Is left wing militarism possible? - /his/ (#17825409) [Archived: 575 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/8/2025, 6:35:13 PM No.17825409
RTN+170+pic+1-3192828754
RTN+170+pic+1-3192828754
md5: b513f4feabad9fce7993740211996b91🔍
Or does militarism inevitably only perform well with a right wing mentality society?
Replies: >>17825507 >>17825785 >>17825824 >>17825852 >>17826425 >>17826844 >>17826947 >>17826958 >>17827053 >>17827086 >>17827096
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 6:38:57 PM No.17825416
1742676039921214
1742676039921214
md5: 0222f15e5b899e62fd704bb2270270ba🔍
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 7:30:59 PM No.17825507
Ee05PjxU4AUxWAL
Ee05PjxU4AUxWAL
md5: 7204dba7f5eaa0dc38ed232d8296c696🔍
>>17825409 (OP)
Stalin's militarized version of socialism and similar parties and their armies in the 20th century. It's more about a spirit of struggle and self-sacrifice which are not inherently left or right-wing concepts. The YPG/YPJ more recently which evoled out of Maoism:
https://youtu.be/_Q90M75_6pc
Replies: >>17825541
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 7:48:07 PM No.17825541
>>17825507
Stalin was right-wing and state capitalist too.
Replies: >>17825823 >>17826477 >>17826845
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 9:40:17 PM No.17825785
direction brain
direction brain
md5: 60f7a547afe2e844a7429853e06d5167🔍
>>17825409 (OP)
Left Wing/Right Wing is a retarded political model. The seating plan of the French Revolutionary Parliament is no longer relevant. You'll find pretty much every possible cultural, social, and policy positions on both the 'left' and 'right' if you look for them. Try another paradigm.
Replies: >>17825816 >>17826950
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 9:52:35 PM No.17825816
>>17825785
>Try another paradigm.
Yeah, like based and cringe.
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 9:55:27 PM No.17825823
>>17825541
Do you even dress yourself in the morning?
Replies: >>17825846
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 9:55:27 PM No.17825824
groid
groid
md5: 7a6f8aeae25b1bfa89141b1b89e87363🔍
>>17825409 (OP)
>what is the red army
>what is the vietcong
Replies: >>17826849
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 10:03:26 PM No.17825846
>>17825823
>UHHHH BUT HE LEFTIST EGONOMIGS

the political divide was never actually determined by economics, thats just how people came to see it over time.
it originated around collective will, national character, and martial character as without hereditary kingship competing views now had equal play on the field of "ideas" (read:political violence)
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 10:06:45 PM No.17825852
>>17825409 (OP)
What exactly do you mean by "militarism"? A great emphasis on war and military formations in a society can either be a case of powerful ruling class interests seeking to defend and expand their power or it can be towards a revolutionary objective.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 3:30:34 AM No.17826425
>>17825409 (OP)
Literally every socialist state was heavily militarized
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 4:03:40 AM No.17826477
>>17825541
There are aspects of Stalin's rule that I think you could say represent a turn to the right within the communist movement. But right/left are also kind of relative. Is Stalin right-wing or left-wing relative to Hitler? I'd say he was to the left and the conflict between the Third Reich and the USSR can be considered a conflict between right and left.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 9:08:24 AM No.17826844
>>17825409 (OP)
Yes. Look at North Korea for example. Far left commie regime with a military first policy
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 9:09:25 AM No.17826845
brainletjak
brainletjak
md5: c27213618a1897bc8964df39a6f70ccd🔍
>>17825541
>Stalin was right-wing and state capitalist too.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 9:10:27 AM No.17826849
>>17825824
>>what is the red army
a gang of rapists
>>what is the vietcong
commie terrorists
Replies: >>17826952
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 10:35:56 AM No.17826947
>>17825409 (OP)
Retarded worship of the army is a chud thing, yes.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 10:38:28 AM No.17826950
>>17825785
you're expecting too much from /his/tards
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 10:41:10 AM No.17826952
>>17826849
Coping amerigolem
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 10:45:45 AM No.17826958
>>17825409 (OP)
Liberals have to take on the aspects of other ideologies like a skin suit in order to survive. Generative ideologies like fascism and communism need not act unnaturally in order to defend themselves. Confidence is only a contradiction in liberalism.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 12:09:43 PM No.17827053
>>17825409 (OP)
what you and the poison culture war of today thinks of as left and right wing has nothing to do with political "left vs right" reality of 100 years ago which is also completely different from 100 years before that
that being said make what you will of
>the french army during the collation wars period
>the union army of the america civil war
>the allied armies of the first world war
>the soviet army of the second world war
>the vietnamese forces in their war
>the american and their allies armed forces in our time
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 12:49:32 PM No.17827086
>>17825409 (OP)
Peace, land, and bread. No war but the class war.
It's not that the left won't fight when necessary, but we never lose sight of the fact that war is bad and desire a world without it (and other forms of social murder).
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 12:53:30 PM No.17827096
>>17825409 (OP)
What kind of loaded question is this?