← Home ← Back to /co/

Thread 149018701

47 posts 20 images /co/
Anonymous No.149018701 >>149018724 >>149018828 >>149018870 >>149018874 >>149019191 >>149020507 >>149020541 >>149020551
Uncanny X-Men
Genuine question, is this lorebreaking? I thought the story was that people didn't know mutants existed until recently, but all of a sudden they were commonplace knowledge to the point that cemeteries would refuse to take them a century ago?
Anonymous No.149018724 >>149018759 >>149018828
>>149018701 (OP)
Mutant awareness skyrocketed worldwide in contemporary times but they were always a thing throughout history, just in isolated pockets and not widely known
Anonymous No.149018746 >>149018759 >>149018828 >>149019726
She says right there they weren't called "mutants" but witches so yeah it doesn't contradict anything.
Anonymous No.149018759 >>149018823 >>149018870 >>149018973
>>149018724
>>149018746
After seeing how badly Simone assassinated Rogue's character in Raid on Graymalkin I assumed the worst, but I guess it makes sense.
Anonymous No.149018823 >>149019482
>>149018759
qrd?
Anonymous No.149018828 >>149018852
>>149018701 (OP)
>>149018724
>>149018746
It's always funny when an ignorant writer meets their equal in their readership.
If mutants were real, specifically the heavily mutated ones would've been priced subject of menagerie collections and art.
Anonymous No.149018851 >>149018905
are you one of those "mutants only showed up after the Cold War" retards?
Anonymous No.149018852
>>149018828
Mutants were real and they existed in circus freak shows.
Anonymous No.149018870 >>149019849
>>149018701 (OP)
There are buildings in this country and instillations that are much much older then the supposed founding of america and unbelievably advanced.
Many of them suck underneath lakes or hidden in plain sight.

Mutants being treated the same as any super being, mystical being, or named something else and treated differently compared to mutants are now is not a stretch at all.

>>149018759
The moment Rogue got their ability to touch she broke up with gambit to go fuck magneto in a fucking holocaust museum. Became able to use every single power she ever copied ever at any time and was seen as a massive bitch by EVERYONE for years.

Rogue has been ruined forever in comics. And Xmen97 permanently ruined her in the eyes of the very audience that made her popular.

You can't fuck up a flaming dumpster.
Anonymous No.149018874
>>149018701 (OP)
>Genuine question, is this lorebreaking?
No, but it doesn't make any sense, which is fine for the genre and the audience.
Anonymous No.149018905
>>149018851
"Children of the Atom" used to MEAN something.

Though today they should probably call themselves "Children of Vaccination" and move their date of emergence back to 16th century China.
Anonymous No.149018933 >>149018943 >>149018994
Mutants are so sexy. Why are we flatscans so lame?
Anonymous No.149018943
>>149018933
The ugly ones have a pool of their own.
Anonymous No.149018973 >>149019411
>>149018759
No, you're just a casual retard
Anonymous No.149018994 >>149019220
>>149018933
Who is the guy above Nightcrawler’s head?
Thunderbird?
Anonymous No.149019155 >>149019190 >>149019218 >>149019220 >>149019242 >>149019411 >>149019746
Serious question, ya'll. They referred to Magneto as a Holocaust survivor, but I know that can't be right? That would make him way to old. Do writers not even do there research anymore, like?
Anonymous No.149019190
>>149019155
Capeshit characters are all functionally immortal and ageless and have a perfect recovery factor.

It's the basic set of powers you get from wearing your underwear over your pants.
Anonymous No.149019191
>>149018701 (OP)
They've always existed, it's just like other anons have said that they were identified as a witch or some kind of divine/demonic creature in different cultures. They didn't get a proper identification with all of humanity until Magneto had his historic chimpout trying to kill everybody.
Anonymous No.149019218
>>149019155
He was deaged to a baby once
Anonymous No.149019220
>>149018994
Yes, it's Jimmy

>>149019155
They have deaged him a couple of times before and Resurrection of Magneto made him to an ageless being
Anonymous No.149019242
>>149019155
Magneto was deaged in the past and was resurrected in a younger body recently.
Anonymous No.149019411 >>149019453 >>149019488 >>149020527
>>149018973
>>149019155
Why do you think I asked the experts, jackass? Since Marvel editorial cares more about ruining Spider-Man's life than keeping storytelling consistent, I'm not exactly inclined to give anyone other than Jonathan Hickman the benefit of the doubt.
Anonymous No.149019453 >>149019523
>>149019411
>other than Jonathan Hickman
He's the Gay Agenda guy.
Anonymous No.149019482 >>149019532 >>149022341
>>149018823
The Graymalkin arc was a disorganized mess; Kid Omega flat-out vanishes from the story halfway through, Rogue is a huge bitch to Cyclops for basically no reason and criticizes him for recruiting Magneto even though she fucked the guy herself, and it ended with the X-Men basically having accomplished nothing.
Anonymous No.149019488 >>149019523
>>149019411
>Jonathan Hickman
Lmao
Anonymous No.149019523 >>149020150
>>149019453
>>149019488
He saved X-Men and revived Ultimate Marvel with minimal cringe, in this house Jonathan Hickman is a hero, end of story.
Anonymous No.149019532
>>149019482
Always blame Brevoort.
Anonymous No.149019623 >>149019875
When the fuck is From The Ashes ending
This shit so ass
Anonymous No.149019726 >>149019817
>>149018746
Mutants themselves didn't know they were one specific thing though.

That's the lorebreak
Anonymous No.149019746
>>149019155
>ya'll
Go back
Anonymous No.149019817 >>149020255 >>149020497
>>149019726
Eh, depends. Apocalypse figured out what he was after seeing Essex's research back in the 19th century.
Anonymous No.149019849 >>149020061
>>149018870
>mfw my favorite character in comics is married to that dumpster fire so I have to keep inhaling copium that she's not as bad as people say and then when it seems like the writers are dialing her back some she turns around and does another cunt move every single fucking time
Anonymous No.149019875 >>149020093
>>149019623
I'll devil's advocate a touch and say I'm still enjoying parts of Uncanny, a couple of the new kids are fun, and Gambit fucking off to hang with a dragon was neat, I'm just hoping they actually do a few more passes on the plot ahead of them, since some of this really feels like a first draft for an arc
Anonymous No.149020061 >>149020166
>>149019849
If it makes you feel any better Simone is probably killing him off because nobody in Marvel other than the FF is allowed stable relationships.
Anonymous No.149020093
>>149019875
Deathdream is based and it's funny he became BFFs with Magik, one of the highlights of the Graymalkin arc
Anonymous No.149020150 >>149021500
>>149019523
>he saved X-Men
Did he?
Anonymous No.149020166
>>149020061
On one hand that's great since it could lead to him getting a solo run, on the other hand I do find the full factory reset route lame and would just prefer her not being fucking retarded for 5 seconds and actually give as much as Gambit does for the relationship
Anonymous No.149020255
>>149019817
Exactly. If it took Apocalypse that long it's not realistic most anybody else did, not in any organized way.

Mutants were RARE.
Anonymous No.149020497
>>149019817
They've tweaked that in recent years by adding stuff. Apocalypse met Essex back when, but by then Apocalypse had met thousands of other mutants and regarded them as one people.
Anonymous No.149020507
>>149018701 (OP)
No, the retcons happened during Morrison's run so that not only have there always been a huge amount of mutants but they were well-known enough to establish their own communities.
Anonymous No.149020527
>>149019411
Hickman is happy to trash any and all comics he works on to bend them to his big Image-reject sci-fi verse he knows will never sell on its own.
So he has to ruin 3-4 Marvel properties now to make it happen.
Anonymous No.149020541
>>149018701 (OP)
it's by simone so nobody cares.
Anonymous No.149020551
>>149018701 (OP)
Anon back then the learned men of the world proposed, claimed and sometimes believed that there were dog headed men, long eared people who wore their own ears as clothing, and people who had faces on their chest.

Not to say they didn't casually just believe it, many actually sought to prove or disprove their existence, explorers and missionaries wrote of how "Manticores" were actuallt tigers and "Sciapods" were actually indians who sat under trees and used umbrellas, an Emperor from the HRE i believe actually tried to check if the fabled barnacle birds of Ireland were real and came to the conclusion that they couldn't actually exist.

Furthermore people back then also believed shit like a book that would give you knowledge of everything, or people given holy visions, or vampires and werewolves, as revently as the 19th century someone got burnt for being a "vampire"

With this in mind, it's more likely that people "knew" of mutants under different names because a kid who can levitate objects is either a spawn of satan or given divine powers or are actually an angel in disguise.

and that's just the European perspective, what about other countries who had their own curiosities?
Anonymous No.149021127
Luv me prehistoric goof-up girl
Anonymous No.149021500
>>149020150
nta but yes, Krakoa only went to shit when he left and other writers didnt get the memo. it's their fault we've got people thinking a mutant ethnostate was a good thing when Hickman's whole deal was that it's a terrible idea
Anonymous No.149022341 >>149023526
>>149019482
oh I just realized why I didn't recognize anything you said, you're talking about the From the Ashes storylines. I stopped reading those since I didn't hear good things
Anonymous No.149023526
>>149022341
The main run with Cyclops is kino, Magik & Psylocke's solo runs are fun too. Everything else is just ok.