Thread 42449024

It's night time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnMlebxoG4E

I'm glad he just stole music. I wish more pony game developers stop pretending to be real legal studios. Hasbro can never sue Pokehidden even if he ever finished his MLP sex game, because I doubt any of his information is online.

>>42449024 (OP)
Based thread

BfED is the best pony game, factually.

i enjoyed the game, very fun
too bad the creator is somehow off nowadays

>>42449053
the creator's gone? so no sequel or update?

>>42449166
Onihidden on inkbunny. His personal life hasn't been good throughout the years.

>>42449183
Ahh, that explains why then. Hopefully it gets better.

>>42449024 (OP)
[sarias song]

>>42449024 (OP)
Why is it that after all the time that's passed since this game, no other pony game has felt so... soulful? Comfy? Passionate?

>>42449605
The animations are top-tier. It's not exactly fap fuel for me but he did an amazing job making it feel silly and fun.

>>42449024 (OP)
that game was fucking hilarious at times

>>42449605
It's got a beautiful charm that no other pony game can seem to replicate.

>>42449666
The game has a lot of great gags, like Big Mac finding you and Applejack or you having to teach Derpy to not bite your dick.

>>42449024 (OP)
Replayed this and I like the 3 day gimmick, even if its taken from LOZ.

>>42450104
Yeah, the game isn't exactly original but it limited its scope in a really smart way.

>>42449024 (OP)
for me it's https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UDH7UKGU0j8&ab_channel=PokQuayMlp
so comfy

>>42449039
what does the 馬語 say?

>>42450205
It says if you don't reply to this post red will kiss your mom in her sleep

>>42450104
Not just the time period, the dancing scarecrow literally comes from Majora's Mask.

Protip: Fly over the boulder before breaking it and you can find a stash of bits where Applejack would be bucking trees.

>>42451001
I see, now it makes so much sense...

I've never bothered, but what happens if you have enough money to buy one of Rarity's outfits?

>>42451105
You can't. It's not in the game.

>>42451014
Just checked. How did I not know this? gonna save so much time

Banned from 4chan (Daily)

>>42451014
>>42451108
I remember using auto clicker at bucking game, but make sure to not pass over 50+ or more, the game detects it and triggers sex scene and also the bits cap at 40.

>>42451107
Boo.

>>42451156
KEK

>>42451156
That's a flash reference I did not think was going to survive this long holy shit.

In case anyone doesn't know: you can start the hidden Big Mac gay scene by right-clicking and selecting "Play" (or something of the sort - it's been ages since I used Flash) when talking to him. You can't stop it without restarting the game though so you'll lose all progress.

>>42449024 (OP)
I have this mandela effect that it was possible to get an extra day from Trixie by having sex with her.

>>42451249
The game would break (not in terms of crashing, just in terms of goals) if you could get an extra day. The 3-day limit is there to force you to build out a route to Mane Six%.

i got a fucking dsi xl to use animanatee just like pokehidden and the save feature no longer works god damnit

>>42451263
just use paint from win xp

>>42451270
i replicated the style in aseprite, with a canvas of 256x192 but painting on the dsi is waaay better. i'm even thinking of making a pixel art homebrew from scratch, or trying to fix animanatee

>>42451278
have you uploaded your works already? I love this style.

>>42451156
HAHAHA kino

>>42451280
i don't really post them since im still learning

>>42451429
I've been trying to get this style myself, but I've always had issues drawing the snouts.
Was pokehidden drawing in 256x192? I thought the game was 640x480

>>42451452
yes it's 256x192, the same resolution of the nintendo ds

>>42451456
And what brush sizes were used for body, eyes?

>>42451457
pokehidden used 5 pixel brushes or lower. the fluttershy i uploaded was made entirely with a 5px brush

It's Night time
https://youtube.com/watch?v=J8pBhDfERGk

>>42450146
look at her spin, wow!

>>42451263
i was using animanatee at the start of the year and i was able to get the save feature to work

im pretty sure all i did was create a blank file named "Animation01.anm" in the animanatee folder and the save files started working

Wait, did Pokehidden make all of that from a DS? How did he imported it onto the PC?

>>42451780
You homebrew the DS and transfer the files and then he put the animation and game together in Flash.

I want more comfy mlp games. Actually I just want more mlp games in general.

>>42449024 (OP)
This game is one of the GOAT as far as I'm concerned.

>>42451687
did it corrupt your files before that? like you save your drawing and from the center it starts to glitch out. that's what happens to me

>>42449024 (OP)
>Queen Chrysalis is the bad ending
Wish it wasn't forced to a bad ending...

>>42449024 (OP)
newfaggot itt
link? Any guides in case of seecret endings?

>>42452127
It's Banned From Equestria Daily, and it's also banned from Equestria Daily.

>>42452127
Can't you just look it up?

>>42449024 (OP)
I've never actually played cave story so I only associate this song with this game.

>>42452484
same desu

I learned about Avril 14th through this game. (Best ending btw)

>>42452484
Same. I tried it recently, but my autism doesn't really allow me to play new games unless I really want to play them (and I don't see anything appealing in Cave Story). It was simpler for me when I was like 11 years old with a lot of ROMs and emulators from the internet. There was some good sense of discovery there.

>>42450146
derpy is indeed the best pony

>>42449024 (OP)
Beautiful night in Ponyville

>>42452790
Princess Luna's Moon is always the most prettiest.

>>42452930
Well obviously, there is only one moon around.

It's a cold night.

>>42454195
It's another day, and ripe for love.

>>42454306
guys is this real??

>>42454306
Ps4 has one (1) game

>>42454429
ONE GAME
I DON'T KNOW WHY

>>42454306
kek i'd play that in VR, Big Brian experience.

I liked the attention to detail of the game. For example, look at Dash's sprite when racing her (something you might not notice when playing because your sight is focused on your character avoiding the clouds).

>>42449046
>>42449053
>stallion MC on mare
It's shit.

>>42454729
You're shit, faggot with no taste.

>>42454699
Definitely, it really holds up even after all this time.

>>42454729
>I like creatures in Equestria

>>42449024 (OP)
Big Brian SWEEP

>>42455290
Certainly one hell of a sweep

>>42454306
she must love that game

>>42456204
Hopefully not a bit too much if she's getting farther into the game.

>>42451452
The resolution of the game's graphics is actually 248x184, for some reason. Everything is upscaled to 496x368 in Flash, though. I've never managed to get Animanatee working myself, so I don't know if that's the resolution it exports at or if Pokehidden cropped everything slightly to allow for camera movement or something.

>>42456794
Why would you want to draw on a Nintendo DS? Is it just a cheap way to get something resembling a very barebones drawing tablet with screen?

>>42456938
I think that is exactly why Pokehidden was using a DS in the beginning, since he didn't have access to a tablet or even a computer for a while (going off of some really old Fur Affinity posts). The tutorial image I posted is from his old website and Tumblr, for anyone who doesn't recognize it.

I wanted to get Animanatee working just out of curiosity to see what the workflow was like, but it crashes on every single emulator I've tried and I don't have a flashcart.

>>42456980
Flashcards are cheap, about $10, but make sure to change the firmware to something open source because for over a decade now the chink software has a time bomb which bricks the cart after about 2-3 years so that they can sell you another flash card.

>>42456794
Does the DS borders crop it or no?

did you guys see the meteor shower tonight?

>>42449024 (OP)
Fuck off, you can't fucking fuck the great fucking Trixie!

>>42452484
Cave Story is quite good and it's free. Don't have enough free time?

>>42457679
NTA but it's a bit overhyped.

>>42457700
Overhyped as in you didn't like the gameplay, story or?

>>42452127
https://pokehidden.archive.hexstream.net/banned_from_equestria_daily/halloween.swf.html

>>42457824
Somehow this sort of thing still gives me the chills.

>>42457832
I don't know whats wrong with me but this is some of the hottest stuff ever

>>42457824
Is the glass part referencing something that happened?

>>42458218
pony.mov series
pinkie states multiple times that:
>"my daddy make me put glass in my vagina"
first at the end of shed.mov and it´s more of an actual plot point in party.mov, i recommend you watch it, it´s kinda fun, there´s a playlist on youtube

>>42457700
k

>>42457679
I just never got around to it, and now I hit the point where I only replay the same few games over and over. Playing something new is rare.

>>42458407
I could say the same for myself, I haven't played crypt of the necrodancer despite having it on my library but even then I still check it out and perhaps complete new games time to time. You got to just resist the urge to play the same games over and over and press play on something new.

He's still working on it, 20 more years.

>>42452484
Man, this song is so deeply emotional in the context of the game, I don't want to spoil it (and I can only remember vague details anyways) but it's kinda brutal. I will always love cave story and while its inclusion in bfed cheapens the song a little, it definitely was a kino pick on pokehidden's part.

>>42452586
cave story is kinda old school these days, but it still holds up as a really good platformer with a beautiful original story and style - it's the kind of thing that only comes from a passionate solo dev that loves what they do. It's worth playing for the story alone. I daresay it even has snowpity if you think of the mimiga as maremiga.

BUMP IT BUMP IT AAAAAAAHHHHHHH

>>42458701
You alright, buddy?

>>42457818
Overhyped as in it's an okay indie game, but there are so many better ones out there especially if you look at the non-free ones as well (not saying you should pay for them though - never pay for anything you can get for free).

>>42458701
Don't worry nonny, this thread will last till September.

>>42458726
>so many better one out there
With the same sort of gameplay like Cave Story?
Could you tell me?

https://youtu.be/RjYEVXzGCF8?si=YBQtdAJWkDeX2-MB

Isn't it strange how this picture features Octavia but she never appears in game?

>>42459398
I presume she's cut content sadly

>>42459398
She actually does appear in one of the More Bullshit Mode scenes. To unlock it, trigger the sex scene with Vinyl, then go back to her house and click on the window. After finishing the game, you can see the "Remixing Time" scene which has Octavia in it.

>>42459618
Thanks, never saw this one.

If it ever gets updated, the epilepsy should be toned down.

>>42458588
last update about pokehidden was 2 months go about something about his family taking care of him

>>42458588
>>42460029
He needs to add Cheerilee and Spitfire to complete the early season kino.

>>42460029
ah found it, hopefully he can get better because it's taking him so long.

>>42458588
>>42460231
I don't think there's gonna be another update to Banned from Equestria. Those posts are from 2014, so I assume that Tiara was talking about the now current and final version, which was released in 2015. He even made an April Fool's Day animation joking about a sequel a few years ago: https://inkbunny.net/s/2683318

>>42460297
fuck your way outta equestria. unf

>>42460297
Yeah I'm pretty sure he's done with BFED. On his old site there was a link "Will there be a BFED 2?" and it went to a page with a big rotating NO.

>>42460656
what a shame then

>>42460297
that april fools animation is kino though

>>42454306
I wouldn't be surprised if this happened in reality but without the vr stuff.

>>42449024 (OP)
I was exposed to this game when I was about 11 years old. I didn't understand a thing about sex back then but I stayed for the music and cute art. What's funny is that this game was actually hosted on a couple of sites that had flash games for kids. Guess nobody checked beyond it further than 1 minute in.

>>42461093
It's very funny.

>>42454429
and it's not even exclusive now that we can emulate BloodBanned From Equestria on PC
it is truly over for snoykeks

>>42454306
Here's the actual image if you want it

>>42461311
How could you not understand what sex was? I knew what it was when I was 9.

Have there been any other good pony games since this one?

I like the way Pokehidden says "Banneded from Equestria Daily"

>>42462071
I liked how he said "nuked" when his page (forgot where) got removed.

>>42462068
No

>>42461311
and that's how Anon learned about jacking off

>>42462068
Not as far as I can recall, sadly.

I wish the CMC had gotten a scene

>>42462131
My Tumblr got nyu-ked!

>>42462068
Tiarawhy is working on Pony Waifu Simulator, which is another clop/dating sim game and has a much larger scale than BfED. I played it for a bit and I wasn't that into it because it's mostly story and the clop scenes are human-on-pony anyway, but some others here might like it.

It's amazing that so many years have gone by and no one else has managed to make anything as charming and unique as BfED. Pretty much all the other Flash stuff from that era was hot garbage and just tried to emulate the show's art style with awful, high frame rate, tweened animation.

>>42462068
yes, but not lewd ones

>>42462268
So, the answer is no then.

>>42462198
I don't think BFED would be that popular if it had such a scene

>>42462198
He should've hid it through a specific personalized sequence like a Battlefield easter egg.

>>42462544
Nah just make it separate from the game and upload it anonymously so Pokehidden can claim he didn't make it

The challenge has been issued, announce everyone who is horny on /mlp/:

>>42462733

I have a question, did this game inspire friendship with benefits?

>>42462894
>anthro
Never have I been so disinterested in a game by just looking at it.

>>42462894
>>42462913
same but i lol'd

>>42462068
If we're talking lewd games specifically, Secret Horse Files 3 is pretty neat. I think the developer abandoned it to work on some kind of sequel, though

>>42462913
People want something human looking. Finding quadrupeds stimulating is ... I'm not sure what is honestly ... since ironically most South Americans here are into Equestria Girls that looked like infantile stick figures but not midget ponies, go figure. Maybe it's exclusively a South American thing to be into cheap badly produced versions of Monster High dolls.

>>42463173
anthro is the most normalfag shit and it's horrible, who cares what they want

>>42463173
It's because they more closely resemble real little girls than ponies dom South Americans are huge pedophiles.

>>42463173
>people want
We don't want that.

>>42462504
I think you've forgotten how little people gave a shit 13 years ago
Also there's already a Spike scene

>>42449183
>>42449166
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gyHPdTK5obY

>>42452484
play it nippa, it's free

>>42463970
I don't play "new" games anymore unless I really really want to
The newest game I beat was from 2 years ago

>>42464134
>pic
kek

>>42462544
>a Battlefield easter egg.
What? First time I hear about this, how do I get it?

>>42464134
What do if you see this at night? What comes after is almost guaranteed

>>42464765
hoof him in the ass

>>42464765
Fight or flight
https://youtu.be/phgSTsVJEfU

>>42464782
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fee0GYSTebg
This would be a better battle theme and a bit more fitting.

>>42464631
anon, "Battlefield Easter egg" is in Battlefield games

>>42465050
what's so special about battlefield that you needed it to add it beside "Easter Egg"?

>>42464996
But what if he has a boner
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCmUonp3qkU

>>42465172
>you
NTA
and Battlefield easter eggs are
>personalized
>insanely difficult
>give lame rewards lmao

>>42463970
>Did you buy Flash CS6?
>Why? are you working for Adobe?
Funniest shit ever.

>>42451108
What is this dog?

>>42465273
that's Paprika from Them's Fightin' Herds

>>42465392
It's a game? What it is like?

>>42465421
It's a 2D fighting game made after the devs got CC by hasbro after trying to make it MLP themed. I haven't played it but I presume it'd be like any 2D fighting game like Street Fighter 3 and so on. I've only played JJBA HFTF in the fighting game genre so I wouldn't really know much about it.

>>42465175
That'd be the second phase, haha.

>>42465648
What would be the third phase?

>>42464134
Who's that on the right?

>>42466824
my oc

>>42462068
There will be my filly throwing puzzle platformer that I totally won't abandon as soon as I remember I only have middling art skills and no programming skills

>>42464134
I don't even know what 'new' means here. Do you mean new to you?
cave story is from 2004.

>>42466956
ConfusedSanae.jpg

>>42466956
>Do you mean new to you?

>Suri fart scene is paywalled on Patreon
Seriously? He didn't do it with the Lucky Star SU intro.

>>42466956
He wasn't talking about Cave Story, Anon.

>>42467162
Then what game was he talking about? BFED? In terms of the fandom, it's not new either.

>>42449024 (OP)
BFED is absolutely packed with content, it's crazy.
Here's a secret easter egg nobody in the thread has mentioned yet. If you lose to Rainbow Dash's race multiple days in a row, you get different scenes.
If you lose all three days in a row, she says she's looking forward to seeing you tomorrow

>>42467194
He didn't say a game, just said that in general that the last time a game that recently came out has grabbed his attention and made him play it was 2 years ago.

>>42466977
What are you doing out of /jp/?

>>42467834
A special scene I only found out about recently is the one that plays if you click on Berry Punch's house on night three without collecting the wine bottle.

>>42467914
I'm ditching 2hu for mlp because of the sorry state the series is in.

>>42468048
Is 2hu really that deep in the gutter?

>>42468171
Yeah, the games have been shit since 2017, no new good music, stagnant manga in which nothing ever happens and introduces characters you're supposed to give a fuck about even though there was no mention of them beforehand. And recently, ZUN has gotten so lazy that he's using AI to generate graphics for the latest game, even though 2 years ago when he release Th19 he said this in the picrel.
I haven't been here long in MLP, since February as I dropped the series around the end of Season 3 in 2013, but coming here and rewatching the show was refreshing.
/jp/ is a hell hole with lack of moderation. Actual Touhou threads are dead, and the only ones that keep on going are Discord friend circles from /v/ and vtumor threads.
/mlp/ compared to /jp/ is Heaven.

>>42467914
I don't actually use /jp/, I was just referencing the Sanae retro consoles image.

>>42468182
I always thought /jp/ had the same strict moderation that /a/ had, huh

>>42468243
You'd wish.
Also on the 21st it's going to be 10 years since Alpha 1.5

>>42468316
Time is just too cruel...

>>42468182
>/jp/ is a hell hole with lack of moderation. Actual Touhou threads are dead
You could say the same about /mlp/ and actual pony threads

>>42468631
no shit

Derpy bit my gock

>>42469150
its ok Big Brian it's how disabled ponies talk to other ponies.

How do you unlock her?

>>42469992
Milky Way isn't in the main game. That pic is from the Milkmare Bitcrushed flash.

>>42469992
Complete the janitorial minigame 100 times

>>42470135
can confirm this but you had to play as that one janitor pony for some odd reason

>>42455045
I want to FUCK creatures in Equestria, not BE them, I'm not a furry.

>>42469992
Big Brian must love some good milk.

>>42470900
Back to the sharty with you.

>>42470900
I think he's saying that being a non-pony in Equestria makes you a creature
I'm not sure I agree with his point, but keeping humans and part-humans out of Equestria is something the show consistently did right

>>42470987
>but keeping humans and part-humans out of Equestria is something the show consistently did right
minotaurs

>>42471031
Had fully human bodies in mythology
And centaurs were human from the waist up, too
Same with harpies
Cyclopes were just giant one-eyed humans

For every half-human mythological creature in the show, they took out the actual human parts and just kept them human-shaped at most.

>>42470900
>not wanting to turn into a stallion and be bestowed with a massive 20-inch horsecock

>>42470900
we got a self-inserter over here

>>42461492
heh

Let's forget time. Wanna dance until night falls?

>>42471059
>it's not self inserting if you transform into yourself but pony
i keep seeing this
literally what is the logic

>>42449024 (OP)
kino game

>>42471612
Why was this post deleted?

>>42472418
likely a 4chan mod did a ip wipe so he must of made a shitty post on another thread to get such action taken against him

>>42472425
Yeah, he must HAVE. Fucking ESL tard.

>>42471608
Why couldn't you fuck the scarecrow?

>>42472656
it's not a pony, anon.

>>42472656
Risk of hay in your dickhole

>>42469992
I love milk.

>>42469992
MOOOOOOOODS

>>42469992
MY JOB ITS GONE

>>42471608
I don't know why, but this drawing makes me feel nostalgic. its so cute

>>42475041
I guess it's just really easy to get immersed in this world Pokehidden portrayed. I could replay it for hours.

>>42468182
That's grim as hell

>>42469992
>still up

>>42476466
janny has to see it with his own eyes to remove milky and he doesn't check threads because he's a lazy faggot who doesn't do his job

>>42476477
Janny should pick up the slack and do it then.

>>42476974
yeah right, he'll never do his job ever

>>42449024 (OP)
Why nopony else made a game like this?

>>42451014
I believe this is the most obscure BFED feature, if true, but I cannot replicate. Which specific pixel should I click in that context?

I know there is a "YOU FOUND 50 BITS" message in the Flash file, but I thought it was unused...

>>42477819
Should be where AJ is normally when the boulder is gone.

>>42477825
Obviously I tried that like hell, but it doesn't seem to work...
(And how the hell did you reply so fast, lol...)

>>42449024 (OP)
For me it's Big Mac, that shit awakened something in me as a kid.

>>42451156
Wasn't the sauce from an instructional video about dealing with retarded children?

>>42451230
> You can't stop it without restarting the game though so you'll lose all progress.

Wrong, fortunately!

You can just right click and click "Play" again to continue playing.

>>42477846
Yes, it's linked from the video's description on YouTube.

>>42477836
Maybe he took it out of a later version?

>>42477819
It works randomly. Most consistent was entering the area where AJ sits, back to the farm, then back to it and 50 bits should spawn.

If you want to make a game like this, should your learn Flash in 2025? Or there are better tools around now?

>>42478327
Definitely not, Flash was likely used for portability sake and lack of engines back then. Something like Ren'py would be good enough I believe, but not exactly like this game. I bet you could do it in Unity or something else, but the game will be bigger in size of course.

>>42478411
Would something like GameMaker Engine be good for 2D nowadays without going to shitnity?

>>42478420
I think so, it's versatile.

>>42477939
HOLY SHIT IT WORKED!!!

>>42478327
godot is neat if you know how to use it
also gamemaker if your last name is Fox

>>42478411
Flash had a lot of games because everyone was using it, it was everywhere and animators didnt need to know how to code to use it, although some actually learned actionscript for fun

>>42479153
I remember people complaining about doing stuff in flash being a pain in the ass

>>42479162
Wouldn't any game engine be a pain in the ass with all the stuff you have to do to make a game?

>>42479162
I recall a friend that used flash explaining it to me as the perfect hybrid of programming and animation software that made people from both disciplines have to learn enough of the other to use it well, and naturally not everyone that's good at one was going to be as good at the other

>>42477840
>big mac
fag

>>42480406
A homosexual is not someone who finds other homosexuals attractive, but it's someone, who upon seeing a stallion, immediately wants to befriend him.

>>42480597
Nah I just wanna get fucked in the ass by Big Mac, but I'd totally become bros with him afterwards.

>>42480614
faggot

What laptop is this?

>>42481550
is that actually real

>>42481550
it's a photoshopped one

>>42481550
Have you ever seen anyone playing BFED publicly?

>>42482421
we played it at school about 10 years ago,

>>42449038
What's to sue for anyway though? This game was never profitable nor could be mistaken for something official due to the artstyle.

>>42482444
Really? Did a teacher or another student saw what you were playing (I presume with someone else with the "we".) How did they react?

>>42482467
Most of Banned from Equestria looks deceptively SFW, especially if you're bad at it...

>>42482467
No one really reacted, we were around 14 back then, the classroom had like 15 computers, and it was just a day when we were playing games online. By we I mean myself and two other guys. I wonder what they're up to nowadays.
>>42482527
beat me to it

>>42482421
I got someone to play it in school once about 11 years ago and the librarian snuck up behind us during the Rainbow Dash racing minigame. I think we got kicked out of the library after that, but thankfully nothing NSFW was on-screen when we got caught. I also remember gathering together with a bunch of guys to watch someone play it at another library around the same time.

>>42477819
Ah, thank you so much, kind Anon!! I got it to work after all, this is such a profoundly useful trick!!

I made a video to help spread awareness of the fact that the trees bucking sequence is no longer required to get to the later parts of the game, THANKS TO YOU!!

I credited you in the video's description.
You are now a part of history! :)

https://hexstream.link/bfed/trick

>>42482718
I think it might have been discovered by some speedrunners. There were a few uploads by some Chinese guy on derpibooru, although I don't remember whether he used that method at all or not.

>>42482718
Hum, and here is a direct link to the YouTube video for embedding, since the redirect apparently prevents that...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3b5axrPQac

>>42482725
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_A3drDUn6mg
kek nice video

>>42482763
Yeah when Pokéhidden showed me that I was like... "Wut?" But it has grown on me...

>>42482813
pokehidden has definitely made something on me grow many a time that's for sure

>>42478420
Unity is the Game Maker of 3D games. Why the fuck would you ever use Game Maker? That shit makes Final Fantasy and Zelda tier games require 4GB of RAM and a quad core processor AND a GTX 750 TI GPU in order to run efficiently.

>>42482830
>3D
Anon asked if someone wanted to make a game like BFED then it would be 2D. Christ sake.

>>42482825
LOL!! Same.

>>42482825
Certainly for all of us.

>>42482825
lol'd

>>42481550
>me waiting on my flight to Mare Fair

>>42481550
This makes me really really want to play BFED next time I travel somewhere, lol

>>42484139
do it for the laughs

Today marks 10 years since 1.5 release. Say something nice about it.

>>42449024 (OP)
Wasn't there a guy making BFEQD2 on the board until last year? Did he disappear?

>>42484667
People will still be playing BFED 100 years from now!!

It will be ported to all suitable platforms (most notably HTML 5), in many cases with important quality of life improvements (like autosave), and will feature a vibrant modding community, with at least one full-featured open-source engine.

This is only the beginning! All hail Pokéhidden!!

>>42484787
This sort of project is nearly impossible to build without proper infrastructure.

>>42484787
>>42484810
besides what can you even add to make this remotely more interesting? Starlight Glimmer, Maud and a few background mares aside, this little game is the perfect package of all MLP had to offer in its peak.

>>42484844
It could not be ptfgshit for one thing

>>42484877
fuck you chaser

>>42484877
>being this obsessed and mad over the fact the protagonist is a pony
fuck off faggot

>>42484880
>>42484926
Dial 8

>42485341
>proving my point you're this obsessed AND mad
Pony protagonist is best. Now fuck off faggot.

>>42484667
It should get a sequel

>>42484667
It's the only porn/clop game I've played with genuine SOVL

>>42484667
>10 years
Happy birthday and cheers to you, BFED

I've never actually beaten BFED because I always stop playing after I cum just like with every other porn game.

>>42485921
>he cums before all three days are up
Quickshot?

>>42486038
It only takes like 3 scenes tops for me to cum. If I'm in a real good mood just the derpy scene is enough.

>>42485921
I'm sure you can have some restraint to beat the game fully and then crank it out after that

>>42485921
Great motivation to implement the autosave feature as part of the HTML5 port, thanks!!

>>42485921
Time to become the first BFED speedrunner.

>>42484667
10 years of kino, love it!

I guess another thing that could be added was a
>rape
scene with Celestia right after you beat Luna. It always frustrated me how Celestia is unfuckable

>>42487120
I always thought Twilight's experiment should stabilize your transformation enough that Celestia couldn't detect you if you can get to her, leading to a different scene of some sort.

>>42487131
Good idea.

BFED wouldn't work today because it would end up like this.

>>42487644
How? I'd imagine if BFED was made more recently then It would be more different as Majora's Mask grows even more older that the 3 day gimmick wouldn't be considered

>>42487528
Thanks, Dave

>>42484667
10 YEARS?! Fuck, the time is moving to fast!

What a horrible night to have a curse.

>>42487932
I mean how else are you supposed to spend 3 days, Trixie?

>>42487932
good reaction image

Would be cool if a successor had a character creator, although it might limit the kinds of animations you can do. Even something as simple as color swapping and optional wings/horn.

>>42488053
One game that comes to mind with multiple sex scenes and character customization is MNF Club.

>>42484810
What "infrastructure" you fucking nigger? BFED was made by a single guy? You just need a single guy to sit down "code" as in download something off github that works as a point and click adventure game and draw a some pictures. This is something that a single mildly dedicated person can make in a few weeks to a few months the latest. And now, within a literal decade no one has done this, despite the constant gaggles of retards forming and everyone trying to be the "ideas guy" and coming up with retarded scope creep scenarios.

>>42488076
Scope creep only happens after a project starts

>>42488076
Then do it by the end of the year and prove us all wrong.

>>42488083
Sure. I work for about 70 dollars per hour, if you can afford it. If not, too fucking bad, because the company I work can. And you remain still just as wrong.

>>42488079
Wrong. It happens right from the retarded daydreaming. When the "I wanna make a video game!" faggots congregate in a discord and cant even decide what they want to make, so they just keep piling on ideas how they need MOAR.

>>42488108
NTA but I think you found the crux of the problem
Most of the people with the dedication to actually work on something like this consistently, will generally have actual full-time jobs instead

>>42488115
You'd need a single guy able to draw some basic pixel art, animate and "code" a point and click flash game. This does not need exception skill or "dedication". Speaks volumes about how much of an inept fuckup this community of coomers around BFED is. During all this ten years it did not release a single fan animation or a fan patch of extra content or anything, and all the decent fanart to it were drawn by a single guy.

>>42488150
You did nothing either, so shut the fuck up, little retard.

>>42488150
What "community"? it's just people who remember it fondly. People do style emulations because it's a fun callback, not because there's some kind of community around the game itself.

>>42488108
beautiful projections

>>42488162
Correct. I'm not going anything for free.

>>42488176
You missed the literal DOZENS of groups that formed during the years trying to make sequel to BFED?

>>42488229
You don't do anything at all, little retard.

stop bickering over nothing jesus christ

>>42488247
Correct, I don't do anything at all for you.

>>42488325
>>42488229
You don't even take the trash out for yourself and cook for yourself. Anymore retarded lies?
I saw your so-called group and what you "did" 500 replies of nothing but bumps while asking for somebody to spoonfeed you and even better: you didn't know what you wanted.

>>42488391
Schizo meltdown.

You coomers had a literal DECADE to make a sequel, yet here you are, daydreaming about it and seething when called out,

What on earth is going on in here

>>42488937
Man, I don't know. I just wanna talk about the funny poni sex game.

>>42488937
rage bait and derailing

>>42488076
What you're missing is that it is a goddamn MIRACLE that BFED (especially 1.5) happened at all, and indeed it nearly didn't happen.

Pokéhidden nearly gave up when his tumblr got nuked for no fucking reason (per his live video), but fortunately he pressed on and actually finished the damn thing. I simply cannot BELIEVE the truly legendary overall quality of this game, it's not perfect but it's still completely WORLD-CLASS and one of the best things EVER to exist!!

I did say this sort of project is "nearly" impossible to do without proper infrastructure, which is indeed the case. Pokéhidden succeeded because he's a goddamn GENIUS!!

I am planning to make a great open-source web-based flash decompiler/debugger (forget JPEXS) which should for instance make it MUCH easier to port any flash game (or other content) to HTML5. That's a MUCH saner approach than just going off the deep end and predictably drowning.

>>42489360
What's the point of porting Flash stuff to HTML5 when Ruffle exists and works in the browser? Modern web standards are infinitely more complex than Flash and things keep changing and breaking over time. HTML5 is a total dead end for media preservation.

>>42489360
It sounds like you don't understand game development.

>>42489514
Ruffle is great for preserving old stuff as-is, but if you want to make any non-trivial modifications or enhancements (particularly including quality of life enhancements or more general modding), you'll want to port over to more modern platforms.

>>42489525
I don't claim to understand game development, but I do profoundly understand programming.

>>42489732
Oh, good point. It's too bad that there's no modern replacement for Flash Professional.

>>42489360
What a coincidence, i've been creating the will to port a flash game to html5 as well. Actually, to openfl (which imitates the flash api, btw), so it's a sdl (win, linux) and html5 port as well and the haxe foundation actually had a tool to convert actionscript 3 to haxe but it's discontinued ( https://github.com/HaxeFoundation/as3hx). The tool is still great for a headstart but i'm gonna need to do the casting and some other stuff manually and review if there's any different behavior to the original game, while creating helpers to automatize the rest of the conversion

>>42489747
if you do know programming than it should be simple enough to look and see how to replicate said features to then try to shift thing arounds to make something anew

>>42489360
Its a fucking flash game you bozo, what "infrastructure" you need? Want me to lend my 2007 beigebox running Windows XP? Cause you don't need more.

>>42490229
Retards always want to reinvent the wheel, when entire code libraries exist online for free. They just want the feeling of mucking around, that feeling of "progress", of working towards somewhere, when they actually just digging and filling back holes. On some level, they are just scared of shipping a finished product and being judged on its merits, so they stay in eternal alpha or more accurately, eternal idea guy phase.

>>42488112
Sounds like you speak from experience.

>>42488555
All I hear is a little baby crying he never got a sequel to his favorite porn game. Why don't you make it, you little bitch boy? "I get paid to do work!" Yeah, so do we, little nigglet. Either put up or shut up.

>>42490392
Indeed, as a project manager I have a lot of experience with retards. You have been idea guying nonstop for ten years by now and forming gay discord groups over making a sequel to a FLASH GAME. You are worse than the average retard, you are special retards.

>>42490406
Schizo meltdown. Projecting will not work either.

>>42490448
Cry more baby boy

Ignoring everything above this reply, you did beat the game and experience every ending. Right?

>>42490569
I thought I saw everything this game has in it, then I found something new about it, repeat eight or so times. So. I don't know.

>>42490569
I got all scenes except the Luna one. Never managed to complete that minigame and I was tired of running through the entire game again and again just to try.

>>42487932
kek that's true for /mlp/

>>42490818
It's fairly simple. Spam click yourself, click on her once, then spam click yourself. Time it right with when she summons projectiles as you'll need some shield to protect yourself.
Once her shield is down, you can spam click her if you feel lucky. Do not spam click her when her shield is still in tact, because it'll hurt you.

>>42490508
Melty.

Schizos REALLY hate getting called out like this.

>>42490374
There are always 2 types of complexity in any project: inherent (unavoidable) complexity and accidental (avoidable) complexity.

If you don't have proper infrastructure, then you'll inherently have a lot of accidental complexity, which will make everything harder for no reason.

The irony is lamenting that people don't have enough discipline while failing to recognize that having the discipline to create the proper infrastructure would drastically lower the overall amount of discipline required to successfully complete and otherwise manage projects.

TL;DR: Increasing efficiency through infrastructure translates into better results with less work, which is much easier than increasing will and/or discipline, or more colloquially "being less lazy".

>>42491252
Its a fucking flash game, retard. There is no "complexity". Its not a "project". Its something you make on your own over a weekend or two.

You are just a fucking loser trying to come up with excuses

>>42491403
>Its something you make on your own over a weekend or two.
You have lost basic touch with reality.

>>42491411
Its a fucking flash game. Not a project. I made flash game over a weekend when I was 16. People make flash games in one sitting during game jams. Ten years wasn't enough for you gooners to make one.

>>42491252
YOU ARE BOILING AN EGG. YOU INCOMPETENT BUFFOON.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mw-5pQBbZvA

>>42491425
YOU CAN'T EVEN DESIGN A PEN & PAPER GAME YOU DONKEY. YOU MULE.
DON'T PUT THE PAPER CART IN FRONT OF THE PAPER HORSE.

>>42491425
Making something worthless and forgettable in a weekend is certainly easy, and if you're happy living the rest of your life with a toddler's mentality, more power to you I guess.

>>42489937
Nobody cares nigger

>>42489937
Interesting, I'll be looking forward to see what you make.

>>42491443
Don't project your own failure on others.

>>42491455
You had a decade to create something so easy that it takes a weekend. No amount of coping will change that.

>>42491550
I create useful stuff regularly, and it usually takes months, if not years. (Sometimes a week or less if I'm lucky, but that's rare.)

You would do well to scale back your assumptions based on literally NOTHING, but hey, it's not like there's any real form of accountability here.

I'm the man in the arena.
Enjoy your seat in the peanut gallery.

>>42491577
You sound like a loser coping, unable to even make a flash game.

>>42491637
Most people are unable to do most things.

You are unable to contribute meaningfully or shut the fuck up, for instance.

>>42491647
Ten years. No sequel to a flash game. No matter how much you seethe, whine and cope, this remains true.

How are you people still arguing over this? The thing that takes so much time and skill when making a game like BFED is all the drawings and animations, not writing the code and putting it all together. The platform it's made on hardly matters because the code is going to be super simple regardless.

>>42491657
Wow, truly life-changing insights here! I commend you.

>>42491665
> putting it all together
In many instances it's precisely the "putting it all together" part that will make or break the project. If you come unprepared you will pay the price, typically by having wasted your time flailing around for nothing to show for it except the "experience" of what not to do next time.

Talk about the game or the characters for Christs sake.

>>42491681
You are welcome.

>>42491665
Ten years weren't enough to draw some pixel art. Maybe in another decade.

One of my favorite childhood flash games, brings back good times

>>42449024 (OP)
The best pone game i've seen yet

Here you go, frens:

>42492711
what does this have to do with the BFED game in question

>>42493088
It's just some spammer, don't mind him.

>>42491403
>Its something you make on your own over a weekend or two.
Well then why are you complaining? Get to it, if you'll be done in a few days.

Oh, what's that? You want someone ELSE to do it? Well, guess there's no other option left for you than to QQ about it then.

>>42493893
How many times do I have to spell out to you retarded autistic fucks that I don't work for free? Put cash on the table and there will be many takers to make BFED2. I have no intention of making it for you. Especially when I just got my Cessna and my free time could be spent on you know, flying. The fact remains that you are still busy idea guying for a decade over a a flash game, and getting ZERO work done. How many times you have made entire discords of dozens of idea guys throwing ideas around and ended up making nothing? If you sat down from scratch with zero coding or drawing knowledge, and just spent a day improving you could have made something within a year or two. It boggles the mind how incompetent you are.

This guy is hilarious

>>42465172
Battlefield has a long history of extremely autistic, drawn-out, and highly-specific easter eggs.

>>42493988
Ahh ok.

>>42449038
Pony game developers should stop showing their game in development off if they want to release it.

>>42494881
I've been thinking this for a while. If developers would just finish a fangame before announcing it to the broader public and releasing it, then C&Ds probably wouldn't be very effective and stopping the files from being spread is way harder than just sending a scary letter and nipping the game in the bud.

>>42494901
C&Ds actually do nothing, there are pony fangames sold on steam right now. This is just another excuse. You have to be insane to assume Hasbro would sue some random on the internet for making a fangame and distributing it, especially if its a porn game,

>42493936
nonny needs his drug money

>>42494930
Nintendo is no stranger to taking down a Mario porn game (Peach's Untold Tale) back in 2018.
Hasbro did DMCA a few games in the early days, mainly because they featured canon characters I think. The pony games on Steam don't have them.

>>42493936
>How many times do I have to spell out to you retarded autistic fucks that I don't work for free? Put cash on the table and there will be many takers to make BFED2.
How much do you want, just for background?
I am offering 2$ CAD.

>>42494901
>>42494930
I'm not sure why anyone ever complies with nonsensical C&D's, especially in the case of obviously brand-enhancing non-profit fan projects. And brand-clashing projects benefit from the implicit threat of a Streisand effect.

In almost all cases, the cost in lost reputation to the issuing companies of actually carrying out the threat and suing to completion for no reason would obviously cost at least several millions of dollars in lost reputation, possibly up to tens or even hundreds of millions of dollars in the worst cases.

Button's Adventures and Fighting is Magic, I'm looking at you. We lost that world-class shit for NOTHING.

>>42495226
>And brand-clashing projects benefit from the implicit threat of a Streisand effect.
Probably why BFED never got a C&D, I should add...

>>42449024 (OP)
lots of charm this game has

>>42495226
That is because and have no idea why companies send out C&D letters. They don't really give a shit if you comply or not, it is for legal reasons, so they could prove before court if it gets there for whatever reason that they did their part to protect their copyright and it was not just randomly forgotten but STOLEN away, proving culpability on the part of the C&D'd project, just by continuing, Most of the time they have no intention of actually suing, they are just reserving the right with a simple C&D and be done with it.

>>42494987
Its like, its a completely different corporate entry in a different country and different laws and different corporate policy and different industry and everything

>>42495195
Posted already before. I get paid 70 dollars per hour at work and spending my free time flying my plane now. These are what you are having to compete with. Maybe should have spent some parts of the last decade learning how to draw or something.

>>42495419
indeed

>>42495732
>That is because and have no idea why companies send out C&D letters. [...]

Makes sense, but there is still the question of why anyone EVER complies with that shit.

"Culpability" or even liability is meaningless if actually enforcing it would be financial suicide in terms of lost reputation.

Same thing as terrorism, really. Complying with terrorism demands automatically means more terrorism, and systematically refusing to comply with terrorism automatically means less terrorism.

Wipe your ass with nonsense C&Ds, destroy terrorism. They can't bankrupt all of us, and they probably won't even bankrupt ONE of us if it possibly means losing millions of dollars worth of reputation and goodwill.

And even if it somehow happened, we could make an EXAMPLE of that company and effectively bail out the would-be martyr as a hero, and the C&D tactic would be conveniently destroyed forever.

TL;DR: Having a fucking spine is always the best solution.

>>42493796
ahh ok

>>42481550
literally me

>>42495195
9USD recorded hour

>>42495732
>I get paid 70 dollars per hour at work and spending my free time flying my plane now.

This game never stops on giving.
If you tell Twilight you're busy, she won't mention that she had lost the book. You can enter her house and learn the spells, but once you go over to Trixie, she also does not mention anything about you looking at the book with curiosity.

>>42496929
Real?

>>42497118
Are you that much of a loser that you cannot conceptualize others being one?

>>42496434
Because if you don't comply and your project gets unexpectedly successful or popular or profitable you WILL get sued and the amount of money it costs to bankrupt a small company or a fan project with lawyer fees is meaninglessly trivial to Hasbro. They could bankrupt hundreds of fan projects, and it would be still more profitable than risking losing the IP by not defending it. There is no "goodwill" to lose either, because internet drama does not affect their toy sales, no matter what autismos think.

>>42449183
Pokehiddens life has always been a nightmare, he used to be made fun of on tumblr for being a constant whiner, and wasn't he homeless before?

>>42497488
Does anyone have a timeline or recap of Pokehidden's life so far?

>>42497488
>>42497676
From interview it seemed like his parents were rich, having traveled around the world. Assuming he's in his 30's now, I wonder if anything's different.

>>42497676
Woooo, parasocial time! I'd suggest reading through his old Fur Affinity journals and Tumblr posts:
https://web.archive.org/web/20150401134131/http://www.furaffinity.net/journals/pokehidden/
https://web.archive.org/web/20120515000000*/pokehidden.tumblr.com

Each individual FA journal post has been saved by the Archive, so you can even read all the comments. More Tumblr posts can be found by searching for pages further back (pokehidden.tumblr.com/page/2, etc.). There are snapshots of a whole bunch of pages, up to like 14 or 15 if I remember correctly.

>>42497294
Haha, nice! I'm STILL learning stuff about this game! Incredible.

Although, this really has to do with if Twilight mentioned the book to you or not. Even if you say you're busy, if you talk to her after she will still mention the book and Trixie will do the freak out thing.

>>42497488
>constant whiner
Doubtful, actually I would say he tends to understate his troubles. Source?

>>42497118
I don't know what's funnier: his pathetic begging for someone to make a sequel for him for free, or the fact he seriously believes anyone here buys his "I actually fly a plane and have a job with a six-figure salary" bullshit.

>>42497766
Which interview?

(One particular "Pokéhidden interview" I saw on YouTube seemed FAKE AS FUCK, for instance...)

>>42498162
What's funniest is he thinks one can do anything worthwhile and notable in a weekend (it could happen but it's like winning the lottery) and that building infrastructure is a waste of time.

With that kind of attitude, we would literally still be living in caves. And I refuse to believe anyone who doesn't understand the most basic concepts somehow ends up with a very fulfilling and enviable life.

what does this have to do with Banned From Equestria Daily?

>>42498209
>And I refuse to believe anyone who doesn't understand the most basic concepts somehow ends up with a very fulfilling and enviable life.
You'd be surprised, sadly.

>>42498209
What "infrastructure" a flash game needs you fucking retard?

>>42498212
nothing it seems

>>42498209
did you ever try to make a flash game? you make it in flash, and you don't need to be an actionscript magician. In fact, flash makes it super simple so most animators have tried making a few games in the 2000s. Any infrastructure came from consecutive games if there were any. Going a bit off-topic, the thing is that if you don't dive headfirst you will probably never leave the planning stage and this has been like this for most things. You pick something and improve as you go, planning or no planning. Doom and Quake algorithms came from someone working on the engine and improve it, getting ideas from articles and whatnot, for example. Anyway anon, good luck with your html5 ports. If you start it, you're already ahead of most, but it takes some good will to finish a project.

>>42498347

>>42491252

>>42449024 (OP)
I wonder if there are still new people finding BFED and playing it today.

>>42498515
Yes
t. watched MLP this year after getting ponypilled by seeing cute mares on 4chan index page

>>42498522
It's weird seeing newfags newer than me but I guess two years of being in the fandom leaves plenty of time for it to happen.

>>42498522
Based!

>>42498383
He is probably one of those idea guy retards who keeps daydreaming about his project, thinking about it all day, designing it out to the slightest details, but never actually sits down to make it, so he has to blame external factors for his own laziness.

>>42498481
What "infrastructure" a flash game needs you fucking retard?

>>42498522
>>42498545
>All these young whippersnappers discovering pony
I remember when Discovery Family was still called The Hub

>>42498515
hexstream.net got 40k+ visits for BFED in the past 30 days, so I would guess A LOT of people are still discovering the game...

>>42498847
I can't fix you, Toddler Dude.

>>42498857
I remember the hub from when I was a kid but I don't remember watching any of the shows that it had. My favorite channel was Jetix because I wanted to watch Kirby.

>>42498863
40k+?! Damn, that's waay more than I expected.

>>42498876
What "infrastructure" a flash game needs you fucking retard?

>>42499012
An internet connection.

>>42499012
I can't fix you, Toddler Dude.

>>42499012
It's a secret. Anyone who finds out about the Flash infrastructure gets taken away by the Adobe Illuminati.

>>42498898
Does this mp4 imply that Big Brian/red has been stuck in the 3 day loop for 50 years?

>>42499222
I think it's implied that Trixie is long dead, so probably not.

Also, winter. (Could theoretically be a faraway location, but probably not.)

Also, weather. (It's always nice weather during the 3 days.)

>>42499222
Samurai Jack reference, so instead of three days dude got stuck there for 50 years straight

>>42498898
Sorry, I was hasty and made a stupid mistake. I added the ~20k visits for the landing page with the ~20k visits for the game page for a total of 40k+, but of course there must be a lot of overlap in those visits, so the most conservative, worst-case estimate would be 20k+.

It didn't help that Cloudflare somehow counts same-subdomain referrals as "direct visits" without a referrer...

Overall the stats on Cloudflare free plans are a bit anemic, and I haven't yet bothered with (re-)installing Google Analytics, but I'm not that fond of that asynchronous javascript shit...

Anyway, 20k+ is still a lot more than anyone could reasonably expect I think, but I do profoundly apologize for the initial figure. It's the first time I externally share stats from that section of the dashboard, but I wanted to make sure I capture BFED-specific stats only.

>>42499376
its ok anon I forgive you

>>42499388
Thank you!! :)

So let's say I have the programmers, graphics artists and musicians to make BFED2 ... personally I hate the art style since it looks nothing like G4's faces and I'm tired of pixel shit in my porn, I personally would prefer a button to switch between art style A & art style B, but ah well if you faggots really want it....

Anyway the thing is I want to prove how incompetent /mlp/ is at discussion, ideas, layout, maps, level design, creativity, imagination. Design stuff in general.
------I want you faggots to ideafag a complete game like it's a pen and paper boardgame and just come up with shit you'd normally use to make-believe a game like toys, google images, maps that don't quite fit equestria, etc.

and I'll have my programmer, graphics, audiofags do their magic, but if you fags can't even "Lol I want a game" Ok what kinda game? "Uhhhhh...BFED2" can you narrow it down and work with me? "Uhhhhh..." so yeah my team will need a little more than "Make gud game" we don't want executive producers know nothings who go "Bake me a cake ..." WHAT KIND OF CAKE YOU RETARD? SPECIFICATIONS. How much sugar do you want in it?

>>42499633
Honestly most sequels are SHIT, and I don't see why we should expect anything different from a BFED sequel, especially given how stratospherically high the original placed the bar. I certainly don't expect a fucking "Terminator 2".

The most straightforward approach I can think of is to port BFED to HTML5, which would already be very valuable since we can add modern features like autosave and add easy modding features, and then we can possibly use the resulting game engine to make similar games, possibly including (possibly crappy but could still be fun and nostalgic) sequels...

Think for instance of those sorts of "Multiple Animator Projects" we could do by just reanimating the original game's scenes with various artists (graphics and voice acting), adding new scenes (getting Celestia without being detected thanks to Twilight's experiment), etc...

Of course, more generally, a great open-source web-based Flash decompiler/debugger/recompiler would be really great to help port and enhance the trillions of legacy Flash games...

>>42498522
>this year
oh god im getting old, can't wait to wake up in a old people's home

>>42499734
anon... this is the old people's home

>>42499345
>50 years of plapping mares
My god

>>42499633
>personally I hate the art style
Already starting off on the wrong foot.

Okay, but what's the lore reason for Rarity being the only pony that won't have sex with you after one 5 minute conversation?

>>42499999
>quints
i see no issue plapping mares for 50 years

>>42500003
She just got done fucking another random stallion, like she does every day.

>>42500003
You're ugly.

>>42500003
I'm pretty sure Pokehidden just figured she'd be a mare of taste.

>>42500003
It'd be boring. More characters should take steps to get sex with but I guess currently it's balanced well.

>>42500067
Why are you talking about yourself like that

>>42499665
>add modern features like autosave and add easy modding features
but both these things can be implemented in flash. The only reason to port it to html5 is to get it to run on canvas2d and remove the requirement for flash/ruffle. Performance, controller, whatever improvements html5 could have over flash doesn't apply for a game this simple. Also i don't think you really need to plan this shit at all, it shouldnt be hard to port it to html5. There's no animation tweening it's just frames and the code shouldn't be large

>>42500120
I feel like it's a good balance. The Rarity route makes you do some interesting routing in ManeSix% but if half of them had a proper quest it'd probably be annoying.

>>42499999
checked and he must have a shit ton of foals to continue his legacy

>>42500003
>>42500070
>>42500278
>Twilight
You need to buy the ticket for Spike then come at night as pegasus.
>Fluttershy
You need to click a specific spot on the screen and then be able to talk your way through her.
>Rainbow Dash
You need to beat her in a race.
>Pinkie Pie
You need to bring her a ball and have Mrs. Cake wrap it up for you.
>Applejack
You need to destroy the rock and then buck some trees. You get to say no.
>Rarity
You need to see her at the boutique, ask for sex, then ask if you can help her. Learn the cutting spell, then you need to go through Twilight, and meet up with Spike in his cardboard box near the boutique, cut the glass and then you finally get to watch him go at it with her.
>Derpy
Click on the mail box a few times.
>Vinyl
Click on the Vinyl on her door.
>Chrysalis
Labyrinth, but it's just 2x right, 1 left until you get to Zecora's hut.
>Zecora
Same as above but drink water and click on the cupboard.
>Celestia
Fly to Canterlot
>Trixie
Learn Twilight's spells, eat a muffin if you don't want to eat your own spunk.
>Trixie 2
You get anal devastation
>Luna
Have lots of sex, beat her in a fight.
>The Twins
They don't count. Even if you get a lot of money and pay for sex, you will get masturbation ending if you won't fuck anypony else, probably because their encounter does not progress time.
I feel like I might be forgetting somepony, but hopefully that narrows it all down. I skipped on encounters for more bullshit mode.

>>42500311
>>Applejack
>You need to destroy the rock and then buck some trees. You get to say no.

>You get to say no.
Clicklet spotted

>>42500311
Also worth adding that you get more scenes if you take the book from Trixie and return it to Twilight. That's not relevant for beating the game but it is a little mini-quest.

When do these tracks play?

>>42500344
Top one is during an extra scene where Pinkie has your foal. Bottom one is during the all M6 route I believe.

>>42494881
Why do devs even show a little glimpse of it anyway? Is having a ego boost more wanted than releasing a game?

>>42500538
Usually it's just simply wanting to show that they're working on something and making progress with it to gain support for it, if even just vocal support. A lot do need to learn that the bigger the ip they're working with the lowe profile they need to keep, unless it's a sonic fangame

>>42500538
Unironically, to these people yes. And the stupidity is they could do it as long as they stayed pseudonymous. If Hasjew knows nothing about you but your online nickname, what can they do? Yeah they can tell a website owner to take down your page, but it's meaningless because you can just upload it to some place that doesn't care or ultimately even just to an onion domain if needed. The problem is these people usually want $$$$$ and crypto donations don't bring you much because many people don't know how to use it, so they resort to Paymetons and such. And then they can get you.

>>42500677
>they want money for making a game that they don't own the IP to
Jeez, and I also bet that they would suddenly slow down development so they could extract more money if patreon and the sorts

>>42500677
>And the stupidity is they could do it as long as they stayed pseudonymous. If Hasjew knows nothing about you but your online nickname, what can they do?
Almost nobody has good opsec (too complicated and annoying, the traditional tradeoff between security and convenience), meaning any legal discovery process would automatically and trivially expose your real identity.

>>42494881
>>42500538
If Pokéhidden hadn't released BFED in stages with the alphas, he would almost certainly never have finished the game, probably he literally wouldn't even have come close. We might never even have heard about it.

>>42497406
I think there should be no problem even if you get very popular, as long as you do things BY THE BOOK in terms of fair use, NO REVENUES especially.

> risking losing the IP by not defending it

Doesn't that mostly apply to trademarks?

Also, copyright should honestly not even apply in the case of stuff that is obviously unrelated to the brand, such as NSFW MLP stuff since Hasbro is obviously a family-friendly company, so you obviously don't compete with them with NSFW stuff, and they obviously don't endorse that shit even if they did nothing to stop you.

Also also, copyright is a SCAM and should be completely abolished. BASIC INCOME is all we really need to ensure funding of the arts and all the other good stuff. Capitalism can still exist as a nice add-on, but our modern slavery system sucks too much shit.

>>42501059
The way BFED handles the foal stuff is 10/10, no notes.

>>42501131
True.

>>42501131
I agree. The way how Sweetie Belle seduced Big Brian like the slut she is felt very in character for her.

>>42459398
And where does that brown stallion appear? The one next to Mrs. Cake

>>42501169
horrible scaling

>>42487932
kek

>>42501175
Train station.

>>42501249
Shit, you're right.
I remember some old PC games having some promotional renders which never were part of the game which was annoying me as fuck.

>>42501254
+1000

>>42501254
I presume said renders not in game was scrapped content they couldn't be arsed to remove from said promotional art

>>42449038
even if they could sue, would they? all that would do is bring public exposure to it, putting their brand in jeopardy. and all that for the zero pesos the lawsuit would manage to squeeze out of the greasy spic? artists don't have money silly hasbro

>>42501499
Exactly, I have no idea why anyone EVER complies with threats of lawsuits that will obviously NEVER materialize.

>>42486062
Are you 12 or something?? How do you cum so fast??

>>42500918
How? If you literally use a nickname for your project that you do not use anywhere else you'd have to be a complete brainlet to still get exposed. More importantly, you're dealing with a company here, not law enforcement, so they can't just act on a hunch or spotty information.

>>42500945
>Doesn't that mostly apply to trademarks?
It does, but the character names are trademarked. It's why anthro comics like Hoofbeat get away with it by calling the characters Twibright and Applesack. You could probably also even get away with it in show style as long as you keep the cutie mark out (the defining aspect of the Hasbro pony design).

>>42501932
>If you literally use a nickname for your project that you do not use anywhere else you'd have to be a complete brainlet to still get exposed.
No, you still get easily exposed by default unless you consistently take somewhat complicated and inconvenient precautions since the start and for years and basically never make mistakes. Good luck! You're probably shit out of luck before you even begin thinking about these things correctly, if you ever even make it that far.

> More importantly, you're dealing with a company here, not law enforcement, so they can't just act on a hunch or spotty information.

That's not how that works, a company can typically easily obtain your identity just by suing you and then the legal "discovery" process will probably easily find your identity and all other relevant info. The court will compel any relevant companies such as your ISP to reveal all relevant info. They will easily find out your identity in almost all cases.

Sure you can try to hide your real IP through various means but there will typically be n+1 ways they can identify you regardless. You just need to slip up ONCE and you're DONE.

(That's why my typical approach is to hide NOTHING, it's much more convenient and you don't get a stupid false sense of security where there is none almost no matter what you do.)

>>42498160
Late reply but heres picrel as an example, there's much more but this is the first post i've found via wayback machine. I thought it was well known that he hated his own art style, hated his life and took to tumblr to let out his frustrations and let everyone know, it was so frequent that other artists he was friends with made fun of him for it. The guy was emo as shit.

>>42498170
I suspect that as well since Pokehidden didn't say anything about that whatsoever on Inkbunny and nothing about it got said on the hexstream archive.

>>42502417
>I thought it was well known that he hated his own art style
That part is well-known, for sure...

> I suspect that as well since Pokehidden didn't say anything about that whatsoever on Inkbunny and nothing about it got said on the hexstream archive.
I literally berated the guy on YouTube for posting an almost certainly fake interview, heh... So yeah, I'm definitely not buying that shit. :)

>>42500538
They want attention to see if their game is worth continuing

>>42502417
The artist urge to make the most peak shit imaginable but still hate your own art style.

>>42502999
It's a fucking MIRACLE BFED got finished at all...

Also, now he can paint...

>>42502999
Wow he's literally me

>>42502228
>The court will compel any relevant companies such as your ISP to reveal all relevant info.
Nope.

>>42502999
I don't see anything wrong with the art style, looks better than what I produce.

>>42503655
I love his art style and it's still the main inspiration on my own style. I've seen multiple cases of artists hating their own styles even though it looks fine and nobody else is complaining about it, which is always sad to see. It probably just stems from the common tendency of people to be more critical of themselves than others are.

>>42450146
I like all of the music, it's quite picked well.

>>42503655
When you make something, you see all the problems with it. It doesn't align with your vision, and you feel the parts where your motor function or learned knowledge aren't enough to get the drawing just right. We're always chasing the inspiration that's unique to us, but it's an impossible task to achieve and this can be destructive to your will, especially if you have other things bringing you down.

>>42503482
Yep. Or did you think being nominally anonymous magically makes you invincible?

>>42501169
>filename says but in hd
>jpg crust
lol

>>42499088
Must be the reason why not one of the literal hundreds of idea guys made any progress towards a sequel or spinoff or even a tribute to BFED.

>>42499633
What programmers, retard? Its a point and click flash game. You dont need to code a single line for that, you can download fully functional ones after five minutes of googling.

>>42500945
Why are you trying to argue this to me? This is how copyright works in the US. Any IP must be "defended" or risk losing it, and all it takes with an intern to send out some e-mail form letters, which legally counts as taking steps towards defending it. Just because they do not intend to sue every case, it is enough to establish legal culpability if they do decide to sue, because they DID warn that one and it DID continue, so there is little to argue. And non-fair use of their IP could qualify for it, they don't need to profit from it or directly profit from it.

>basic income
Lmao, communist retard. No one will hand you out free money for existing.

>>42502228
This. A company can go silly lengths on legal fees to wreck you if they decide to choose it. a few hundred grands is chump change for a company but absolute bankruptcy for the average person. Even the threat of doing so is enough to force people into compliance. The ISPs, banks, etc. will also naturally hand out all your data right away. Sure, TECHNICALLY you can do the whole behind 9000 proxies and tor and onion and airgapped by encrypted smoke signals thing but that would make it such an impossible hassle that no one would go for it, unless they want to larp as an 80s cyberpunk hacker. In fact, overdoing it might be even easier for them to claim that you are doing it out of "malice", because no reasonable person who likes the IP and just wants to make fan content for it would go such lengths and you are doing it out of criminal intent, to hurt their IP. Their lawyer would bang the table what could possibly be the REASON to stay this anonymous when all the other fans are just drawing quirky images of ponies or Optimus Prime having sex with a lizard and uploading it to boorus.

>>42504632
>No one will hand you out free money for existing.
Too late, the Canada and Québec government already gave me several thousands over the years (since my revenues are around 0 and I file my taxes), already with at least a 100x return (and probably a lot more) on investment in terms of value delivered to global society.

If I had been on Basic Income from the start I would already have delivered for at least a billion dollars worth of value to global society, instead of merely a few million.

I literally almost died from poverty.

Poverty should be ABOLISHED, because it's TOO EXPENSIVE. It literally wouldn't even be hard. It's literally self-funding.

The only requirement is for society to GROW A FUCKING SPINE, which will of course probably never happen.

And btw Basic Income literally almost happened with Andrew Yang ("Freedom Dividend"), but of course the Lamestream Media had to censor him like a bunch of bitches...

And btw I am no communist, capitalism is mostly great but we just need a few simple fixes like Basic Income for at least a 100x increase in global productivity.

>>42504718
Basic Income is literally self-funding, I obviously meant...

>>42504718
>reddit spacing communist

Figures.

Once again I repeat, what does this have to do with the game in discussion?

Anons Try Not to Have Pointless Off-Topic Arguments for Five Seconds Challenge (Impossible)

>>42505066
What is left to discuss about the game?

>>42505510
this thread lasted way longer than it should

Multiple people have already attempted to make bfed-type games. First one was one from the now dead bfed general, then the Them fighting herds one and none of them got finished or worked on past the initial idea and this is whats wrong with most of you here, none of you want to put in the work that it takes to create a game, you expect a game to be done by weeks at best like the fag that shat up the thread above
Bfed took years to make by the way.

>>42505645
Shut up, Fluttershy, or I will pet you again.

>>42505645
Indeed, a game like BFED should take days, not weeks.

>>42505680
I mean you need the art and planning of locations and said locations of where the player can go with the three arrows and what character is there and what key items you need to activate certain scenes and so on.

>>42505680
If that was the case, which it clearly isn't, then we wouldn't have this situation where all BFED-related projects magically stall like a bitch.

People throw their faces head first at a brick wall and get surprised when their teeth suddenly fall off.

>>42505976
On second thought it would be pretty hard to throw your face head last at a brick wall, but you get what I mean...

>>42505645
>Bfed took years to make by the way.
Toddler Dude clearly never took note of that fact, or at the very least thoroughly failed to realize its significance.

>>42505890
and much more, it's a long ass process.

>>42504325
Nope. Maybe get out of that police state Muttistan sometime and you'll notice that everywhere else in the world police don't bend over backwards for companies, because they have actual REAL crimes to solve.

>>42504632
Christ, you're still here? Wrong on all accounts. Go dilate, kill yourself... whatever, just fuck off.

>>42505890
Yeah, and a point and click adventure is game jam material, especially when multiple people are making it.

>>42505976
Because they are retarded idea guys.

>>42506566
No.

>>42506969
Ending the thread on the note that your impotent tears are delicious.

bfed tip: if you unlock all six post-game extra scenes and either get the mane 6 ending or defeat luna, you unlock a real celestia scene
thank me later

>>42505510
>>42505577
you could say that for many of the other threads and generals like the Mane 6 characters which are just imagebumps and necrobumps

I can do BFED style art if there’s another thread.

>>42507091
>That's bullshit, but I believe it.

>>42507216
Make another thread then, please.

>>42507091
What, the gay gangrape scene was not "real" enough for you? :)

>>42507091
aren't all the scenes ripped out of the game especially since it's flash?

>>42507570
(Well, technically bi gangrape...)

>>42507575
The best decompiler I know of is the JPEXS thing and usability is low enough that it's easy to miss content or get bored before you even get to it.

For instance, I found out there is a music test thing, but I'm not sure if it can be activated.

>>42507592
dos the extractor show the code? Might be able to find out what enables the music test. likely inputs or a really hidden button.

>>42507624
Technically I think it shows all the information in some form, but overall usability is low enough that it's just a pain to use, especially if you wanted to make sure you review 100% of the information about the game.

It would actually be less effort to just build a better open-source flash decompiler from scratch, which would then make it easy to fully decompile and understand ANY flash content.