What lost texts would you like to read? - /his/ (#17869127) [Archived: 190 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/24/2025, 10:00:31 PM No.17869127
IMG_4806
IMG_4806
md5: 18e581593994f8dae1bc791114881f83🔍
Of all the lost texts, the one I’d like to read most is Porphyry's "Against the Christians". It was a massive 15 volume work refuting every aspect of Christianity from both a historical and philosophical perspective. Porphyry had access to sources we don't have anymore like histories of the Phoenicians (he was from Tyre himself). It's arguments were so searing that multiple Christian emperors had it banned and every copy burned. Even mentioning his arguments was banned, so stuff Christians wrote in an attempt to "refute" it didn't survive either. We only have a few fragments via quotations, and even from what little we know, he prefigured a lot of what was later independently discovered by academic Biblical study, e.g. the Book of Daniel NOT being written during the Babylonian exile but rather, being written in the 180s BC under the reign of Seleucid king Antiochus IV Epiphanes.
Replies: >>17869163 >>17869180 >>17869528 >>17869558
Anonymous
7/24/2025, 10:13:44 PM No.17869163
>>17869127 (OP)
I wish we'd have the texts written by Diogenes. Obviously having the full collection of original texts by Democritus and Epicurus would rock.
Anonymous
7/24/2025, 10:20:08 PM No.17869180
>>17869127 (OP)
Arrian's After Alexander
Ptolemy's Memoirs
Aggripa's memoirs
Hannibals Memoirs and textbook on tactics/strategy
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:44:38 AM No.17869528
>>17869127 (OP)
>atheist fairy tales
Replies: >>17869545
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:49:33 AM No.17869545
>>17869528
nah what fedoras don't get is that most of these ancient polemics against Christianity by pagans and Jews were trying to defend their own superstitions, they were very much not fedora tippers the way Reddit thinks.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:55:16 AM No.17869558
>>17869127 (OP)
Cārvāka texts a.k.a. Ancient Indian Atheists
Replies: >>17869560
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:56:18 AM No.17869560
2810d4_06f7cef3f6db4e5ebdb30cd62c1b1819~mv2
2810d4_06f7cef3f6db4e5ebdb30cd62c1b1819~mv2
md5: 7cd2119df125d55864e5565ad63e5528🔍
>>17869558
They were hardcore, but not primary texts survived.