Who is the greatest post hardcore band of all time? For me, it's My Chemical Romance. In just a few albums, they mogged everyone, then just dropped the mic and left at legend status.

unwound

also MCR are pop punk / emo

>>126770879 (OP)
Tie between Brand New and Thursday

The only people who think MCR is post hardcore are zoomoid culture vultures who have never listened to a proper post hardcore band in their life

>>126774351
>zoomoid culture vultures
Aren’t people

>>126774351
Their first album is undoubtedly post-hardcore. After that though yeah, pop-rock/pop-punk.

>>126774459
Nah. It’s mall emo

>>126774517
You've clearly never listened to their first album

>circa survive- juturna
>dance gavin dance- downtown battle mountain
>the fall of troy- doppelganger

>>126774542
Why would I waste my time listening to mall emo

>>126774579
kys

>>126774579
It'd be an improvement over the shit you listen to probably?

>>126774579
literally admitting you didn't listen to it. shut the fuck up faggot

>>126774574
Oh look, an actual man of culture.

>>126774574
>>126775173
I want to give shoutouts to Blue Sky Noise and Violent Waves, though, because both of those albums are very special to me.

>>126774574
Juturna is a masterpiece. DGD can be pretty annoying pretty quickly. FoT is good but I never thought they were worth all the praise but I'm also not a guitarist.

poser band

>>126774579
Why are you participating in this discussion if you haven't done your homework? You're not only wasting your time but also everyone else's time.

>>126775896
This isn’t a post hardcore band. It’s mall emo. Throwing a tantrum about it won’t change this from pussy music to good music.

/mu/ retards malding over mainstream pop slop
this board is truly a shadow of its former self

>>126770879 (OP)
>Joe Rogan's glownigger cousin
>Watered-down NIN for kindergarteners who like Brittany Spears
Yes, I'm sure they were granted instant fame and fortune because of raw talent

>>126776204
You literally admitted you haven't listened to their debut. It was released by an independent label with small distribution, you couldn't find it in a mall, so by definition it wasn't mallcore.

>>126776470
Why would I listen to this shit mall emo band

LMAO

>>126776310
Gerard and the Fear Factor guy didn't even know each other or that they were cousins before they became famous and they've never met. Also you overestimate Fear Factor guy's influence in the early 00s.
>Watered-down NIN
Only if that's the only other spooky alt rock you've ever heard, they sound nothing alike otherwise.

Same, with At The Drive-In second

>>126770909
their first album and some songs on three cheers lean on post hardcore, but emo is post hardcore anyway, and who even cares this much about genres anyway, fucking autism

>>126776310
They literally sound nothing like Nine Inch Nails, doofus. Also, Nine Inch Nails is gay lifting music for men who can't get on any rides at Six Flags.

>>126778009
one thing I noticed about MCR haters on this board is that they are completely braindead

mcrsperg gets to Nico sperg levels of seethe

KEK

>>126770879 (OP)
Shut up

Post-hardcore feels like it's even more of a loose label than post-punk. It's really weird that people would try to throw bands like My Chemical Romance into the same genre as Husker Du or Fugazi or Minutemen
I'm sure there's plenty of info out there as to how the "genre" developed but unlike most other genres, I wouldn't try out listening to a band just because they're described as "post-hardcore" because you have no idea what sort of sound you're actually going to get out of it

>>126778007
>but emo is post hardcore anyway,
No, it isn't. The original "emotional hardcore" movement was confined pretty exclusively to the 80s, bands like Embrace and Rites of Spring.
There are three waves of emo music. The third wave, which is what you're thinking of, is an offshoot of pop-punk, alt rock and or indie rock. The majority of the bands in that third wave take no influences from the first wave, even if they have actually listened to them a bit

MCR fucking sucks

>>126776310
>t. underage
rogan was a literally who in the early 00s.

>>126770879 (OP)
It's actually Shellac. My Sloppable Shartmance can eat a dick with their pop garbage.

>>126780239
weird fetish

>>126780155
...sucks the air out of your lungs, because it is breathtakingly awesome !!!. Like most good things in life, their period of recording lasted only for a short while, but left some of the most iconic, mind-blowing, inspirational music pieces ever written. One day they'll be archived, as culturally/artistically significant, and even their haters will swallow their pride, and admit, that once they were genius.

>>126780155
>>126780155 #
...sucks the air out of your lungs, because it is breathtakingly awesome !!!. Like most good things in life, their period of recording lasted only for a short while, but left some of the most iconic, mind-blowing, inspirational music pieces ever written. One day they'll be archived, as culturally/artistically significant, and even their haters will swallow their pride, and admit, that, once upon a time they were geniuses.

>>126780155
...sucks the air out of your lungs, because it is breathtakingly awesome !!!. Like most good things in life, their period of recording lasted only for a short while, but left some of the most iconic, mind-blowing, inspirational music pieces ever written. One day they'll be archived, as culturally/artistically significant, and even their haters will swallow their pride, and admit, that, once upon a time they were geniuses.

>>126782611
>>126782657
>>126782675
based

>>126782675
jesus christ lmao

MCR sucks dick

>>126778007
>who even cares this much about genres anyway, fucking autism
Yeah, subgenre autism, among other things, killed rock.

Captcha: NJ NGR

>>126780152
ok, I don't give a fuck, sounds emotional to me so they're emo :)

>>126782748
you'd know, you fucking faggot bitch

>>126785278
>projection

>>126785394
yes, that's exactly what i'm saying. stop projecting cunt.

MCR is embarrassing dogshit

>>126782748
>>126785576
>>126780155
>>126778599
>over 24 hour gap

Holy shit. This anti-MCRsperg truly is a schizo

post hardcore isn't a real genre anyways

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fOLfblOB2e8
For me it's Early Sunsets Over Monroeville.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=HSAXVVl9BUU&pp=ygUTb3VyIGxhZHkgb2Ygc29ycm93cw%3D%3D

>>126770879 (OP)
>post hardcore
MCR are a Pop Punk band. Always was, always will be. Revisionists tongue my motherfuckin anus.

>>126789621
meds now

>>126770879 (OP)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V2kWUJkRvVs
>GET
>UP
>COWAAAARD

>>126789621
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaLaMd_EAo4
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gyu_hqpxj8M
>pop punk
Calling them pop punk is also revisionist, if you check contemporary reviews from the early 00s they never call them pop punk, it's more likely to see them described as emo or goth-punk which is a term no one uses now.

>>126793041
>drowned
Who?
Anyway, fuck journos. I trust only my ears and when I listen to that garbage I hear Pop Punk. Pure juvenile trash.

>>126793094
Did you listen to those two songs?

>>126793041
You suck and so does this mall pop punk band

>>126793127
Nope and I won't. No way I'm going to pause Kevin Ayers for fucking MCR lmao

>>126793041
cool find tbqh

>>126793041
they did matt dirty man
yeah bob is the better drummer and all and can keep a tempo
but who cares I liked the chaos of the first two albums

>>126770909
Fpbp

>>126770879 (OP)
Anthony Green

>>126793401
>is

>>126793094
>fuck journos.
It was the journos who told you they are pop punk and you went along with it like a sheep, but they didn't always call them that. All genre names are made up by the press.
Here's also Rolling Stone calling them goth-punk in 2005.
>I trust only my ears and when I listen to that garbage I hear Pop Punk
You just said you didn't listen, schizo.

>>126770879 (OP)

Circa Survive - Juturna holds a special place in my heart. Listened to that album a ton when i was in Italy the winter of 2017-2018

>>126796133
Circa is my favorite band, but I have a hard time calling them post-hardcore. Joturna and On Letting Go are borderline, I guess. Influenced by, sure.

I'm so fucking sad Circa is probably done though. LS Dunes is good, but no substitution.

>>126770909
Although I'm not the biggest fan of MCR, pop punk/emo are sub-genres of PHC

ya they played dub

ya juanita■ still plays literally
\ /mu/
not actually aware of what emo is

>>126770879 (OP)
that saykd i invented emo literally

>>126785171
ya that not actually what it is about that

>>126770879 (OP)
i think fugazi!

>>126793183
So you don't know what you're talking about. Opinion discarded. Go make a Kevin Ayers thread and stop spamming this one.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXq_q1PUD38

> got mogged in the last thread
> has to samefag in a brand new one

nobody likes emos. you guys are/were all faggots.

>>126800574
>spams the board for weeks
>throws a tantrum when people inevitably get sick of it
>keeps worthless threads bumped to annoy the board even more

jfc this mcr sperg has to gtfo

>>126804570
I didn't make any of these threads, schizo. You're the one who's throwing tantrums. Why don't you make threads about music you like to counteract the ones you don't like instead of bumping them? lmao

>>126770879 (OP)
dont know. all post hardcore and all the subgenres that came from it fucking suck dick.

>>126807579
samefag

>>126774579
Lmao emo poser fags btfo

>>126774351
Oldfag here - at the time they were 100% considered post-hardcore

The line between emo and screamo was pretty blurry at the time but they were definitely in the screamo camp

>>126807724
samefag

Ugh, I hate rock

>>126808120
Nope lol nice try zoomie. We saw them as pop punk.

>>126810805
>t. 2008 born

>>126810805
Who's "we"? You're not fooling anyone larper. They were seen as emo at the time and that was an insult. The trve emo whiners were a minority.

>>126770909
Yeah, it's probably unwound. Fugazi and Slint come in second and third, respectively.

>>126780142
I count Husker Du as hardcore, and I know I'm wrong; but it makes more sense to me.

>>126770879 (OP)
Nobody took MCR seriously back in my day, and for good reason.

>>126774351
This is true.

>>126808120
no, they were clearly emo.

>>126770879 (OP)
I personally consider Sonic Yourh post-hardcore in some ways, so I guess them

>>126770879 (OP)
MCR transcended post hardcore to become the greatest rock band of their generation

>>126814745
Honestly based.

>write a fucking incredible comic
>drop it to rewrite it as a TV Show
>continuously gas light the comic fans with "it's being worked on!"
Fuck Gerard Way. FINISH THE GOD DAMN COMIC FUCK YOU.

Don't like their music but my sister loves them. I respect them well enough.

>>126815028
A new Umbrella Academy comic came out this month.

>>126814745
They're not even the best band from New Jersey

Best post-hardcore band overall is Fugazi. Best post-hardcore album is Repeater. Best post-hardcore song is Moss Icon's Lyburnum Wit's End Liberation Fly

WHEN I WAS

>>126815470
Fugazi sucks

>>126815604
Fugazi is a billion times better than MCR

>>126815639
They are but they're also not very good

>>126815678
Better than anything you could do

>>126815712
True but that's not saying much

>>126815678
What's the best post-hardcore band and album in your opinion?

>>126815734
Unwound probably

Alesana

>>126815133
Fuck I had just googled this shit to see if it had come out yet and got, "still waiting".

Thanks anon! I know what I'm gonna be reading now.

>>126816322
>>126815028
>>drop it to rewrite it as a TV Show
>>continuously gas light the comic fans with "it's being worked on!"
There was also another volume release while the show was airing, if you hadn't noticed. The Umbrella Academy Volume 3: Hotel Oblivion.

>>126818420
Fuck off

>>126818440
>not even 3 minutes
>immediately notices when thread he doesn't like gets bumped
what a loser lmao

>>126818440
Actual fucking schizo. Take a bullet in the head.

What's with all the MCR threads?

>>126820308
Some gay schizo is obsessed with them and noticed they can keep their threads bumped indefinitely because the board is slow. Nobody actually likes this garbage. There is no real discussion in these threads. Notice how when the mcschizo stops posting they all slide down the catalog. This board is dead

>>126822538
I was going to let this thread die, but now you're forcing me to reply.

>>126822734
No you weren’t. You suck

>>126822788
Yes, I was. Here, I saged, happy? Just so you know, this thread stayed alive this long thanks to you, you gave us reasons to reply again and again, you fucking idiot.