A provocative claim has emerged that may disturb many, but it is one worth considering: the Jews of the Old Testament were replaced by Christians, and the people who call themselves Jews today share little continuity with the ancient Israelites.

Before diving into this claim, let’s make something clear: this post is not about disparaging or dismissing the Jewish people. Rather, it is an exploration of the historical and theological implications of the biblical narrative and the rise of modern Judaism.

To be continued.

1. The Biblical Replacement: A New Covenant

In Christian theology, the concept of the “replacement” of Israel is based on the New Testament's claim that the covenant with the Jewish people, established through the patriarchs and fulfilled in the Law, was superseded by the coming of Christ. The Apostle Paul clearly articulated this in Romans 11:17-24, where he described the Gentile believers as being grafted into the “olive tree” that once represented Israel.

To put it simply, Christianity argues that the promises made to the ancient Israelites were fulfilled in Christ, and that those who follow Christ—Jewish or Gentile—are the true inheritors of God's covenant. This view is rooted in scriptures like Matthew 21:43, where Jesus Himself tells the Jewish leaders that "the kingdom of God will be taken from you and given to a people who will produce its fruit." The idea of replacement isn't some offhand Christian theory, but a core theological teaching that the New Testament itself proclaims.

Thus, when we talk about the continuity of God's people, we must ask: does the Israel of the Old Testament still exist today? Or have Christians, those who believe in Christ as the fulfillment of God’s promises, become the true Israel?

>>17780340
2. Modern Judaism: A Response to Christian Europe

Here is where the story takes a controversial turn. Modern Judaism, as we know it today, did not exist in its current form during the time of Christ. While the Jewish people remained after the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 AD, the Judaism that arose in the centuries following—particularly after the 6th century—was in large part a reaction to the Christian world.

Historically, after the Roman Empire embraced Christianity, Judaism experienced significant transformations. The destruction of the Temple, the diaspora, and centuries of living under Christian dominion led to the formation of Rabbinic Judaism, which is the foundation of what many today identify as Judaism. It was during this period, particularly in the early Middle Ages, that the teachings and traditions of modern Judaism began to take shape, seeking to preserve Jewish identity in the face of overwhelming Christian influence.

Some scholars argue that this development was in large part a counter-response to the rapidly growing Christian population in Europe. While early Christianity had been seen as a sect within Judaism, over time, as the Christian faith took hold across Europe, the distinction between the two grew sharper. Rabbinic Judaism emerged not in continuity with the ancient traditions of Israel but as a reactionary movement to preserve the distinctiveness of the Jewish faith in a world dominated by Christianity.

>>17780341
3. Breaking the Chain: A New Identity

This raises an uncomfortable question: if modern Judaism is, to some extent, a reaction to Christianity, then how can it claim the same lineage as the Jews of the Old Testament? The Jewish people, as we know them today, may be culturally and ethnically connected to the ancient Israelites, but theologically, they are far removed from the Israel of Scripture. The teachings and practices that define Judaism today—many of which were codified after the rise of Christianity—are not the same as those found in the Old Testament.

Moreover, while the ancient Israelites were the recipients of God’s covenant and the Law, Christians believe that they are now the true heirs of those promises. Through Christ, they claim the mantle of Israel. In other words, the relationship between God and His people, as outlined in the Old Testament, finds its fulfillment in the Christian Church.

This theological shift isn't some abstract theory—it has deep ramifications. The Jews of the Old Testament, according to Christian theology, were replaced, not by a separate group of Jews, but by the followers of Christ. The New Covenant made through Christ extends to all who believe in Him, regardless of ethnic or national origin. Thus, Christians are not simply inheritors of Jewish teachings; they are the true spiritual descendants of the ancient Israelites.

>>17780339 (OP)
>let’s make something clear: this post is not about disparaging or dismissing the Jewish people

it should be

>>17780343
So, let’s stir the pot: If modern Jews follow a faith that evolved as a response to Christianity, and if Christians are the true heirs of Israel’s promises through Christ, what does this mean for the modern Jewish claim to continuity with the ancient Israelites? Are the people who call themselves Jews today truly the spiritual descendants of the Jews of the Old Testament, or have they taken a different path entirely, diverging from the covenant in the person of Christ?

All this is to say Modern Jews do not lay a legitimate claim to the Land of Palestine according to my theory.

We’ve heard this shit before.

The final cope

I just reject the mentally ill 4chan Jew obsession to begin with

>>17780339 (OP)
Christ is boiling in shit.

>>17780339 (OP)
>people who call themselves Jew
Isn't this in the book of revelation?

I will make those who are of the synagogue of Satan, who claim to be Jews though they are not, but are liars—I will make them come and fall down at your feet and acknowledge that I have loved you

>>17780343
>breaking the chain
just to go back into the chains again thru their own design.
>can we claim the land if we <prove> we are really the same as the history says we are?
Today it's the Zealots and Sanhedrin just reconstructed 2.0, so it's important to ask where the influence is really coming from that are making that claim. "Traditionalists" make outcries about them all the time, but because of modern "dictatorships" from the former get silenced all the time.

>>17780339 (OP)
Don't you have migrant cock to clean?

>>17780339 (OP)
>the people who call themselves Jews today share little continuity with the ancient Israelites
Objectively more than christcucks in every single way.