The Moses narrative was fabricated after the 4th century BC - /his/ (#17809578) [Archived: 720 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:20:20 PM No.17809578
1749933557857137
1749933557857137
md5: 3798ddf2c91407adb00878d0400fce28🔍
There was a Jewish community on Elephantine Island in the Nile River, and the evidence suggests they were not familiar with the story of Moses and the Exodus from Egypt. Archaeological discoveries, particularly the Elephantine Papyri, reveal a Jewish community with its own temple and distinct practices, seemingly unaware of or not adhering to narratives central to mainstream Jewish tradition.
Here's a more detailed explanation:
The Elephantine Papyri:
These Aramaic documents, dating from the 5th century BCE, provide valuable insights into the lives of this Jewish community.
Temple and Practices:
The community had its own temple dedicated to Yahweh, where animal sacrifices were performed. Their religious practices, as evidenced in the papyri, differed significantly from those described in the Torah.
Lack of Familiarity with Moses:
The papyri make no mention of Moses, the Exodus, or the covenant at Sinai, suggesting that these core narratives of Jewish identity were not part of their religious framework.
Replies: >>17809678 >>17809723
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:21:50 PM No.17809585
This was what made me reject all abrahamic religions. There is no evidence for Moses ordeal in Egypt, even when we should have such evidence.
Replies: >>17809706
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:28:08 PM No.17809608
Satan altered the documents
Replies: >>17809706
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:34:06 PM No.17809634
that excerpt from the bible is a excellent example of a good seethepost, you can really sense how buttmad whoever wrote it was, just absolutely livid
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:46:29 PM No.17809678
>>17809578 (OP)
They didn't speak about him because it wasn't necessary. If they needed to know more about Moses they would just read the Torah scrolls in their local synagogue.
Replies: >>17809699
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:54:37 PM No.17809699
>>17809678
They had no Torah there tho
Replies: >>17809706
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 9:56:10 PM No.17809706
>>17809585
fpbp

>>17809608
OP paid good money too.

>>17809699
This lmfao
Anonymous
7/2/2025, 10:01:23 PM No.17809723
>>17809578 (OP)
Several of the Moses stories have identical plots to Vedic stories, and other Proto Indo European religions. The names differ of course, but the basic plot is the same.
It's clear that they were incorporated from earlier mythos. Is this even a question though? The flood story was obviously taken from Mesopotamian myths, so this isn't new.