Thread 214060796

Why are baltics and kazahs so superior?

Tajikistansisters...

>>214060796 (OP)
>Baltics
EU gibs
>Kazakhstan
oil, gas, coal, iron ore

>>214060813
Yes, but probably not in the way a lot of smoothbrains think. When people read "EU gibs" they think it's some kind of helicopter money, meanwhile if you look at the numbers, over the depicted timespan, "EU gibs" were under 2% of GDP.
But sure, I'll give you that, without EU we would have been much much worse.

>>214060813
>>214061076
it's both; direct gibs and investments. Poles like to cope about it by posting an infograph that says more profit flew out of Poland than investments went in, as if that wasn't the very point of investment in the first place to create surplus profit. But I understand for a nationalist fucktard it's too hard to appreciate/acknowledge outside support.

>>214060796 (OP)
>baltics
EU
>kazahs
mineral deposits

>>214060813
>>Kazakhstan
>oil, gas, coal, iron ore
Then why has Russia's rank dropped?

>>214061254
Russia has 120 million people
Kazakhstan has like 20
pic is oil reserves per capita

>>214061140
>GRRR le Polen ist schlecht
Le rent free

>>214060796 (OP)
Georgia grew the most doe

>>214061282
Russia has shittones of other resources and industry

>>214061309
You do too. It’s not just oil. There’s coal and iron in Karaganda, precious metals in the Altai mountains, and the highest uranium production in the world.

>>214061282
That doesn't answer the question.

>>214061300
no, you're just annoying, ungrateful and generally unlikable people on average

>>214061328
It does? Russia’s GDP is marginally smaller. And if Nazarbayev’s clique weren’t spending all that money on their kids’ private Swiss schools and apartments in London, it would have been much higher.

>>214061324
Russia still has more resources by any metric including poor capita cope

>>214061333
Pfffff

>>214061351
I literally provided the data. And many of these are in bumfuck Siberia where it’s uneconomical to dig them up.

>>214061372
>Barrels
>All resources

>>214061348
So why did Russia's rank fall and Kazakhstan's rise?
Did someone put those resources under the Kazakh soil after USSR collapsed?

>>214061328
You don't understand, Pekka. Russia HAS to start 3 day military operations every few years. Its existence depends on it.

>>214061388
Nigger, don’t pretend Kazakhstan doesn’t have resources besides oil either. Didn’t they repeat the whole “Kazakhstan has the whole periodic table” addage in school to you?

>>214061393
The industry was underdeveloped in Kazakhstan. The first ever industry in Kazakhstan was the evacuated European industry that was moved during WWII. Many yuro and American companies set up shop in the 90s. There was fuck all infrastructure for all that stuff beforehand.

>>214061448
Now do per capita. Canada and Australia mog Russia for example.

>>214061282
>IMG_4586.jpg
>>214059157
>IMG_4584.jpg
why are you defending the poor shithole your parents escaped from, HIVan? when are you going back?

>>214061474
Who am I “defending” here? The idiot I’m arguing with wasn’t taught division in his mamber aul apparently. Neither he was taught Kazakhstan’s geography.

>>214061474
It's probably Denis

>>214061473
And russia mogs us, we aren't even in top 10. And the 10th place already has 5 times less resources than Kazakhstan

>>214061515
>resources than Kazakhstan
Than Russia

>>214061497
>>214061474
Wait, it's not Denis. The hand isn't fat

>>214061515
Don’t pretend like kz has nothing. It has 2/3 of Cental Asia’s GDP despite Uzbekistan having like twice the population. It’s because everything below has fuck all, Turkmenistan excluded.

>>214061562
Kazakhstan doesn't have largest reserves of uranium, after the first sentence it's pointless to read rest of ai slop

>>214061588
It literally is the world’s largest uranium exporter, you utter retard.

>>214061600
Well, I will not add any comments because you do the job of cooking yourself better than me

>>214061630
>TSAAAAAR DO NOT REDEEM PUBLICLY AVAILABLE INFORMATION
>FAKE NEWS NO RESOURCES ALL OUR GDP IS FROM QAZY AND BESHPARMAK SALES
What’s your endgame, seriously?

>>214060796 (OP)
saw this on ig. russians in the comments immediately pulled out poor people points to cope, in addition to talking about eu gibs and how we don't produce anything

>>214061776
If gibs were the deciding factor Belarus would be at the top of the chart.

>>214061695
I said your ai generated screen is bullshit

>>214061834
Sure, sure. Now tell me what pretending that kz doesn’t have resources do for (You). We all heard of the famous high tech kz industry, that’s surely where the GDP is from. The fucks in charge couldn’t even build a modern airport in Almaty without embezzling everything and depositing it in Swiss banks. You’re not any different from Russia, Azamat.

>>214061868
I am just telling you that any sane person knows that russia has more resources than kazakhstan. You created the point I dont have and attacked even though I talk about diffrent things

>>214061912
Yes, it does. It also has more people. Was division part of your school curriculum? Refer to >>214061282.

>>214060796 (OP)
Kazakhstan imports stuff to re import it to Russia
>>214061351
Actually Kazakhstan natural resources revenue is about 1.5x of Russia's, this has more to do with Russian extraction rates being low, for example Norway's natural resources revenue is 4 times the Russian

>>214061937
I don't know if im talking to a disabled or just a troll that uses barrels of oil to describe all natural resources a country has

>>214061970
>Kazakhstan imports stuff to re import it to Russia
Learn the gdp formula or at least what gdp means and don't tell seething bulshit again

>>214061993
Yeah, same. I have no idea why all the graphs and data I have provided so far can’t convince you. How did you even pass EHT?
>b b b but it’s not just oil
both kz and ru have oil-based economies. >>214061868 is kz’s export map. Picrel is Russia’s. Kz has more oil reserves per capita. End of story. Cope and seethe.

>>214060796 (OP)
Why has Uzbekistan worsened so much?
Also, what's happening in Tajikistan? I've never seen an anon from there. Is it really so poor there so they don't even have the internet?

>>214062063
Retard, if a kazakh buys a car then SELLS it to Russia it's still counted in the gdp

>>214062095
Russian problem that they can't generate money despite having much more options for resources and other industries. You are just proving that russia is ineficient which was my point. So you actually owned yourself

>>214062173
We can, our economy is just not as currency oriented for obvious reasons
If dollar becomes 120 rubels tomorrow our gdp will plummet, meaningless thing

>>214062173
Nigger, how many times do I have to reiterate? You have the same amount of resources per capita. The same fucking export map. Everything is the exact fucking same.

>>214062172
Only the profit of selling, and such operations dont have big margin of profit in absolute numbers and therefore gdp contribution

>>214062359
Selling, tax, logistics
For thousands and thousands of cars, appliances, furniture, medicine etc

>>214062454
The profit added only around 1 to 2 billion to gdp. All other expanditures are extracted to net zero gdp contribution.

>>214060796 (OP)
No way Turkmens are richer than Azeris or Georgians.

>>214062551
They have an insane amount of natural gas. To the point they had made it free for citizens and had to cancel it when retards started dying from gassing themselves.