>>283696508
Shitnuki is an egoistical shitter who thinks he can create rules for thee and not me. He insults anyone that calls him out on his trash takes yet has the audacity to believe he is above everyone else and can ban people for daring to make fun of him.
I need to send a letter to Kawaguchi to convince him to make a manga like Red Sonja or Xena: Warrior Princess for his 3rd serialisation. Fuck them shotas.
KINO Piece
Me & RoboKINO
SaKINOto Days
The Elusive Samurai
KINO Watch
BLEAK Box
AKINO-baNINO
Nue's Exorcist
KINObachi
Ultimate Exorcist KINOshi
Hima-Ten!
Ichi the WINNER
KINObi Undercover
Otr of the Flame
KINOkaze Mound
KIKINO Kaisen Modulo
SomeWON Hertz
Gonron Egg
The CHAD Next Door
Hero Girl and Demon Lord Call It Quits
>>283696969
I just really like the art and the stylized frames and stuff
And the Nordic setting
I would very much like something that's beautiful in a way that's not what everyone else is doing to get a chance to shine
And for the Viking stuff to get better representation than Vinland Saga
Man Vinland was so disappointing...
>>283697053
The nordic setting is completely wasted on Otr. It's literally just a bunch of random terms and names thrown at the screen without any rhyme or reason. It doesn't comply with nordic mythology in any way. It's just decoration. Ice Head Gilly, or whatever the fuck, was better.
>>283697076
I hated purposefully avoided any discussion about Vinland Saga on /a/ while I was reading it, and I concluded on my own that it was trash written by a man who doesn't understand any of the themes he thinks he's being clever and profound with, and has a worldview that makes him incapable of portraying the warrior spirit as anything but cartoonishly stupid and evil
>>283697133
It's stylistically inspired by it, not even trying to be a direct representation of it.
I don't think that's a bad thing.
Unlike, again, Vinland Saga, which went extremely into depth but in the end just made it that much worse with the way it disrespected it.
>>283697189
If you want to be "stylistically inspired", create your own names and terms and places, that are inspired by the whatever. You can't just lift the whole terminology and famous names, use them randomly, and say you're inspired. Looks in fact like you're uninspired.
>>283697241
Maybe the names and terms you use for things should be different if they aren't a direct 1 to 1 representation
Or maybe the familiarity with them allows the audience to draw upon their outside knowledge and quickly understanding the concepts you're introducing with less time required for you to build up those associations through exposition
It's a case by case basis
One of the kinds of questions you have to ask when you write fantasy >Looks in fact like you're uninspired.
I'm sorry, was that supposed to mean something in this context, or did you just fall face down in the mud while grasping for an insult?
>>283697280 >>283697323
Is Shinuki secretly a mod seething about getting mocked on this board? Because no other mangahelper or xitter schizo has posts deleted about them.
>>283697241 >You can't just lift the whole terminology and famous names
Yes you can. You wanna know how many nords through history have named their boys Thor and their girls Freya?
dear kawaguchi, i hope if you still have an energy to get your 3rd serialization, please do it outside WSJ because frankly your fans are fucking delusional and ruining the thread because of that.
>>283697438
eat piss kawagushit, I hope you are blacklisted from making a 3rd serialization, and I mean industry wide because your fans are as fucking delusional as you thinking that you could every create a success of any kind and have to cope to deny reality by shitting this thread up because of that.
I have one crazy idea about Kawaguchi
What if, instead of cattering to fujos and ditching lolis and big muscle mommies, he actually wrote a good story, fixed his pacing and drew better designs?
I know, wild, but I think it might work
>>283697593 >>283697613
Every single popular manga from the 2010s is a retread of older stuff with good execution. There isn't a food story just good execution.
>>283697595 >One good page and 17 mediocre >Sword Saint in person is Might Guy instead of Madara or Itachi - instant loss of aura >Yura peed his pants >Azami is barely explored character so his performance lands on a dry soil >Timing of Uncle reveal is bad
This is the chapter of missed opportunities and letdowns.
>>283697737
just think it's funny that manga is almost completely undetected in shoseki. i checked its first vol and it only had one entry in daily shoseki.
>>283697646 >Every single popular manga from the 2010s is a retread of older stuff with good execution
You should read more than goon shit anon. Thats called the hero's journey, almost every story in the past 5000 years or so follows the same structure. Everything else is just flavoring and sauce
>>283698023 >>283698043 >Thats called the hero's journey, almost every story in the past 5000 years or so follows the same structure.
And? You do understand you just agreed with my point that a good story is not needed in JUMP right? or did you just bring up 'le hero's journey' to stroke your own ego.
>>283698543
You've got things backward. Saito didn't give Kawaguchi a chance, Kawaguchi gave Saito a chance. Nakano fucked up hard when he axed red hood and Saito learned from his mistake.
>>283698574 >Nakano fucked up hard when he axed retard hood and Saito learned from his mistake.
Lol, the only fuck up was giving Kawagushit a chance in the first place, let alone giving him another chance. Retard Hood was a dumpster fire that only sold 4k and was rightfully axed for being dogshit. Saito, the incompetent buffoon he is, let Kawagushit create another manga instead of canning it immediately. Now Oturd has lowered the standard even further by allowing a 2k selling (worse than gushits previous U19 disaster mind you) to live. Kawagushit shouldn't be allowed back into Jump or any magazine for that matter, the only place where he belongs is on the floor drinking saki.
>>283698620 >gonron 60k
In you dreams eggfag. Egg will be the first of the batch to go, while Hero Girl and Demon Lord will survive from from nips shit taste. Meanwhile, you will be seething.
>>283698465
Why WSJ only get absolute dogshit artist as newbies?
Like, having a shitty plot and pacing, fair enough. But they can't get someone that excel on the art department at very least?
>>283698634
I doubt that anon, a 10k boost for a high profile battle shounen from jump getting an anime announcement? That's way too low. >>283698798
I think you're underestimating it instead, it's not far off what jjk did back before it got its anime announced. >>283698750
From the release order we already know Saito prefers Gonron over jk yusha. A fantasy adventure is a safer bet.
