>>24644812
>non cthulhu ancient aliens shit
The Music of Eric Zahn
Pickman's model
The Rats in the Walls
The Outsider
Cool Air
The Hound
The Picture in the House
The Colour out of space
Herbert West Re-Animator
I'd stay away from any of the Dream Quest shit. Cats of Ulthar is alright because it's barely a paragraph. Lovecraft has a bunch of great short stories. You can almost do no wrong but everything above is a good starting point to be honest. Some of his other stuff would probably not give the best impression like the Dreams in the Witch house or
>cthulhu mythos shenanigans and other ancient alien crap
Call of Cthulhu
At the Mountains of Madness
the shadow over innsmouth
the shadow out of time(a pretty high concept one for the time)
Dagon
Azathoth
The Other Gods
Nyarlathotep
History of the Necronomicon
>honorable mentions
In the Walls of Eryx(co wrote apparently)
Under the Pyramids also known as Imprisoned with the Pharaohs(some crazy collab with the Harry Houdini also starring Harry Houdini)
The whisper in the Darkness
>>24644812
>absolute essential required definitive reading
Call of Cthulhu
Shadow out of time
Color out of Space
Pickman's model
Shadow over Innsmouth
These stories are solid but also will give you a good example of all his tropes to the point when you read something like At the Mountains of Madness it will feel almost self parodying. So many of his stories are really fun or at least high concept and downright spooky. You can't really go wrong. Except with the Dream quest shit was was weird and not too great to me.