>>105774499It's not only about being able to find things - but also about familiarity.
Like in a huge hierarchical menu, everybody is able to find what he wants without a manual - under the assumption that he can read - it might just take a long time till he gets there.
It is usable, but not effective and not familiar.
On the other hand, you got phone UI rip-offs, they are familiar and the normie can effectively and fast use them.
But you either can not find everything without a manual (rare actions hidden behind keyboard shortcuts), or they simply don't have those actions anymore in the first place and you simply can't do what you wanted to do.
>Don't fall into the trap of imagining that the average user is some kind of subhuman idiot.This is true. IF you have a target group. If you average the people who might download and use your software, those people will probably be more skilled than you expect.
But if you average over a general population (in a false sense of "accessibility"), then you are left with a billion people who never used anything else than their phone. And this is the crowd that people who want "popularity" appeal to.
Those are the people Microsoft, Apple, Google, Gnome appeal to.
They also assume that those people are drooling retards who never learn. If you use a desktop the first time in your live, there are things you just have to learn.