?
Anonymous No.283668257 [Report]
>>283667418
It depends on what you mean by "Magical Girl". By the classic definition, it's Sally the Witch. By the modern definition, it was Sailor Moon (or Sailor Venus or Chinese Magical Girl Paipai, depending on whether you count manga and toku).

There's also Cutie Honey, which is a bizarre outlier because Toei lumps it in with the other Majokko series even though it falls pretty squarely into the Battle Heroine genre.
Anonymous No.283668271 [Report]
>>283668230
If you claim to be an "expert" on "magical girls", yet neglect to mention their importance, you're fraud. I don't care how "ancient" they are.
Anonymous No.283668278 [Report] >>283668331 >>283668406 >>283671924
>>283666945
>literally a franchise made to sell toys gacha and license pachinki
Anonymous No.283668331 [Report] >>283668367
>>283668278
That doesn't make it necessarily bad.
Where does this argument even come from?
Anonymous No.283668367 [Report] >>283668430
>>283668331
You watch little girl slop that isn't even good and plaguing the genre
Depart from this thread immediately
Anonymous No.283668406 [Report]
>>283668278
Sounds like a perfect thing to mention when you make a video about the commodification of mahou shoujo.
Anonymous No.283668430 [Report]
>>283668367
Heartcatch mogs most magical girl shows alone.
Anonymous No.283668438 [Report] >>283668517
>>283668067
wtf don't tell me she didn't mention Bewitched either?
Anonymous No.283668464 [Report] >>283668562
Why is she like this bros?
Anonymous No.283668484 [Report] >>283668612 >>283668627
>>283667304
Sailor Moon ruined the magical girl genre.
Anonymous No.283668517 [Report]
>>283668438
No, in fact, she did not mention Bewitched. At all. Sally at least got a slight clip, but that's it.
Anonymous No.283668562 [Report]
>>283668464
She took the fact that Yukito is railing her brother very well. Admirable
Anonymous No.283668583 [Report] >>283668621
>>283666008
Define transformation sequence. Creamy Mami is definitely a magical girl anime but it doesn't have a stock transformation sequence, instead it changes for most of the times she transforms. And magical girl manga don't often have anything that could be considered a transformation sequence, though sometimes their anime adaptations add them. As someone else in here said too, Sakura's transformation is basically just getting her staff out and she doesn't transform into a costume like many other series.
Anonymous No.283668612 [Report]
>>283668484
It elevate it from despair slop
Anonymous No.283668621 [Report]
>>283668583
Sakura sequence is iconic even.
Anonymous No.283668627 [Report] >>283668714
>>283668484
You know what? Unironically, yes. Sailor Moon unironically made every midwit think a magical girl series need to be a tokusatsu-lite series with obligatory transformations. The fact people say CCS is not a magical girl series because she doesn't transform is fucking stupid. It's kinda sad the classic "majokko" side of the genre is dead because they'd honestly be a breath of fresh air in the genre rn.
Anonymous No.283668683 [Report]
>>283667651
>3x3 mahou shoujo
>posts a 4x3 image instead
Anon...
Anonymous No.283668714 [Report] >>283671778 >>283672303
>>283668627
>the classic "majokko" side of the genre is dead
No. It's still around. It just evolved.
Anonymous No.283668765 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
>>283665744
This is an irrelevant Twitter thread?
Anonymous No.283668783 [Report] >>283668816
>>283666324
this is what majority of /a/ looks like btw
Anonymous No.283668816 [Report] >>283668840 >>283669196
>>283668783
/a/ is female?
Anonymous No.283668818 [Report]
>>283665621
She could capture my cards, if you know what i mean
Anonymous No.283668840 [Report] >>283669196
>>283668816
I'd be amazed if /a/ was more than 10% female.
Anonymous No.283668950 [Report] >>283669152 >>283669406
>>283665621
>implying you need magic to be a magical girl
Anonymous No.283669058 [Report] >>283669210
>>283665584
She's a child.
Anonymous No.283669061 [Report]
>>283666324
this has a strong "I read 3 pages of Marx and now I'm an expert" stench coming off it
Anonymous No.283669090 [Report]
You don't have to act like that Astro Boy is greatest piece of fiction but you have to acknowledge it's historic impact on anime as a whole. The same is true for Mahou Tsukai Sally for it's impact on mahou shoujo's
Anonymous No.283669148 [Report]
>>283666324
>video is a month old
>the vast majority of the comments are a day old
So a literal who made a shit video someone found it out and got made oh wow
Anonymous No.283669151 [Report]
>>283667766
I don't think she's a troon. I think she's just really fucking ugly.
Anonymous No.283669152 [Report]
>>283668950
To be fair half the tricks she does are impossible magic shit anyway.
Anonymous No.283669163 [Report] >>283669181 >>283669188 >>283669201 >>283669569 >>283670012
At this point, what DOES count as a magical girl?
Anonymous No.283669170 [Report] >>283669235 >>283669273 >>283673433
We can ALL agree that Sakura is the sexiest mahou shoujo right?
Anonymous No.283669181 [Report]
>>283669163
Real magical girl anime has never been tried.
Anonymous No.283669188 [Report]
>>283669163
People are saying Rayearth girls are magical girls(crazy)
Anonymous No.283669196 [Report] >>283672846
>>283668816
>>283668840
Fucking newfags. We're all little girls here
Anonymous No.283669201 [Report]
>>283669163
generally, it requires a girl, who does magic, and the target audience is either little girls or middle aged men. basically the only disqualifier is if the target audience is young boys.
Anonymous No.283669210 [Report]
>>283669058
Out of ten!
Anonymous No.283669219 [Report]
Someone post that HOEEEEEE compilation
Anonymous No.283669235 [Report] >>283670417
>>283669170
Nod!
Anonymous No.283669238 [Report]
>>283667750
>do better
>by posting slop
kill yourself
Anonymous No.283669266 [Report] >>283669330 >>283669362
https://youtu.be/qounMTmUnAk?si=yEY3OFoA8PwkcTQi
Posting this kino so others can enjoy it too.
Anonymous No.283669273 [Report]
>>283669170
go to bed Tomoyo, you shouldn't be posting on /a/
Anonymous No.283669307 [Report] >>283669328 >>283669557
Basically, 'magical girl' is a aesthetic, rather than a genre?
Anonymous No.283669328 [Report]
>>283669307
its a genre defined by its aesthetics.
Anonymous No.283669330 [Report] >>283669344
>>283669266
It's Tiktok shit but ngl it's ludo.
Anonymous No.283669344 [Report]
>>283669330
>ludo
Anonymous No.283669347 [Report] >>283669578
Does Sakura have a official outfit?
Anonymous No.283669349 [Report] >>283669390
>>283666033
Clow Staff just absolutely mogging the other 2. Star Staff did okay though.
Anonymous No.283669362 [Report]
>>283669266
Oh hey that's pretty neat.
Anonymous No.283669388 [Report]
>>283665539 (OP)
Maybe they mean this kind of magical girl
Anonymous No.283669390 [Report]
>>283669349
Dream Staff looks way too menacing with all those spikes. It looks like a fucking mace.
Anonymous No.283669406 [Report]
>>283668950
she has the power of our Lord Jesus Christ and a fetish for being captured and abused by her boyfriend
Anonymous No.283669437 [Report] >>283669522
What's the best original series Sakura release to download or buy?
Any re-releases, remasters etc?
Anonymous No.283669522 [Report] >>283669579 >>283669606
>>283669437
I always recommend the 2018 remaster. It’s crisp and the colors are closer to the original cels.
Anonymous No.283669557 [Report] >>283673470
>>283669307
You know, that's not a bad assessment either. Cutie Honey is probably the best case to look at. Most of the series in the franchise are aimed at boys, Honey doesn't have magical powers but is an android and it is closer to a tokusatsu than a magical girl.
At the same time, Cutie Honey brought in the transformation element that would influence future magical girl series, expanded on Princess Knight's aspect of fighting girls, had a 90s series that was very much closer in theme to magical girl aspects and it has also been associated a lot with classic "majokko" series, especially the 1999 PS1 game Majokko Daikasuken.
On technicalities, it's not a magical girl franchise, but aesthetic-wise, it's still very magical girl.
Anonymous No.283669558 [Report]
>>283666324
>She
Anonymous No.283669569 [Report]
>>283669163
Vibes.
Anonymous No.283669576 [Report] >>283670335
>>283667804
Heartcatch is the only conventionally good one. The rest are very obvious kodomo anime.
Anonymous No.283669578 [Report]
>>283669347
Technically no but her Vol1/OP1 outfit is the most iconic, even though she never actually wore it in-story.
Anonymous No.283669579 [Report] >>283669627
>>283669522
holy SHIT youre fuckijg retraded
Anonymous No.283669606 [Report]
>>283669522
Right looks soulless
Anonymous No.283669627 [Report] >>283669671 >>283669684
>>283669579
>pissfilterfag
Anonymous No.283669671 [Report] >>283669824
>>283669627
right unironically looks washed out, even if it is crisper
Anonymous No.283669675 [Report]
>nobody said "she is a kaiju"
/a/ is lost
Anonymous No.283669684 [Report] >>283669824 >>283669891
>>283669627
Not saying you're wrong but in cases like this how does one find out which colours are closest to the original?
Anonymous No.283669724 [Report]
Man sunday threads are top bad.
Anonymous No.283669824 [Report] >>283669846 >>283671773 >>283672104 >>283674662
>>283669671
>>283669684
Since I own a cel from the show, I can easily compare it with a screencap from the 2018 remaster.
Anonymous No.283669846 [Report]
>>283669824
And yes, the 2018 remaster’s colors are much closer to the original cels.
Anonymous No.283669891 [Report] >>283674276
>>283669684
You could look at the actual cels, but then, cels were often painted in a way to give a certain feel when watched on a CRT TV in standard definition. That and the sources TV stations used for content were tapes, and those tapes could deteriorate over time so there's no guarantee at any given time what you would be watching on TV would be representative of other viewings. That and the inherent differences between VHS, laserdisc, DVD, and bluray.
Anonymous No.283669896 [Report]
Birdy is a magical girl anime.
Anonymous No.283669928 [Report] >>283669967 >>283670100 >>283671714
>nuke the one piece flag thread
>but leave this twitter thread up
Bravo jannies
Anonymous No.283669959 [Report]
>>283666558
feetkura hnnng, I job every time
Anonymous No.283669967 [Report]
>>283669928
>nuke the one piece thread
based as fuck
only subhuman monkeys watch that shit
Anonymous No.283670012 [Report]
>>283669163
Anonymous No.283670035 [Report] >>283672126
https://aniplexfan.wordpress.com/2018/01/14/cardcaptor-sakura-blu-ray-box-a-new-generation-master-version-4k-scan-of-the-original-35mm-nega-film/
Anonymous No.283670042 [Report]
Tomoyo and Sakura must play rough. There's always heavy breathing coming from the room they're playing in. They should be more ladylike and play with dolls or something.
Anonymous No.283670059 [Report] >>283670136
When this boy was lusting over Yukito because of moon magic, do you think he wanted to suck his dick or be fucked in the ass? Or did he want to being in a dominant position?
Anonymous No.283670068 [Report]
nobody’s saying that, this thread is just an advertisement thread for that twitter account
Anonymous No.283670100 [Report]
>>283669928
To be fair, One Piece is level 1 cancer.
Anonymous No.283670136 [Report]
>>283670059
I think he wanted to be sodomized like the little faggot he is
Anonymous No.283670150 [Report] >>283673711
A Magical girl must be stronk!
Anonymous No.283670165 [Report]
>>283666324
not even a single mention of Minky Momo. what worthless video
Anonymous No.283670197 [Report]
Anonymous No.283670335 [Report] >>283670509 >>283670511
>>283669576
Heartcatch was also too kodomo for me to finish.
Anonymous No.283670417 [Report] >>283671309
>>283669235
sauce?
Anonymous No.283670509 [Report]
>>283670335
I enjoyed Heartcatch until Cure Poochie... i mean Sunshine showed up.
Anonymous No.283670511 [Report]
>>283670335
ED2 slaps harder than it had any right to.
Anonymous No.283670574 [Report] >>283670777
>>283666324
I swear the most annoying takes about magical girls come from people that like Utena
Anonymous No.283670617 [Report] >>283670658
>>283665539 (OP)
Sakura only fucks shotas
Anonymous No.283670658 [Report] >>283671796
>>283670617
Chinese shotas
Anonymous No.283670777 [Report]
>>283670574
I don't even know why people think Utena is a magical girl anime. It has some things you can point to, like something that resembles a transformation sequence, but magical girl anime aren't the only anime with transformation sequences. And the on in Utena doesn't resemble what you typically think of with magical girl transformations. And other than that it basically has nothing in common with a magical girl anime.
Anonymous No.283670932 [Report]
>>283666008
her wand thingy has a transformation sequence, that makes her legit
Anonymous No.283671309 [Report]
>>283670417
https://kemono.cr/fanbox/user/5293337/post/8960801
Ignore the shota porn
Anonymous No.283671418 [Report]
>>283666008
>if a girl that uses magic doesn't have a self-transformation sequence then she's not a magical girl
>if a bug that has six legs doesn't undergo complete metamorphosis then it's not an insect
Anonymous No.283671630 [Report] >>283671888 >>283674699
>>283666008
The progenitor of the genre was recently translated and has no transformation sequence
https://mangadex.org/title/08a46a96-169b-4cb0-8813-1b3b50c53d79/sally-the-witch
Anonymous No.283671664 [Report] >>283671670
Anonymous No.283671670 [Report]
>>283671664
I was hoping someone would post this since I always forget to save it.
Anonymous No.283671714 [Report]
>>283669928
They can't nuke this one because it became the general.
Anonymous No.283671773 [Report]
>>283669824
100% jelly
Anonymous No.283671778 [Report] >>283672060
>>283668714
>Majokko rhythm/dress-up games
Huh. Didn't expect that kind of evolution I'll be honest.
Anonymous No.283671796 [Report]
>>283670658
Gay Chinese shotas
Anonymous No.283671874 [Report]
>>283666324
>"male gaze" mentioned unironically 40 seconds in
Annnnnnnd close tab.
Anonymous No.283671888 [Report] >>283671949 >>283672026
>>283671630
>>283666008
These arguments always devolve into alignment chart-esque bullshit where it's only the autists that argue things in the "rebel/radical/anarchy" categories count as magical girl stories. Things like Sally and Cardcaptor already fit into the "purist" category in some form with the little girls helping people, demographic, and themes of the stories.
Anonymous No.283671924 [Report]
>>283668278
>A franchise that monopolized the magical girl genre for kids by making billions a year that no other compaies are bothering to produce toyetic kodomo mahou shoujo anymore
You'd think that's something to fucking bring up in a Youtube video about magical girls.
Anonymous No.283671949 [Report]
>>283671888
Trips don't lie.
Anonymous No.283671952 [Report] >>283672164
>giving the bitch even more attention
Anonymous No.283672026 [Report] >>283672473
>>283671888
Is there a chart like this for magical girls? I think it would be interesting. You could have one axis be themes/aesthetics and the other be structure. So Madoka would be thematically/aesthetically purist but structurally rebellious while something like Utena would be both thematically/aesthetically and structurally rebellious.
Anonymous No.283672060 [Report]
>>283671778
It makes way more sense when you look at the direction the genre was already headed in before Sailor Moon. It was slowly getting consumed by fantasy stories about girls using magic to become idols, like Fancy Lala and Creamy Mami.
Anonymous No.283672104 [Report]
>>283669824
did you ever ejaculate on one of these Sakura cels?
Anonymous No.283672126 [Report]
>>283670035
I can't find where to buy it where I live...
Anonymous No.283672164 [Report]
>>283671952
Anonymous No.283672184 [Report]
>>283667418
Most magical girl shows can trace their main elements back to Sally the Witch or Cutie Honey
Anonymous No.283672303 [Report]
>>283668714
CHII CHII CHII
Anonymous No.283672317 [Report] >>283672456
Anonymous No.283672456 [Report]
>>283672317
You CANNOT just post that
Anonymous No.283672473 [Report] >>283672668
>>283672026
Here is one that makes the axis aesthetics and themes. I personally feel Yuri Kuma is a poor fit for aesthetic radical because I feel it still uses a lot of imagery of mahou shoujo. Maybe something like Burn the witch would be better?
Aesthetically it doesn't use transformations or anything overly girly but themes of friendship, love and teamwork are present if presented with more of a shonen edge.
Anonymous No.283672668 [Report] >>283672736
>>283672473
There's so many magical girl and magical girl adjacent series you could probably make dozens of these kinds of charts with different combinations of series. I might take this chart and try to make my own, since I haven't seen half the series on this chart. And I still think Utena should go in radical for both, if it's put on the chart at all.
Anonymous No.283672736 [Report]
>>283672668
Honestly, I think Kill La Kill would make more sense in the middle slot.
Anonymous No.283672846 [Report]
>>283669196
I wish to be the little girl
Anonymous No.283672944 [Report]
I really really really like this picture
Anonymous No.283673207 [Report]
I want to hold him down and sniff his hair
Anonymous No.283673433 [Report] >>283673481 >>283674453
>>283669170
Absolutely. Kuro ain't got shit on her.
Anonymous No.283673453 [Report]
Is Flying Witch a magical girl series?
Anonymous No.283673470 [Report] >>283673574
>>283669557
Cutie honey just straight up isn't a magical girl. .
Anonymous No.283673481 [Report]
>>283673433
Damn, how shallow is that pool?
Anonymous No.283673556 [Report] >>283673659
>hurr she's actually a witch/sorceress
HOW COULD LOCALIZATION EVER THINK THIS WAS A FANTASY ADVENTURE SHOW
Anonymous No.283673574 [Report]
>>283673470
Toei just pretends it is because it was EXTREMELY popular in the 70s when their Majokko stuff was airing, so they could sell more merchandise of the others by including her. It's worth noting that every one of Toei's original Majokko series aired in the same timeslot (when one ended, another would start, like modern Pretty Cure). The only two exceptions were Cutie Honey and one other random show.
Anonymous No.283673659 [Report]
>>283673556
It's not that the localizers thought that, it's that they wanted it to be and tried to make it one. They renamed it Cardcaptors to make it sound like Sakura wasn't the only one looking for the cards to play up some connection with Pokemon's capturing aspect that was popular at the time. And so that boys might watch it too.
Anonymous No.283673711 [Report]
>>283670150
Who is the target demographic for this? It feels like no one would be into this.
Anonymous No.283674276 [Report]
>>283669891
I didn't understand my problem with the remaster until looking at this image. The remaster ruins the lighting by making everything overly clear and crisp.
Anonymous No.283674453 [Report]
>>283673433
>posting slop
Come the fuck on dude
Anonymous No.283674481 [Report]
Anonymous No.283674515 [Report] >>283674572
>>283667686
If you're gonna be a faggot about it don't even respond.
Anonymous No.283674572 [Report]
>>283674515
A tripfag who thinks CCS is the first mahou shoujo doesn't deserve to be graced with a real response.
Anonymous No.283674662 [Report]
>>283669824
Never seen someone shut up assmad contrarians so quickly and decisively with one post as I have with this one. Bravo, anon. Capital stuff.
Anonymous No.283674697 [Report]
platinum > *
Anonymous No.283674699 [Report]
>>283671630
I didn't realise Sally was an actual fucking demon
Anonymous No.283674731 [Report]
>>283665588
Some dated boomer idol
Anonymous No.283674779 [Report]
>>283668067
BTW, I remember seeing them when I was a child in Italy.
Akko-chan has a really good op in Italian
Anonymous No.283674803 [Report]