Thread 42366296

Live action movie discussion thread. Previous thread was aborted.
https://variety.com/2025/film/news/my-little-pony-movie-live-action-amazon-mgm-hasbro-1236461858/

>>42366296 (OP)
It will be good.

>>42366296 (OP)
It will be bad.

It will leave me with no strong feelings one way or the other.

>>42366296 (OP)
It will be average.

>>42366296 (OP)
reminder that the previous OP is a tranny trying to insert xerself into 4chan, make sure to ignore the tranny's posts especially when you see xer's ugly ass troon face. Janny fortunately does his job and deletes that tranny's post on sight when he actually does what he is supposed to do.

>>42366296 (OP)
What are you expecting?
>Film Adaptation of G4/'any other G' storylines
>A completely new cast
>A meta film like Chip & Dale
>Sonic/Alvin & The Chipmunks/Hop plot

>>42366296 (OP)
I think I speak for all of us when I say that we thought g4 would never return, but it is doing so in the movie and that at least should secretly make us all happy. You cannot hide behind cynicism forever anons. It might not be a masterpiece but it is still a movie made to capture the lightning in a bottle we once experienced when young, why not give it a chance and be optimistic? Why continue to act like the contrarians of the internet when there is a real chance this movie is everything we ever wanted? when the movie does well MLP will go back to being in the spotlight of worldwide pop culture, this board will be in the spotlight, this is our chance at reviving the happiest moments of our lives

>>42366296 (OP)
>Live action movie
lmao it's so over. there's no way they're not gonna use cringe 3d models instead of the original 2d flash puppets.

>>42366309
Metafilm with lots of memberberries and cameos since that shit sells like hotcakes.

>>42366296 (OP)
As I was saying, human actors for horses
>This is Twilight Sparkle

>>42366322
>My Little Dashie

>>42366311
hasbro will never do it
indie animators will never do it

it's over

>>42366322
Reminder that Ashleigh Ball won't come back and they'll be having Dashie voiced by Awkwafina insteaf

>>42366308
thanks mr. janjan
>>42366311
it will bring some attention alright, it already did. but if we're trying to revive what was more than decade ago, this isn't it
reconsidering the live action, i had low expectations initially and still have, but i'd like to see some leaks from Hasbro first

>>42366296 (OP)
mlp would only work 'live action' if done with puppets or stopmotion like labyrinth or a cuter dark crystal, or in a fantastic mrfox/isle of dogs kinda way
>>42366308
not a tranny nor a faggot, nor french nor kike. i am huffy the horseful here to save pony or what i can. thread was exact same and image is relevant, maybe you should learn to cope better, fag, because we're entering a truly dark era, even worse than this past halfdecade. the end is neigh

>42366335
do not reply to this tranny. Let janny do his job and xer's post will be deleted for ban evasion and proxy use.

>>42366309
>What are you expecting?

EQG with cheaply tacked on CGI horse ears.

>>42366374
this
in the decades before the actors would wear handcrafted plush ears with animatronics inside but now they'll just wear those items that have a bar code on them that later get automatically transformed into video effect ears

>>42366332
Everyone says they won't come back but when they're literal whos with only one good role theyll come. Especially if you dangle money in front of them. But if they don't do it they won't cast that bitch. It'll be Zendaya.

>>42366374
Fuck this shit I'm going to umamusume

>>42366322
>Rainbow Dash rips a disgustingly loud fart in the car when hes driving
>screechy Ashleigh Ball voice
>"Heh told you I was 20% cooler."

>>42366374
100% this, too many people think it will be ponies but knowing the slimy fuckers higher up they will make it EqG.

>>42366308
Kek. Sharty is down the hall and to the left, xir.

>>42366308
OP already has left marks in form of pictures around the board. I remember months ago a debut was made and pictures were posted with a pinkie pie. Iirc, Pinkie panel for marecon was made by OP

>>42366374
>horses for ages: a masculine thing
>cars come along
>horses are now a feminine thing
>ponies become a thing for younger girls to ride every now and then because just like horses, ponies are expensive
>Bonnie Zacherle creates the My Pretty Pony toy line so little kids can have a plastic horse of their own
>G1 is created to sell the toy, the ponies look mostly like ponies but not really
>with each generation the ponies look less equine and more human
>G4 comes along and the neoteny is dialed up even more
>EqG goes even further and eschews all equine features except the ears
>live action movie with regular ass women but tacked on CGI ears, a pure Baudrillardian simulacrum
at this point you might as well lose the ears

>>42366374
I wish this was not true

>>42366296 (OP)
This is literally just going to be a bunch of no hooves in ponysuits, it will suck ass

>>42366302
I agree

>>42366308
Tranny janny you are a terrible larper

>>42366311
Go outside and touch grass weirdo

>>42366374
Since this is Hasbro, their retarded suits and investors we're talking about this really is the most likely outcome.

>>42366715
Like the Cats movie

>>42366409
>umamusume
They're doing this 100% because of the success of that show. 100 fucking %.

Coincidentally 2026 is also the year of the horse
>year of the horse
>make live action "horse movie" showing nothing but humans

>>42366374
>EQG
You're probably right

Since this is a modern movie, I wonder which pony would be the queer representative

>>42366977
Why does this pic have the same energy as picrel

why is this on page 8? Isn't the live action hot news

>>42367232
I think most that can be said has already been said in the first two threads. There's nothing much else to go off on until more news comes out.

>>42367259
More news as in the movie is not happening at all.

>>42366777
No, they're obviously doing it because live action shit is what everyone else is doing. I'm pretty sure umamusume isn't a show either, just a gacha, so if they wanted to copy it we would have had an EQG gacha instead.

This is how our worlds become connected

>>42366296 (OP)
Make it AiE, starring Ryan Gosling as Anon.

mlp was great when it didnt have an overarching villain teased in ep1 and then defeated in episode 26. whatever they chose to do in the movie i hope its just to unite/introduce the mane 6. either reform and join the villain kr defeat them completely. the throughout the season overarching threat has never worked

>>42366309
I'd hate it somewhat less if the human was Megan. I guess Danny and Molly can come too.
But generally, unless it ultimately results in an EQG type thing where the worlds are separated and youre transformed at the threshold i just don't like it much. I dont like AiE outside of jokes/memes either.
If it results in a cartoon it better be 2d in or near the G4 style we know and love. Not just for our, but also for Hasbro's best interests.
The most extreme hollywood wokery seems to be largely dying down by now so that's good, but as nice as it'd be if they don't drizzle that bullshit in, I wouldn't bet on it.

>>42367582
what is AiE?

>>42366296 (OP)
>There are people who think it won't be EqG in real life when likely hasbro executives and Sony executives will just pull up EqG art and watches from south america and say it's the better choice
my sweet little angels only if you knew...

Does anyone have the screencap from 15 years ago of the hypothetical live action MLP movie

>>42366308
>complains about trannies
>has 40 eqg threads as we speak

peak hypocrisy.

>>42366311
>there is a real chance this movie is everything we ever wanted

Source?

Sounds like you made this the fuck up.

>>42366374
>>42366419
eqg is not MLP though. How exactly would this be a MLP movie?

>>42367680
Anon...

It will be complete shit.

>>42366311
>I think I speak for all of us when I say that we thought g4 would never return,
Are you retarded? Its the defining gen, eclipsing utterly all before it. Of course they were going to milk it to death.

>>42367680
>itoddler is retarded
classic, EqG was only made because hasbro employees collected a shit ton of humanized ponies art so executives will see it and say "muh audience wants humans not ponies" which the haslab thing leaked

>>42366329
but Anon will be played by James Marsden instead of Brendan Fraser, and everyone knows his acting in the original is the best.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RiGKQCENk68

>>42366329
but Anon will be played by James Marsden instead of Brendan Fraser. A shame because everyone knows his acting in the original was the best.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RiGKQCENk68

>>42367825
Impossible, that's way more effort than what Hasbro is willing to put.

>>42367690
G4 is especially huge in CHYNA, where the toys are made anyway, so the few non-retarded Hasbro execs are trying to get the stupid as boomers on the board into picking up this free cash. I bet this money will be either some kind of compromise or the boomers trying to sabotage it with retarded ideas from the eighties. I know this because I briefly worked in the >creative industry as a financial consultant(rented out prime use rights of my soul to Lucifer on a a very favorable tax-deductible lease) and practically every stupid concept they come up with is some buzzword laden shit from their youth that gets watered up for a "wider audience" anyway, as they are terrified about their audience is not getting it and potentially losing sales, so they play it safe with slop. And this is the outright PREFERABLE, risk free option, to what some of the old boomers are idea guying on some board meetings. I've seen <REDACTED> multimedia company's big plurality owner go and propose to abandon all internet and social media presence and advertisement and "go back to TV" and the likes. Companies, especially large ones are just plodding ahead based on momentum. Just understand this, because G4 was massively successful it will NEVER be fully abandoned. 20 years from now it will get rebooted or referenced as it got evergreened into recognizability and marketability. Its like Batman movies, you will get a new one every decade or so.

>>42366332
Why? She get sick of it like Cathy did?

Going to be modeled after the minecraft movie with member berries from every generation before G5. Live action mixed with animation, pony to human transformation to save on animation budget and EQG member-berry on top. For me it's just going to be slop, but it'll be fun to watch with friends on the internet

I predict that on the day that this movie releases, if it does, I will be capable of asking an AI to generate an MLP movie, and the AI will do a slightly better job.

>>42366308
Obsessed

>>42366309
What's the Sonic/Alvin & The Chipmunks/Hop plot?

>>42367988
>Live action mixed with animation, pony to human transformation to save on animation budget
They're going to bring back the original VA but then have them transform into big name actresses without any explanation why their voices sound different like with that one Fairly OddParents live action film

>>42367988
>A CUTIE MARK!
>IT'S A CHANGELING!
>PARASPRITE!
>Show some respect! She's an ALICORN!
>THE ELEMENTS OF HARMONY!
>Don't worry bros. It's just the Wonderbolts!
>IT'S NIGHTMARE NIGHT!
>TIMBERWOLVES!

if you guys actually wanna do something cool for once then write what a GOOD live action movie would be like
as in, we all get on a collaborative doc and write it together

>>42368239
A live action MLP movie is fundamentally not a good idea. A good version of it can't exist.

>>42368252
not with that spirit

thread, I think the three biggest questions are:
1. Is this going to be for G6?
2. Is it going to have humans and ponies in the same setting?

3. Will it be canon to G4 and G5 i.e. the same continuity?

I hope the answer to all of these is no, and especially 1 and 2 if it turns out 3 is a yes

As long as we can keep g4 untouched that' the biggest priority but I woul also hope this isn't gonna set the tone for G6 FFS; MIND YOU, G5 died a death without a story conclusion, and Opaline's voice actor confirmed there were no finalised plans for the story in the works, any what-could-have-beens so it would be pretty hard to link the Amazon movie to it if there's no actual ending to thread it to. So that makes 3 unlikely and 1 hard to achieve.

If that's the case, who care's what 2 is? Just ignore it.

What if it's Anon in Equestria

>>42368239
>stuff happens
>stuff happens
>stuff happens
>a mare and a human kiss on the lips
>the end

>>42366296 (OP)
Maybe it'll be a G1 remake with Meegan being live action while the ponies are animated.

>>42368468
>into: a mare and a human kiss on the lips
>into: a mare and a human kiss on the lips
>into: a mare and a human kiss on the lips
>the end

>>42368672
Thanks kek

Page 9 bump

>>42367704
Bullshit, they made EqG because they wanted to cash in on shit like Monster High

>>42369156
This. Its a toy company making toys. The autistic seethe about EQG will never be not funny.

>>42368672
This is a self-fulfilling prophecy
The movie is going to be exactly like this and it's our fault

>>42366311
decent bait, made me reply, but only the best bait is the bait that posters aren't aware is bait.
5/10, could be better.

>>42366309
>>42367582
This ^

If the live action is a complete remake of escape from Midnight Castle, and the actress for Megan is a genuine fit with white skin, blue eyes, and long blonde hair it will be kino.

if its a DEI, than its DOA.

>>42369806
>if its a DEI
sorry to disappoint, nonny, but that's exactly what you're getting.

>>42369812
not even the dead are sacred.

>>42368197
Kino

>>42367680
>My little porny

>THIS SUMMER
>an anon will learn...
*sigh*
I'll never reach closure with this franchise, will I?
I remember being autistically invested in this show from the end of 2013 to the start of 2015 (I can't explain why I feel I have memories from 2012 tho), then I've stopped caring for a while and in 2019 I discovered it had ended based on a few tweets on my timeline. Then I got a nostalgic attack around 2022 that I wanted to wash away, so I binge-watched the entire show to see if seeing what I've missed would let it out of my system, but it didn't. None of the ways G4 concluded (Magical Mystery Cure, The Last Problem and whatever G5 implies about the M6's future) left me satisfied. I thought that participating in the antithology and giving to the fandom something in return for what it gave to me would help, but it didn't do much.
There's something about MLP and how Hasbro handled it that makes me feel stuck with it in a manner that other franchises I hold dear haven't. The only way I can imagine getting a satisfying conclusion that would easily allow me to move on with my life without intrusive thoughts would either be Faust getting a final season to end what she started as she wanted, or a series of movies with a meta-narrative diving into what the show, the fandom and its cultural impact actually meant (like what the Evangelion movies do to some extent) but this is very unlikely given how Hasbro manages their IPs.
I'll watch the live-action non-sense anyway, either streamed by anons or at the movie theater, to see if it can at least laugh at the train-wreck this movie will be.

>>42368672
oh god i hope that anon is still around
>>42369900
>I'll watch the live-action non-sense anyway
i hope when one of us gets it available, we'll do a movie night, however horrendous it may be

>>42368197
Most accurate prediction in this thread

>>42367680
Anon, I…

i would start hysterically laughing if the movie gets cancelled

anyways i would watch

>>42366296 (OP)
Is there any more info on this or do we only have confirmation that it exists?

>>42371858
the latter

bump

>>42367825
I will now watch your movie

>>42368672
Staring Brendan Fraser.

>>42366296 (OP)
it will get cancelled. there is no movie

>>42366311
What makes you think it’ll be a G4 movie, Anon?

I hope the movie will look at least as good as this!

>>42374901
AHHHH VHHHHH SEX THE UNCANNY LITTLE CRIPPLE

>>42374914
BIG FILLO TOT, PUSH HER IN WATER AND WETMANE

>>42374901
Foalmaking sex with Scootaloo.

>>42374901
It won't

>>42367259
Dude i havent caught up the news gill now and now i missed everyones opinions...

>>42374596
Source?

>>42375439
im from the future

>>42374901
you will eat your humiliation ritual slop and you will be happy

>>42376522
>breed pony x
Don't mind if I do!

>>42366311
Thanks for this, and I think you're right. With no g4 content besides Rise of Cadence recently, it should make a lot of us really happy - I'm certainly willing to hope

>>42376522
>>42377659
-BUT PONEFESSOR UTONIUM ACCIDENTALLY ADDED AN EXTRA INGREDIENT TO THE CONCOCTION

>>42367964
cathy felt that "spike's character arc is finished" and didn't want to fuck things up more with pony life
if he was respected, maybe she'd come back

>>42368197
when was it obvious this man had no shame left

>>42369806
>DEI
super funny how nobody said this word until a couple months ago. not noooticing or anything

>>42369785
Best captcha omg. This has exploitable meme material written all over it.

>>42366309
What the heck is a "meta film"? I havent seen Chip and Dale and dont know ehat that is.

>>42368049
Weird monster animal shows up and has to find a way back home. Goes on a rode trip and becomes best friends with the human sidekick>>42368025

>>42377689
>when was it obvious this man had no shame left
It's called having fun

up

>>42377829
Self-referential trash written by one of the smuggest fart-huffers in LA.

>>42366296 (OP)
How the hell do you do a live action for ponies? Isn't that just CGI? A live action for EQG would make more sense

>>42378943
"Live Action" like Lion King Remake.

>>42377829
Spiderverse 2.

>>42379296
How would that even work out.
Super realist pony seem horrifying

>>42366311
Definitely the Sonic type, with the token human MC being played by the exact same actor.

>>42377829
The Disney+ Chip and Dale film was a fun little movie, where characters from a lot of Disney owned shows appear. It's a nice comfy watch and I'd recommend it

>>42377695
>until a couple months ago.

>>42377829
It's a tumblr retardation where a mouse got fucked by a fly a hundred times, I'm not kidding

>>42379296
>Lion King Remake
Didn't everyone hate that? Never watched it myself but it looks soulless

>>42379800
It was terrible, but it made loads of money anyway

>>42366296 (OP)
Imagine if G6 was Mane 6 and it had animation on part with the MLP movie. Pure kino.

It's gonna be good bros! Just trust in the plan

bump

>>42377689
>when was it obvious this man had no shame left
He is an actor, shedding their sense of shame is the first part of their career. it's not about integrity or dignity, he simply suck at acting.

>>42380782
pony is the israel of the internet

>>42366296 (OP)
The only way this concept could possibly be good is if they did it "My Little Dashie" style with cartoon ponies in the real world but they won't

Chip and Dale is technically an MLP life action movie
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_El9QCny8Q8

>>42381654
except horsefucker anons somehow consistently take actions to make the world a better place than they found it, even if it's just donating some shekels to a small time horse veterinarian

I just want a sassy black actress supporting character to really push the PG rating

>>42383268
this is for sure going to happen

>>42383268
Rainbow Dash will be recast with a black VA and will be the sassy black character

Is someone having problems coping with their animated series being reimagined in live-action?

>>42383625
Sonic deserved worse.

>>42383625
>shadman