Thread 17874387 - /his/

Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:08:05 PM No.17874387
206984_f11d6ae6c26f4785a4b33b83633aaaf8~mv2
206984_f11d6ae6c26f4785a4b33b83633aaaf8~mv2
md5: 1b1270925942e509ac1bab5c969d3aaf🔍
Why didn't they have armies in the middle ages?
I mean they had strong warriors in the ancient times
And they have elite soldiers today
Replies: >>17874416 >>17874842
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:18:19 PM No.17874411
Are you not aware of the Diaspora? The great exile from their homeland that occurred almost 2000 years ago? Jews had no state in the middle ages. They were scattered into various enclaves around Europe and frequently shaken down for money before being banished. Jews spent the last almost 2000 years walking small and trying not to be seen as a threat, because the last time it happened they were very nearly annihilated by the Roman Empire.
Replies: >>17874448
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:20:05 PM No.17874416
evicted_thumb.jpg
evicted_thumb.jpg
md5: 5f1269eaa4d85317749ce4ca057af17e🔍
>>17874387 (OP)
after temple 2.0 got btfo jews were rightfully identified as enemies of God and persecuted mercilessly for the following two thousand years
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:27:05 PM No.17874448
>>17874411
After the fall of rome it was the perfect time to get together and conquer some land
Now it's too late
Replies: >>17874459
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:34:32 PM No.17874459
>>17874448
Rome only fell in the west, not the East. The eastern empire was the one that ruled over Palestine (formerly Judea). And by the time the western empire fell in the 5th century the Jews had spent centuries in exile. They were scattered all over the place, had only limited contact with other enclaves, and most of Europe was hostile to them, barely tolerating their presence. Often they were sheltered by the nobility or the Catholic Church, who found their literacy and skill with numbers useful, and frequently employed them as tax collectors. Else they were just allowed to live unmolested, and Jews being Jews they'd inevitably amass wealth at which point the nobility or the king would smash the Jewish piggy bank open and reap the spoils. Nobody objects from a royal shakedown when the victims are unpopular, and nobody was less popular than Jews, in Europe.

Hell, Jews were so widely hated that during the First Crusade, the "people's Crusade" that preceded the knightly one swept through Europe lynching Jews in every town and city they passed through basically "just because". The Jews weren't the target of the Crusade, had basically nothing at all to do with why it was called or its objectives, but people were worked up into a religious fervor and everybody liked seeing Christ-killers swing from a tree.
Replies: >>17874469
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:35:25 PM No.17874460
What good are strong warriors when there's only like 50 of you and you all have to live in one street in the bad part of town?
Replies: >>17874467
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:38:28 PM No.17874467
>>17874460
>there's only like 50 of you
Replies: >>17874472 >>17874530
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:39:13 PM No.17874469
abd al-malik
abd al-malik
md5: aa95684242f112ecdbbf2cd2a6248ced🔍
>>17874459
Hello, who do you think funded Muhammad's expeditions into Roman Syria-Palestine? Money flowed like water from Babylonia into Tayyaye purses to buy their loyalty. Why do you think they even built a temple in Jerusalem when Umar had captured the city? The Eastern Empire lost in the areas that mattered 1400 years ago and we've been living with the consequences.
>And when all the remnants of the people of the children of Israel assembled, they joined together, and they became a large army. And after that they sent a letter to the Greek king, and they said as follows: “God gave that land to our father Abraham and to his descendants after him as a hereditary possession. We are the sons of Abraham. You have occupied our land long enough. Leave it in peace, and we will not come into your land. Otherwise, we will demand that possession from you with interest.”
Replies: >>17874487
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:39:30 PM No.17874470
hey how is the weather in Israel right now?
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:39:59 PM No.17874472
>>17874467
Jewish populations were not very large in most towns. Major cities with a big artisan / tradesman class might have a Jewish population in the hundreds or thousands, but most medieval cities and towns wouldn't have very many Jews.
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 10:49:01 PM No.17874487
>>17874469
Muhammad had not even been born when the Western Empire fell, you're talking about events almost 200 years later than what I was describing. The Jews were obviously very interested in the power shakeup in their homeland and tried to capitalize on it, but they were too few in number to actually hold the city for themselves. Muslims ruled, and were more tolerant of Jews than the Christian Romans had been, but they were still very strict masters. Jewish exile did not end simply because the Jews were no longer legally banned from Jerusalem. They were still scattered all over Europe, and when the news reached those far flung Jewish enclaves it must've seemed momentous, but probably not enough to make them pack up everything and move. After all, they had no real guarantee the new masters of Jerusalem would be any better. They weren't Jews, after all, and by this point the Jews well knew what to expect when living under the rule of non-Jews.
Anonymous
7/26/2025, 11:07:40 PM No.17874530
>>17874467
How big do you think most Jewish communities were in the middle ages anon?
Replies: >>17874611
Anonymous
7/27/2025, 12:06:54 AM No.17874611
Shut_it_down
Shut_it_down
md5: 4444d8670e5ca25be349646f980d82ff🔍
>>17874530
They had walkie-talkies
Replies: >>17874615
Anonymous
7/27/2025, 12:09:42 AM No.17874615
>>17874611
Do you want answers or do you just want to shitpost like a cunt?
Replies: >>17874633
Anonymous
7/27/2025, 12:19:48 AM No.17874633
>>17874615
I feel like being a cunt. I just quite frankly do not feel like cooperating right now.
Anonymous
7/27/2025, 1:36:35 AM No.17874782
They did, if you count the Islamic caliphates that occupied them.
Anonymous
7/27/2025, 2:19:05 AM No.17874842
>>17874387 (OP)
Their God got btfo by iron chariots bro
Replies: >>17874867
Anonymous
7/27/2025, 2:34:21 AM No.17874867
>>17874842
Those who claim to be Jews today have nothing to do with the ancient or Biblical Jews.