Thread 64097845 - /k/ [Archived: 38 hours ago]

Anonymous
8/9/2025, 11:45:39 AM No.64097845
012931825752124
012931825752124
md5: 4a5b7b93cfb267cbedf11242c4d2224b🔍
in Inglourious Basterds, athe beginning of the movie Hans Landa aims his pistol at a jewish girl who is running away (it's one of those old timey nazi guns). We get a shot from what I assume is his pov. He decides to let her go, but could he realistically hit her at that distance?
Replies: >>64097861 >>64100814 >>64100883
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 11:56:03 AM No.64097861
>>64097845 (OP)
It would be a real son of a bitch of a shot. He let her go so he could hunt her later. He's doing this for his own enjoyment. At anytime he could have gotten in the kubelwagen to run her down or had one of his men with a rifle shoot her.
Replies: >>64098099
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 12:02:37 PM No.64097870
She runs for about 20 seconds before he gets his gun lined up on her. An average woman runs at about 9 km/h, or 2.5 meters per second, so he would be making a roughly 50 meter shot on a human sized target that has a roughly stationary silhouette. Her entire torso would be approximately the height of a 50 meter pistol target's scoring area, and hitting her somewhere near center of mass would be equivalent to a decently high scoring hit (but not a bullseye).

In other words, shooting here at that range would be a challenging but doable shot for a competition shooter. Your average officer with barely any handgun training would find it extremely difficult, however.
Replies: >>64098099
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 2:20:35 PM No.64098099
>>64097870
yeah that's the thing, I wouldn't have expected Landa to make that shot anyways. but like >>64097861 said if he really wanted to get her they could have just jumped into a car
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 2:50:07 AM No.64100573
This movie sucked
Replies: >>64100686 >>64100863
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 3:19:12 AM No.64100686
>>64100573
It had great dialogue, but besides that it is standard "cheer for the minorities or actual bad guys" that hollywood loves to make.
Replies: >>64100723
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 3:35:20 AM No.64100723
>>64100686
No the dialogue sucked just the same as every other tarentino movie. His best one was Jackie Brown because it was based on something already written by an actually good writer.
Replies: >>64100798 >>64100891 >>64100896
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 3:55:43 AM No.64100798
>>64100723
>his best one was Jackie Brown

What, you didn't like Hateful 8?
Replies: >>64100900
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:01:07 AM No.64100814
1444156170562
1444156170562
md5: 02412d9492b56e8fb0c1772924f79a8a🔍
>>64097845 (OP)
Why didn't Hans Landa hit?
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:13:52 AM No.64100863
>>64100573
>This movie sucked
Its not for retards who need constant meaningless action. Brad Pitt sucked I will give you that.
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:18:14 AM No.64100883
IMG_4200
IMG_4200
md5: 8af2e843aa1cd23da4e57629d70fcc01🔍
>>64097845 (OP)

Okay so I did some quick calculating here. The average running speed of a 20 year old woman according to Torokhtiy (some random weightlifting website) is between 4.5 and 8.5 miles per hour. I will assume that Shoshana’s speed was probably closer the latter due to her state of fitness and adrenaline. 8.5 miles per hour translates to around 750 feet per minute or 12.5 feet per second. I re-watched the scene with a stopwatch and 36 seconds elapse from when she escaped the basement and when Landa puts his gun down (essentially ending his window of opportunity to shoot her). Assuming that the scene occurs in real time and she maintained a constant speed in those 36 seconds, she would have covered roughly 450 feet or 137 meters of ground.

Landa’s weapon is a Walther P38, standard issue pistol in the Wehrmacht and SS. It has an effective firing range of 50 meters, after which point the effects of gravity and air pressure on the bullet make it difficult for even a crack shot to reliably hit anything, although it’s not impossible.

At 137 meters, Shoshana was well over twice the effective range of a P38 away from Landa.

Could he have hit her at that 36 second mark? Honestly probably not. Even if he was an expert marksman with his P38, the mere fact that she was a moving target and already well beyond effective range would have made that shot virtually impossible, at least on the first try. Now if he had opened fire 10-20 seconds earlier, he may have been able to do it, and even if he missed the first shot, he still would have had enough time to readjust for a second or third. But by the time he put his gun down, he would in all likelihood have missed the first shot and not had time for another before she disappeared over the hill.
Replies: >>64100905
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:18:44 AM No.64100891
>>64100723
>Obvious b8 is obvious
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:20:27 AM No.64100896
20250528_000048
20250528_000048
md5: 8dfcde19001fe029d595a6ca089468be🔍
>>64100723
Nah. All the Landa scenes and the basement were great.
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:21:53 AM No.64100900
>>64100798
The story about the guitar is the best part of that movie.
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 4:22:56 AM No.64100905
>>64100883
>closer the latter due to her state of fitness
She is a starving teenager.