← Home ← Back to /cm/

Thread 3986419

22 posts 18 images /cm/
Anonymous No.3986419 [Report] >>3987180
Still You - vote for childhood BL manga to get serialized
Anonymous No.3986420 [Report]
Anonymous No.3986421 [Report]
Anonymous No.3986422 [Report]
Anonymous No.3986423 [Report]
Anonymous No.3986424 [Report] >>3986436 >>3986511
You can read the whole oneshot here:
https://young-magazine-usa.com/

You can vote once per day for which manga should get serialized. If you enjoyed this one - please vote!
Anonymous No.3986436 [Report]
>>3986424
>"hmmm I wonder what the other ones are like?"
>click on one
>literal tranny shit on the first page
I wasn't entirely sold on the Still You one because of them being aged up (shota x shota romance never ever). But I'll still gladly vote for highschooler BL over that plague.
Anonymous No.3986511 [Report] >>3987633
>>3986424
I wanted to read everything before voting, and these are my thoughts:
>Into the Dark
Generic edgy Fujimoto-like slop. Matsui wasn't lying when he said in another contest that newbies today only make Chainsaw Man clones. One of the shotas even dies horribly, making this a bad manga to me.
>Boys Run the Riot
Literal tranny propaganda drawn by a tranny. I wouldn't be surprised if a twitter cabal spams votes to make this oneshot win only for it to flop in views and sales because nobody reads tranny shit.
>To Dusk and Twilight
Generic romcom between a jaded man and a quirky girl. Pass.
>KIKIKAIKAI
Generic exorcist slop with unlikable characters and awful action sequences. Nope.
>Protocol Ryugu
This one has potential to be really good. A war between two subspecies of humans that evolved in completely different ways sounds interesting, and deep sea monsters always are cool. I hope that if this one wins the author gets to explain in detail how their biology and technology works.
>The Graveyard Shift
The thumbnail is completely misleading. I thought it was going to be about skeleton warriors, but it's just a gag manga about an ancient ghost and a wagie robot from the future.
>PROJECT METALLIA
This one is cool too, like an American action movie. I think it's fit for a short serialization with no more than 60 chapters.
>The Knight of Blasphemy
Holy fujobait, literally. The plot is nothing special, but I can see this gaining lots of votes just for the art and the boys. The protagonist even looks like an older Tanjiro, and with the new KnY movie breaking records it may help the manga to get more votes.
>Godmother
The art is beautiful and cool, but honestly I didn't find the story very interesting (grandma kidnaps her granddaughter to train her as a ghost caretaker).
>Fasciation
This one has potential too if it doesn't go full battle shonen and focuses on the two girls traveling through the new old world and trying to survive encounters with monsters and humans.
Anonymous No.3986512 [Report]
>The Journey of a Dark Elf with Fading Powers
This is just Frieren with a genki MC instead of a gloomy one and with more blatant yuribait. "Enough with This Slow Life!" is a better manga about a (male) elf with long life wandering around the world.
>Is My Love Strange?
This is a story about two furfags dressed in the kind of pretty art that you could find on tumblr 15 years ago, and from its story alone I can't imagine it lasting more than 10 chapters.
>GOUMA The Blade that Slaughters Gods
More exorcist slop, now with characters that look like JJK background characters with Skyrim mods on top of them.
>Pregnant
This is another manga with an interesting premise that should keep a low chapter count to avoid dragging the story.
>THE LAST TERRAN
I like the art and the thriller premise doesn't sound bad, but I mecha is one of the genres that immediately bore me.
>Still You
It's a generic yaoi romcom, but I think I would read a serialization if there was a bigger focus on the characters when they were kids and the issues and experiences they had before and after that first kiss.

IMO Fasciation is the best one shot in general, followed by Protocol Ryugu and The Knight of Blasphemy.
Anonymous No.3986675 [Report]
It's in top 5 currently, and it seems to be either 1st or 2nd, so hopefully it stays that way until November
Anonymous No.3987180 [Report] >>3987252 >>3987521
>>3986419 (OP)
I'm so sick of the fag grows up and gets a girlfriend to blend trope. Can they cut it out with this slop already?
Anonymous No.3987252 [Report] >>3987304
>>3987180
>I hate when fiction is realistic
Anonymous No.3987304 [Report]
>>3987252
>wanting fiction to be realistic
You're the problem with manga, why do slop lovers like you always want to involve women into gay shit.
It's like you're women yourselves or bifaggots that don't actually like men.
Anonymous No.3987521 [Report] >>3987557
>>3987180
To be fair, he did drop her with 0 effort immediately
Anonymous No.3987557 [Report]
>>3987521
That's true but the ending doesn't give me much confidence this won't turn into a weird love triangle with the girl.
Anonymous No.3987633 [Report] >>3987649 >>3987792
>>3986511
Boy Run the Riot sounds kino
Anonymous No.3987649 [Report]
>>3987633
It's a sequel to a story about a FtM tranny, which makes it unique compared to the other oneshots which are self-contained stories (like Still You) or narrated as the first chapter of a serialization.

btw, an anon is storytiming every participant manga. You can read Boys Run the Riot here: >>>/a/282183405
And Still You (storytimed two days ago) here: >>>/a/282091932
Anonymous No.3987792 [Report] >>3987815
>>3987633

I disagree, I feel like either the girl's story is over, or the ML will try to convince MC to get back with the girl, so that he can be 'normal', but MC will be completely not interested at all
Anonymous No.3987815 [Report]
>>3987792
Either of those options are what's obviously going to happen
Anonymous No.3987821 [Report] >>3988403
I find funny that Still You falls to 2nd place after Godmother (love the art style, but I'm tired of stories about normal teen girls being forced to deal with spooks) during euro hours, but immediately recovers the first place as soon as americans wake up.
Also Knight of BL-ASS-phemy overtook discount Frieren and is now in 3rd place.
Anonymous No.3988403 [Report] >>3988408
>>3987821
Isn't the MC for the knight one a girl?
Anonymous No.3988408 [Report]
>>3988403
Looks male to me.
I think the author simply likes to draw men with girly faces. The blondie in this pic is a man too.