Anonymous
6/28/2025, 6:25:05 AM No.17797439
Instead of grouping people by culture and attempting to associate haplogroups with them, why not treat haplogroups as the source of truth and then associate cultures with them?
This map covers Y Haplogroup movement up to 8000 BC, which means it is tracking all of the male bloodlines.
Full video with more time periods here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ru3Vkjvt_g
What do you notice?
A couple things I notice off the bad:
- P comes from Southeast Asia, then moves up into central Asia and becomes R. That's the origin of R!
- R expansion really begins around 12k BC, which is around the start of the Meltwater Pulse 1A. They may be either moving away from a flooded area or moving into areas that were wrecked by floods, crop failure, and chaos. If R is a raiding culture, then it makes sense they would move in at this time.
This map covers Y Haplogroup movement up to 8000 BC, which means it is tracking all of the male bloodlines.
Full video with more time periods here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ru3Vkjvt_g
What do you notice?
A couple things I notice off the bad:
- P comes from Southeast Asia, then moves up into central Asia and becomes R. That's the origin of R!
- R expansion really begins around 12k BC, which is around the start of the Meltwater Pulse 1A. They may be either moving away from a flooded area or moving into areas that were wrecked by floods, crop failure, and chaos. If R is a raiding culture, then it makes sense they would move in at this time.
Replies: