Thread 17767873

>Jews invented Judaism, Christianity, Islam, and Marxism
>Indians invented Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, and Jainism
What makes these two peoples so talented at inventing religion? Nearly everyone on Earth worships gods they created

>>17767873 (OP)
It was actually only a small group of northern indians who invented those religions. Kind of sad that today north india is the shit part of the country.

Jew didn't invent christianity. Christians were the OG jews who fled Israel. Rabbinic judaism came afterwards.

>>17767898
Jesus and the original christians were all jews.

>>17767898
>Jew didn't invent christianity
>Christians were the OG jews

>scammers and liars are good at scamming and lying
TRVTH NVKE

Pagan religions
>there's a pantheon of cool gods, each one has a badass backstory. They forged the world like we forge weapons out of crude chaos n shiet. Yes, they're flawed like men, we worship them but don't get too weird about it

Semitic religions
>uhhh... there's a guy who...uh..created everything...and uhhh...he needs your foreskin

>>17767873 (OP)
Those who call themselves Jews today aren't related to the Biblical Jews actually.

You can only credit Marxism to the modern day group.

>>17769637
So what are they then? Slavs larping?

>>17767873 (OP)
They are very creative peoples in a few very narrow senses. Such as matters of the spirit, for example.
>Nearly everyone on Earth worships gods they created
Wrong, no one outside India worships indian Gods. Though to be fair Buddhism does essentially smuggle in much of the Indian cosmovision with it. So it's roughly equivalent to Abrahamic spirit colonization.
Caveats: Jews did not create Islam, and Marxism is not a religion. For that matter Marx had little input when it came to actually shaping Marxism into a system.

>>17770206
Middle easterners in general had, or maybe have, a talent for religion. Indians tither on the edge of such a religious inclination. The Far easterners have their moments. Tibetans I think have a talent that is much their own in religion. Westerners have, in comparison, a diminished capacity for it.

Arabs invented Islam based on Jewish mythology

>>17770218
It's extremely obvious that it's syncretistic with Zoroastrianism though.

>>17770223
A lot of converts from Zoroastrianism (and Judaism, and Christianity, and even some from Buddhism) were involved in like early theology and formalizing Islam as we know it and such.
But the original core were Arabs from the Hijaz.

>>17770242
That's true. However even then some Zoroastrian influence is, imo, visible in the Quran along with some elements of Meccan paganism. Less than the Judeo-Christian element though.

>>17770247
After all Eastern Arabia had a substantial Zoroastrian element. because of Sassanid influence.

>>17767873 (OP)
Marx wasn't Jewish and Marxism is very much a branch of Christian Hegelianism.

>>17770320
Marx was from a comically ancient and illustrious rabbinical lineage from both side though. Even if not religiously a Jew.

>>17770247
Other way around because zoroastrian texts don’t predate islam

>>17770320
Hegel derided the thesis-antithesis-synthesis pattern, clowned, on it in fact:

>When triplicity was rediscovered by Kantian thought – rediscovered by instinct, since at that time the form was dead and deprived of the concept – and when it was then elevated to its absolute significance, the true form was set out in its true content, and the concept of science was thereby engendered – but there is almost no use in holding that the triadic form has any scientific rigor when we see it reduced to a lifeless schema, to a mere façade, and when scientific organization itself has been reduced to a tabular chart.

yet Marxists ran with their wrong interpretation

>>17767873 (OP)
>t. rajesh nosebaumstein
Aryans invented both you retard
yidjeets are just parasitical gypsy larpers
that's what they have in common
No, reviving Sanskrit and Hebrew does not make either of (them) wise or ancient.
Change my mind

>>17767910
shut up edomite
you're not even White and you will never be

>>17770321
Jerry Seinfeld is descended from King David. The only thing that got him was getting permanently banned from the Soup Nazi's kitchen and irritating an old Polish lady who had a pony.
Genes ain't worth shit if you don't know how to use 'em.

>>17770686
Nah, Jewish fairy tales are too retarded to be the product of an Aryan mind. Also, most of what people associate with Hinduism (eating cow dung and caste-based favoritism) was invented by people of overwhelmingly Dravidian descent who wanted to feel like they were above Sentilese-looking negroids. Real Aryan values, like compassionateness, deattachment, and mindfulness, are most profoundly developed in early Buddhism, which was later on spread through the Silk Route over to the West and influenced the Greek Skeptics and Stoics, the latter of whom was a signficant influence on Hellenisitic Judaism and early Christianity.
People don't like to admit this, but the truth of the matter is that the only thing that kept Christianity from being forgotten as just yet another fear-mongering doomsday cult was that it managed to attract some highly educated citizens of the Roman Empire who had knowledge of both Jewish scripture and Greek philosophy.

>>17770686
You insult the Aryans by attributing those creations to them. What next, China was actually founded by Aryans?
>>17770720
Selective retardation. Two bit revisionism helps no one. Promotes decadence and stupidity.

>>17767873 (OP)
google vedic religion and zoroastrianism, it's easy to "invent religions" when you plagiarize someone else's works and make them shit

>>17770838
Zorostrianism and Vedic religion are related but not really connected. And if anything Zoroaster copied the vedas and not the other way around.

>>17770873
the root religions for all abrahamic religions (judaism, christianity, islam) and for vedic religions (jainism, sikhism, buddhaism, hinduism) come from zoroastrianism (made some proto babylonians) and from vedic religion (by some horse lords from steppes called aryans)
neither the jews nor the indians have any claims to either of those civilizations nor the creation of those religions, hell the slavs and mongols have more chance to larp as aryans and proto persians or something near that region probably have the highest chance to larp as creators of zoroastrianism

old religions are old and back in the day (and to this day) religions tend to be plagiarized from somewhere else and even the holy figures and holidays are ripped off shamelessly to integrate them into their religion which itself is a copy of older religions

tldr; worship cossacks, persians and mongols if you want to worship OG religion creators or find a way to trace back where the horselords originated before they came to india

>>17770888
You sound way over your head and are very misinformed. Zoroastrianism has been traced to East Iran and is contemporaneous with the Mature Vedic period when all the Vedas had already been composed and some of the first Upanishads were being formulated.
And for the record, Hinduism is Vedic religion. And there is no relation between it and Western Asian religions.

>>17770920
>some of the first upanishads
have a good day

>>17770670
Depends, the Gathas absolutely do.

>>17770924
Well according to some people.

>>17770170
Converts from paganism to a medieval form of gnosticism. They hallucinate that they are related to the ancient Jews. From there it somehow morphed into something even more grotesque as we see today.