Thread 40304415 - /lgbt/ [Archived: 471 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:38:55 PM No.40304415
7C146C90-7511-453C-85AD-24FBDCB55AE8
7C146C90-7511-453C-85AD-24FBDCB55AE8
md5: 1fdea4ec5f9bc7027eca26b1bf16f32b🔍
>giving middle schoolers a presentation on what mtf and ftm mean
>boy in audience asks if he can transition from amab to afab instead
"sorry but it doesn’t work that way"
>boy starts crying
Replies: >>40304433 >>40304435 >>40304466 >>40304483 >>40305436 >>40306078 >>40306554 >>40306929 >>40307406 >>40307423 >>40307841 >>40308268 >>40311447
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:40:08 PM No.40304433
>>40304415 (OP)
why are you giving a tranny presentation to 12yos
Replies: >>40304450 >>40306199 >>40306235
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:40:14 PM No.40304435
>>40304415 (OP)
t.groomer
Replies: >>40304463
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:41:32 PM No.40304450
>>40304433
nta
So they don't bully their trans friends or end up John 50
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:42:48 PM No.40304463
>>40304435
if this is grooming people like you would be in jail 20 times over.
Replies: >>40305450
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:42:57 PM No.40304466
>>40304415 (OP) lol
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 9:44:23 PM No.40304483
>>40304415 (OP)
well at least shes confronting these feelings now early in life
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 11:20:49 PM No.40305436
>>40304415 (OP)
trannyism is so absurd when you actually think about it
Replies: >>40306699
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 11:22:30 PM No.40305450
>>40304463
i've never tried to get kids to cut their own dicks off so nah
Anonymous
7/6/2025, 11:23:15 PM No.40305458
on one hand i wish i knew about trannyism sooner, on the other I know 12 year old me would have been snickering at this like the little shithead he was and not learning anything.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:29:22 AM No.40306078
>>40304415 (OP)
If you start young enough you can transition from amab to afab
Replies: >>40306108
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:32:27 AM No.40306108
>>40306078
why ? Because you’ll live long enough for the time machine to be invented and you can incapacitate the doctor delivering you and alter your birth certificate?
Replies: >>40308531
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:40:47 AM No.40306199
>>40304433
Eh I'm not OP but middle school is probably a good age to start this conversation. On the cusp of puberty and starting to learn what being a "man" or "woman" is like.

I think it makes sense to include this in general sex ed around middle school.

Definitely not earlier.
Replies: >>40306206 >>40306264 >>40307491
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:41:27 AM No.40306206
>>40306199
that's completely insane
Replies: >>40306218
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:42:32 AM No.40306218
>>40306206
In what way is it insane anon? Can you explain why you think it's a bad idea?
Replies: >>40306253
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:43:05 AM No.40306235
>>40304433
it should be taught at 6 tbqhwy
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:44:50 AM No.40306253
>>40306218
it's self evidently abhorrent to groom kids into trannyism
Replies: >>40306275 >>40306567 >>40307491 >>40307539
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:45:55 AM No.40306264
>>40306199
It tranny stuff had no stigma like 90% of middle school boys would grow tits just to grope them and have access to female underwear.
Replies: >>40306296
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:46:47 AM No.40306275
>>40306253
>it's self evidently abhorrent to groom kids into trannyism
Sure, that sounds pretty bad. However it's not self evident how basic sex education delivered to teenagers is "grooming kids into trannyism".
Replies: >>40306314
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:48:36 AM No.40306296
>>40306264
>It tranny stuff had no stigma like 90% of middle school boys would grow tits just to grope them and have access to female underwear.
I just don't believe that 90% of males are autogynephilic anon. Perhaps you would have done this because you are a repping AGP but I certainly would not because I am a cismale.
Replies: >>40306378
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:50:03 AM No.40306314
>>40306275
tranny-ism is not "basic sex education", it is a perversion.
Replies: >>40306345 >>40306840
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:52:39 AM No.40306345
>>40306314
>tranny-ism is not "basic sex education"
Yes it is. When I was in middle school we were taught about the existence of gay people in our sex ed class.

It did nothing to either increase the number of homo's in the class or decrease the bullying they faced.

Saying "some people have gender dysphoria" is extremely basic sex education.
Replies: >>40306531
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:55:14 AM No.40306378
>>40306296
AGP isn’t necessarily something you’re born with. But it’s not even agp, it’s literally just like an accessibility glitch in the pubescent brain. What I described are some of the most quintessential middle school boy sex comedy joke tropes and it’s like that for a reason. Most boys grow out of it when they start interacting with the opposite sex in a sexual way. But like
>holy shit tits
>I wish I had tits so I can feel tits
is a extremely normal passing thought in 8th grade study hall
Replies: >>40306514
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:06:57 AM No.40306514
>>40306378
>extremely normal passing thought in 8th grade study hall
Yes, it is a very common joke. A joke that learning about the existence of gender dysphoria does nothing to make less of a joke. They grow out of this thought not because of a stigma associated with "tranny stuff", they "grow out of it" because they were never serious in the first place. They want to touch someone else's tits, not their own.
Replies: >>40306590
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:08:18 AM No.40306531
>>40306345
being gay is not the same as cutting your dick off
Replies: >>40306568
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:10:09 AM No.40306554
>>40304415 (OP)
poor girl :(
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:11:39 AM No.40306567
>>40306253
>self evident
appealing to common sense as a basis for your belief is an inherently flawed way of constructing your worldview, and definitely isn't convincing as an argument. It occludes the work hegemony is doing in constructing belief and ignores what has and is being done intentionally and otherwise to establish and maintain the mores of 'common sense'
and sex ed is not 'grooming kids into trannyism' don't be a retard
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:11:44 AM No.40306568
>>40306531
Yes it is. Especially if we are just discussing different lifestyles and habits surrounding sex and relationships. Any argument to exclude trannies also excludes homosexuals.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:13:22 AM No.40306590
>>40306514
Kids aren’t that self aware nigga sometimes they huff cat pee and sniff glue. If you tell them that getting this “joke” means ur a heckin valid lesbian transwoman a decent chunk will follow the lead. Anyone who’s ever gotten hard seeing their friend’s sister’s bra and panties laying around the bathroom is now a girl.
Replies: >>40306658 >>40306696 >>40306846 >>40307746 >>40307773
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:18:32 AM No.40306658
>>40306590
>Kids aren’t that self aware nigga sometimes they huff cat pee and sniff glue
Yes a teenager is more than self aware enough to realize that they don't want to transition just because they made a joke about wanting an easy route to squeeze tits.

>If you tell them that getting this “joke” means ur a heckin valid lesbian transwoman a decent chunk will follow the lead
In no way does teaching about gender dysphoria lead a literal joke into serious transition.

>Anyone who’s ever gotten hard seeing their friend’s sister’s bra and panties laying around the bathroom is now a girl.
Again you project AGP tropes on to transition and sex education but that has nothing to do with dysphoria.
Replies: >>40306718 >>40306734
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:21:33 AM No.40306696
>>40306590
some of you genuinely seem to think that teenagers are a kind of marginally more intelligent domesticated animal
Replies: >>40306718
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:21:58 AM No.40306699
006.wmv_snapshot_01.44_
006.wmv_snapshot_01.44_
md5: ecf28d6cb756a110187277f2d38e6994🔍
>>40305436
>trannyism is so absurd when you actually think about it
I like the idea of gay men who bimbomaxx to become sex toys for men who wouldn't want them otherwise. I also get women who fetishize masculinity via yaoi or gym culture and juice themselves up to be alpha butch superphysiogical androgynes. Both those things are kind of neat and actually understandable. The rest of it is just weird. Take pic related, a "cis" female bodybuilder who obviously uses exogenous hormones. Most pooners aren't as sexy because they don't embody that virile intensity that makes maleness attractive. There's no joy, no power to it. They just look like sad, pudgy teenage boys.
Replies: >>40308953
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:23:21 AM No.40306718
>>40306696
This is true
>>40306658
Middle schoolers arent teenagers for the most part
>Again you project AGP tropes on to transition and sex education but that has nothing to do with dysphoria.
You can transition without dysphoria
Replies: >>40306738 >>40306763 >>40306786
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:24:32 AM No.40306734
>>40306658
Jokes turned many autistic transbians trans. What do you think Astolfo and Bridget are?
Replies: >>40306753
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:24:47 AM No.40306738
>>40306718
>You can transition without dysphoria
Why the FUCK would anybody do that? For fun? With all the social stigmatization and the cost of the drugs/surgery?
Replies: >>40306748
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:25:33 AM No.40306748
>>40306738
yes, for fun.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:26:00 AM No.40306753
>>40306734
fictional characters, do you think they turn people trans?
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:27:07 AM No.40306763
>>40306718
>Middle schoolers arent teenagers for the most part
You really want to split hairs between "teen" and "pre-teen"? A 12 year old and a 13 year old are both mature enough to differentiate between
>HURR DURR ME WANT SQUEEZE BOOBIES
and
>I have a serious and persistent believe that I was assigned the wrong gender at birth and in fact I am actually a girl
Replies: >>40306802
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:28:28 AM No.40306786
>>40306718
>Middle schoolers arent teenagers for the most part
Besides, sex ed doesn't happen until 8th grade when people are 13/14 anyways.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:31:19 AM No.40306802
>>40306763
Absolutely they are not. You’re memoryholing childhood. My friend thought people could deflect bullets with their ki until he was 13
Replies: >>40307002
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:34:45 AM No.40306840
>>40306314
I wasn't taught about transgenderism, intersex conditions, or any non-standard puberty in sex ed, leading my dumb ass to think (hope) that I was turning into a girl when I grew gyno boobs. If we had learned about that shit not only would I have not gotten weird ideas. Wouldn't have stopped that teacher from bullying me for acting/looking 'like a faggot' or got me to stop being an early repper though.
Replies: >>40306857
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:35:04 AM No.40306846
1111
1111
md5: b6cdd1a618f35dc10d5b136093e00e34🔍
>>40306590
>'friend's' sister
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:36:13 AM No.40306857
>>40306840
Society hates MtFs because they are feminine men. What you label yourself as doesn't change that
Replies: >>40306873 >>40306915
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:37:28 AM No.40306873
>>40306857
define 'man' 'woman' and 'feminine' to me right now
Replies: >>40306895
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:39:27 AM No.40306895
>>40306873
Man - male adult
Woman - female adult
Feminine - like or pertaining to that which is associated with womanhood or womanliness
Replies: >>40306908 >>40306992
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:40:45 AM No.40306908
>>40306895
and 'male' and 'female'?
Replies: >>40306953
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:41:18 AM No.40306915
>>40306857
Thought of myself as a girl since 7, gincel, the bullying for being feminine came later when all the adults around me started more strongly enforcing gendered behavior. In either case, there was no "I guess I have to be a girl if I want to play with Barbie", it was "I'm actually a girl inside" then several years later getting yelled at by the teacher in front of the entire class for "dressing like a faggot" because my shirt was too big and it hung off my shoulder a bit (wearing big shirts was a comfort thing for me.)
Replies: >>40306953 >>40307614
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:43:09 AM No.40306929
>>40304415 (OP)
i hope this is a larp :(
still makes me wanna cry sometimes too
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:44:58 AM No.40306953
>>40306908
small gamete and large gamete
testosterone dominant and estrogen dominant
>>40306915
They bullied you and you saw yourself as a "girl" because men/boys doing things associated socially with women/girls is a no-no

Gender roles, cosmetics, and social behavior/affect don't change biology

I understand transition. It works for some people. I just think it treats the symptom and not the disease
Replies: >>40306973 >>40307146
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:46:47 AM No.40306973
>>40306953
I saw myself as a girl before there was any bullying, gincel. I gave you an order of events and you still failed to understand my post.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:48:52 AM No.40306992
>>40306895
Associated by whom? Which traits are associated with womanhood? Must those traits be conditioned on physiological features common to a typical female karyotype, or does it include cultural norms? A typical female karyotype of which human phenotype? In which cultures? If the culture you live in, can you say 'femininity' is the same in other cultures? Why that definition, rather than a, say, Mongolian or sub-Sahara african or Indian conception of femininity? Can you say with confidence that 'femininity' is a concept broadly understood by your definition globally? If not, why is it valid?
Replies: >>40307172
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:49:53 AM No.40307002
>>40306802
>You’re memoryholing childhood
Actually quite the opposite, I remember having this exact conversation with my friends in middle school around the time we were discovering the fact that we wanted to touch tits.

The conversation went something like:
>maaan wouldn't it be great to have tits
>yeah bro then I could touch them whenever I want!
>but then you'd have tits, like always
>yeah I think I'd rather touch someone else's tits anyways
Replies: >>40307303
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:05:57 AM No.40307146
>>40306953
As in 'phenotype which produces small gamete' and 'phenotype which produces large gamete'? What do you mean by 'testosterone dominant' and 'estrogen dominant'? Must both of these criteria be met make someone male or female? Are individuals who cannot produce gametes neither male nor female? Are individuals who cannot produce sex hormones neither male or female? Are individuals who produce both large and small gametes male or female?
Replies: >>40307172
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:09:13 AM No.40307172
>>40306992
>>40307146
Obfuscation and autism
Both of us know what a man is and what a woman is
Replies: >>40307224
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:14:59 AM No.40307224
>>40307172
Both of us have, evidently, different definitions for what a man and a woman is. If you want to have a discussion about it, those definitions need to be clarified and validated. Appeals to 'common sense' are useless and more obfuscatory than what you're accusing me of - not accounting for hegemony and making a frankly stupid assumption that the mores of common sense are rooted in rigorous logic rather than centuries of cultural convention, superstition, and intentional construction by the powers-that-be.
Replies: >>40307288
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:22:48 AM No.40307288
>>40307224
Tell me oh wise sage, what is YOUR definition of man or woman?
Replies: >>40307401
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:24:48 AM No.40307303
>>40307002
>but then you'd have tits, like always
>yeah I think I'd rather touch someone else's tits anyways
throw autism into the mix and this part doesn’t happen
Replies: >>40307552
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:36:12 AM No.40307401
>>40307288
I'm not a 'wise sage', and I don't appreciate the attempt to make me out to be some kind of know-it-all pseud just because I'm making basic inquiries about the underpinnings of your intentionally contrarian opinions.

A man or a woman (by my understanding) is an individual who is generally perceived and understood to be a man or a woman by themselves and the community that they are in. i.e., someone who people think is a man or a woman.
Replies: >>40307418 >>40307480 >>40308025
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:36:44 AM No.40307406
>>40304415 (OP)
:(
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:38:25 AM No.40307418
>>40307401
>A man or a woman (by my understanding) is an individual who is generally perceived and understood to be a man or a woman by themselves and the community that they are in. i.e., someone who people think is a man or a woman.

So sex hormones, anatomy, etc. have nothing to do with that for you? Why? Why even use the words man or woman at that point?
Replies: >>40307441 >>40307635 >>40307648
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:39:17 AM No.40307423
1749569011473675
1749569011473675
md5: 8b790235c605d595feb60532c4346e96🔍
>>40304415 (OP)
>internally homophobic gay boi loses last bit of hope he didn't even knew he had
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:41:26 AM No.40307441
>>40307418
>Being a man or woman is based on the individual's self image as well as the opinions of their community

Unironically positing and believing shit like this is why the LGBT community has such shitty optics rn
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:46:47 AM No.40307480
>>40307401
>Being a man or woman is based on the individual's self image as well as the opinions of their community

Unironically positing and believing shit like this is why the LGBT community has such shitty optics rn
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:47:36 AM No.40307491
>>40306199
I wish I could have learned before puberty
>>40306253
Grooming is actual abuse not teaching people that queers exist. Just another example of cis parents being low empathy control freaks that try to weaponize minority rights in the public mind
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:53:46 AM No.40307539
>>40306253
>If you so much as MENTION trans people existing, it causes them to magically become trans!
Literally heard the same shit but for banning sex ed entirely - just mentioning sex exists is apparently enough to cause every girl to get knocked up...yet somehow, there was only 1 pregnancy when I was in high school (she was raped by a relative).
But who am I to be talking, the day after the cops came to school to give their big anti-drugs speech, I was driven to score some H and become homeless, along with the rest of my 7th grade class.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:55:52 AM No.40307552
>>40307303
>throw autism into the mix and this part doesn’t happen
We were all completely asocial autists. Absolutely none of us got laid in high school. A lack of pussy did not suddenly give us dysphoria or desire to grow tits.

Your moral panic is fucking retarded.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:03:40 AM No.40307614
>>40306915
this is the problem. men think being a woman means dressing and girly clothes, having a vagina, and doing stereotypical female gendered activities. that enforce toxic gender roles. enforcing that is homophobic. that is why trans women can never be women only mock and larp for the rest of their lousy life.
Replies: >>40307631
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:07:47 AM No.40307631
>>40307614
Did you also miss the order of operations going on in my life like gincel did?
Replies: >>40307680
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:07:59 AM No.40307635
>>40307418
They have 'something to do with it' in that they tend to shape a person in ways that cause them to be perceived as men or women. They are not fundamental, definitional aspects.
I guess I wouldn't, in an ideal world, want the words man and woman to be used. It's important to negotiate with reality, though. A person who thinks their dreams contain secret truths has abandoned themselves to their imagination entirely.
Replies: >>40307716
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:09:27 AM No.40307648
>>40307418
they fail to realize you can be a feminine man. instead of realizing it is mental illness, they cope saying nobody accepts them and everyone else is the problem. they know they are trying to be women but continue to enforce toxic gender roles they apparently are against
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:13:11 AM No.40307680
>>40307631
you got bullied for being a feminine man so you decide to become a woman. so you feel comfortable/acceptable being feminine. news flash- you can be comfortable being a feminine man. accept yourself as a feminine man instead of trying to be something you aren't to be accepted by others.
Replies: >>40307706
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:16:17 AM No.40307706
>>40307680
I identified myself as a girl and then several years later got bullied for being feminine. So yes, you can't fucking read either.
Replies: >>40307716 >>40307737
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:17:58 AM No.40307716
actual cis woman
actual cis woman
md5: 6a3406d27f82c67be1b032d46e013019🔍
>>40307635
>I guess I wouldn't, in an ideal world, want the words man and woman to be used. It's important to negotiate with reality, though. A person who thinks their dreams contain secret truths has abandoned themselves to their imagination entirely.

My God, the sheer irony of this post. You can't write satire this good.

>>40307706
They bullied you because they still saw you as a man.
Replies: >>40307732 >>40307739
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:20:50 AM No.40307732
>>40307716
>they still saw you as a man.
It's pretty weird to see a 10 year old as a man. But yes, they saw me as a boy, because I was repping, because my family and church wouldn't accept me being a tranny. I wasn't trying to present myself as a girl, I just wasn't yet beaten down enough to hide who I was very well.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:21:55 AM No.40307737
>>40307706
you convinced yourself that identifying as a girl was the only plausible reasoning for you wanting to be so feminine all of these years. you got bullied because people are homophobic to feminine men. so yes, you are still mentally ill.
Replies: >>40307764
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:22:02 AM No.40307739
>>40307716
>oh thank fuck i can get a cheap shot in and don't actually have to argue
Replies: >>40307807
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:23:10 AM No.40307746
>>40306590
Never understood why guys were so turned on by men's underwear. They're such a mundane part of life. Then again, I've never been into girls, so I probably just wouldn't get it.
Replies: >>40307756 >>40307773 >>40307776
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:24:15 AM No.40307756
>>40307746
*women's underwear
haha
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:25:00 AM No.40307764
>>40307737
Nope, those thoughts came without reasoning or justification attached to them. Sorry, don't fit into your box.
Replies: >>40307783
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:25:55 AM No.40307773
>>40307746
>>40306590
AGP
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:26:03 AM No.40307776
>>40307746
both men and woman's underwear smells very strongly of genital sweat. i really like the smell of genital sweat
Replies: >>40307807
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:27:16 AM No.40307783
>>40307764
Its called subconscious thinking. You can have thoughts with without realizing the internal justification.
Replies: >>40307820
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:29:28 AM No.40307807
>>40307739
If your definition of being a man or woman is based ONLY on the perceptions of yourself and others rather than any physical attributes at all, you've "abandoned yourself to your imagination entirely". What if you get a traumatic brain injury and your perceptions and personality change? What if everyone around you is exposed to some mind altering chemical?

Is anything objective in your world? Can women get prostate exams? Do men get pap smears? Do women ejaculate female sperm out of their feminine penises? Should men get mammograms?

>>40307776
>i really like the smell of genital sweat
Pussy sweat is saltier, though. At least to me.
Replies: >>40307847 >>40307890
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:30:52 AM No.40307820
>>40307783
Oh god now gincel thinks he can read my subconcious mind from decades ago, you're worse than a discount spirit medium.
Replies: >>40307849
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:33:48 AM No.40307841
>>40304415 (OP)
>giving middle schoolers a presentation on what mtf and ftm mean
Not shaking the groomer allegations.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:34:25 AM No.40307847
>>40307807
>Should men get mammograms?
If they notice a breast lump or have more breast tissue than normal, then yes, absolutely. All men have a small amount of breast tissue, the small amount just makes it statistically less likely that it'll become cancerous so they don't normally bother to check. If someone gyno or breast growth from HRT then they are now at increased risk of breast cancer thanks to the growth of breast tissue.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:34:49 AM No.40307849
>>40307820
>Oh god now gincel thinks he can read my subconcious mind from decades ago
He's not me. I'm the one you call "gincel."
Gincels are gay, I'm bi. Shows what you know, buddeh.
Replies: >>40307870
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:36:02 AM No.40307860
you are doing like what drunk drivers have to do for community service.
>alright kids I messed up bad and now I'm here..
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:37:29 AM No.40307870
>>40307849
Doesn't matter if you're gincel or bincel, trying to project weird shit onto me while consistently getting details I'm telling you wrong to justify it is just a really dumb way to do this. Simply accept that I don't fit into your normal box, you can keep going on your screed while accepting exceptions, the only reason I even spoke up in this thread was to mention how the lack of education in regards to transgender, intersex, and non-standard puberty during sex-ed gave me some really retarded ideas about breast growth that could've been avoided.
Replies: >>40307898
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:40:27 AM No.40307890
>>40307807
I don't think it's fair to say that a phenomenological definition of anything is 'abandoning yourself to your imagination'. Or if you're arguing that, it's a swing against George Berkeley and Sartre and his contemporaries as a whole, which I feel like is a position that needs some weight behind it. Do you consider yourself an objectivist?

>What if you get a traumatic brain injury and your perceptions and personality change?
Then your gender changes, assuming it is associated by a perceptive consensus.

>What if everyone around you is exposed to some mind altering chemical?
Then your gender changes, assuming it is associated by a perceptive consensus.

>Is anything objective in your world?
No - not in your world, either. Everything is filtered through your senses and exists in relation to them.

>Can women get prostate exams?
If they have prostates.

>Do men get pap smears?
If they have cervices.

>Do women ejaculate female sperm out of their feminine penises?
If they have feminine penis to do it out of, I suppose.

>Should men get mammograms?
I've read it's best policy for anyone with breasts to get them checked regularly.
Replies: >>40307950 >>40307973 >>40307988
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:41:35 AM No.40307898
>>40307870
>Simply accept that I don't fit into your normal box, you can keep going on your screed while accepting exceptions

I don't fit into yours either. I'm not the transphobic right wing whatever you seem to think I am

>the lack of education in regards to transgender, intersex, and non-standard puberty during sex-ed gave me some really retarded ideas about breast growth that could've been avoided.

As someone who went to a parochial high school that preached abstinence, I do actually feel your pain here
Replies: >>40307969
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:48:30 AM No.40307950
>>40307890 (Me)
I had an excellent critical anthropology of medicine professor who was an advocate of phenomenology and outlined it pretty convincingly. If you want a short and (in my opinion) very interesting reading on how meaning is constructed, give 'The Body Multiple: Ontology in Medical Practice' by Annamarie Mol a read. You can get it on amazon, I'm sure you could find the pdf for free somewhere too, if you tried.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:51:01 AM No.40307969
>>40307898
>I'm not the transphobic right wing whatever you seem to think I am
I don't think you're right wing, but the way you tried very hard along with gincel to fit me into the "you were a flamer that decided to troon out because of bullies" shoebox after I repeatedly pointed out how I had GD years before any bullying doesn't give me a good opinion on the phobic part.
>As someone who went to a parochial high school that preached abstinence, I do actually feel your pain here
We had our sex ed in late elementary, the class was split along boy/girl lines and we were taught strictly about the reproductive anatomy of and how puberty would progress for our assigned sex. No talk about actual sex (obviously) or the other sex either, and it was taught in concordance with the anti-drug classes they do too. It wasn't remotely new information for someone who grew up in a rural household with tons of different kinds of animals that's for sure. Middle school saw a sex ed class that taught the same information but did mention abstinence (no info on how sex functions or condoms etc.) High school had a video that was slightly more informative but literally everyone knew everything by then anyway.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:51:35 AM No.40307973
>>40307890
>Do you consider yourself an objectivist?
LMAO, fuck no.
I read Atlas Shrugged in high school and it was kind of entertaining. I got through about a third of The Fountainhead and lost interest.

I'm guessing you have a philosophy background; I don't in particular. So that may not be very fruitful for you to ask me about unless you intend to explain or give context.

>I don't think it's fair to say that a phenomenological definition of anything is 'abandoning yourself to your imagination'.

I don't disavow the mental concept of gender identity or what have you. It's a thing that happens differently for different people. I think it's disingenuous to not also take biology/physical sex into account as it relates to things like sports, medicine, etc. If you are an MtF, you still need to know what a male sexed body is and how it works so you can have informed consent about your HRT use and proper expectations about what the results will be.
Replies: >>40308190
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:54:07 AM No.40307988
>>40307890
This is where it gets fuzzy. Women have women organs and men have men organs. Having ideals that nothing is objective is why trans women are a danger to women. When trans women make the argument that they are women, it invalidates real women. You are a trans woman but you aren't a woman.
Replies: >>40308004 >>40308190
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:55:21 AM No.40308004
>>40307988
Not only a danger to women but themselves as well.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:57:35 AM No.40308025
>>40307401
>passoids r women and hons r men
yall r so desperate to be seperate from us lol
Replies: >>40308107
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:07:16 AM No.40308107
>>40308025
its only logical. if you don't pass a woman you aren't a woman. isn't that what all the medication and surgery was for in the first pace? to be seen as a woman even though you are a man?
Replies: >>40308190 >>40308270
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:16:00 AM No.40308190
>>40307988
I'm not a trans woman, I'm just enthusiastic about them. I believe that transgenderism is the root of a modern philosophy which transcends the limitations of the body to wonderful ends.

>>40307973
I have a *little* bit of a philosophy background. I've taken some classes and read a little on my own but I definitely wouldn't consider myself comprehensively educated on the subject. I'm sorry if I weighed down my last response with jargon, I wasn't trying to make my argument inaccessible.
I think that the concept of gender identity which is defined by perception *does* take into account things like sports, medicine, etc. If those are your sticking points, then considerations of things like mtfs having an advantage in some sports factors into your perception of them, which influences whether you perceive them as men or women. The same with genitalia, and etc.
Sex is real, obviously. I *would* consider myself comprehensively educated in that, I did my masters in genetics. It is because sex is biologically real that sex can be changed. The things that make up sex are meaningfully real and that is why when those things are changed, sex then changes. Loads of things are real and also mutable.

>>40308107
This is a little mean, but yeah. I think the standard for what 'passes' is widely variable and that there is active work being done to broaden the accepted definition of woman to include people it didn't before, but yeah.
Replies: >>40308349
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:23:06 AM No.40308248
>wehhh it's grooming
People like you trivialize actual grooming and are hurting real grooming victims this way.
violet
7/7/2025, 4:25:36 AM No.40308268
>>40304415 (OP)
I wish I was taught that it's ok to be transgender when I was in middle school. my life could've been completely different
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:25:44 AM No.40308270
>>40308107
>to be seen as a woman even though you are a man
yeah
being born with genetics that let you disguise yourself better than us doesn't make you not a man or not a tranny
Replies: >>40308284 >>40308376
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:27:01 AM No.40308284
>>40308270
this also means that man and woman are defined by net worth lol instead of something much simpler like biological sex. but that puts you guys in the same group as us. sucks rite?
Replies: >>40308296 >>40308303
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:28:02 AM No.40308296
>>40308284
can be defined*
as much as genetics and starting age
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:29:04 AM No.40308303
>>40308284
luckily though most cissoids put us all in the same group either as all men or all women :)
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:35:33 AM No.40308349
006.wmv_snapshot_02.53_
006.wmv_snapshot_02.53_
md5: 6cbc0c91b4df4001350f3898129afb54🔍
>>40308190
>I'm not a trans woman, I'm just enthusiastic about them.
Hello, fellow chaser.
> I believe that transgenderism is the root of a modern philosophy which transcends the limitations of the body to wonderful ends.
I kind of see it this way too but it's more daring and sexy to me to see MtFs as bimbomaxxed, sexy men. I also like butch, roided women who don't go all the way down the pooner path. I agree that the possibilities of new kinds of hormone therapies, anti-aging, etc. are quite provocative. I think visible public displays of GNC/androgyny in general is the best way to fight the regressive Judeo Christian puritan fuckery I was force fed as a kid, but I feel like the modern trans movement does a lot to reinforce certain harmful stereotypes. That's my main issue with it. The ideology and glossary of terms, neopronouns, etc. packaged alongside the newfound visibility of trans or GNC people vexes me.
Replies: >>40308510
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:39:33 AM No.40308376
>>40308270
>being born with genetics that let you disguise yourself better than us doesn't make you not a man or not a tranny
congratulation you're getting the real women experience. some women are biologically prettier and more feminine looking then other women. everyone cant transition into the perfect looking girl. some people get visibly unlucky. i'm sure if everyone could be conventionally attractive everyone would be.
Replies: >>40308388
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:41:24 AM No.40308388
>>40308376
sure but ur saying hons arent women lol
luckily society puts us all in one box whether transphobic or allies
Replies: >>40308413 >>40308444
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:45:37 AM No.40308413
>>40308388
can i ask what does make hons women, in your opinion
Replies: >>40308427
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:47:56 AM No.40308427
>>40308413
i dont think we're women
not any less than passoids are though
and if we're basing being a woman on "public perception" do passoids suddenly stop being women if they come out? what if they're in a conservative area?
i'm pretty sure there's a way to classify men and women which is a hell of a lot easier and doesn't require mental gymnastics to include yourself and exclude others (biological sex)
Replies: >>40308431 >>40308456
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:49:14 AM No.40308431
>>40308427
come out as opposed to stealthing
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:51:38 AM No.40308444
>>40308388
trans women and women are two different things. hons are trans women. passions are trans women who could trick us into thinking they're women.
Replies: >>40308447
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:52:13 AM No.40308447
>>40308444
agreed
passoids got ego'd into thinking they're real women tho
Replies: >>40308541
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:53:51 AM No.40308456
>>40308427
biological sex based definitions of gender are incredibly boring. besides, physical objects don’t exist independently of your perception of them, so how could you say someone's sex doesn't make them a woman unless you were staring them straight in the penis?
if they come out as being trans? to an extent, i guess. i mean, hunter schafer is a good example. if she'd never told anyone she was trans, she'd pass perfectly, but because she is out, there's a subsection of people who'd otherwise never give her a second glance who insist she isn't a woman. in the context of living in a very conservative area i think that a practical definition wouldn't define you as a woman, though i think that active effort to change definitions, perceptions, and attitudes so that is no longer the case are important.
didn't mean to make you feel bad, though. don't beat yourself up and keep improving you'll get there
Replies: >>40308466
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:55:40 AM No.40308466
>>40308456
because as we all know we understand and classify the world around based on whether or not it's boring
dont need ur pretentious platitude im doing great
Replies: >>40308474
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:56:50 AM No.40308474
>>40308466
sorry :(
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:01:58 AM No.40308510
>>40308349
I'm not a chaser. I don't have any sexual interest in trans women that exceeds my sexual interest in cis women, I'm just very impressed with some of the ideas which underpin trans theory. uh. like harrier du bois famously said while being a bit of a sex pest: 'I agree with this, it's very futuristic.'
>it's more daring and sexy to me to see MtFs as bimbomaxxed, sexy men. I also like butch, roided women who don't go all the way down the pooner path.
okay. i hope that is a fulfilling masturbatory fantasy for you
>I think visible public displays of GNC/androgyny in general is the best way to fight the regressive Judeo Christian puritan fuckery I was force fed as a kid, but
I agree
>The ideology and glossary of terms, neopronouns, etc. packaged alongside the newfound visibility of trans or GNC people vexes me.
what about it vexes you?
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:04:28 AM No.40308531
>>40306108
>doesnt know that you can change your birth certificate
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:05:09 AM No.40308541
>>40308447
truth nuke

trans peoples goal is acceptance from everyone else that they look woman/man enough. if you don't look how the societal gender roles think that gender should look, then you failed as a trans.
Replies: >>40308583
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:09:17 AM No.40308583
>>40308541
i think you replied to the wrong person
Replies: >>40308600
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:11:26 AM No.40308600
>>40308583
I replied to anon to further enforce their point.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:20:53 AM No.40308677
This thread is a shining example of what chronically online autistic men with weird fetishes think about in their spare time.

The two anons going back and forth read as proto-AGPs whose eggs haven't cracked yet. If they aren't arguing stupid shit over the internet, they're both gooning to trannies. All this debate because of deeper shame over liking men in dresses. There's not a real woman in this entire thread. Or a real man.
Replies: >>40308717 >>40308776
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:26:24 AM No.40308717
>>40308677
hey. agp? if i was trans i would be the good kind
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:35:12 AM No.40308776
>>40308677
Proud bisexual male here. Trannies are mentally ill. LGBQIA is real. I for intersex which is a rare genetic mutation, not something you can transition into.
Replies: >>40308805 >>40309236 >>40310749
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:38:24 AM No.40308805
>>40308776
>Trannies are mentally ill.
Yes, they're men in dresses who hate the other men who want to fuck them.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:40:43 AM No.40308817
I had dysphoria when I was 12 and I didn’t even know what trannies were.
Replies: >>40308936
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:55:58 AM No.40308936
>>40308817
>I had a symptoms at mental illness at 12 and I didn't even know what the mental illness was

Trannies are unintentionally retarded
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 5:58:22 AM No.40308953
>>40306699
based pro androphilia anon
Replies: >>40308986
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:02:40 AM No.40308986
005.wmv_snapshot_01.02_[2025-04-25_18.51.50]
005.wmv_snapshot_01.02_[2025-04-25_18.51.50]
md5: 6d9285747bc9ad3094ac19445245cf90🔍
>>40308953
I'm glad someone else understands.
Replies: >>40309091
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:18:00 AM No.40309091
>>40308986
hell yeah brother
Replies: >>40310738
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:41:55 AM No.40309236
>>40308776
they'll come for you next
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:33:34 PM No.40310738
275272
275272
md5: a913accb3a591ecb10308fc653b8b1b1🔍
>>40309091
Indeed
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 12:38:43 PM No.40310749
>>40308776
>proud pedophile rapist here
>trannies bad or something
>clap for me
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:35:27 PM No.40311018
89394690_591430204791313_3363146769901544757_n
89394690_591430204791313_3363146769901544757_n
md5: fb74935a7e2eceb8820d37784fb7b013🔍
Don't worry guys, biological sex is MEANINGLESS!!!1!

Transitioning isn't hypersexualized at all!

Ignore whatever dysfunction and maladaptive behavior you see with your own two eyes, of COURSE we should teach this to young kids!!!1! No, this thread is NOT in fact full of men on the spectrum trying to justify their fetishes! It's beautiful diversity of thought and opinion based on SCIENCE and REASON! Get rekd, Chuds!!!1!
Replies: >>40311157
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 1:59:17 PM No.40311157
>>40311018
capitalizing the odd word and capitalizing the 1 key doesn't make anything you say true. of course this is your perspective; you're a degenerate fetishist
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 2:55:35 PM No.40311447
>>40304415 (OP)
Oh my god :(