Thread 17809080 - /his/ [Archived: 666 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/2/2025, 5:35:10 PM No.17809080
UN_Palestine_Partition_Versions_1947
UN_Palestine_Partition_Versions_1947
md5: 29a4cf3a5daa3f2e05ab27f87f7e6c94🔍
How did they think this was going to work in 1947?
Replies: >>17809108 >>17809320
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 5:38:39 PM No.17809086
>Jews agree to the plan
>Arabs agree to the plan
>UN starts managing the city while both new nations begin governing themselves
Replies: >>17809191
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 5:48:51 PM No.17809108
>>17809080 (OP)
Why did there need to be two separate states.
Why not just one state that included both Arabs and Jews?
Replies: >>17809188 >>17809266 >>17809304
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 6:30:50 PM No.17809188
>>17809108
Not enough support on either side for it. It's a sort of tragic conflict where both sides think they deserve to have all of it and that the other side wants to wipe them out, which makes compromise impossible outside of short-term tactical maneuvers.
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 6:33:32 PM No.17809191
>>17809086
>Imperialist USA and USSR
>only gained 44% of the land
Majority native Arabs disagree
Replies: >>17809248
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:02:32 PM No.17809248
>>17809191
I'm just saying that was what the ideal was
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:08:31 PM No.17809266
>>17809108
They did that.
It caused a civil war.
By splitting Palestine, it was supposed to prevent war.
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:22:55 PM No.17809304
JewishOwnedLandInPalestineAsOf1947
JewishOwnedLandInPalestineAsOf1947
md5: 5a0161685618492f017b5d49f6a2b320🔍
>>17809108
They could also have tried a plan where there wasn't a transfer of land from Arab Muslims to Jews, and without a significant population of Arab Muslims under Jewish rule. All such plans were rejected by the Jewish authorities.
Replies: >>17809316 >>17809318
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:27:38 PM No.17809316
>>17809304
>Landownship
How did Jews own southern Palestine?
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:29:07 PM No.17809318
Partition-plan-Peel-Commission-report-1937
Partition-plan-Peel-Commission-report-1937
md5: c2d310286849d1a7d82458d7397e663e🔍
>>17809304
Britains partition plan actually made more sense in terms of jewish concentration of land
Replies: >>17809324
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:30:59 PM No.17809320
MPI-1_402_2_1911-1925-source-4-scaled_jpg_80
MPI-1_402_2_1911-1925-source-4-scaled_jpg_80
md5: b8152bb7b69bd175aeed43ad90b72511🔍
>>17809080 (OP)
Because picrel "worked" about 20 years prior.

Remember, the British Governor of Jerusalem said that Israel could be
>"a loyal little Jewish Ulster."
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:34:02 PM No.17809324
>>17809318
Haifa, Acre and Naza can be Christian free city
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 7:40:05 PM No.17809337
Was there any way to avoid a tragedy or conflict. It seems like every possible solution or timelines would've faced the Palestine issue at some point, whether the British held onto or just let the Turks keep it
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 8:15:27 PM No.17809410
#FreePalestine