Anonymous
7/4/2025, 12:10:00 PM No.17813559
>reading Deuteronomy
>realize it never mentions Jerusalem
>not once
>whole book is just "the place YHWH will choose"
>but keeps leaning toward Shechem and Mount Gerizim
>Deut reads like a legal code more than a narrative
>functions independently from Exodus-Lev-Numbers
>and surprise: Numbers ends at Moab, right where Deut picks up
>Genesis is a patchwork anyway
>shared ancestors like Abraham and Jacob probably meant to unify factions
>Melchizedek in Gen 14 is the only pro-Jerusalem bit
>doesn't match the style, smells like a Zion priestly insert
>makes sense when you realize Torah was likely a political project
>not divine, not even purely Jewish
>probably a compromise between Gerizim priests and Jerusalem ones
>shared myths, shared law, ambiguous cult site
>basically ancient power-sharing to control both Samaritan and Judean populations
>Gerizim = pilgrimage, trade, regulation for Shechem
>Zion = same for Jerusalem
>each faction inserts their claim
>eventually stops working
>Samaritans and Jews break off, both claim sole legitimacy
>Judeans wipe out Shechem under John Hyrcanus
>burn the sanctuary, probably torched their Torahs too
>now we only have the Jerusalem version
>entire Hebrew Bible built on the ruins of a failed religious federation
>realize it never mentions Jerusalem
>not once
>whole book is just "the place YHWH will choose"
>but keeps leaning toward Shechem and Mount Gerizim
>Deut reads like a legal code more than a narrative
>functions independently from Exodus-Lev-Numbers
>and surprise: Numbers ends at Moab, right where Deut picks up
>Genesis is a patchwork anyway
>shared ancestors like Abraham and Jacob probably meant to unify factions
>Melchizedek in Gen 14 is the only pro-Jerusalem bit
>doesn't match the style, smells like a Zion priestly insert
>makes sense when you realize Torah was likely a political project
>not divine, not even purely Jewish
>probably a compromise between Gerizim priests and Jerusalem ones
>shared myths, shared law, ambiguous cult site
>basically ancient power-sharing to control both Samaritan and Judean populations
>Gerizim = pilgrimage, trade, regulation for Shechem
>Zion = same for Jerusalem
>each faction inserts their claim
>eventually stops working
>Samaritans and Jews break off, both claim sole legitimacy
>Judeans wipe out Shechem under John Hyrcanus
>burn the sanctuary, probably torched their Torahs too
>now we only have the Jerusalem version
>entire Hebrew Bible built on the ruins of a failed religious federation
Replies: