← Home ← Back to /lit/

Thread 24856686

11 posts 6 images /lit/
Anonymous No.24856686 [Report] >>24856699 >>24857053
>the count of Monte Cristo is a fairy tale, nobody ever really gets revenge
Is he right?
Anonymous No.24856699 [Report] >>24856702 >>24856732
>>24856686 (OP)
Lenin literally overthrew the 300 year old royal Romanov dynasty who executed his brother. Kurds testified against Saddamn at his trial for the Anfal campaign of gas attacks and then watched him hang but that is the exception to the rule. Revenge is often just a life well lived, victory is happiness.
Anonymous No.24856702 [Report] >>24856712
>>24856699
>Lenin literally overthrew the 300 year old royal Romanov dynasty

No he didn't.
Anonymous No.24856712 [Report]
>>24856702
>No he didn't.
White army recruit, let it go, you lost, the battle is over.
Anonymous No.24856732 [Report] >>24857089 >>24857458
>>24856699
Stolen valour
Anonymous No.24857053 [Report]
>>24856686 (OP)
>What I CoMC is actually ... A book of disquiet?
Anonymous No.24857088 [Report]
That book is so fucking cool
The part in which the guy keeps looking for what should be the skeleton baby he burried like 15 years ago in the churchyard is fucking sick
Stays in your mind
Anonymous No.24857089 [Report] >>24857135 >>24857447
>>24856732
If we say that Lenin did not do it (which is somewhat fair but still debatable), then Kerensky most definitely did not do it. Specifically Nicolas was done in by a military leadership clique, with the Petrograd Soviet activity as a justification for their actions. Those guys get the first credit on overthrowing Nicolas specifically - Ruzski, Evert, Sakharov, Alexeev, Brusilov, nepenin, etc etc. Duma was rather passive and useless as far as forcing Nicky to abdicate, and Kerenski was not a party in the abdication plot from the Duma - and even those Duma and government members who were involved did basically nothing and got nothing of what they wanted, hence all of them GTFO immedeately afterward, and Kerensky ending up in the limelight of democratic consensus and, much more importantly, foreign powers. He himself learned of the whole thing post factum. At the same time, his participation in the Petrograd Soviet was directed wholly and entirely towards neutering it in favor of empowering Duma and Provisional Government, and he not only did nothing to contribute to the protest and strike activities organized by the Petrograd Soviet, he opposed most of them.

Post-February, the created power vacuum (which Kerensky and Co failed to fill utterly and completely) left a lot of consideration for maintaining and/or reforming monarchy and the Romanov dynasty itself, just without Nicky. Kerensky did nothing to support or dismantle those, he and the the rest of Provisional Government overall did nothing at all beyond holding on to the illusion of power that they had, which was shaken nearly every day by every which general, garrison commander, protest, strike or gangster who felt like it. The only legitimacy it had came exclusively from the Entente powers recognizing it (and kinda sorta actively working to control it), Petrograd Soviet and Bolshies tolerated the Provisional Government only as far as they expected the Constitutional Assembly to just pass all this legitimacy to them no questions asked. Once that did not happen, Bolshies blew away the PG basically by sneezing, with the subsequent struggle for control unfolding between the real powers in Russia - Bolshies, remnants of the old Imperial army and their supporters including foreign Entente powers, and various local opportunists. Which was the event that acted as a definite curtains down on the Romanov dynasty's last aspirations to retain any sort of relevance.

So overall, Kerensky's involvement in overthrowing Romanovs can be described as limited to what his complete and total incompetence and helplessness achieved by making it easier for Lenin's gang to double-tap any remaining chances to install a Romanov as at least a constitutional monarch.
Anonymous No.24857135 [Report]
>>24857089
>A Russian named Ruzski
Anonymous No.24857447 [Report]
>>24857089
Langston Hughes wrote the poem
>the Negro Speaks of the Rivers when he was very young, but you speak of the deep knowledge of the Russian Revolution that can only come from years of private study, in the following poem just replace soul with deep knowledge of Russian history and it describes you perfectly.

I've known rivers:
I've known rivers ancient as the world and older than the
flow of human blood in human veins.

My soul has grown deep like the rivers.

I bathed in the Euphrates when dawns were young.
I built my hut near the Congo and it lulled me to sleep.
I looked upon the Nile and raised the pyramids above it.
I heard the singing of the Mississippi when Abe Lincoln
went down to New Orleans, and I've seen its muddy
bosom turn all golden in the sunset.

I've known rivers:
Ancient, dusky rivers.

My soul has grown deep like the rivers.
Anonymous No.24857458 [Report]
>>24856732

KEK did they really?

Kerensky died of arteriosclerotic heart disease at St. Luke's Hospital in New York City on 11 June 1970, after being initially admitted for injuries sustained from a fall.[51] At 89, he was one of the last surviving major participants in the turbulent events of 1917. The local Russian Orthodox Churches in New York City refused to grant Kerensky burial rites because of his association with Freemasonry, and because they saw him as largely responsible for the Bolsheviks' seizure of power.[53] A Serbian Orthodox Church also refused burial rites. Kerensky's body was flown to London, where his two sons resided; he was buried at the non-denominational Putney Vale Cemetery.[54]