← Home ← Back to /mlp/

Thread 42299052

118 posts 54 images /mlp/
Anonymous No.42299052 >>42299055 >>42299069 >>42299079 >>42299086 >>42299129 >>42299146 >>42299162 >>42299164 >>42299166 >>42299170 >>42299171 >>42299337 >>42299496 >>42299695 >>42299706 >>42300038 >>42300051 >>42300087 >>42301021
G6 is 100% going to be the G4 Reboot that was originally planned for G5.
And judging based on this concept art its going to have a somewhat more serious vibe to it.
Trust me, I'm always right.
Anonymous No.42299055 >>42299370 >>42300991
>>42299052 (OP)
I love how tribal, Celtic, and shamanistic the Earth Ponies look in this.
Anonymous No.42299069 >>42299104
>>42299052 (OP)
G6 will never happen troon
Anonymous No.42299079 >>42299106
>>42299052 (OP)
>they will do thing based on *rejected* concept art
sure thing buddy
Anonymous No.42299086
>>42299052 (OP)
>G6 is 100% going to be
shit
Anonymous No.42299104 >>42299305 >>42300112
>>42299069
2026 and 2027 has been confirmed by hasbro as a re imagining of MLP. The concept in the OP fits that idea.
Anonymous No.42299106 >>42299317 >>42299375 >>42300976
>>42299079
You think companies don't reuse previous ideas? They do. Why pay for an entirely new concept when they have backlogs of ideas?
Plus the reception for this concept art has been really positive.
Anonymous No.42299129 >>42299140
>>42299052 (OP)
>twilight
>not a unicorn
fuck no
Anonymous No.42299140
>>42299129
I like her not being a unicorn. The idea of her being an earth pony who casts magic using alchemy, and shamanistic/druidic rituals is kino as hell.
Anonymous No.42299146
>>42299052 (OP)
Well let's see anon, does it pass the I want to impregnate Fluttershy test?
*looks down at pants*
Yes, yes it absolutely does.
Anonymous No.42299158
Anonymous No.42299162 >>42299409
>>42299052 (OP)
The cutie mark designs in these looks way better than G4 & G5 cutie marks.
Also the style and vibe somewhat reminds me of "The Last Unicorn".
Anonymous No.42299164 >>42300067 >>42300604
>>42299052 (OP)
Hasbro hires people who don't know what made the early FiM so special, brace yourselves for another slopfest.
Anonymous No.42299166 >>42299176 >>42299371 >>42299838
>>42299052 (OP)
Not going to lie, family, that looks bad.
Anonymous No.42299170 >>42299179 >>42299183
>>42299052 (OP)
>DUDEEEE! BRO! MLP... IS LIKE.... SO MUCH MORE THAN A LITTLE GIRL'S SHOW DUDE?
>LOOK AT THIS BRO! THEIR DESIGN IS COMPLEX... THEY HAVE FUR AND GRADIENT COATS!
>THIS IS A SERIOUS CARTOON, BRO!
These people pissed me off then and they still piss me the fuck off, it's a show for little girls, stop trying to make it something bigger than it actually is.
Anonymous No.42299171
>>42299052 (OP)
If this comes to fruitiion the most popular ships will be
>Rarity x Fluttershy
>Rarity x AJ (legacy ship)
>Rarity x Twilight
>Rarity x Rainbow Dash
>Twilight x AJ
>Twilight x Pinkie Pie
>Twilight x Rainbow Dash
>Twilight x Rarity
>AJ x Fluttershy
>AJ x Rainbow Dash (legacy ship)
>AJ x Rarity (legacy ship)
>Pinkie Pie x Twilight
>Pinkie Pie x Rainbow Dash
Anonymous No.42299176 >>42299181 >>42299182
>>42299166
What looks bad about it? I think it looks extremely soulful and interesting.
Especially since it seems like this setting would avoid modern technology. I think if there is technology in this setting it would be Magitek.
Anonymous No.42299179 >>42299190
>>42299170
>stop trying to make it something bigger than it actually is.
>"NOO STOP TRYING TO RAISE THE BAR! WE SHOULD ALWAYS SETTLE FOR THE BARE MINIMUM!"
Also anon "little girls show" doesn't mean boring and safe. Little Girls regularly watch anime and enjoy darker themes in stories.
Anonymous No.42299181 >>42299206
>>42299176
It looks good for a little golden book, not a cartoon.
Anonymous No.42299182 >>42299206
>>42299176
NTA but these artists genuinely just don't know what made Faust's design so compelling in the first place, they remove the simplicity from the original designs and replace it with these overdesigned ponies that accomplish nothing to tell the viewer more about the character, it's visual clutter for the sake of it.
It's the art version of people who pour sauce all over their food cause they can't cook.
Anonymous No.42299183 >>42299185 >>42299190 >>42299193
>>42299170
>"little girls show"
Little Girls loved sailor moon and it had a lot of serious themes and stuff in it. I know its hard for you to believe anon because of your ignorant assumptions but little girls like cool stuff too.
Anonymous No.42299185
>>42299183
Based if you look at the type of media little girls aged 11 and up regularly consume its not safe and boring shit in fact some of it is edgier than the stuff little boys watch.
Anonymous No.42299190 >>42299201
>>42299179
>>42299183
Look anon I get your misunderstanding but I'm not saying we should settle for the bare minimum, what pisses me off is this demographic of people who believe they need to force FiM into something it isn't for the sake of making it less embarrassing to watch.
I'm not saying MLP can't have serious themes either, because early FiM did, but making moral lessons without making it corny or preachy is a task only the best of writers can make, and in the end, when you really look at it, the people who want to make FiM something it isn't force darker themes for the sake of it being darker, not because they genuinely think it fits the overarching theme.
Anonymous No.42299193
>>42299183
Sailor moon was the most popular "girls show" in the 90's when it aired in America and Japan.
It shows that girls enjoy stuff with action and doing cool shit as long as the leads are female and pretty.
Anonymous No.42299201 >>42299385
>>42299190
>what pisses me off is this demographic of people who believe they need to force FiM into something it isn't for the sake of making it less embarrassing to watch.
You literally love G4 and that in of itself is a departure from the previous generations. G4 was defintiely more mature and "edgy" compared to G1-3 which were mostly extremely safe.
This concept just feels like a further evolution to it, they wouldn't remove the comedy or light heartedness its just that it wouldn't be afraid to take itself more interesting and they would understand that little girls like stuff like that as well as boys.
Anonymous No.42299206 >>42299217 >>42299714
>>42299182
>these artists genuinely just don't know what made Faust's design so compelling in the first place
>he's a faust purist
Season 1 of G4 had flaws btw, and G4 while enjoyable was nowhere near perfect. This potential G6 reboot could do some great stuff.
>>42299181
You don't watch enough animation if you think this.
Anonymous No.42299209
If this happens and this G4 Reboot is a success then it will guarantee the Mane 6 as being the true faces and leads of My Little Pony.
Anonymous No.42299217
>>42299206
>had flaws
I disagree, design wise I think Faust's FiM is genuine perfection, I'm saying this from a design standpoint, mind you.
Anonymous No.42299305
>>42299104
OPs images are from 2019 , its not happening
Anonymous No.42299317 >>42299331
>>42299106
>Plus the reception for this concept art has been really positive.
As measured by who and in what way?
Anonymous No.42299331
>>42299317
By the people who's opinions Hasbro actually pays attention. Twitter users.
Anonymous No.42299337 >>42299340 >>42299347
>>42299052 (OP)
>Celtic Earth Ponies
Soul
Will all earth ponies have an iris/scottish accent?
Anonymous No.42299340 >>42299347 >>42299353 >>42299390
>>42299337
Earth Ponies = Celtics
Unicorns = French
Pegasus = Britbongs
Anonymous No.42299347 >>42301226
>>42299337
>>42299340
Earth Ponies = Druids/Barbarians
Unicorns = Wizards/Clerics
Pegasus = Fighters/Rogues
Anonymous No.42299353 >>42299355 >>42299421
>>42299340
Wrong.
Earth Ponies = Norsemen
Unicorns = French
Pegasi = Roman
Anonymous No.42299355
>>42299353
I can concede on Pegasi = Roman but the Earth Ponies in the concept art in the OP look celtic.
Anonymous No.42299370 >>42299373
>>42299055
>tribal
They won't greenlight this.
Anonymous No.42299371
>>42299166
it is bad and it's not cute, that other Anon is retarded
Anonymous No.42299373
>>42299370
European Tribal is socially acceptable. American and African Tribal isn't.
Anonymous No.42299375 >>42299380
>>42299106
There's no chance because i can tell production would be expensive. You're talking about Disney 2D creation. Hasbro will not foot the bill for this.

It was likely rejected in the first place for being recognized as expensive to produce
Anonymous No.42299380 >>42299393
>>42299375
I will continue to believe that they will green light this for G6.
Anonymous No.42299385 >>42299387
>>42299201
>compared to G1
How to kill your argument. You never watched G1 if you think it's safe.
Anonymous No.42299387
>>42299385
I meant to type G2-G3
Anonymous No.42299390 >>42299410
>>42299340
>all white coded in 2025
You guys are DELUSIONAL if you think this will be greenlit.
Anonymous No.42299393 >>42299412
>>42299380
YWN see this for G6
It's best not to dream.
Anonymous No.42299409 >>42299413 >>42299418
>>42299162
>cutie mark designs in these-
Would be a fucking nightmare to animate. Even in Flash it would slow things down.
Anonymous No.42299410 >>42299426
>>42299390
>all white coded in 2025
Its fine. One of them will have an asian voice actress.
Anonymous No.42299412
>>42299393
I'd rather hope and be disappointed than not hope at all.
I like the overall style though my only real critique would be to not make the foreheads so damn big.
Anonymous No.42299413
>>42299409
Eh they can be simplified while still keeping the overall vibe especially in certain scenes.
Anonymous No.42299418
>>42299409
Most women are retarded and throw a bunch of unnecessary shit over their designs because they're frauds and don't fathom that less is more.
Anonymous No.42299421 >>42299422 >>42299722
>>42299353
I think you're right about the Roman thing. The pattern on Dash's gogles here look roman esque.
Anonymous No.42299422 >>42299425
>>42299421
Damn don't zoom in these mares look like shit
Anonymous No.42299424
Scottish Applejack
Anonymous No.42299425
>>42299422
Calm your autism. I'm not a big fan of aspects of the art style either (foreheads are too big) but I love the concept.
Anonymous No.42299426 >>42299430
>>42299410
Please. There are ppl still whining about F*R*I*E*N*D*S
Anonymous No.42299430 >>42299448 >>42299450
>>42299426
Anon as long as the concept is cool no one but a small minority of engagement baiters will complain about there being no black culture representation in the main cast.
I do wonder though if this was greenlighted and they added a group of characters that were african if they would make them zebras again or just ponies.
Anonymous No.42299446 >>42299502
>what if mare... but with stallion proportions no ass and visual clutter
bravo tumblr
Anonymous No.42299448 >>42299452
>>42299430
I want inner city Applejack.

Just so the morons who keep returning to the same restaurant realize that the chef left and the owner of the restaurant was lucky to ever have him.

Hasbro will never stumble on the accident of making an amazing show. Did you not notice that by season 9 the show was visually and emotionally unrecognizable? That's the new chef trying to make the old dish and didn't even learn what made the old dish edible. And that is who Hasbro retained while not retaining the initial staff. You can see the slow bleed over the seasons as more of that original talent left. And then by s9 they even ditched the model and it visually became unrecognizable.

Stop returning to Hasbro. It's never going to make good Pony again.
Anonymous No.42299450 >>42299474
>>42299430
>it's good because npcs will buy it
Anonymous No.42299452
>>42299448
FiM was lightning in a bottle. We should just be happy we got what we did. And stop looking for Hasbro to drop mana from heaven. Hasbro is retarded. FiM being good was a fluke.
Anonymous No.42299474
>>42299450
>npc = not a cynical incel like me
Yes.
Anonymous No.42299496 >>42299503 >>42300235
>>42299052 (OP)
what the fuck are these designs
>Twilight Sparkle just looks horrible, where is her Horn, Alicorn wings if sheโ€™s already a princess?
>For some unholy reason Pinkie Pie is given wings, while Fluttershyโ€™s wings are removed
>Earth ponies have too much going on, they canโ€™t be just simple? Why do they have so much hair and body markings/clothes?
>Applejack is missing her hat, and doesnโ€™t even have any stoutness for bucking, she looks more like a dyke then anything

The only M6 design I donโ€™t have problems with is Rarity, Fluttershy looks fine too but needs her wings back.
I canโ€™t wait for the abomination that is the redesign of all the fillies
Anonymous No.42299502
>>42299446
>Stallion proportions
Luna and Celestia look like Stallions to you?
Anonymous No.42299503 >>42299513
>>42299496
>Twilight Sparkle just looks horrible, where is her Horn, Alicorn wings if sheโ€™s already a princess?
>Likes Alicorn Twilight
Stopped reading here. Just joking but lame take. Alicorn Twi is worst Twi.
>Fluttershy looks fine too but needs her wings back.
imo Fluttershy's wings were such a non-feature for the character since she was actively afraid of flying (and most things).
Anonymous No.42299507
Anonymous No.42299513 >>42299517
>>42299503
>Alicorn Twi is worst Twi.
Twi is Twi retard. With or without wings she is still cute
Anonymous No.42299517
>>42299513
Nah. Twi is objectively better without wings. Whether she's a unicorn or an earth pony,.
Anonymous No.42299695 >>42299712
>>42299052 (OP)
It's going to be shit just like g5 was.
Trust me, I'm always right.
Anonymous No.42299706 >>42299709
>>42299052 (OP)
It looks like fucking shit no offense to imalou
Its not her fault because working on this shit made her depressed and she wants to become an airline pilot or something now
Anonymous No.42299709
>>42299706
>her
>she
Anonymous No.42299712
>>42299695
Asian Pone
Anonymous No.42299714 >>42299781
>>42299206
>he's a spiteful anti faust contrarian
Anonymous No.42299722 >>42299775
>>42299421
That looks like fucking shit
Anonymous No.42299775
>>42299722
Show me a better style then anon.
>inb4 its generic porn
Anonymous No.42299781
>>42299714
>thinks Faust's vision was perfect.
Lol. Lmao even.
Anonymous No.42299838 >>42299861
>>42299166
Yeah, very overdesigned. Just doesn't fit with the brand.
Anonymous No.42299861 >>42299870
>>42299838
no offense but I don't trust people who call things overdesigned without explaining how and why it is. Usually people who say that end up being kind of dumb.
Anonymous No.42299870 >>42299913
>>42299861
Okay, how about the swirls, the accessories, the gradients, the fetlocks..
Anonymous No.42299913
>>42299870
Do you consider Spider-Man who is an iconic character design to be "overdesigned"?
Anonymous No.42300038 >>42300126
>>42299052 (OP)
>the dogpony style of that trannylou artist we hired turned out to be a flop
>let's do that again for our next attempt!
they can't be for fucking real. there is a limit to the retardation one person should have. how do they keep doing it?
Anonymous No.42300051 >>42300056 >>42300153
>>42299052 (OP)
While I dig the Celtic/tribal aesthetic, I donโ€™t like the actual artwork. I get that itโ€™s only concept art and itโ€™s for a new iteration, but the artstyle is so unappealing and it falls in the same vein of artists on tumblr or instagram that will redesign a character like Sonic for example and remove everything that made them appealing in the first place.
Anonymous No.42300056 >>42300157
>>42300051
Of course it's terrible it's drawn by a tumblrfag foid
Anonymous No.42300067 >>42300072
>>42299164
It's literally impossible to replicate what made early FiM so special, it is a product of its time thanks to very very specific market and social conditions. FiM will never ever happen again, accept it.
Anonymous No.42300072
>>42300067
I don't buy that, I'm not optimistic but I'm not totally hopeless about MLP. I'm not asking for a masterpiece, I'm not asking for something that is social phenomenon like FiM, I'm merely asking for a cute, simple, slice of life pony show.
Anonymous No.42300087
>>42299052 (OP)
Thatโ€™s McCarthyโ€™s original G5 design from 2017 before Hasbro denied the idea and give the job to G.M. Berrow.
Anonymous No.42300112 >>42300159 >>42300691 >>42300953
>>42299104
They said a total brand reinvention, not a total FiM reinvention. Also this gives the impression that Hasbro will just change the hat and call it a day. G4 was way more of a re-invention than anything before and after it simply because some milf working at CN liked the horse when she was little.
Anonymous No.42300126
>>42300038
Each day, Hasbro employees have a retardation competition to see who can make the most stupid decision ever, followed by the "Sinking your head up your ass" competition.
Anonymous No.42300153
>>42300051
OP here yeah I think the style could use some tweaking but I love the concept of the Earth, Unicorn, and Pegasi.
Especially with Earth Ponies looking Celtic, and the Ponies having a more magical & naturalist vibe.
Anonymous No.42300157 >>42300191 >>42300246
>>42300056
Chuds can't create good art. Of course all art is made by "tumblrfags".
Also Lauren Faust is a "tumblrfag"
Anonymous No.42300159 >>42300953
>>42300112
Brand reinvention could mean "we're going to take ourselves more seriously now" and the conceptual direction in the OP could fit that.
Anonymous No.42300191 >>42300202
>>42300157
First things first, the first wave of tumblr hired artists came from DEI programs, this trend started on the 2020s. Ever wondered why animation studios are putting out box-office bomb after box-office bomb? It's not just executive meddling, they're hiring minorities and queers in order to secure funding from diversity quotas. Therefore, Faust isn't a "tumblrfag" in the traditional sense, she's a second wave feminist, not someone who grew up on Tumblr, where being as loud and performative as possible granted you attention, also explaining Tumblr SJW's obsession with adding queer and minority characters, it's got an audience that will applaud and consume it like it's crack.
Second off, this isn't about chuds vs troons, what I'm saying is that the people who truly care about the artistic process aren't inserting themselves into the industry because they're disgusted by it, why the heck do you think people say Hollywood is dead but European cinema is still thriving? The latter is more independent from profits and driven by artistic vision alone, so the only thought process that happens for that work of art is contained between actual artists, not an executive board evaluating how profitable and marketable something will be.
My main point is: The people who Hasbro has hired ever since G4 ended are not people who treat art as art but as a commodity to signal their virtue, they're not on Tumblr anymore but they still seek that same high of getting attention by mere virtue signaling.
Anonymous No.42300202 >>42300207
>>42300191
>DEI
Lauren Faust is a woman.
Anonymous No.42300207
>>42300202
Yes, and her talent stems from the fact she's an incredibly talented writer, the issue is Hollywood and animation studios in general are hiring people not based on their merits but how oppresed their identity is perceived.
Anonymous !!oatZii+RBqa No.42300235
>>42299496
>>For some unholy reason Pinkie Pie is given wings, while Fluttershyโ€™s wings are removed
Anon, Faust originally planned this tribe configuration for FiM
Anonymous No.42300246 >>42300465
>>42300157
Faust was deviantart, not Tumblr
Anonymous No.42300465 >>42300631
>>42300246
Same thing in practice.
Anonymous No.42300604 >>42300640
>>42299164
I won't mind it being slop, I just don't want it cling off G4 hat like G5 did
Anonymous No.42300631 >>42300759
>>42300465
No, not at the time.
Anonymous No.42300640 >>42300658
>>42300604
And no more pandering this time please. I hate it and don't want any zoomer tiktok social media focused nonsense like G5 had. Pandering points far more towards the subject of its target and much less towards what's important: The story, characters themselves, and situation/plot. It also makes them far less believable; having depth is important for emotional connection.
Anonymous No.42300658 >>42300763
>>42300640
>writers decide to include characters based on cultures other than white americans
STOP PANDERING YOU FUCKING RETARDS
>writers decide to include rural southern apple farmer horse even after seeing that she's the least popular main pony for the entirety of FiM's run
Well... I deserve a little pandering.
Anonymous No.42300691
>>42300112
>G4 was way more of a re-invention than anything before and after
Bruh, FIM was just a hodge podge of G1, G3, and G3.5; it's just really good at that.
Anonymous No.42300759 >>42300827
>>42300631
Yes it is. I was there.
Anonymous No.42300763
>>42300658
based
Anonymous No.42300827 >>42300851
>>42300759
So was I. You're wrong. And I win by virtue of being MUCH older than you, trust me.
Anonymous No.42300840 >>42300859 >>42301021
Just make her the main character of g6.
That's the only way to save it.
Anonymous No.42300851
>>42300827
u dont know how old I am chuddy
Anonymous No.42300859 >>42300868
>>42300840
>Rarity but pink, blonde,and evil
Anonymous No.42300868 >>42300871
>>42300859
>Rarity but pink and blonde
FTFY
Anonymous No.42300871
>>42300868
>dumbass Rarity hater
Of course. All opinions from you are henseforth discarded. Find God.
Anonymous No.42300953 >>42301064
>>42300112
>>42300159
They're probably going to try to shed the notion that it's a franchise exclusively for preschool aged little girls, instead selling it as something that's safe for kids but also fun for everyone.
Anonymous No.42300976 >>42300984 >>42301069
>>42299106
There's only one possible art style that will be positively received (truly)...

Just do the goddamn G4 next generation with Flurry Heart, some coolass Draconequus pony hybrid, and Pinkie Pie's kid. Like "Degrassi: The Next Generation"... I can guarantee good reception from both kids and autistic adults alike.
Anonymous No.42300984
>>42300976
Thats not how you say "more season 1"
Anonymous No.42300991
>>42299055
>trefoil
St. Patrick is canon?
Anonymous No.42301021
>>42299052 (OP)
I just want more racist/mean characters like Posey, Diamond Tiara, or >>42300840
Anonymous No.42301064
>>42300953
>They're probably going to try to shed the notion that it's a franchise exclusively for preschool aged little girls, instead selling it as something that's safe for kids but also fun for everyone.
Agreed. Its what I was saying.
Anonymous No.42301069 >>42301411
>>42300976
>more of the same please!!
No.
Anonymous No.42301226
>>42299347
I think fighter would be able to fit any of them since it's a pretty flexible omni-class, but I also can't think of any other class pegasi can have for themselves that isn't in some way done better by the other two. Maybe ranger? Unless we want to get into the more game/edition specific stuff like Tactician
Anonymous No.42301411
>>42301069
It's not the same, it continues the story from the next generation like Degrassi. Degrassi Next Generation is the most eponymous one and starts with the protagonist Emma (the teen mom's baby from the earlier Degrassi series) and goes from there... Flurry and Pinkie's kid, and the Cake twins, are ready to have their stories told. Why rob them of their story? You have another filly encased in stone who could escape like Discord and be the primary big bad.

Look around you. Every single thread is FiM and some special snowflakes with whatever else. FiM is the only successful iteration, nobody cares about the rest, and the G6 gap was long enough that the little girls buying the toys will be a whole new generation of little girls who haven't "already got" the FiM looking toys. Or they can try something different again, like with G6, and fail to reach the same heights yet again, and have nobody but little kids who don't know better follow it again.