>>76499737 (OP)
They'll like you more invariably. Maybe not ultimately. You should also consider that having some muscle and athletic ability is better than just a lot of walking.
And if you're really worried about relationships, you also need to be a good person to go along with it. You have your intangibles like patience, how accepting you are, and sense of humor. Then you also have your tangibles like "the walk-a-lot girl who didn't get something at the tea shop because she brought her calorie friendly yogurt" vs "oh, she's that basketball girl" vs "Oh, the lifter weeb?"
THEN you have your attributes like cleverness, speed of calculation, time management, etc.
So it really kind of depends.