A serious good faith objection to ethical veganism - /an/ (#5015668) [Archived: 146 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/13/2025, 3:19:39 PM No.5015668
Spray-Agriculture-Wheat-Farm-Farmer-Pest-Fertilizer-1223856508
Crop deaths

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fS4fd67aJ4c

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sMqdYsTaw9Y

Sorry too much to put in text but it's not the standard crop death argument
Crop deaths do seem to cause more suffering and death then grass fed pasture raised beef
So they fail utilitarianism

They also seem to lead to more rights violations because of all the wild herbivorous animals that are killed that aren't even attacking crops

So unless vegans are advocating for people to starve to death I see a contradiction

Why don't vegans focus on making synthetic food out of inorganic material like rocks and sand?
Replies: >>5015672 >>5015717 >>5016644
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 3:50:50 PM No.5015672
>>5015668 (OP)
>So unless vegans are advocating for people to starve to death
There is not much human empathy in vegans to begin with. They are not a broad spectrum compassionate about life. Just this narrow spectrum they consider themselves personally responsible for. What the farms do they don't care about as long as they're not eating a dead animal which again is an incredibly narrow and callous way to view ecosystems or life in general.
Replies: >>5015680 >>5015777
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 4:18:20 PM No.5015680
>>5015672
That's a straw man
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:49:39 PM No.5015717
>>5015668 (OP)
Also vegans advocate people not eat organic vegan food because it uses manure from factory farms for fertilizer which indirectly makes factory farming more profitable.
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:55:40 PM No.5015720
what about setting all the vegan or vegetarian or whatever shit aside an just focuse on what tortures and kills the least animals
Replies: >>5015723
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 7:00:51 PM No.5015722
Veganism is performative virtue signaling. There are no ethics to be found.

Also, humans are not trapped divine sparks. there are no souls here. there are no beings of light to ascend or be freed. there are no gods. there is no such thing as morals or ethics. only action, consequence, survival, reproduction, and death.

vegans are a cult with a birthrate of zero that is obligated by its beliefs to force other humans to starve.

under the objectively correct framework of pure material and consequence, where "ought" is not a high concept but rather a petulant faggot child sniveling that the world doesn't always make them feel good, there is nothing to do with a vegan but stuff their face with steak. whether an animals life has value or not depends on whether it is a good use of humanity's time and resources to end that life or preserve it, and what consequences that has for humanity as a whole.

there are very few species for which they are worth more dead than alive
and there are very few species with anything resembling moral consequence because of their anomalous relationship with human psychology (humans can lungshot deer many times a year without an increase in crime rates, humans who do this to cats have higher rates of rape, murder, and assault).
Replies: >>5015727
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 7:02:26 PM No.5015723
>>5015720
when are you going to stop treading on mites and squishing mosquitoes?
Replies: >>5015731
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 7:06:49 PM No.5015727
>>5015722
And how do you expect to convince the bumbling idiots that are over 50% of the population of the right thing to do to keep the most people alive, preferably everyones friends, and not everyones enemies, without spooks like morals, ethics, and religion
Replies: >>5016427
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 7:18:28 PM No.5015731
>>5015723
neither are sentient or have the capacity to experience pain
Replies: >>5015732
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 7:21:33 PM No.5015732
>>5015731
You don't know if anything is sentient or not
Unless you would like to now claim to be a religious prophet who has spoken with a god or gods, prove that a mosquito experiencing pain or not has any relevance to the survival of my bloodline and I, followed by my friends and my people

To be "good" according to made up bullshit, in the absence of a higher power, is a waste of time. The only higher power being pleased is your ego and the meaningfulness of your actions does not exist outside of your head.
Replies: >>5015766
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:05:13 PM No.5015766
>>5015732
I do have access to a higher power, god has written everything I need to know on a stone tablet, but only I can read it. He says you're a faggot and squishing mosquitoes is ok
Replies: >>5016428
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:16:42 PM No.5015777
>>5015672
You need to leave your house once in a while, you spend way too much time on the internet and no I'm not a vegan, but you're clearly a shutin who forms all opinions based on things he sees online
Replies: >>5015780 >>5016425
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:28:53 PM No.5015780
>>5015777
whenever someone says this you know the person they’re trying to shit on is right

vegans are virtue clowns. its an act. most of them are bored narcissistic bourgies. their children end up short dumb and ugly. every damn time.
Replies: >>5015794
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:00:32 PM No.5015794
>>5015780
>my sample group? Americans
Yeah no thats just the average countryman to you, not limited to vegans
Replies: >>5016577
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 10:49:32 PM No.5016425
>>5015777
Crop fields kill way more creatures than livestock slaughter. So vegans consider large animals more worthy and important than the billions of insects and small buggers killed every time a crop field is worked? They have no moral standards
Replies: >>5016542
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 10:50:52 PM No.5016427
>>5015727
police/military force
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 10:52:10 PM No.5016428
>>5015766
lmao
Anonymous
7/15/2025, 3:01:35 AM No.5016542
>>5016425
>cows eat air
Retard.
Anonymous
7/15/2025, 4:45:32 AM No.5016577
>>5015794
The few vegans that aren't schizos or clowns are just wrong about fad diets
Anonymous
7/15/2025, 6:09:47 AM No.5016644
>>5015668 (OP)
No it isn't.

Threadly Reminder: cattle ranchers and hunters have INSANE lobbying power in america. They're almost solely the reason that all "nature" and "animal welfare" agencies in america exist to kill animals and destroy Nature.
Replies: >>5016648
Anonymous
7/15/2025, 6:11:47 AM No.5016648
>>5016644
This is paleoschizo off his meds btw. This is his alternate conspiracy theory when his clarity of thought is too poor to discuss dinosaurs.

You can trigger him by saying wolf reintroduction's benefits are hard fact and are not up for debate.