Thread 149287991

Does this belonged on /a/ or /co/?

>sonic
It belongs in the /trash/.

The episodes based on SA1/SA2 just make wish I was playing those games instead

>>149287991 (OP)
It belongs in the library of congress for being the source of vector's need to breed vanilla

I only like the gaming half of the Sonic franchise. Couldn't care less about the shows and comics.

>>149287991 (OP)
/tv/ for being the prototype of the movies
>sonic is an alien from another dimension that winds up on earth
>gets taken in by a human family as he's hiding from the feds

>>149287991 (OP)
This show is boring as fuck, and this is coming from someone who enjoyed the Shadow game, the 2006 reboot, and Secret Rings

>>149287991 (OP)
Could it go on /v/?

>>149287991 (OP)
>Does this belonged
Holy ESL, Batman!

>>149287991 (OP)
Does the Japanese IP animated in Japan by a Japanese studio, licensed by a company that exclusively imports and dubs Japanese shows, belong on the western comics and cartoon board? It's a mystery, almost as big a mystery as the cocks that disappear in OPs ass.

>>149287991 (OP)
Fun show.
Season 3 was peak kino.

>>149287991 (OP)
/a/ is /a/ dumbass

Season 3 counts as /co/

>>149287991 (OP)
Both.
>>149288416
What about the last season? That was made exclusively for America and is in the same camp as cartoons that were outsourced to Korea.
I think Sonic X should be an exception because it was also way more popular here too.

>>149288545
>>149288910
cosmo...

>>149287991 (OP)
How did eggman get to sonics dimension if he's from earth

>>149287991 (OP)
>The character that made me a furry.
I swear lipstick makes a character 100 percent more attractive idk why.

>>149288041
>>149288206
Vanilla wants Ultimate Lifeforms, not poor ass low wagers. She's maga not a lowly democrat.

>>149289166
Shadow is poorer than Vector is, manlet self-inserter. Unlike Vector he doesn’t even have a job or a house.

>>149288910
>>149288946
No exceptions
Not /co/
Fuck off

>>149289219
It's an exception!
LEAVE!
>>>/co/

>>149288946
Written, storyboarded, and directed by the Japanese
Not /co/
>think Sonic X should be an exception because it was also way more popular here too.
That opens the floodgates to MORE off topic bullshit
/co/ shouldn't be /a/'s dumping grounds of rejects
Piss off

>>149287991 (OP)
Even heavily flawed stuff like Heroes and Shadow 2005 had more effort put into them than this show ever did

>>149289166
Cream is cute CUTE!

>>149289233
Anon a lot of DIC cartoons were outsourced to Japan, so your argument means jackshit. And I'm sure spamming will get people to side with you so knock yourself out.

>>149289227
If we accept Sonic X as an exception we'll have to accept MORE anime as an exception
We can't lose our identity as a board because it raises the question on why /co/ should even exist and threads like these take space away from what could go to ACTUAL western comics and cartoons
Don't be an idiot
The last thing we need is more newfags who hate western comics and cartoons trying to turn /co/ into a general fiction board

>>149289245
>DIC
Still written and directed by the west

>>149289262
Yeah but it was animated by the Japanese.
I'm not arguing anymore, it's /co/ because of the archie comics and it's /co/ because Sonic is targeted towards the US.
Piss off, I could care less if this board got taken over by weebs.

>>149289237
She sure is!

>>149289274
>but it was animated by the Japanese
Make those DIC threads on /a/
See what happens
>I'm not arguing anymore, it's /co/ because of the archie comics
That's not how it works
Are American Spider-Man comics /a/ because Spider-Man manga exist?
>Piss off, I could care less if this board got taken over by weebs.
Then you are no /co/mrade you disgusting rat

Would someone mind please explaining why puppetry, picture books and other things that are neither comics nor cartoons are considered /co/?

Tails is one lucky motherfucker.

>>149289300
>Changing the subject
/a/
is
/a/

>>149287991 (OP)
Technically it's /a/, but /a/ don't like you discussing more "western" animes.
Anyway, if Sonic X lasted a few more seasons, how do you think it'd tackle games like Sonic Rush and Shadow the Hedgehog?

>>149289327
>Anyway, if Sonic X lasted a few more seasons, how do you think it'd tackle games like Sonic Rush and Shadow the Hedgehog?
Fuck off
>>>/a/

>>149289327
>Anyway, if Sonic X lasted a few more seasons, how do you think it'd tackle games like Sonic Rush and Shadow the Hedgehog?
They'd probably do what Viva Pinata did and incorporate some show related quests into the game and add some new characters to the show to tie in with the games.
Imagine Silver or Jet in Sonic X that would be crazy.

>>149289301
>that episode where Rouge molests Tails against his will in some dark secluded alley
>>149289048
Maybe it’s cause of all the Tim Burton style femme fatales from 90s toons, those characters know what they want

(I was thinking of redrawing this, either of you guys tell me if it’s a good idea? I was thinking her lips should stick onto Tails’ harder and maybe stretch his mouth when she moves back)

>>149289365
>I was thinking of redrawing this, either of you guys tell me if it’s a good idea? I was thinking her lips should stick onto Tails’ harder and maybe stretch his mouth when she moves back
Yes and her lipstick needs to be more shiny too.

>>149289327
They would probably just add Jet to the show.
>>149289365
Yes.

>>149289383
Shiny is nice! Makes them look more glossy/liquid. Good idea

>>149289365
>either of you guys tell me if it’s a good idea?
Take it somewhere else

>>149287991 (OP)
Boy, I wonder if the JAPANESE anime that was handled by a JAPANESE crew led by JAPANESE writers and directors would belong on /a/ or /co/?

Sonic X season 3 wasn’t even broadcasted in Japan until like 2 years ago.
It’s a japanese animation studio (but who have made multiple /co/cartoons before like SPIDERMAN) making a cartoon for America, with American actors, only broadcasted in America

>>149289448
>>149289490
We get it you hate /a/ fags, go to a thread that matters retard, if we talk about the 90s cartoons will you shut up?

>>149289490
Written, storyboarded, and directed by the Japanese dumbass
Make Spider-Man cartoon threads on /a/ using your logic
See what happens

>>149289448
We get it you hate /a/ fags, go to a thread that matters retard, if we talk about the 90s cartoons will you shut up?

>>149289506
Wasn't there a Spidey anime?

>>149289506
Exactly, except its directing and storyboarding came from the exact same studio as spiderman. Neither belong on /a/ cause they were both made for america

>>149289506
There was a Tom and Jerry thread there a few days ago so they'll allow it.
Spiderman has mangas you tard.
>>149289520
Yep, there was even a Captain Marvel anime where she actually looked hot.

>>149289529
>There was a Tom and Jerry thread there a few days ago so they'll allow it.
That was about the anime spin off dunderhead
Spider-Man TAS wouldn't get a pass

>>149289533
Well then make a thread on /a/ and prove me wrong. Until then shut up.

>>149289533
Why not? It had japanese animators, storyboarders, directors? Same as Sonic X. They were both just made for America, by japs

>>149289525
>Exactly, except its directing and storyboarding came from the exact same studio as spiderman
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0112175/fullcredits/
Oh yes, the Japanese director that is Bob Richardson and just look at all those Japanese storyboard credits amirite

>>149289542
You stupid fucking idiot
The ones who were on Spider-Man were outsourced assistant directors, not the primary leading ones
The storyboarders weren't Japanese

>>149289541
I'm not gonna make that thread because I know it's not /a/
You're too much of a fucking pussy to stand by what you believe in
Spider-Man TAS isn't /a/
Sonic X isn't /co/

I’m surprised people complain just cause the studio is japanese, America-japan collabs have been a thing since forever. Hell these same nips made Mighty Orbots, Spider-man, Bionic Six. Sega even hired the 4kids American actors to become the official voiceactors

>>149289547
But the animation was animated in Japan, also a director doesn't mean the director of all the animation dumbass, 95 percent of the crew who made it were Japanese, Sonic X had 4kids overlooking the last season and funded it.
They are very similar.
Actually study how the production of shit is made retard before you start sending IMDB links.

>>149289585
>complain
Bitch why do you think we have two separate boards?
Where do you draw the line if you keep blurring it to allow off-topic crap on /co/?

Would a non-Japanese but still Asian cartoon be on-topic for this board?

The wannabe janny's in top form today.

>>149289547
Doesn't know about Terushisa Yamji and Kuni Tomita.
There were still Japanese storyboard artists anon so technically it is /a/ or those episodes that they animated are.
That also means we can technically talk about One Piece because there are American artists working on it.

>>149289601
It’s not blurring anything to say an opaquely American-Japanese collaboration can belong on both. We have so many examples of those on /co/, Toei Animation worked on some of the biggest adventure shows of their decade including G.I. Joe and Transformers

The dumpster.

>>149289604
Yeees, they are supposed to be /co/.

>>149289655
So I could post a thread about a Korean webtoon without getting in trouble?

>>149289655
But what about if all the animation was outsourced to Japan but only being made for America and never airing in Japan? Would that be /co/ or would it be /a/?

>>149289660
Yep. I've seen Korean cartoons posted here before and people seem to like them.

>>149289624
That means we can also talk about Trigger shows as well as they too have american artists working for them

>>149289664
Are the writers, directors, etc still non-Japanese?

>>149287991 (OP)
The anime? No, the archie comics? Yes, either way idrgaf.
Only as an adult did I start to understand why people hate chris.

>>149289616
Do you WANT /co/ to be /a/'s dumpster?

>>149289635
MAKE THOSE SUNBOW SHOW THREADS ON /a/
IF THEY DONT TOLERATE THOSE
WE SHOULDNT TOLERATE SONIC X

>>149289593
>95 percent of the crew who made it were Japanese,
In that case, try talking about it on /a/
Do it faggot

>>149289742
They literally do “tolerate” them, there have been hundreds of G1 Transformers threads on /a/

>>149289801
Specific to the sunbow show and not Victory, Headmasters, etc?

>>149289739
At this point yes.
>>149289818
All of them anon.

>>149289327
The Sonic Battle adaptation in X was not accurate at all. If they did more adaptations they wouldn’t be accurate.

>>149290007
>All of them anon.
Checked Desuarchive
Most people there said Sunbow G1 belongs on /co/ but the JG1 anime is /a/

>>149290007
>At this point yes
Why?
We gain NOTHING
We lose EVERYTHING
If you want /co/ to be an extension of /a/ that means you hate /co/
Fuck off

>>149290063
I want it to be an extension if it means you fuck off. Now fuck off.

We literally had an Astroboy thread the other day nobody cared
>But but but it's the French show
Everyone talked about the 80s anime and the 2003 one mostly and everyone seemed to have fun for a bit

>>149290166
Yeah but the thread still opened and discussed the French show first
People bring up comics in Marvel game threads on /v/ but those threads don't start with the comics in mind
There's no retarded "honorary" bullshit involved

>>149290153
>Board quality is bad
Keep /a/ /a/
Keep /co/ /co/

If you have to wonder if something is /co/ or not, odds are IT'S NOT FUCKING /co/!

>>149290189
So if I post a western magical girl cartoon thread then we can talk about magical girl anime?
And Sonic X is honorary /co/.
Space Dandy could also count too because that show aired in America first this making it /co/

>>149290166
>Everyone talked about the 80s anime and the 2003 one mostly and everyone seemed to have fun for a bit
The 2003 one has the best looking visuals in my opinion. However Uran is cuter in the 80s one.

>>149287991 (OP)
I know nothing about Sonic but I remember watching AMVs about this show on youtube back in the mid 2000s

>>149290236
>So if I post a western magical girl cartoon thread then we can talk about magical girl anime?
Not how it works
Magical girl is a whole ass genre
That's like Anons on /a/ making MHA threads just to talk about Astro City
>honorary /co/
Mootykins isn't here anymore
Honorary /co/ is dead because of basic double standards
There's no honorary /v/, no honorary /a/, no honorary /tv/, etc

>>149290273
It's Honorary /co/ and no amount of crying is gonna change it.
The last season was literally funded by the west and aired only in the west. Japan didn't get the last season until like 3 years ago.
Now shut up, there's room for both cartoony cartoons and anime stop gatekeeping.

Who even cares? You fags don't even discuss the show. All the threads die in 60 posts and they would die faster on /a/ so why does it even matter?

>>149290296
And yet it's still not media of western origin because it's written, directed, and storyboarded by a majority/solely Japanese team
>Now shut up, there's room for both cartoony cartoons and anime stop gatekeeping.
Yeah
The former is /co/
The latter is /a/
Entire boards dedicated to their sole subject matters
/co/ shouldn't be a refugee board
Remember when you think about these situations think, would /a/ accept this in-reverse?

>>149290327
Don't care.

>>149289301
God bless the MadLad who directed this scene

>>149290296
>stop gatekeeping.
/co/ is an awful board because we DIDN'T gatekeep

>>149290333
Yet you replied.

>>149287991 (OP)
It belongs on /a/, but since the only /a/ Sonic stuff people give a shit about are this and the OVAs, it means nobody wants to talk about it there.
Meanwhile Sonic has like 3 comic series and 5 cartoons so non-game Sonic discussion pretty much happens on /co/.

>>149289197
>Shadow is poorer than Vector is
>Has been hired as a merc, a agent and generally has abilities that allow him to be a asset for any military organization with Rouge touching for his skills making money off of saving the world and probably contracts from GUN and the president

Anon please, Shadow could force Team Chaotix to work for him if he wanted to. And has.

>>149289301
>>149289365
>>149289383
>>149289431
>>149290389
>tailouge memes
>Tails never had a shot to begin with and is canon wise a cuck to Sonic

This meme is dead along with the tails self inserters

>>149290877
he's never been hired as a merc, nice headcanon
only ever was an agent in 06 then was fired/quit
never been part of any military organisation, Dark Beginnings showed still not part of GUN either

He's canonically a neet manlet who eats Hot pockets for breakfast

>>149290907
Chadow

>>149290907
>>149290939
you’re the definition of a self-inserter, crybaby nigger

>>149290974
KEK

>>149290919
>he's never been hired as a merc
>Hes this in Boom and GUN is technically a government that hires temporary people who dont join for life but work for with them for a personal reason, Shadow was this, so yeah he was a merc
>Shadows height is irrelevant

Kys

>>149290051
They were admittedly closer than anyone else's. Sonic X has the dubious honor of being the best Sonic adaptation pretty much just by being the only one that tried and wasn't some furry's gay politicial drama meets Endless Superhero Crisis fanfiction with only like 3-4 actual characters or plots from the games taking itself too seriously.

>>149290974
Go lick a anus, crybaby liberal

>>149290977
He's not a merc in Boom, dumbass. Eggman tricked him into fighting Sonic with a youtube poop because he's retarded and actually believed it. Shadow isn't hired by GUN, as showed in Dark Beginnings.

Shadow's height is manlet level and canonically shorter than Rouge too, kek. That's why manlets like you self-insert as him

>>149288416
There's a whole category of shows that strictly by category would go on /a/, but the real answer is "dont try to discuss this on 4chan"

>>149291010
I agree, I died laughing at you seething self-inserter blacks

>>149289585
>Sega even hired the 4kids American actors to become the official voiceactors
Only because it was cheaper to hire the whole group instead of just Mike Pollock to replace Eggman. Ironically, Pollock has now been the longest-running VA for Eggman.

>>149290990
your self-insert is canonically a gay liberal, Jamal

>>149290998
>Tdlr

Shadow will never fuck you. He'll still get more pussy than you

>>149291021
>>149291039
Still seething about a fictional hedgehog.

>>149290998
No shadow got employed by eggman, gun, and for Rouge for merc reasons and to fight sonic on his own terms. You're retarded

>>149291044
Tldr, I play the games and you don't.
You self-insert, cry like a bitch on your computer, and fap to cuck porn. I get real pussy and am laughing at you.

>>149291070
Shadow's never been employed by Eggman, in SA2 he literally kneeled down and said "what is your wish my master?"
Gun only hired him in 06, then fired him/had him quit confirmed by iizuka
He has never been a merc, that's just you self-inserting and being an edgy 13 year old.
I play the games, you don't.

>>149290978
AoStH is the better one still.

The Tails and Shadow guy are basically this right now lmao.

>>149291135
I'm not a Tails guy, I'm a Chaotix guy. The Shadow faggot just keeps crying like a bitch every /co/ Sonic thread, because he has no life except self-inserting as a furry sasuke on his computer

>>149291225
NTA but being any kind of "guy" in regards to Sonic makes you a gigantic faggot.

>>149288946
>That was made exclusively for America
it was made largely because of the show's success in america, but it was not made EXCLUSIVELY for them. it aired in many countries around the world. it only didn't air in japan for a long time because of a fuckup where the japanese versions of the episodes were accidentally released on home video in other countries before they were set to air in japan, and sponsors paying for the timeslots pulled out. the show did reasonably well in japan as well as the rest of the world.

>>149291856
So it's /co/ then.

>>149291951
you will respond to literally any argument by saying you think it should go on /co/ anyways because you cannot bear the thought of going on the anime board to discuss anime.
it's anime. it's not a cartoon. it's a japanese IP. it was written by japanese people. it was animated by japanese people. the only shred of an argument you have in favor of it being a cartoon is that it was made with the knowledge it would be popular in america because it was based on a japanese franchise that was already popular in america.
grow up and accept it doesn't belong on entirely the wrong board just because you watched it on fucking fox or something.

>>149291951
>So it's /co/ then.
No
It's still a Japanese led production with Japanese creative staff as the lead

>>149292010
>grow up and accept it doesn't belong on entirely the wrong board just because you watched it on fucking fox or something.
That argument was always retarded because it assumes everyone here grew up watching the same channels, in the same countries, in the same time, etc and that it's as dumb as saying western cartoons be posted on /a/ because they aired on Japanese television channels

>>149292020
>>149292038
Nope it's /co/ and you spamming is just gonna attract even more /a/fags to post here.
So please keep spamming I wanna see some good threads for once.

>>149287991 (OP)
Both?

>>149292801
No, just /a/