← Home ← Back to /lgbt/

Thread 40044889

156 posts 14 images /lgbt/
Anonymous No.40044889 [Report] >>40044906 >>40044920 >>40044921 >>40044929 >>40044976 >>40045041 >>40045149 >>40045222 >>40045259 >>40045308 >>40045784 >>40046084 >>40046195 >>40046271 >>40046846 >>40047291 >>40049127 >>40049219
She's not AGP you guys
>She's just doing it to be ironic
>She's just doing it for attention from men
>There's nothing sexual about this at all
>It's just subtle political commentary
>It's just mocking how men find this erotic
>It's just commentary on the male gaze.
>It's men who insist on making this sexual
>despite what it may look like, thisnis nothing like TRUE AGP. >She isn't crossdressing (or male)

Women can't be AGP because.... because... because it messes up our narrative okay??
Anonymous No.40044906 [Report] >>40044917
>>40044889 (OP)
cope harder agp-chan
go goon somewhere else
Anonymous No.40044917 [Report]
>>40044906

Who's the one coping here exactly?
Nina !!dumxcG0IEPs No.40044920 [Report] >>40044933 >>40044938 >>40045499
>>40044889 (OP)
who cares? who the fuck listening to this anyways ? who the fuck even knows who this is?
Anonymous No.40044921 [Report] >>40044941 >>40045089 >>40045095 >>40047016
>>40044889 (OP)
> Women can't be AGP because.... because...
because AGP is a male’s propensity to be aroused at the thought of being a woman. Hope this helps.
Anonymous No.40044929 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
That's not agp.
Anonymous No.40044933 [Report]
>>40044920
Pretty sure a lot of people know who Sabrina Carpenter is
Anonymous No.40044938 [Report] >>40044968
>>40044920

I listen to it because I like pop music by female artists in general... idk it's called being fembrained???
Anonymous No.40044941 [Report] >>40044990 >>40044996
>>40044921
nothing in the term "autogynephilia" precludes women from having it. it means you're arouse by thought of yourself as a woman. which cis women are obviously culturally conditioned to be aroused by. hope this helps
Nina !!dumxcG0IEPs No.40044968 [Report] >>40045029 >>40045035
>>40044938
ok me too but listen to good ones
G~ !!2Ag5BbIcpdQ No.40044976 [Report] >>40046017
>>40044889 (OP)
Why do people care about this so much? When did gen z get so puritanical
Anonymous No.40044981 [Report]
Naturally being able to have tits and wanting to be pretty isnt agp retard
Anonymous No.40044990 [Report] >>40045019 >>40045027
>>40044941
this fact triggers the autogynephile.
Anonymous No.40044996 [Report] >>40045019 >>40045027 >>40045089
>>40044941
Type it into Google and let me know what the definition is. Good luck
Anonymous No.40045019 [Report] >>40045033 >>40045036
>>40044990
>>40044996
>muh heckin prescriptivity
Anonymous No.40045027 [Report] >>40045065 >>40045077 >>40045192
>>40044990
>>40044996
>using google to define words for you as an argument
literal middle-school tier. you're not even using a fucking dictionary to make your definitional argument. bye bye, children
Anonymous No.40045029 [Report] >>40045777
>>40044968

Theres music i listen to because it's good and music i listen to because I like to save pictures of the artist and think about how a woman like that would never even look at me
Anonymous No.40045033 [Report] >>40045105
>>40045019
no its a description of some male exclusive phenomenon behavior that exists
and its very accurate
Anonymous No.40045035 [Report] >>40045088
>>40044968
She’s so dogshit why can’t people just say she sucks instead of making up retarded moral controversies. It’s not like musicians stopped making good music either like I don’t understand
Anonymous No.40045036 [Report] >>40045105 >>40045135
>>40045019
>confuses descriptivity for prescriptivity cuz labels are oppressive or something
Many such cases
Anonymous No.40045041 [Report] >>40045147
>>40044889 (OP)
How exactly is being a submissive dishrag to men the desire to see oneself as a woman o woke algo Jesus?
Anonymous No.40045065 [Report] >>40045107
>>40045027
>I have no rebuttal
I'll take your concession.
Anonymous No.40045077 [Report] >>40045107
>>40045027
>nooooo you have to find a source that confirms my bias nooooo
Nina !!dumxcG0IEPs No.40045088 [Report]
>>40045035
her attempt at social commentary isn’t even very profound or interesting anyway. she’s prolly a nepo baby industry plant
Anonymous No.40045089 [Report] >>40045106 >>40045116
>>40044996
>>40044921

So what do you call a woman being aroussed by wearing sexy clothes and doing seemingly degrading hyperfeminine things, assuming the woman involved enjoys it and get aroused, independently of any other rationale such as profit or "it's halloween?"

Because my assumption is that you're going to fight me on that and say "women never get aroused by doing normal woman things you disgusting AGP pervert"
PriInChastity No.40045095 [Report] >>40045126 >>40045146
>>40044921
bc the one who invented the term agp said its like this, despite making no sense at all. Agp is a real phenomenon, but it can happen with any gynephile, not only tgirls.

Psychology is a fucked up science bc most people who try to study it always choose one relevant author of any theme and becomes their bitch who will defend them in any way possible.

idk how it is in other places, but where i live it is kind of a problem in the academy, bc theyre just recycling the same material from the same authors that died decades ago

im not saying blanchard is inherently wrong but you all should start criticizing him, he was one of the first ones who started to deeply study transgenderism
Anonymous No.40045105 [Report] >>40045185
>>40045036
>>40045033

>something made up with an extremely limited data set by an old straight guy in the 1980s and NEVER REVISED REPRODUCED OR UPDATED is not only accurate but it can NEVER be changed or revised!

You pseudointellectual hons disgust me. I assume you still think atoms resemble pudding with raisins in it.
Anonymous No.40045106 [Report] >>40045119
>>40045089
She’s not having a cross sex fantasy.
Anonymous No.40045107 [Report]
>>40045065
>>40045077
there is no point to rebut. a definition is *defined* as something discrete from an argument
Anonymous No.40045116 [Report] >>40045284
>>40045089
>what if my cat likes playing fetch
That's what you're asking.
That's a category error.
Anonymous No.40045119 [Report] >>40045131
>>40045106
true, stop using term agp then and just call it cross sex fantasy for men and women
Anonymous No.40045124 [Report]
oh no, the identity politic ideology isn't logically cohesive!
Anonymous No.40045126 [Report]
>>40045095
> it can happen with any gynephile, not only tgirls.
Only male gynephiles
> you all should start criticizing him
For what exactly?
Anonymous No.40045131 [Report]
>>40045119
it even has kinda pedophilic acronym - CSA
Anonymous No.40045135 [Report] >>40045145 >>40045216
>>40045036
You are using it in a prescriptive way
If we used a descriptive definition, we would've acknowledged agp also happens to females because its basically the same behavior
Anonymous No.40045145 [Report] >>40045301
>>40045135
You're missing the point that females aren't having a cross sex fantasy because they're already female dumbshit
Anonymous No.40045146 [Report]
>>40045095
My primary criticism of Blanchard is that he (understandably) never foresaw a future where transexuality could be a youth subculture niche constructed through social connectivity hive programs beamed to screens on an ubiquitous transhumanist sensory organ that fits in people’s hands
Anonymous No.40045147 [Report]
>>40045041

I don't know. I have a feeling I can't describe when I weaR sexy clothes and participate in mildly degrading cheeky activities and i don't think science yet has a satisfactory explanation. So i am discussing it with my peers, the trannies of /tttt/
Anonymous No.40045149 [Report] >>40047825
>>40044889 (OP)
Being a slut isn't AGP you retard.
AGP is arousal at the idea of being female, not arousal at the idea of being dominated by a man.
If anything she's being HSTS.
Anonymous No.40045185 [Report] >>40045359
>>40045105
>old
He wasn’t old in the 80s. Even then who cares? Are you ageist?
>straight
Ray Blanchard is gay
>guy
Nice misandry. Anne Lawrence is a trans woman who also studied AGP.
>1980s
So?
>NEVER REPRODUCED
Very false, just do a cursory search on Google for peer reviews and subsequent studies. Everything you’re saying is all the common AGP cope
Anonymous No.40045192 [Report] >>40045203
>>40045027
>using established definitions of words is bad
Lmao
Anonymous No.40045203 [Report] >>40045233 >>40045253
>>40045192
prescriptivism really is an IQ limit, isn't it?
Anonymous No.40045216 [Report] >>40045296 >>40045374
>>40045135
Women are getting turned on at the thought of being desired by a man as a woman (which they already are). AGPs are turned on by desiring their own self as female, which they are not. These are not even close to the same thing.
Anonymous No.40045222 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
i don't listen to her but i find all the pearl clutching over this to be deeply ironic and very funny
>women can do and say what they want
>wait not like that!
Anonymous No.40045226 [Report] >>40045387
Its a campy charactature of like a 1950s woman which is her entire persona.
All her fans are gay men and women. Also pop artists don’t do anything publicly for their own sexual enjoyment this is all to max money.

But afab woman can be AGP
Anonymous No.40045233 [Report] >>40045243 >>40045286
>>40045203
Idk what that word means anon. Should I look it up? Nta
Anonymous No.40045240 [Report] >>40045249 >>40045286 >>40045401 >>40047298
Threadly reminder Blanchard came up with the term autogynephilia and has been very clear about the question of whether natal females experience it (they don't), so if you disagree with him you should use your own terminology instead of trying to alter the meaning of his.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WLN38t_eOjk&t=1400s
Anonymous No.40045243 [Report]
>>40045233
They don’t know what it means either, which is why they keep misusing it
Anonymous No.40045249 [Report]
>>40045240
daddy.....
Anonymous No.40045253 [Report]
>>40045203
if you need a new word make a new fucking word
I think "auto-gynephelia" is a little clunky myself. I prefer "happy whore"
悉尼人 (Xiniren) No.40045259 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
I don't even know who this is or why we're seeing 1980s boomers
Anonymous No.40045284 [Report] >>40045291 >>40045296 >>40045350
>>40045116

Right but I'm not asking if a cat plays fetch i' asking about women being aroused by their own female body and/or being perceived as female and/or being sexualized in a way that some onlookers might perceive as degrading. Why must you keep dodging the point?

Is this a thing that happens or is it not? Is it AGP or is it something else?
Anonymous No.40045286 [Report] >>40045304 >>40045319
>>40045233
no, you should infer the meaning from context, like human beings used to do. you fucking troglodyte

>>40045240
and the artist's interpretation of their work is the correct one? the question was rhetorical, you don't have to prove me right so quickly
Anonymous No.40045291 [Report]
>>40045284
it's agp but to admit that makes the whole concept of agp fall apart so that's why they get so mad
Anonymous No.40045296 [Report]
>>40045284
See
>>40045216
Anonymous No.40045301 [Report] >>40045320
>>40045145

Women can experience/be subject to emasculation or feminization to whatever extent they can act masculine/androgynous or be perceived as masculine or androgynous. This is known and written about. It's part and parcel of female sexuality and sexualization of women.
Anonymous No.40045304 [Report] >>40045327
>>40045286
It isn't subjective artwork. It's an objectively defined research term.
Anonymous No.40045308 [Report] >>40045424
>>40044889 (OP)
The thing that depresses me about this is that young girls see it … :(
Anonymous No.40045319 [Report]
>>40045286
> no, you should infer the meaning from context, like human beings used to do
It seems like it means a philosophy that holds established canon as absolute redlines that cannot be further discussed, given your conversation with that anon. But it’s probably broader than than, as the root word prescriptive doesn’t exactly jive with the meaning the context clues has led me to interpret,
which is swhy I asked
Anonymous No.40045320 [Report] >>40045437
>>40045301
bro just stop arguing and say you don’t get it, this is embarrassing
Anonymous No.40045327 [Report] >>40045338
>>40045304
yes, and, to mengele, "the jew" was also an "objectively defined research term"
Anonymous No.40045338 [Report] >>40045384
>>40045327
>AGP is like nazism
lmao funniest AGP cope yet
Anonymous No.40045343 [Report] >>40045390
The whole point of Blanchard's thesis is that men who are hetero (female-attracted) get their aroudal wires crossed and start being attracted to a fantasy of themselves being female.

This is distinct from females who submissively attracted to men because of fembrain.
Anonymous No.40045350 [Report] >>40045457
>>40045284
I'm not. You're missing the point. The female isn't having a cross sex fantasy
You're also equivocating that agp ==degrading.

That's not the case. You dont even know what agp is.
Anonymous No.40045359 [Report]
>>40045185

I am pretty sure Ray Blanchard is married to a woman... and isn't gay. The AI you like to use for support comes backwash no publicly available information.

This leads me to think that everything else your saying is more lies and misdirection i.e. "look over there!"

Also the fact that something was studied in the 80s when trans medecine was primitive and virtually unknown is extremely significant because it tries to construct a typology ina n environment where many more trans people will be repressed, no access to legal or social gender change, and much less passing.

Basically his patients pretty much socially had a gun to their head to contextualize their desire to be a woman as a fetish at least for somsignifigant portion of their lives.
Anonymous No.40045374 [Report] >>40045439
>>40045216

What if a bisexual (or lesbian) woman found herself attractive though? In addition to arousal about having sex with men?

I mean a person can participate in a threesome and be attracted to two partners of different genders, can't they?
Anonymous No.40045384 [Report] >>40045399
>>40045338
the absolute lack of reading comprehension. anyone can say any category means anything. blanchtard is scheler's "explanatory psychologist": he forces his subjects to fit his categories, not the other way around ("psychology of understanding")
Anonymous No.40045387 [Report] >>40045419
>>40045226

>afab women can't be AGP

Side question but why is this side of the argument dogmatic and absolution as if the idea of questioning or broadening AGP is scary to them and undermines their world view?
Anonymous No.40045390 [Report] >>40045480
>>40045343
>females who submissively attracted to men because of fembrain
And if there's people born male that like men then they're HSTS? That makes sense

>welcome to being a tranny here's blanchard's thesis please fill out these boxes
Anonymous No.40045399 [Report] >>40045414
>>40045384
agp deniers are like literal flat earth npcs holy shit
Anonymous No.40045401 [Report] >>40045533
>>40045240

Science isn't a creative enterprise anon. It's supposed to be publicly shared, discussed, built upon, and repressed at will in the name of experimentation and development.

Trying to guard research like a kid with a sand castle just means you're not doing real research.
Anonymous No.40045414 [Report]
>>40045399
the concept of descriptivism, with continual reference to this fucking thread
Anonymous No.40045419 [Report] >>40045531
>>40045387
>why dont atheists believe in god? Don't they know they'll go to hell?
Anonymous No.40045424 [Report] >>40045453 >>40045654
>>40045308

And this is what underpins the strict definition of AGP folks. Social conservatism, the gender binary, and morality policing others.
Anonymous No.40045437 [Report]
>>40045320

Who doesn't get what here, exactly?
Anonymous No.40045439 [Report] >>40045467 >>40045569
>>40045374
You’re still not getting that this is a cross sex fantasy. It’s so, so obvious that’s what you’re not understanding. Why can’t you get this?
Anonymous No.40045453 [Report] >>40045569
>>40045424
You haven’t even demonstrated that you understand the original definition. AGP denialism is all one big cope.
Anonymous No.40045457 [Report] >>40045473
>>40045350

>you don't even know what AGP is

AGP/MEF is a subcategory experienced by many heterosexual trans women and probably cis as well. This is different from the "lesbian" and autosexual trad AGP but the root feeling is (probably?) The same

And also I can assure you that I'm smart, have a lot of sexual experience and know a lot about what all these tranny things are. Do (you)?
Anonymous No.40045467 [Report] >>40045487 >>40045490
>>40045439
>the word "faggot" means "bundle of sticks," it's not a slur! here, look at this definition some old retard who collects sticks wrote
Anonymous No.40045473 [Report]
>>40045457
> also I can assure you that I'm smart
Lmfao
Anonymous No.40045480 [Report] >>40045500
>>40045390
>And if there's people born male that like men then they're HSTS? That makes sense
Are you being ironic?

Homosexual Transsexual is the term for males who are into males and seek transition
Anonymous No.40045487 [Report] >>40045515
>>40045467
>category error
>again
Anonymous No.40045490 [Report] >>40045515
>>40045467
False equivalence. Crazy mental gymnastics going on here damn
Anonymous No.40045499 [Report]
>>40044920
>who the fuck even knows who this is?
Buddy, this chick ended up being what kicked off the federal investigation into Eric Adams. If she were not such a thot, his dealings might not have been uncovered.
Anonymous No.40045500 [Report] >>40045512
>>40045480
All gay males are "HSTS" but dont troon out because 90% of them can't pass
Anonymous No.40045512 [Report] >>40045525
>>40045500
agps cant pass and they transition
Anonymous No.40045515 [Report]
>>40045487
>>40045490
go tell black people to stop calling each other "nigga." i really don't know how many other ways i can put this so you two can understand it
Anonymous No.40045525 [Report] >>40045535 >>40045629
>>40045512
yes exactly. now you get it!
agps transition regardless if they pass or not. they actually want to be female

hsts just want to fit in.
Anonymous No.40045531 [Report]
>>40045419

I'm an atheist but I'd be an absolute fool if I told you I understand how the universe works, or otherwise ignore the limits of my own knowledge snd understanding.
Anonymous No.40045533 [Report] >>40045551 >>40045581
>>40045401
Anyone's welcome to prove him wrong. But disputing his claim isn't the same thing as taking a word he coined and using it to mean something completely different from how he defined it.
That would be like going around saying iguanas are a kind of black hole because you disagree with Laplace on what the term black hole should refer to.
Anonymous !......lia. No.40045535 [Report]
>>40045525
>agps transition regardless if they pass or not
reporting in to confirm
Anonymous No.40045551 [Report] >>40045568
>>40045533
the term "black hole" refers to my fucking sphincter, and Laplace can blow my girldick. how many more times
Anonymous No.40045568 [Report]
>>40045551
>the term "black hole" refers to my fucking sphincter
Not even light can escape your asshole? Are you single?
Anonymous No.40045569 [Report] >>40045597 >>40045609
>>40045453

I understand the original definition fine, you have to be male to have AGP. However, I question whether that's really the case.

>>40045439

It just doesn't seem so simple and categorical to me. I feel i experience AGP but there's nothing "cross sex" about the feeling, i have dysphoria about male sex characteristics. I feel aroused by feminine characteristics, and attire, and sometimes social roles or sexual behaviors or the like. But the idea of not medically transitioning and crossdressing and being in a relationship with a woman and using my penis for sex is utterly repulsive.

So i have experimental data that causes me to doubt that the traditional definition of AGP is accurate.
Anonymous No.40045581 [Report]
>>40045533

Now THAT argument is a false equivalence.
Anonymous No.40045597 [Report] >>40045662
>>40045569
Nothing you’ve described is incompatible with having AGP
Anonymous No.40045609 [Report] >>40045631
>>40045569
Are you male?
Anonymous No.40045629 [Report]
>>40045525
I don't know who you are. I was explaining the difference between AGPs and female sexuality that OP is confused about. HSTS is irrelevant here.
Anonymous No.40045631 [Report] >>40045648
>>40045609

I'm trans, mostly heterosexual, getting srs in 4 months.
Anonymous No.40045648 [Report] >>40045674 >>40045681
>>40045631
So AGP, got it. Yea this whole thread makes sense now.
Anonymous No.40045654 [Report]
>>40045424
I wasnt even saying anything about AGP in my post. I was saying that it’s sad when young girls (afab or amab) see adult women depicted as animals or in such objectifying positions. Because likely these children viewing this are also watching their parents relationship be governed by old patriarchal rules and it just is gonna fuck them up mentally and give them a bad idea of what it means to be a adult and a woman. It’s sad because young girls will emulate sabrina and be submissive to young men who will (probably) treat them horribly because everyone’s brain is poisoned with violent misogynistic porn. But that’s just the plight of straight young women these days
Anonymous No.40045662 [Report] >>40045718
>>40045597

people in this thread seem to implying that AGP requires as a predicate

>having/maintaining a male identity
>aroused by cross sex nature of the fantasy
>no dysphoria/detachment from primary sex characteristics, (i.e.penis and physical masculinity is a feature of the fantasy, not a bug or an obstacle)
Anonymous No.40045674 [Report]
>>40045648

What exactly makes sense to you anon?
Anonymous No.40045681 [Report] >>40045724
>>40045648
as if your motivations weren't equally bald. what a sanctimonious, canting slug you are. friendless, i have no doubt
Anonymous No.40045686 [Report] >>40045693 >>40045699
>agp is when a woman expressed sexuality
Anonymous No.40045693 [Report]
>>40045686
>said no one ever
Anonymous No.40045699 [Report]
>>40045686
Some trannies seem to want to redefine AGP as that so they can say they're just normal women instead of natal males on estrogen with a paraphilia.
Anonymous No.40045718 [Report] >>40045822
>>40045662
>>having/maintaining a male identity
That would be wrong. What is required is the physical state of being male, an XY small gamete adult human. Identity has nothing to do with it.
Anonymous No.40045724 [Report] >>40045752
>>40045681
Wrong! I’m actually super popular and very hot and smart too!
Anonymous !......lia. No.40045725 [Report] >>40045735 >>40045785
lets at least acknowledge we all agree that foids are categorically ace
Anonymous No.40045735 [Report] >>40045746
>>40045725
wrong. they're walletsexual
Anonymous !......lia. No.40045746 [Report]
>>40045735
kek finally i can soothe my self esteem issues
Anonymous No.40045752 [Report] >>40045767
>>40045724
i almost pity you. almost. i try to be kind to worms but, you, i would step on
Anonymous No.40045767 [Report]
>>40045752
Cringe reply
Anonymous No.40045777 [Report] >>40046232
>>40045029
Your post is honestly the most interesting in this thread. Which artists fall into the latter category for you? Ariana, Marina, Lana, Lorde, Demi Lovato, Gaga, Sabrina, Hailee Steinfeld, Halsey, Rihanna, Kim Petras, Nikki Minaj, Beyonce, Doja Cat, Julia Michaels, and/or Selena Gomez? Do you also like thinking about how the women you listen to wouldn't date you or just the saving their pictures part? What about it drives you to listen to music think so little of yourself? Self-pity or hatred? A desire for femdom?
Anonymous No.40045784 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
>Women can't be AGP because.... because... because it messes up our narrative okay??
a woman being aroused by being a submissive woman is not the same as a man being aroused by being a submissive woman
Anonymous No.40045785 [Report] >>40045805 >>40045988
>>40045725
I think i have most similar to hsts sexuality as a straight cis afab. The visualized thought of a hard or c*mming penis is probably the pinnacle of arousal for me ^_^
Anonymous !......lia. No.40045805 [Report]
>>40045785
>as a straight cis afab
there are no women on the internet silly
dismissed
Anonymous No.40045822 [Report] >>40045839 >>40045975
>>40045718

You're saying a meta-textual fetish involving contemporary symbols connected to gender expression is dependant on chromosomes? That seems counter intuitive.
Anonymous No.40045839 [Report] >>40045980
>>40045822
as a male, you just wouldn't get it.
Anonymous No.40045975 [Report]
>>40045822
> dependant on chromosomes
Insofar as the gendered symbols you’re permitted to initially embody are largely dependent on your natal sex, yes. This is the structure of the cross sex fantasy.
Anonymous No.40045980 [Report] >>40046019
>>40045839

>rigid categorical thinking
>transphobic
>ad hominem/ you're stupid!
>spiteful, argumentative, appeals to the lowest common denominator.

I see you're one of those people. You're the complete opposite of a clinical deliberative autist like me.
Anonymous No.40045988 [Report]
>>40045785

Agreed. When I'm focused on cock all thoughts about my body /gender take a backseat.
Anonymous No.40046017 [Report]
>>40044976
Sexual promiscuity is a boomer vice that caused AIDS.
Anonymous No.40046019 [Report] >>40046268
>>40045980
>>rigid categorical thinking
cope
>>transphobic
there's nothing I said that was transphobic. you can't just label everything you disagree with as bigoted

also you're God Emporer Ray Blanchard supports your transition. good luck with the srs im happy for you.

>>ad hominem/ you're stupid!
i literally dont know how else to explain it to you like the other people already have.
I get it. You want agp to be redefined as female sexuality in order to fulfill your agp paraphilia. that would be the apex of your agp desires.

>>spiteful, argumentative, appeals to the lowest common denominator
projection.
Anonymous No.40046084 [Report] >>40046441
>>40044889 (OP)
AGP is a disorder where men are attracted to themselves as women, or (here's the important part) PLAYING THE ROLE OF A WOMAN.
Women cannot have AGP.
Anonymous No.40046195 [Report] >>40046260
>>40044889 (OP)
No matter what its always going to feel like prison sex if its not biological boy/girl.
Anonymous No.40046232 [Report]
>>40045777

so i mainly listen to kpop these days since there's more i like but of those:

>artists i actually like:
Ariana, gaga, Halsey, Rihanna, Kim petras, Beyonce, doja cat, lorde, dual Lipa, (should have been on there as well as some others i think)

>like for MEF

Sabrina, Selena gomez, demi Lovato, Kim petras

>indifferent
Nikki minaj, don't know the rest.

To answer your questions:
(1) I feel agp/mef when listening to the music and looking at pictures of the artist
(2) nothing drives me to it, I've listened to feminine pop music and felt emasculated by it since my mom played Madonna for me at age 5
(3) there is no self pity per se, I am very happy and relieved to feel emasculated, it is pleasurable, like scratching an itch or popping a zit.
(4) there is some sensation of being dominated, cucked, enslaved, or castrated by beautiful women. It produces a thrill, makes me want to dance.
(5) generally i feel lust for the male body triggered by the female form. i would say the only self hatred comes from feeling sexually attracted to the women. But that would be a stretch. Mostly it's a positive, affirming feeling of being feminized or made harmless.
Anonymous No.40046260 [Report]
>>40046195
what is prison sex
Anonymous No.40046268 [Report] >>40046298
>>40046019

First off it's *your and second off... I'm the one who doesn't thing AGP is scientifically valid here. But that's a nice crash out maybe I'll finish reading later. Try to keep the emotions in check please. There's no reason to be so keyed up about this. And yes you were being highly transphobic, literally misgendering me as an arguing tactic stop gaslighting.
Anonymous No.40046271 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
An afab can never be agp because she cannot understand the pleasure of breaking free from amab socialization.
Anonymous No.40046298 [Report] >>40046352 >>40046400
>>40046268
Thanks. I take your concession.
Anonymous No.40046352 [Report] >>40046366
>>40046298
I take yours, "something can be only if x because it just is, okay?" anon
Anonymous No.40046366 [Report]
>>40046352
take your pills, Alice.
Anonymous No.40046400 [Report] >>40046430
>>40046298

I think even you have to admit that's petty. The fact that you're this opinionated and dedicated about this and invested in the the subject is noted. Thanks for coming.
Anonymous No.40046430 [Report] >>40046457
>>40046400
>make thread about topic
>nah im not reading anything
based
Anonymous No.40046441 [Report] >>40046613
>>40046084

I believe i asked this earlier but what if a woman was bisexual (or lesbian) and was attracted to herself as a woman? (As in, she's objectively attractive in her own opinion?)

What about the "mirror on the ceiling" fetish? (Referenced in the lady gaga song)
Anonymous No.40046457 [Report]
>>40046430

I'm multi tasking but i will read and respond later. I rarely let comments go unanswered.
Anonymous No.40046613 [Report] >>40046676
>>40046441
It was also answered earlier. She’s still not having a cross sex fantasy. Being a lesbian doesn’t suddenly make her male.
Anonymous No.40046676 [Report] >>40046718
>>40046613

But all she has to do is imagine being a man and fucking herself, right? It satisfies the cross sex element and the autogynephilic element, It also doesn't seem that far fetched in the context of "fetishism" (which is a loaded term but used here to denote atypical fantasies), esp if she's bi with a preference for men. I remember seeing on a diagram that "meta AGP" had been coined as a term to describe transbian attraction, is this that?
Anonymous No.40046718 [Report] >>40046760
>>40046676
Is your question “what if she imagined herself as a guy attracted to herself and was also attracted to that guy she imagines is attracted to herself”?
Anonymous No.40046760 [Report]
>>40046718
In the hypo the fantasy is focused on her arousal and enjoyment of heterosexual sex, she prefers men so imagines being the pov of a man fucking her. But the man is an afterthought in the fantasy, just a generic "hot" guy, no arousal or tho7ghts about possessing male sex characreristics just marionetting a male meat puppet at best.
Anonymous No.40046846 [Report] >>40046900 >>40047074
>>40044889 (OP)
Transphobes don't have legitimate or sincere beliefs or viewpoints, they have fear and hatred born from the evil in their hearts. To anyone who cries "agp" at a trans woman experiencing normal female sexuality, they deem it fundamentally okay for this cis woman to make something like this, but fundamentally wrong for a trans woman to do the exact same thing. they don't have reasons, they have hollow rationalizations.

you are completely correct OP. your only mistake was offering these animals your valuable time...
Anonymous No.40046900 [Report] >>40046973 >>40047074
>>40046846
>everyone who disagrees with me is a transphobic animal
Did r/MTF/ get banned or something? Why are you even here?
Anonymous No.40046973 [Report]
>>40046900
To write as anonymous you smarmy fuck.

AGPs have these thoughts because of memes originating from here. It's polluted their thinking because they've always been filterless spergs that take in everything they see. They're simpletons through and through.
Anonymous No.40047016 [Report] >>40047033
>>40044921
Case in point, trans men with AGP exist aplenty. And AAP trans women are HSTS
It's wanting to be what you're attracted to, regardless of your genitals.
Anonymous No.40047033 [Report]
>>40047016
>the men who transition to women to sleep with men are actually fantasizing about being men
Words don’t mean anything anymore it seems
Anonymous No.40047074 [Report] >>40048683
>>40046846

I tend to split the difference. Perscriptivism, rigid thinking, appeals to traditional, ad hominem attacks are wrong, but debate is useful. AGP probably doesn't make sense as a taxonomic category, but it can have independent descriptive validity or be a useful term. It really just depends on how you think about things. Binary thinking is usually suspect, but comparative analysis, and using better models, like the original "kinsey scale" for intance can cure most obvious problems with that. Plus I kind of like being mocked, bullied, and aggressively contradicted.

>>40046900

Yes but the inverse is also true, if you're holding on to stereotypes and received cultural knowledge and you're squeamish about approaching taboos through a neutral dis interested lens you fall into the exact same trap, "I'm right, everything else is bad/wrong/deviant"
Anonymous No.40047291 [Report] >>40047311
>>40044889 (OP)
>huge public ally
>community immediately starts roasting the fuck out of her when LGBTpuritans decide she stepped one inch out of line
>even though this is the tamest most standard BDSM stuff possible
>and might additionally also be an ironic joke, there's literally no way of knowing yet since the album hasn't been released
Good job continuing to be our own worst enemies, boys! Keep up the firing rate!
Anonymous No.40047298 [Report]
>>40045240
The whole problem is that Blanchard, in his desire to categorize all not-exclusively-adrophilic trans women as AGP had to stretch his definition of AGP so large as to deliberate conflate large swathes of behaviour that would be considered entirely normal for cis women and pathologize it when trans women do it.

Fundamentally, Blanchard deliberately conflates erotic desire of the self at the idea of one's self as a woman with wanting to be desired BY OTHERS for one's feminine qualities.

The former is typically seen in late transitioning trans women prior to and in early early stages of transition (or indefinitely in the hondosed) because they still have testosterone dominant libidos, whereas Blanchard's on clinical experiences point to extended HRT at appropriate dosages mostly causing the AGP tendencies of those trans women yo eventually go away.
Anonymous No.40047311 [Report]
>>40047291

What LGBT people have taken an issue with this? You're trying to create a problem that isn't even there. Mainstream feminists are mad at her, not trans people.
Anonymous No.40047825 [Report]
>>40045149
stupid
Anonymous No.40048683 [Report] >>40048924
>>40047074
>if you're holding on to stereotypes and received cultural knowledge and you're squeamish about approaching taboos through a neutral dis interested lens you fall into the exact same trap
Weird projection. You’re the one motivated throughout by a discomfort with your own AGP and an aversion to even understanding the concept such that you’re contorting yourself into these absurd pomo queer theory knots to reframe it as something it’s not.
Anonymous No.40048924 [Report]
>>40048683

I don't know where you get that idea. I LOVE being AGP and i like sabrina carpenter generally. i long since stopped caring about fetishes or being seen as valid by anons because no one here knows each other. Saying projection is just writing 'no u' with more letters so I won't bother dealing with that.

You haven't done anything but personally attack me and others in this conversation and your only contribution is "cis women can't be agp because cis women can't be agp." Not everything is about hating and stigmatizing some imaginary group. Having any value judgments going into this particular discussion and being heated is very strange, we're not discussing murder or the israel Palestine conflict here.
Anonymous No.40049127 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
>female celeb puppet is used as a puppet to sway media
Shocker
Anonymous No.40049219 [Report]
>>40044889 (OP)
the whole thing is just kind of cringe honestly. like oh you're sexually submissive to a man as woman that's sooooo crazy