>>17773479 (OP) >Collectivists >Intellectual Coming up with reasons to steal other people's shit doesn't make you an intellectual, no matter how many / intricate your reasons are.
>>17773493 He could have trusted him more, that's for sure. There were talks to get the Soviet Union into the Axis in 1940, and apparently the dealbreaker was Bulgaria choosing German over Russian influence
>>17773479 (OP) >intellectuals don't make good politicians Not really a surprise desu, M-Ls were AFAIK the only group to even try to merge the two categories and even there only Lenin and Mao (and Trotsky, I guess, among Trots) are still widely read today
Serious answer is that Stalin dumbed down communist theory enough to make it practically applicable, while Trotsky dreamed about a global proletarian revolution that never came to be.
>>17773928 >proletarian revolution is no more than a slave revolt to kill the current master so a new master can exploit them
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:04:03 PM No.17773952
>>17773933 >He wasn't the thug Stalin was. Thug gets goons to take everyone out then kill the goon. That's exactly what happened to the Tsarist officers Trotsky compelled into Red Army service. Their families were held hostage, they followed orders to try to save them, fought their friends, and then they all got shot together. Long live the revolution.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:15:13 PM No.17773970
>>17773479 (OP) >Stalin, one of history's most infamous idiots By who? >Retained power until his death in a very viscious political entity >Led his state to fend off the Third Reich >Left the USSR the second strongest nation on Earth
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:20:29 PM No.17773978
>>17773500 He did author several short works https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Works_by_Joseph_Stalin
It's not that he was poorly educated stricto sensu, more like he had little interest for non-political literature