Thread 17758322 - /his/ [Archived: 1077 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/12/2025, 7:25:31 PM No.17758322
Albigensian_Crusade_01-2217745791
Albigensian_Crusade_01-2217745791
md5: 44e0f7ffc2bfd352a71829ca18b40c64🔍
If the purging of the Cathars can be classified as a genocide, despite the targeted population being a religious group and not an ethnic one, can classicide also be classified as genocide?
Replies: >>17758923 >>17759175 >>17760355
Anonymous
6/12/2025, 10:02:51 PM No.17758923
>>17758322 (OP)
The deeper question is, who actually "gets to decide" what is or isn't a genocide.

The real answer is nobody really does decide that question. There is no objective and authoritative list of genocides to be found anywhere, people are always free to disagree with whatever anyone puts forward, and it's largely a buzzword that has been used by almost everyone for various different agendas at different times.

Now that we've settled that, the real question becomes, how has this term been used. What was its original purpose when it was first coined and how has it been used and picked up by others since then. For example, if the news media uses the term genocide enough times, does it become official? Do they have to describe something as a genocide a certain number of times for it to officially become one? What if the news media in one country always describes something as a genocide, but another country's media doesn't? Are they both right at the same time, or is only one right, or does it even matter.
Replies: >>17760357 >>17760359 >>17760369
Anonymous
6/12/2025, 10:22:46 PM No.17758996
definitely a genocide

forces of the demiurge killing real christians (gnostics) to suppress the truth
Replies: >>17760352
Anonymous
6/12/2025, 11:19:12 PM No.17759175
>>17758322 (OP)
Yes
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 10:54:09 AM No.17760352
1736688374375316
1736688374375316
md5: ea8ae3a17a14b86bcd510e15f8c73171🔍
>>17758996
>forces of the demiurge killing real christians (gnostics) to suppress the truth
TRUTH NUKE!!!!!!!
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 10:59:30 AM No.17760355
>>17758322 (OP)
Cathars had it coming.
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 11:00:17 AM No.17760357
>>17758923
Legitimately a rare intelligent and interesting post on /his/ written by a sober and clear minded individual
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 11:01:50 AM No.17760359
>>17758923
Fart. Faaaaaaart. Piss shit peepee poopoo.
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 11:11:29 AM No.17760369
>>17758923
Are you Israeli, by any chance? Genuinely asking. I don't mean to take away from your well thought out post but context matters, I feel.