Pound-for-pound, can we all, finally, once and for all, collectively in good faith and with a non-objective lens, agree wholeheartedly and without a shadow of a doubt that Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge is the greatest album of the 2000s era?

>>126734593 (OP)
No because pop punk is garbage for emo faggots like you

>>126734593 (OP)
Yes.

>>126734666
MCR isn't pop-punk.

>>126734666
MCR is post hardcore.

mcr is both pop punk and post hardcore
post hardcore is kinda a meme genre anyway

literally never listening to this

mcr is mallcore

I remember when this came out on iTunes

>>126734593 (OP)
Greatest albums of the 00s? Come on, there has to be at least 50 runner ups that are better than three cheers.
>Inb4 it is bait
I actually like MCR

>>126738948
like? Except for the interlude part, Three Cheers is a non-skippable album

>>126739152
Saosin translating the name is unskippable front to back
Glassjaw? Thursday? At the drive in? Chiodos? I'm not hating on MCR, three cheers and the black parade are good, but the best album of the 00s? Yeah, that's a stretch

>>126739297
Glassjaw and At the Drive In are outrageously overrated

>>126740422
I prefer glassjaw for that rawness they bring. ATDI is a little too new wave for my tastes.
If we're talking out of all the albums from the 00s, I can't agree that three cheers is the best. Maybe top 20

>>126740422
>I MUST HAVE READ A THOUSAND FAAAAAACEEEEEEEEES

>>126734593 (OP)
Nah. Brand New, Thursday and about a dozen other bands mog the shit out of this and the rest of their albums. It's still good though.

>>126740666
Brand New is probably the most overrated band of that scene/era but ok lol

>>126734775
>>126734818
lmao MCR is Pop punk you delusional twat

>>126741114

that 2025 deluxe edition mix is something else
pound-for-pound i think we can definitely agree that few albums were more deserving a proper mix because for all it's heart, the original album sounds like a fuzzy mess compared to the new mix.

>>126741495
The new mix is great.

i am so fucking gay. i've sucked a million cocks and i hate mcr.

>>126734593 (OP)
Pound-for-pound.......

>>126734593 (OP)
You could maybe argue it's the best album of it's release year. But do you have any idea just how much music released in the 2000s? Nobody thinks it's the best album of the decade unless they're trying to bang a (poseur) emo chick

>>126734593 (OP)
What's so good about it?

u all just love to hate things that are popular and it shows

>>126741114
They have moments of post-hardcore. Less fugazi and more literal post-hardcore, they're primarily pop punk and "fake" mall emo
T. Ackshually

>>126745060
Everything.

>>126745060
OP just wants to fuck Gerard. That's usually what all this boils down to

>>126745060
It's the one album from the pop punk emo wave at the time that really felt authentic. Every single song sounds exactly like the album cover, which if you were a teenager in 2004 that was exactly what you wanted. Twelve songs and an interlude, just at 40 minute run time, every song has a massive chorus with extremely melodramatic lyrics and a singer who is probably the least talented popular musician alive but extremely loveable regardless which makes the entire album super fun to sing along to because you can't be out of key. I think the "bullets and love notes and cyanide and gravestones" thing probably comes off as extremely corny if you aren't in the right audience, but compared to similar bands like Wednesday 13 or whatever MCR seemed like the real deal.

>>126750828
Hmm. Sounds like you want to fuck Gerard

>>126750304
this except to the end and jetsite life

>>126751272
HE CALLS THE MANSION NOT A HOUSE BUT A TOMB

>>126750334
Same tbqh. I wish I had a dick.

>>126751272
if you don't pop a boner when he says "hotel bella muerte" you're gay

>>126753451
As much as I find him cool I don't find gerard sexually attractive, I much prefer frank, maybe bc I'm an aries too, but in general I prefer masculine men

>>126753524
>I prefer masculine men
Ew, different strokes I suppose

>>126734593 (OP)
yes agree but can we also put some respect on Danger Days

>>126734818
>>126734934
Absolutely false.

>>126739297
>>126741114
Absolutely true.

I love the album and even though I can't say for sure it's the best of the decade I know those literally who albums posted by anons can only be about as good as David bowie (not good)

>>126755482
the only respect i can give it is how good gerard looked during its run. not a good album.

>this thread
MCR are absolute faggots

>>126759209
They're all married to women though

>>126734934
>post hardcore is a meme genre
No.
https://youtu.be/1sMkCe_1BPg

One of my fav tapes and I barely listen to post hardcore. Good music is good music faggot.

>>126753524
Masculinity is a fake concept invented by the government. In the cavemen days women did most the hunting cause the men where making fires and inventing different traps for animals. Yeah ik, your retarded and did it know that.

>>126756990
>Saosin
>good
terminal case of tasteletitis

>>126760104
>Translating the Name
good
>everything else
bad

know the difference

>>126759278
"women"