← Home ← Back to /k/

Thread 64150723

59 posts 46 images /k/
Anonymous No.64150723 >>64150818 >>64150856 >>64151003
There is a thread up discussing some of the world war movies ever made. Lets discuss some of the good ones.
Anonymous No.64150724 >>64150827
Anonymous No.64150760 >>64150797 >>64150835
Come and See, for best comedy.
Anonymous No.64150797 >>64150800
>>64150760
kill yourself
Anonymous No.64150800
>>64150797
Anonymous No.64150818 >>64150832
>>64150723 (OP)
I fell asleep watching that, the 1979 version is better than the other two....if you can consider the recent version even the same fucking story.
Anonymous No.64150827 >>64153117
>>64150724
Hands down winner. I like when war movies actually make war not look fun.
Anonymous No.64150832 >>64150861
>>64150818
I do agree that i actually think the 1979 version is a little better but i like the 1930 version just because the cast was either actual WW1 veterans or people who had seen the war and it was true to the actual events of the war. The 2022 version was just over dramatized netflix slop.
Anonymous No.64150835
>>64150760
kek
Anonymous No.64150850 >>64151003 >>64151990 >>64153206 >>64153249 >>64155301
I watched the full 4 hour long version of the movie. A lot of people say the plantation seen wasn't very good hence why it was cut from the release version but i liked it.
Anonymous No.64150856 >>64150868 >>64150879 >>64153188
>>64150723 (OP)
>other /tv/ thread hasn't even hit 110 posts
one marginally off-topic thread at a time, moron

anyone who replies below this is a gunless nigger
Anonymous No.64150861 >>64156476
>>64150832
I just wish they hadn't cast an old man as Kat in the 1979 version. Ernest Borgnine was great, but Kat was supposed to be 40, not at least 60.
The 2022 version, it's a mess. The action and special effects are literally all I watched it for after realizing how far off they were straying from the story. The book opens with "this is neither an excuse nor apology" but the 2022 version was BOTH of those things. It's nothing but modern European apathy packaged in a classic and attractive wrapper. Absolutely bullshit, and the peripheral characters were pure cringe.
Anonymous No.64150868
>>64150856
I have more guns than you and I'll talk to other /k/ommandos about war movies as much as I want
Anonymous No.64150879 >>64151759
>>64150856
Here's your (you) faggot
Post gun + movie or gtfo
Anonymous No.64150915 >>64152389
The train (1964) is probably one of my favorite war movies of all time.
Anonymous No.64150939 >>64151003 >>64151978 >>64154390
I usually don't like older war movies because they were often so corny and made it look like the US hip fired their Thompsons to Berlin without taking a single casualty, but this is good
Anonymous No.64151003 >>64151064 >>64152389 >>64153309
We watched Gallipoli in high school and the soundtrack still haunts me to this day. As an important piece of our national birth and mythology, properly visualising the campaign for the first time really helped my understanding of something I had heard about since I was a little kid. It gives you a taste of the pride, the guts, and the tragedy, all while immersing you with great set design and environments. I can't say, as I wasn't alive in 1915, but it really feels authentic.
>>64150723 (OP)
The 1931 film is incredible. While it's clearly an entirely anti-war work and everything within it serves that explicit purpose, I enjoyed it thoroughly and compared to more modern stuff is still one of the best films I've seen in a long, long time, even its depiction of the actual fighting itself. Such a shame that the 2022 adaptation was total ass.
>>64150850
Watching Apocalypse Now for the first time was an experience. I never understood the hype around it and always assumed that as a movie people frequently cite as the best, it would be something I wouldn't enjoy but a friend is writing a paper on it and so we watched it one weekend and that opening sequence is absolutely one of, if not the best I have seen in my life. It sucked me right in.
>>64150939
Watched this while painting models one evening, it was good fun. Some incredible actors in their prime and absolutely riveting the whole way through. A lot of movies focus on individuals or a smaller group, but A Bridge Too Far really helped to piece together, to a degree, the whole scale of the Operation from individual effort to collective, and how that pieces into the wider picture of the war as a whole. It's something you often lack with a lot of other films and books, really.
Anonymous No.64151064 >>64152389
>>64151003
Gallipoli was fantastic. The captain's last little speech he gives his men made me tear up a little bit.
Anonymous No.64151759 >>64153188
>>64150879
>hurrr guns are le only weapons

Burger education.
Anonymous No.64151802
Any good grounded near-future war films? Doesn't have to follow the soldiers themselves.
I'm waiting for Zero Day Attack to get a Western release.
Anonymous No.64151978
>>64150939
Possibly the best war film of all time
Anonymous No.64151990
>>64150850
Hello, fellow kinoplex member
Anonymous No.64152389
A reminder that watching Das Boot and The Cruel Sea back to back is one of the best ways to spend an afternoon.

>>64150915
Holy shit, someone else who's seen it!

>>64151003
>>64151064
Personally I prefer The Lighthorsemen, but Gallipoli is still great
Anonymous No.64153117 >>64154455
>>64150827
I thought it made some parts of war look kind of fun. Mostly in the first two acts.
Anonymous No.64153188
>>64150856
Fuck off, go obsess over one of the several drone missile speculation threads, or whatever other nonsense you post about
>>64151759
Noguns need not apply
Anonymous No.64153206 >>64153212
>>64150850
I said in the other thread I don't even really think of this as a war movie. It's almost like some Hitchcock psychological thriller or something.
Anonymous No.64153212 >>64153231
>>64153206
Oh boy anon, do I have a book for you
Anonymous No.64153231 >>64153243
>>64153212
Oh? Please tell me
Anonymous No.64153243 >>64154137
>>64153231
Heart of Darkness, the story that Apocalypse Now is based off of

https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/219
Anonymous No.64153249
>>64150850

I understand the context and importance of the plantation scene, but holy shit does it bog down the pacing of the film
Anonymous No.64153256 >>64154461 >>64158080 >>64160030
Any ANZACs here?
Anonymous No.64153309
>>64151003
>Gallipoli
My man. Apart from being a good war film, it has Oxygène from Jean-Micheal Fucking Jarre. I was stoked when I heard the music in the film on my VHS copy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bbzq7EKKbm8
Anonymous No.64154112 >>64154405 >>64154468
Anonymous No.64154121 >>64154445
The only good war movie other than Narvik that was released in the last 5 years and one of the few good ones released post 2000
Anonymous No.64154137
>>64153243
Yeah I've read it, it's great. Thanks for the link though I've been meaning to reread it, I'll probably do so at work the next two days.
Anonymous No.64154390
>>64150939
They really don't know how to do epics like this anymore.

It's actually amazing how much they manage to show in this movie and still make it easy to follow the operation and feel cohesive
Anonymous No.64154405 >>64154414
>>64154112
Absolutely great film.

I caught The Steel Helmet on TCM one day as a kid with my grandfather. Really good war movie, especially for it's era.
Anonymous No.64154414
>>64154405
clicked on the thread to post steel helmet, tremendous feat of low budget filmmaking
Anonymous No.64154435
Das Boot
Anonymous No.64154445
>>64154121
slop.
Anonymous No.64154455
>>64153117
It looked fun until the train hit the east, total vibe change. That was a really good touch to emphasize the massive change in the movie's tone
Anonymous No.64154461
>>64153256
I'm not but I thoroughly enjoyed that movie. Great gun porn besides being a good movie
Anonymous No.64154468
>>64154112
Mein neger
Anonymous No.64154530 >>64154539
That new Warfare (2025) by A24 was really good, I love GWOT stuff. My favorite war kino is Generation Kill, although obviously not a movie.
Anonymous No.64154539 >>64154721
>>64154530
Only gwot film i liked was Jarhead and that was more so pre gwot. Everything else was glorified and dramatized trash.
>yeah we all know you cleaned toilets in a fob for your entire deployment and don't even know what the Taliban look like.
Anonymous No.64154721 >>64158160
>>64154539
Eh, still more action than me. I've been meaning to check out Jarhead, just added it to my Plex not too long ago. Really like Jake Gylennhal so I'm looking forward to it.
Anonymous No.64155301 >>64155317
>>64150850
You have supreme taste and too many people are filtered by Redux
The additional scenes add to the vibe of the descent into darkness and the heart of the jungle
It feels closer to the book, IMHO
Anonymous No.64155317
>>64155301
Such an ethereal experience
https://youtu.be/BXqPNlng6uI
Anonymous No.64156476 >>64158099 >>64159801
>>64150861
More than that, it really misses the entire apolitical tragedy of the book. The title isn't "war is bad because evil greedy warmongers kill everyone (and everyone is dead so its all quiet now" but "the sheer scale of the industrialized war machine has dehumanized the individual to such an amount that your death will be so insignificant as to not even bother reporting it." The old neoliberal trope of "war is bad only when leaders are bad (conservative) because it gets our guys killed and for bad reasons" like M*A*S*H and most Vietnam war era stuff and not war and violence especially post industrial revolution being manmade hell that leaves permanent physical scars on the landscape and the psyche. The trap of there being a good clean way to inflict this and not the yucky bad way and somehow despite the guns and tanks and planes being the same, if you have good politically correct leaders none of the bad parts will happen. I blame the utter whitewashing of WWII for this really. Not in a nazi apologist sort of way but in how we think of the European theater as this clean honorable fight. Too many vets died too early to really give a better look but IIRC something like 30,000 civilians died between Normandy and the liberation of Paris specifically from Allied bombing and ground offensives. I'm getting too off topic now but new All Quiet's added political scenes really ruin the message of the book.
Anonymous No.64158080
>>64153256
Really good Vietnam film without any baggage from a US POV
Anonymous No.64158099
>>64156476
The end of the 2022 film was such dumb bullshit that had no basis on any sort of reality. They transplant the stab in the back myth into that general who demands his troops carry out a final attack minutes before the armistice to prove they hand lost or some shit, when every German solider and officer knew they had lost in autumn 1918. They were reaching forwards to the weimar Republic and trying to set up things from that in the end of the film.
They strayed so often and so pointlessly from the book, why change how Kat dies, why add all the Versaillies stuff.
Shame because all the trench stuff was kino
Anonymous No.64158160 >>64159762
>>64154721
Jarhead kinda sucks honestly
Anonymous No.64159762
>>64158160
Suckhead kind of jars honestly
Anonymous No.64159776 >>64160241
Anonymous No.64159784
Anonymous No.64159786
Anonymous No.64159801
>>64156476
>The title isn't "war is bad because evil greedy warmongers kill everyone (and everyone is dead so its all quiet now" but "the sheer scale of the industrialized war machine has dehumanized the individual to such an amount that your death will be so insignificant as to not even bother reporting it."
It was awhile ago (before that movie) where my impression of that war was also less "evil greedy warmongers" but more like "incompetent blunderers." That often doesn't get into movies because it doesn't fit the standard adventure-story model. I haven't seen anything like that really except Starship Troopers where the first battle is a complete disaster that they just bumble into, but it's also told within the adventure-story frame as satire of propaganda aimed at civilians back home. The Russian filmmaker Alexander Nevzorov (who made war films in the 90s) predicting a dark-comic disaster in 2021 proved to be more accurate than many military analysts:
https://youtu.be/OutvYSl_TLc

>I blame the utter whitewashing of WWII for this really. Not in a nazi apologist sort of way but in how we think of the European theater as this clean honorable fight.
Yeah. I'm going to metnion Paul Fussell who wrote about WWII (which he was involved in) in a way that tried to bust the myths about it as clean / honorable.
Anonymous No.64160030
>>64153256
Good movie but the 2006 documentary is better
Anonymous No.64160241
>>64159776
That's a good one