>>216634687 (OP)
I mean, we don't sing it (or at least we never did when I was growing up). The theater just plays the national anthem and we all just stand up for it. Tb h it is pretty weird. I can understand a sporting event or something but a movie?
>>216635178
in communist era the daily TV broadcast here started (and maybe ended too) with the national anthem
I think it was like that in many other countries as well, before TV/cinema was fully commercialized
>>216634687 (OP)
i school when i was in it we stand and pledge the national anthem every day (saying it with out hand over heart) and this was in jew york
>>216634687 (OP)
In the US it's pretty normal to have the national anthem play before political, war, or holocaust movies; but you usually don't sing it. Just listen.
>>216635457 >or holocaust movies
why? Did it happen in the US? Did the US have anything to do with this event in any tangible way? I just don't understand why exactly before this kind of movie and not any other movie about whatever else cruel historical event
>>216635457 >>216635480 >>216635322 >>216635627
Yeah I remember the first time I saw Europeans calling Americans cult-ish for standing up for their anthem and for having a pledge of allegiance and I was like "Wait, is that supposed to be weird?" We have our own pledge of allegiance
>>216636421
I didn't know anyone else had a pledge of allegiance but I hadn't really thought about it, either. I've always thought it was weird to have one. I also thought ours was invented in the 50s during the "red scare" era as like some sort of magical incantation to ward off communism. turns out it's from the fuckin 1800s. it was the "under God" that was added in the 50s. Anyway, it doesn't work at all; they should get rid of it. nobody likes doing it. it doesn't make anyone feel patriotic.
how do people feel about the Indian pledge?
>>216637212
People probably see it as just "garden variety patriotic thing to do." I think it's corny but if I had to take the pledge, I'm not gonna sit out. Don't wanna be the brick the sticks out
>>216636421
People forget two things about the US pledge of allegiance
First, we fought a civil war and had Southern culture as a prominent aspect of the country up until about the 90's. So there was always a worry we'd have a second civil war.
Second, anti-communism was a big deal in the 30's and 50's.
>>216635178 >Jeet admits something in his country is weird >Doesn't mindlessly defend it
Wtf? Are you actually a westerner stuck there? Blink twice if you need help.
>>216635491
Obviously there's a political aspect but America has had one of the largest Jewish populations on Earth for a while now, so a ton of European Jews moved to America after the holocaust
>>216638381
we have a huge Ukrainian diaspora but still can't imagine the Polish national anthem to be played before any movie important for this community, it would just feel weird
>>216638435
It wasn't as huge and glaring of an issue as it was 1918-1920 but the federal government was still actively subverting communist groups and having communist labor organizers murdered by strikebreakers and other thugs. The CPUSA was actually very prominent in the 30s and was very well represented in union halls. It wasn't until the 50s that American communists stopped being as visible, but the party was an active member in the Comintern and coordinated well with the CPSU until the Soviet-German nonaggression pact.