Why are American natives depicted as black? - /his/ (#17769197) [Archived: 1069 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:41:37 PM No.17769197
RDT_20250616_1738048158321619616808587
RDT_20250616_1738048158321619616808587
md5: 608dbcc4e15e1a6f20a341d0550ef3b9🔍
In the artwork contemporary to early america, why are American natives depicted as black? Are African-Americans actually native to america?
Replies: >>17769202 >>17769287 >>17769524 >>17770827
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:43:04 PM No.17769202
>>17769197 (OP)
WE WUZ NATIVE AMERICANS N SHEEEEEEEEIT
Replies: >>17769205 >>17769524
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:44:07 PM No.17769205
RDT_20250616_1743285593262901812359011
RDT_20250616_1743285593262901812359011
md5: 1683385900021ab89f2f5ae7a6dadaf3🔍
>>17769202
It's one thing to lampoon it, but can anyone actually explain it?
Replies: >>17769222 >>17769287
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:51:57 PM No.17769219
Many artists of that time didn't know what Native American phenotypes actually looked like, so they drew them how they knew, as either a) dark skinned white people wearing native clothes, or b) African people wearing native clothes
Replies: >>17769242
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:52:39 PM No.17769222
>>17769205
That's just a generic brown person, you have to provide more evidence.
Replies: >>17769524
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:58:57 PM No.17769242
5.1.25-Photo-Who-Were-the-Yamasee-Hannah-Hoover-image-2-yamasee-war
>>17769219
Your statement is pure conjecture.
Replies: >>17769250
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:00:58 AM No.17769250
>>17769242
And you've provided exactly zero evidence to refute it, Mr. 18th century art history
Replies: >>17769252
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:03:09 AM No.17769252
FgmsmDxVUAEMkfd
FgmsmDxVUAEMkfd
md5: fb9ddf2f5391e328d842c3584a35aec5🔍
>>17769250
Artwork contemporary to the era in question is a form of evidence.
Replies: >>17769259 >>17769287
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:05:32 AM No.17769259
>>17769252
No I mean to refuting my point. Hell, your picture there. It's clearly French, why would a French artist know well what a Native American would look like? They'd probably have seen some mulatto people, but they'd have to be traveling far inland or have access to anthropological photographs to know what a Native American looks like
Replies: >>17769275 >>17769528
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:11:24 AM No.17769275
>>17769259
There's no point to refute. You expressed an opinion you pulled out of thin air.
Replies: >>17769285
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:15:08 AM No.17769285
5616
5616
md5: 7658378b66c3e43b8e8b4131c73810c0🔍
>>17769275
I visit a lot of museum galleries and that's how I've seen them explain it. There's a local one which has a fairly realistic portrait but that's because there would've been a small but real Native American presence at the time
>inb4 he looks black
That's what the New England Natives look like, I've been to the Narragansett rez a few times and Foxwoods/Mohegan Sun which are really the only locales that still have them down here
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:15:37 AM No.17769287
>>17769197 (OP)
>>17769205
>>17769252
Cheap mass produced prints by people that had never been to america trying to make a cheap buck selling visions of something exotic
Replies: >>17769295
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:22:23 AM No.17769295
>>17769287
How do you know the artists had never been to america?
Replies: >>17769311
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 12:31:45 AM No.17769311
>>17769295
because it's based in london and was specifically known to churn out cheap slop. basically the equivalent of a gas station post card
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 2:04:00 AM No.17769524
>>17769222
Facial features
>>17769197 (OP)
Because people depicted everybody that wasnt white to be black
Same thing with the moors
>>17769202
Retard he is not saying that natives were black
I hate overeacting fags like you
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 2:05:07 AM No.17769528
>>17769259
>why would a French artist know well what a native american would look like
Holy shit retard
They possed half of northern america
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 3:47:59 PM No.17770827
>>17769197 (OP)
because snowtroons are obsessed with niggers