Thread 17850893 - /his/ [Archived: 272 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/18/2025, 3:13:34 AM No.17850893
third-reich-at-its-greatest-extent-in-1942-map-of-nazi-germany-in-G2XHP9
WWI Germany: Japan is an enemy
WWII Germany: Japan is an ally

WWI Germany: Italy is an enemy
WWII Germany: Italy is an ally

WWI Germany: Romania is an enemy
WWII Germany: Romania is an ally

WWI Germany: France, and even Belgium, withstand for 4 years
WWII Germany: France and Low Countries collapse early

WWI Germany: Almost win, and probably would have if they had just a few more advantages


So how did Hitler manage to fuck it all up?
Replies: >>17850895 >>17850907 >>17850921
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 3:17:12 AM No.17850895
>>17850893 (OP)
>So how did Hitler manage to fuck it all up?
Invading the Soviet Union instead of focusing on North Africa
Replies: >>17850995
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 3:28:47 AM No.17850907
4NcHwAV
4NcHwAV
md5: 8f367c7b3751c684c3d6fd1e3f4f9cc7🔍
>>17850893 (OP)
>WWII Germany: Italy is an ally
So how did Hitler manage to fuck it all up?
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 3:35:47 AM No.17850921
World_War_I_alliances
World_War_I_alliances
md5: f9c96a8681511d87acfb7584a6763c9e🔍
>>17850893 (OP)
Germany didn't 'almost win' in WW1.
If you're asking why they defeated Russia it's because it was still an agricultural state at the time
Replies: >>17850993 >>17852369 >>17852389
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 4:21:05 AM No.17850993
>>17850921
Lol that wasn't the reason.
Russia collapsed from the stress of the war.
As did Austria-Hungary and Germany. All 3 fell to domestic revolution, with their new governments suing for peace. Starving people really don't care about anything except for food. Nearly every revolution begins with people starving.
All 3 states also had their minority demographic seceded.
Replies: >>17851067
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 4:22:15 AM No.17850995
>>17850895
Never have an opinion on ww2 ever again retard.
Replies: >>17851071
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 4:24:13 AM No.17850997
WW1 Russia: A backwards agrarian empire
WW2 USSR: A modernized industrial power
WW1 USA: Joins at the last moment, but its very presence in the war made German victory impossible
WW2 USA: Has to fight for 3+ years, but still wins, because its economy rivals the rest of the world put together and the Axis has no realistic way to disrupt its industrial production or knock it out of the fight
the Axis lost when they bombed Pearl Harbor and WW1 Germany lost when they sent the Zimmerman Telegram and resumed unrestricted submarine warfare.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 5:08:51 AM No.17851067
>>17850993
you realize to be an industrial state requires a huge agricultural surplus. So when the person you retardedly responded to called them an agricultural state that also means they cant produce food on the level of an industrial state. Agriculture must first be industrialized to enable urban industrialization. How else would you feed everyone.
Germany and austria surrendered because they were defeated on the field of battle by superior forces. Not because they were closer to medieval states than modern ones like russia.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 5:12:38 AM No.17851071
>>17850995
Retard cope.
Replies: >>17851079
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 5:15:27 AM No.17851074
Lol
No one has mentioned oil yet.
In ww1 oil wasn't a factor.
In ww2 oil was the factor.

And unironically Germany in ww2 would have been better off without her allies.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 5:19:29 AM No.17851079
>>17851071
You don't even know the basic facts about ww2.

The reason why Germany couldn't focus any more on North Africa than they did irl has been endlessly discussed here.
You're either a newfag or low iq cretin. Either way, lurk more and stfu.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 8:11:53 PM No.17852369
>>17850921
Germany came extremely close to winning WW1, what are you talking about? Those spring and summer offenses nearly collapsed France & co. The only reason it didn't was because of American involvement.
Germany effectively solo'd Russia, France, and Britain (Austria-Hungary and Italy canceling each other out). It took America to tip the scales in the others' favor.
WW2 is more elusive. Again, it is America that is the deciding factor. Without American help, Germany probably does subdue the USSR, but at a far greater cost than it was to subdue Russia just a few decades earlier. But because America will always be involved, that's a moot point. Germany can't really win if America supports the other side, ehrn other side are the British and French Empires, and the USSR.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 8:18:13 PM No.17852389
>>17850921
Powerful allied power Brazil. Truly a gamechanger.