In retrospect and in complete and total unbiased honesty, was it the greatest rock album of the 2000s?

Not even their best album.

STOP SPAMMING

>>126880650
IM NOOOOTTTT OOOOOKKKKAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

>>126880650
Stop whining. It's a legitimate question and quite possibly true, when considering the album in a pound-for-pound, objective lens type of perspective and point of consideration.

>>126880641
shit taste

>>126880714
Fuck off. You already have a thread to discuss this shitty mall emo band. Stop spamming

>>126880764
>*teleports in front of you*
"Hey pal, leave him alone and BACK THE FRICK off? Hows about YOU stop spamming."
>*does a backflip*

>>126880795
Embarrassing faggotry

>>126880806
"Heh, look who's scared now."
*throws on shades*

>>126880795
Hehe that's pretty epic, anon :^)

>>126880829
Samefag

>>126880864
Schizo

>>126880954
>projection

>>126880795
Based.

>>126880622 (OP)
Even just talking about music in this basic landscape of super popular pop punk/emo-ish stuff, picrel completely ethers it. So no, far from the greatest album in any genre in the 2000s.

>>126880795
>>126880829
>>126881203
embarrassing samefag

>>126880795
kek

>>126880714
You do have this fucking thread at least five times a week. It's an alright album. They're an okay band. That's it. Nothing about them warrants this much discussion. Holy shit.

>>126881549
more samefagging
>>126881567
exactly. get some help for your mental illness op

>>126880650
>>126880740
>>126880764
>>126880806
>>126880864
>>126880960
>>126881304
>>126881580
embarassing samefag

>>126881266
Underrated post. Not only did they completely change their sound but they changed the sound of pop punk going forward. A hell of a lot more influential than MCR.

>>126881675
>>126881266
cringe. Blink has good songs but they have always been basic and unthreatening. MCR absolutely mogs them and in way fewer albums.

>>126881735
You are wrong and annoying

>>126881735
There's nothing threatening about MCR either. There's also nothing influential about them. They'd be a footnote if girls weren't creaming their spinach over Gerard. Shit, Box Car Racer alone clears MCR's discography. They don't mog Blink and they never will.

>>126881780
Nah

>>126881990
That's not an argument for anything but alright. Hopefully you will take this minimal approach and limit your constant posting about this damn band already. Far more interesting things were happening in the scene around this time anyway.

>>126882012
This guy gets it

Search your heart; you know it's true.

>>126880622 (OP)
In retrospect and in complete and total unbiased honesty, is the MCR spammer the biggest faggot in the history of this godforsaken, faggotladen board?

>>126882340
The Kurt spammers are up there but MCRfag takes the cake

>>126880622 (OP)
i wanna fuck a china girl with david bowi cause its not gay if its in a three way

>>126880622 (OP)
probably in the top 100. nowhere near the top tho. idk shit decade for rock anyway.

>>126880795
holy shit I keked

MCR is one of the worst bands of all time

>>126882478
Agreed. Watch the MCRfag bump this thread like a bitch

>>126880622 (OP)
It was honestly very good and their (justified) reputation for being bawwwwwww emo music didn't start until The Black Parade came out

It was always mall emo. Nice try samefag

>>126880622 (OP)
Probably yes, but it is absolutely 100% within the top 10 best rocks albums of the 21st century so far. Having said that, The Black Parade is widely regarded as their best album, so I'd say BP would be the number 1, and Three Cheers either 2, or 3 best.

>>126882478
Even if the only bands that ever existed were Black Sabbath, Led Zeppelin, Queen, AC/DC, Metallica, The Doors, Iron Maiden, Def Leppard, Aerosmith, The Who, Van Halen, R.E.M Linkin Park, Nirvana, and Green Day, they still wouldn't be dead last, would stay right in the middle. They were geniuses, their biggest flaw, was dropping only 4 albums, had they released 6, as they planned to, of similar quality as their 2nd and 3rd, they could go toe to toe with any of them, and be second to none.

>>126880622 (OP)
In retrospect and in complete and total unbiased honesty, I can say with confidence that I could beat the shit out of Gerard Way in a 1v1 fight

>>126882478
Even if the only bands that ever existed were The Beatles, Rolling Stones, Black Sabbath, Led Zeppelin, Queen, AC/DC, Pink Floyd, Metallica, The Doors, Iron Maiden, Def Leppard, Aerosmith, The Who, Van Halen, R.E.M Linkin Park, Nirvana, and Green Day, they still wouldn't be dead last, would stay right in the middle. They were geniuses, their biggest flaw, was dropping only 4 albums, had they released 6, as they planned to, of similar quality as their 2nd and 3rd, they could go toe to toe with any of them, and be second to none. >>126882125
American Idiot isn't even half as good as Three Cheers, 1 MCR album, is worth 2 Green Day ones.

>>126885220
Jfc you suck

>>126885249
Zip it, schizo.

>>126885220
Half those bands suck. And their biggest flaw is releasing Danger Days at all and dropping the edgy/dark vibe. Foundations was a step in the right direction in fixing the mistake of DD, but looks like that went no where.

>>126881735
>Blink has good songs but they have always been basic and unthreatening
Wait are we talking about Blink 182 here or MCR?

>>126885220
> The Beatles, Rolling Stones, Black Sabbath, Led Zeppelin, Queen, AC/DC, Pink Floyd, Metallica, The Doors, Iron Maiden, Def Leppard, Aerosmith, The Who, Van Halen, R.E.M Linkin Park, Nirvana, and Green Day

Every single one of these bands is easily better than MCR. Even Def Leppard

>>126885436
>mall emo should’ve stayed in the mall!

>>126882125
This, and anyone that denies it is delusional
>>126880641
Also great
>>126880622 (OP)
Mediocre

>>126885471
Yes obviously.

>>126885128
why would you want to do that though? it's mean ;_;

>>126880622 (OP)
>>126880641
You might not like it but pic related is probably the greatest rock album of the 2000s, objectively speaking

Apparently it was the best-selling rock album of the 2000s, so I suppose it is the most-liked album of the 2000s:

https://bestsellingalbums.org/decade/2000

>>126881266
>>126881675
It was a great album

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC_cnPRSHQA

>>126881735
Blink was one of the best rock bands of the 90s and 2000s. MCR were widely mocked because they weren't that good. They had some catchy songs but they weren't that good.

>Blink was one of the best rock bands of the 90s and 2000s.

>>126885934
Objectively true

>>126885934
You know this is an MCR thread right? That can't strike you as a crazy comment in this context.

>>126885957
You only get one thread. Fuck off

>>126886064
I don't know what the fuck that means. I don't even like MCR.

>>126881780
>>126885453
>There's nothing threatening about MCR either
Believe it or not, MCR faced satanic panic backlash, they were blamed for driving kids to suicide, that they were telling them to join the black parade aka kill themselves lmao. Blink was nothing more than a frat boy band.

>>126885890
Very good but not as good as>>126882125

>>126886288
>Blink was nothing more than a frat boy band
You're showing that you have no idea what the fuck you're talking about

>>126886288
>Blink was nothing more than a frat boy band.
Obviously not. I think I saw Mark Hoppus a while ago say that Blink was meant for people who felt like outsiders. I think he said he was originally attracted to punk rock because it accepted outsiders who weren't that popular at school.

>Top 15 best bands in history, along with their greatest song (by the greatest music connoisseur : me X-D )
1- Queen (best song : https://youtu.be/fJ9rUzIMcZQ?si=cbuB5Un93UOte9al )
2- The Beatles (best song : https://youtu.be/usNsCeOV4GM?si=TE3XCELy2C1pKp-o )
3- Iron Maiden (best song : https://youtu.be/HAQQUDbuudY?si=vT9qhdDhGE1cmLAA )
4- Black Sabbath (best song : https://youtu.be/RVUK2rtAkJE?si=YAyERQIoqlM7dYbZ )
5- Gun'n Roses (best song : https://youtu.be/-ucDiz3GYrg?si=gKYWZj2G-cKOqsue )
6- Pink Floyd (best song : https://youtu.be/7jMlFXouPk8?si=A6OukP_IC07Ym1UN )
7- My Chemical Romance (best song : https://youtu.be/UCCyoocDxBA?si=6umE09RAcI4Ucu2O )
8- Simon and Garfunkel (best song : https://youtu.be/qqQ_VJPn3xQ?si=tTEyx1mQpLXTc0fd )
9- Rolling Stones (best song : https://youtu.be/EyYI6lLRYxM?si=KoP_yFP1XKmClPZ6 )
10- L'arc en Ciel (best song : https://youtu.be/bzuuxp7dsxQ?si=NsTykqove25aGFwG )
11- Judas Priest (best song : https://youtu.be/8Ksksu9JDkg?si=JFwwr83tAtmdoUro )
12- Aerosmith (best song : https://youtu.be/qbexOeoH5hg?si=NU2A2Rvrmrg3ONGf )
13- Linkin Park (best song : https://youtu.be/eVTXPUF4Oz4?si=KJa7lf3LUAAbbs7V )
14- The Carpenters (best song : https://youtu.be/8CX83EQA8dc?si=n6-eBkgJCTjwwVFI )
15- Green Day (best song : https://youtu.be/pGhwBFYtn1s?si=FIAfYBJY2YZ-aWgz )

>>126886288
>driving kids to suicide
That just what "emo" was, and also the reason why it was (and still is) fucking cringe.
All these emo/scene revival the past years rubs me the wrong way.

>>126887964
dios mio....

>>126887964
Generic ass taste but still better than most fags here

>>126885128
You sure keep visualizing yourself with Gerard 1v1. Keep your homo fantasies to yourself, you don't need to remind us in every MCR thread.

]>>126887271
their fans were and are absolute normies, not outsiders.

Remake edition "honesty" (my genuine favorites, don't judge X-( ")
>Top 10 best bands
1- Iron Maiden (best song : same as before)
2- The Beatles (best song : https://youtu.be/jenWdylTtzs?si=xvaqyOpVgQ6uTClx )
3- My Chemical Romance (best song : same)
4- Stratovarius (best song : https://youtu.be/Tn58-Nl9NYw?si=u6lcEbo4uv3i83bX )
5- L'Arc en Ciel (best song : https://youtu.be/RaV8KtB2QTM?si=yTgE8mya8We_ZbZW )
6-Gun'n Roses (best song : same)
7- Muse (best song : https://youtu.be/O2IuJPh6h_A?si=PrargxfRE7lXJwkQ )
8- Galneryus (best song : https://youtu.be/yGVd2TnlLxs?si=z1IL44ZH9-UyXi_f )
9- Queen (best song : same)
10- Black Sabbath (best song : same)

>>126888089
You clearly know nothing about the music then. Most of it is about catharsis and letting go of that shit. I have no idea where anyone would get the idea of suicide from MCR to begin with. Most of their shit up tempo and about horror movies or comic books.
>>126889515
They've had a few hits where the masses would be exposed to them but that's not their core audience. The same shit could be said about MCR. It was everywhere and they're just about the most normie band in all of emo.

>>126888196
I tried to put bands that are widely regarded as the best, and I like, but aren't exactly my favorites, higher. Being honest, I like Queen and Pink Floyd, but I prefer L'arc en ciel, or MCR.

>>126880622 (OP)

>>126888196
Thinking it through, I think 1) Iron Maiden 2) The Beatles 3) MCR 4) Stratovarius 5) L'arc en Ciel 6) Black Sabbath 7) Gun'n Roses 8) Galneryus/Muse 9) Queen would be the closest to a definitive personal ranking I could come up with.

The samefag autism is strong in here

>>126890758
It's strong in every MCR thread. Could be since 95 percent of the posts are from one person.

>>126890765
That ain't me though, I only made 5 comments total, starting with this : >>126885220 ending with this : >>126890738 (well 6 now)

>>126890803
>That ain't me though
>spergs out another schizo list
>That ain't me though
Obvious samefag is obvious

>>126890803
Didn't mean you, anon

>>126890655
>bands that are widely regarded as the best
Music is the least objective art form. Be yourself no one else will

>>126881780
>if girls weren't creaming their spinach over Gerard.
As if Blink isn't a boyband with one member married into the Kardashian clan.

Totally authentic reply

Specifically Decode the aucoctic.

Haley is amazing

>>126890686
thanks for posting the real cover bro

>>126891502
You are aware he married her just a couple years ago, right? They had to grind it out for a while before they achieved any real success. And I doubt you're gonna find anyone who is swooning over the members of Blink. 99 percent of MCR's popularity is girls and fags wanting to fuck Gerard. Their music isn't anything special.

>>126891690
>You are aware he married her just a couple years ago, right?
Yes, I am, my point was that they are a chick band just as well and mainstream as fuck, if they weren't the Kardashians wouldn't be interested in them, I don't see Gerard or anyone from MCR dating soulless A-list celebrities.
>Their music isn't anything special.
Neither is Blink's

>>126881266
>>126880641
>>126880622 (OP)
CDs were awful to album art
look at this shit, who'd wanna hang that on their walls? looks like something drawn on a teenager's notebook

>>126891690
Dude, I'm neither a girl nor gay, most mcr fans are neither. Blink is not a bad band, but both Green Day and the Offspring do their stuff better, MCR songs have more uniqueness to them, than pretty much anything Blink ever did, MCR actually had an influence on music : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Parade blink didn't, they simply did what was popular at the time. mcr songs were uniquely good, blink's were generic good.

Shit band. Samefag thread

>>126891882
See my post above. Blink changed the entire genre they're in. What have MCR done except inspire countless spam threads here and move gay marching band merch at Hot Topic?
>>126891948
>I'm neither a girl nor gay
You could fool everyone with the way you're obsessed with this very average band. Green Day fucking sucks and so does the Offspring so your ears and your opinion can't be trusted.

>>126892260
Agree but they are less than average. Mcr is embarrassing dogshit

>>126892285
This one anon on here overrating the hell out of them has really soured me on them. I liked their first two albums well enough but they really are a middle of the road band.

>>126891895
they're great cd covers, why would they need to be hung up walls lmao get a grip retard

>>126892138
If mcr is shit, blink is just poop stain, blink got nothing on mcr. blink changed nothing, maybe they need to change your diapers, big baby. if you're part of this band's fanclub or are a member yourself, that's your problem, blink is as generic as punk rock could possibly get, I wouldn't call them shitty, but pretty forgettable.

>>126892411
Kys mcrfag

>>126885934
Yeah, but they were studiobabbies.

>>126892411
See >>126892416

>>126892450
>>126892416
Kys blinkfag. Blink is so boring, that's how they got their name : you start to blink, until you doze off.

>>126892479
There's that wit that's so common in these spam threads of yours

>>126892622
I never made a mcr thread, you retard.

>>126890832
There were some albums I listened only for the sake of their cult status, and to be able to say I listened to them : Cause of Death, Slow Deep and Hard, In Utero etc... the whole time I was just praying it would end soon.

>>126892673
No one believes you. And it'll be fun tomorrow when another one of these pound for pound threads about your favorite middle of the road band pops up

What's with all the MCR threads?

>>126893534
Dude, that's your problem whether you believe or not, but the only threads I remember ever making on this board, was one for metal, and another for phonk. I just really enjoy mcr music, don't know why, I of course don't think they're factually better than Queen, or Black Sabbath, it's more of a guilty pleasure thing.

>>126893538
Some fag is obsessed with Gerard Gay and has been spamming for a while and getting butthurt when someone posts in his threads

>>126893611
You should gain taste

>>126893642
Like what exactly ?

>>126893708
Anything besides MCR and Queen

>>126880622 (OP)
*blocks your samefaggy way*

>>126893538
If you've been paying attention, ever since MCR reunited we have been getting a lot of MCR threads, some of them even hit bump limit. Now these past few threads have been lasting longer because there is an anti mcr autist who keeps provoking the MCRfags to reply back, which makes the thread last longer.

>>126895354
Nah, we can pay attention and there are so many threads because you create them and they reach bump limit because you bump them pathetically.

>>126892260
>Blink changed the entire genre they're in
So did MCR, like it or not, now everyone, excluding trve emo purists, thinks that emo sounds and looks like them. Saying they had no impact is disingenuous.

>>126895754
It’s fake emo lmao. Nobody thinks mcr and rites of spring are similar at all

>>126880764
What music for teenagers of other generations have you based you life on while constantly decrying the music for teenagers of your generation and those slightly younger than you?

>>126886288
>satanic panic
Satanic panic was bullshit promoted by American psychiatrists. They'd tell their patients they were victims of stantic rituals.
>A 1994 article in the New York Times stated that: "Of the more than 12,000 documented accusations nationwide, investigating police were not able to substantiate any allegations of organized cult abuse".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bennett_Braun#Satanic_ritual_abuse_theory
This guy was one of the main initiators of it but the whole American Psychiatric Assosiation was in on it.

Psychiatry is a scam.

MCR is overrated bullshit. i prefer my other fake emo teen rock

>>126882125
hell nah, american idiot is when green day stopped being cool pop punk and started fagmaxxing. it has some good tracks but a rock opera is built to suck

>>126896008
Dude, it's fall out boy that is seriously overrated, some of their songs are good, but most are forgettable, don't have any distinctive characteristics, to the point if it's your first times listening, you can't tell a song from the other, they're more Coldplay than "fake emo"

>>126896057
You seem troubled mentally

>>126896008
>claims to dislike overrated bullshit
>posts the most overrated bullshit of the era

>>126896021
kys trumpie

>>126880622 (OP)
not even close

>>126897610
i'm actually a bushie :)

>>126897843
Kek, comparing 3 cheers to the artist in the ambulance, is like putting Usain Bolt to race a couch potato. Thrice is better than fall out boy/panic at the disco, but even their best album would struggle to compete with bullets. if I were to choose a rock album from the 2000s to try beating it, would be either Absolution, Black Holes and Revelations, or Brave New World. But if we're talking only emo, I wouldn't even try, even JEW can't.

>>126895754
No they didn't. They were very successful but you hear zero influence on anyone. They're literally a nostalgia act.
>>126896057
First two Fall Out Boy albums mog anything and everything MCR ever did. FOB don't have any distinctive characteristics? What the fuck are you talking about? Their singer has one of, if not the most distinctive and recognizable in the entire scene. Everything you say is horse shit.
>>126898448
Thrice obliterates MCR in every way. Musicianship, songwriting, having something to say, having integrity while navigating their major label debut and their influence on emo and post-hardcore is immense. You're talking out of your ass on every level.

>>126880622 (OP)
>unbiased honesty

>>126895917
Yeah, it's obviously bullshit, but it's a fact that a lot of bands faced backlash because of this, in the 2000s it was more about kids being manipulated into suicide not as much about satanism, but MCR was called a suicide cult by the press, in the UK mostly, even though they weren't glorifying suicide in any way.
A lot of emo kids at the time got "the talk" being asked if they are depressed or suicidal by their parents and teachers just because of the way they dressed and the music they listened to. I believe the 2000s emo kid fad led to the normalisation of mental illness as it is today. Before the 2000s talking about it openly was taboo and around that time you saw a lot of films and TV featuring suicidal and depressed characters as it was trendy because of the emo fad, which made it less taboo.

>>126900184
>A lot of emo kids at the time got "the talk" being asked if they are depressed or suicidal by their parents and teachers
lmao literally me back in the day

>>126900184
>things that didn’t happen but mcrfag imagined

>>126900115
Lol, your band sucks, fall out boy barely qualifies as "fake emo" is it's equivalent to popslop, they're double shit, once for being sell outs, and twice for being worse at their actual genre than coldplay. 3Cheers is widely regarded as not only among the top 10 best emo albums ever, but among the best albums of the 21st century, by critics and fans alike, even 4chan /mu/core mentions both mcr albums in their list of top 10 albums for 2004 and 2006. As for deep writing, regardless of what Thrice or MCR may or may not be, the fact remains that fall out boy is shallower than a plate, Taylor swift writes deeper songs than their slop.

>>126900760
Meds, schizo.

>>126901002
You are just making shit up. Get the fuck out of here fanboy

>>126901002
You're so fucking retarded it's unreal. You know nothing about that scene or this kind of music in general. Bunch of nonsense arguments that revolve around you thinking Three Cheers is some big accomplishment when countless other albums, in the same genre, came out that same year and wiped floor with it. You should go bust to Gerard and maybe the post nut clarity will help you see things as they actually are.

Seems about right, MCR albums were the pinnacle of multiples genres mixing into was dubbed emo, resting among the greatest albums in history, popslop like fall out boy doesn't deserve an inclusion.

>>126901154
Yup. Mcrfag is clearly making shit up to feed his obsession. He’s another nicosperg tier seething retard

>>126901154
Both fall out boy and panic at the disco, are made out of the crap MCR thought was below them, they combined doesn't have the talent a single MCR album had, MCR albums are the kind that make you stop to appreciate and be at wonder, FOB are to be put in the background as your brain rots.

>>126901228
Mcrfag clearly lives in a delusional fantasy of his own creation and isn’t interested in interacting with other anons in a meaningful way. This is basically another Emily/Linkin Park obsessed coomer schizo that is going to permanently shit up the board while he masturbates to his own threads.

>>126901203
Seriously
>>126901228
Take This To Your Grave is widely considered one of the greatest albums in the genre, you dumb fuck. Patrick Stump alone has more talent vocally than Gerard could ever dream of.

by reading the thread I believe that I speak for everyone when I say that the answer is yes

https://www.besteveralbums.com/thechart.php?b=1719 vs https://www.besteveralbums.com/thechart.php?b=1334

>>126901305
>widely considered

>>126902262
You suck

>>126881780
>Box Car Racer alone clears MCR's discography
lol

>>126902424
Pedo

>>126902262
Why do you bother arguing about a genre you clearly know nothing about?
>>126902424
I know it's tough for you faggots in the marching band merchandise to hear but it blows anything MCR have done out of the water and it was just Tom fucking around.

>>126880622 (OP)
>mogged by Brand New
>mogged by Thursday
>mogged by Thrice
>mogged by Fall Out Boy
>mogged by Blink 182
>mogged by Box Car Racer

>>126902557
All false.

>>126902581
All true and it's totally unbiased

>>126902557
These bands suck and they are still a thousand times better than mcr

>>126886288
lol adam's song was around long before MCR started up

>>126902557
These bands are dogshit, pathetic even, when compared to MCR, /mu/ agrees, every music magazine agrees, is just your retarded brain, and terrible taste that says other wise. Fall out boy is garbage, disgraceful popslop, isn't even worth talking about, just like most of these other bands, blink 182 is a copycat green day, but without the talent, even MCR worst songs mogs all of them, even Gerard's used toilet paper, is a better music piece than any thing those losers ever put out.

>>126902779
Nobody agrees with you faggot. Stop making shit up to support your unhealthy obsession with this dogshit cringe band

>>126902787
Are you blind you stupid retard ?>>126901184
>>126901608
Black Parade is ranked 333, and 4 for 2006, while FOB best album isn't even on that list, and is ranked 1700 on best albums, no music critic/magazine ranks that popslop anywhere near 1000.

>>126902804
That’s a made up chart. Mu didn’t even exist in 2004. Go fuck yourself mcrsperg

>>126902818
Yeah, was made up by thousands of people much smarter than a dipshit like you, with much more knowledge and better taste, "didn't exist in 2004" so what you ?, it didn't exist in 1960 either, but it is still ranking albums from that decade, you lost, you dogshit garage band doesn't impress anyone with 2 brain cells to rub together.

>>126902818
Yeah, was made up by thousands of people much smarter than a dipshit like you, with much more knowledge and better taste, "didn't exist in 2004" so what you dumbfuck ?, it didn't exist in 1960 either, but it is still ranking albums from that decade, you lost, you dogshit garage band doesn't impress anyone with 2 brain cells to rub together.

>>126902697
Yeah but was blink seen as the band that makes kids cut and kill themselves? Blink was the fun toilet humour band. Would people ask you if you cut yourself because you like Enema of the State?

>>126902779
>blink 182 is a copycat green day, but without the talent
Extremely weak bait or you're ungenerous in the extreme, but either way it's unpersuasive.

>>126902865
>thousands
lol nice try schizo

>>126902818
You're a fucking idiot omg.

>>126902897
>projection

>>126902907
>That’s a made up chart. Mu didn’t even exist in 2004.
What a fucking retard.

>>126902818
bro you dum dum nigga what is wrong with you hahahahaaaah

>>126902875
That ain't bait, their songs are just your average 1990s punk rock, doesn't stand out, Green Day mogs them compare : https://youtube.com/shorts/AYWT7WWWhF8?si=DwL-XEKG8GbPM-sL vs https://youtube.com/shorts/G98rZWMDZDA?si=HToyo0jPL2GPziU1

>>126902921
How do you think your precious charters created? Some autist made a thread that maybe half a dozen other autists went into and they voted for their favorite albums. There was no unanimous vote or decision making. It’s like one of those “mu is 1958” threads, nobody is paying attention but a few shit posters and autsimos. You cherry picked the chart from hundreds if not thousands of charts, all created by a handful of losers. You annoying retard. MCR sucks and has always sucked. It’s the cringiest dogshit of the 2000s and it was a fad. It’s the fucking Harlem shake/ ice bucket challenge of the mid 2000s. Nobody with any taste listened to this garbage. You dumb fuck

>>126887964
>(best song : https://youtu.be/-ucDiz3GYrg?si=gKYWZj2G-cKOqsue [Embed] )
based pick

>>126902943
>shorts
Fuck off, retard

>>126902943
I really don't know what you expect me to be hearing here. The self-titled Blink 182 album is nothing at all "average punk" from the 90s. I don't recall Robert Smith on any Green Day songs. The arrangement of Blink 182 songs is also much different and more distinct. If anything can be said, it's that Green Day songs all sound very similar, but Blink 182 more or less escaped that box at some point while retaining a quality that identified it as them. I think you've probably tricked me into responding to bait though, so bravo.

>>126902956
>they voted
how else would you have be preferred these to be made you moron

>>126902988
You dumb piece of shit. Six random autists do not decide something is permanently Mu core. You seriously suck at reading and understanding words

>>126903011
so confident about the number of autists, given that the activity on this board has fluctuated a lot over the years. I know I have taken part of /mu/ strawpolls where at least 20 autists responded in 10 minutes.

>>126903183
Considering how much you samefag, your numbers shouldn’t be trusted

>>126903197
You're an imbecile, "samefag" like a cornered rat you lash out in the dark, not knowing you're talking to different people, I posted that chart, and called you and you dogshit band out, not the anon you're replying to. >>126902988
This moron thinks only his ignorant uninformed opinion should matter.

>>126903273
Keep seething, it won’t make mcr any less cringe

>>126902956
Yeah they were created by the democratic process, no need to write an essay, sperg. Your problem you didn't participate and weren't an active member of the community. The people of /mu/ have spoken. Cope.

>>126903333
>shit that never happened

>>126903333
Stop pretending like you have always been here you obvious newfag

>>126903011
And those six random autists happened to be MCR fans right? So you're admitting that the most active and dedicated members of this board that make charts are MCR fans. Let me remind you that when these vote threads happened the number of IP addresses was visible.

>>126902779
It's alarming how terrible your opinions on music are. You're so cock hungry for Gerard Way you can't even wrap your brain around anything other than praising him and his very average band. There's no point in arguing with you about anything. It's like talking to a child whose only retort is NUH UH. Sincerely hope you get banned and end up like Nicosperg.

>>126903333
honestly, dismantling THE /mu/ consensus is the most deranged shit I've seen here in a while

>>126903409
BASED.

>>126903417
pretending like your cherry picked chart is some sort of official consensus is the most deranged shit I've seen here in a while

>>126903183
This, antiMCRsperg must be a newfag. /mu/ has been warming up to MCR the past decade, then this autist showed up and now there so much seething hate like it's 2007 again.

>>126903443
there’s that projection again lmao

>>126903349
>>126903359
Cope, samefag, yeah the voting never happened.

>>126903409
> Sincerely hope you get banned and end up like Nicosperg.
MCRfag is the most unhinged lying faggot I’ve seen on the board since him. Agreed that he needs to go

>>126903481
>talking to himself again

>>126903438
are you serious? I've been on /mu/ for 13 years and I can attest that that chart right there is based on anons speaking positively of all the albums I can recognize. You seem to be hellbent on disproving his point that you attempt to strawman the legitimacy of fucking sacred scrolls. Get bent, you pathetic fuckwit. Get some real arguments.

>>126903481
It's clear he doesn't know anything about that period in music and he triples down on it so it's very much in line with how Nicosperg argued. It's just a matter of time until he gets bullied into a permaban. Very excited to see it happen.

MCRsperg is such a newfag he’s just repeating what everyone else says to him
Lmao

>>126903545
The only one getting bullied here is you, you poor delusional fag, you're a moron, a shit-for-brains, a cringe pathetic manchild "hehe hE wILl got da bans" most likely you're the one samefagging this thread, contradicting everyone else, lost in your delusional ignorance.

>>126903438
>cherry picked
When the next election happens and you don't vote, don't cry when you don't like the new president.

>>126900760
You wouldn't know because you weren't born yet.

>>126903593
I've had actual arguments to back up everything I've said. You're simping for a middle of the road emo band that is only big because people want to fuck the lead singer. It's a tale as old as time but you're making this out to be something special. It isn't. Your opinions are garbage and you argue like a child who has nothing to contribute but is desperate to feel like he won. You don't know shit about emo, pop punk, post hardcore, scene or anything else.

>>126903967
Agreed

>>126900115
>FOB don't have any distinctive characteristics? What the fuck are you talking about? Their singer has one of, if not the most distinctive and recognizable in the entire scene.
FOB's singer has a very technically good voice, but MCR's is way more distinctive and recognizable. People either passionately love or furiously hate his voice, with Patrick Stump's voice there's more of a general consensus that he has a great voice but no strong feelings.

>>126895763
They're not real emo but the regular public thinks that's what emo is, therefore the term has been redefined, words change, I'm not saying I agree, but it doesn't matter what /mu/fags think. Changing public perception means they had an impact.

>look at these charts! The definitive democratic charts voted on by thousands!
>it doesn't matter what /mu/fags think

holy hypocrite lmao

>>126904062
>people universally loving someone's voice isn't a strong feeling
You're exhausting and the lengths you go to to worship MCR is embarrassing

>>126903967
And you think you do ? Sucking up to one of the most mediocre, bland, excuse for "emo" ?, you're not bringing any "arguments" just your dumb, ignorant opinion based on nothing but gut feeling. a chart showing the position of/mu/ was posted, you ignored, the ranking of besteveralbums was linked(in which 3 cheers appears at 1420, Black parade at 334, and the best fob album at 1700) you ignored, again, you bring no "arguments", no "facts", we were discussing 2 things here: 1) which is a better band, and 2) who better represents the punk-rock/emo of the 2000s, MCR is a much better band, everyone agrees, from most music publications, from rolling stones to loudwire, to the poll on /mu/, as for who better represents "emo" jew does it better than both, mcr is a punk-rock band with emo influence, fob is just the fake emo version of popslop.

>>126903967
And you think you do ? Sucking up to one of the most mediocre, bland, excuse for "emo" ?, you're not bringing any "arguments" just your dumb, ignorant opinion based on nothing but gut feeling. a chart showing the position of/mu/ was posted, you ignored, the ranking of besteveralbums was linked(in which 3 cheers appears at 1220, Black parade at 334, and the best fob album at 1700) you ignored, again, you brought zero "arguments", no "facts", just your retarded opinion, stop smelling your own farts. we were discussing 2 things here: 1) which one is a better band, and 2) who better represents the punk-rock/emo of the 2000s, MCR is a much better band, everyone agrees, from all music publications, from rolling stones to loudwire, to the poll on /mu/, as for who better represents "emo" jew does it better than both, mcr is a punk-rock band with emo influence, fob is just the fake emo version of popslop.

>>126904215
Everyone agrees you are an annoying fag

>>126904237
Everyone agrees you're an ignorant moron with your head up your own ass.

>>126904141
Agreed

>>126904215
>rolling stone
Yes because if anyone knows what the people want in 1972 it's them. And I've brought in plenty of things that you completely ignore. You somehow bring up Coldplay or god knows what fucking else to distract from the fact that outside of girls wanting to fuck Gerard and the fat kids in the freshman class wanting to dress like half dead marching band leaders, they weren't that important to the scene as a whole. The problem isn't them as a band. The problem is you sucking them off with all of your might. They're an alright band. You're an autistic shithead who is doing more harm than good when it comes to discussing them or music in general on this hellhole of a site.

>>126904323
This guy gets it.

>>126904323
https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/2005 highest position reached by a FOB album : 36 , https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/2004 2nd highest position reached by a MCR album 26, https://bestsellingalbums.org/year/2006 highest 15

>>126904432
>chart positions are all that matter
And I've said they're successful, dumbass

>>126904445
You stupid piece of shit, you complained that only people from the year he also were released should opine "1972" MCR were more popular in the year of their release, and in the following, than fob, you're a dumbfuck, your opinion is crap.

>>126904445
You stupid piece of shit, your complaint was that only people from the year the albums were released should opine "1972" MCR albums were more popular in the year of their release, and in the following ones, than any fob, you're a dumbfuck, your opinion is crap.

lol mcrsperg is melting down

>>126904495
That wasn't my point at all, you fucking retard. My point was Rolling Stones hasn't been relevant or important since then if they ever were important to begin with

>mcrsperg doesn’t understand what the difference between The Rolling Stones or Rolling Stone is

KEK

>>126904584
Oh I do, you're the mentality challenged manchild who spergs out over a typo, you're pathetic, making a comment over a letter, you're lower than a worm.

Everyone agrees, MCR sucks

What a sad thread, I don’t like MCR but why spend hours talking about it if you don’t like it.

>>126880622 (OP)
no, I gotta agree that take this to your grave is just more fun all around

>>126904679
Shut up

Fall out boy is forgettable cheap popslop, I'd call them sell out, but they never had shit to sell in the first place, and their attempt failed, seeing how any other popslop band beats them at sells. Both blink 182 and FOB are the definition of uninspired shit, boring, formulaic, even Sabrina carpenter is better, for at the very least she doesn't pretend to be something she isn't.

that's brilliant, but I like this

>>126904679
It's a mentally handicapped moron, who doesn't have anything going in his life, and has shitty taste, so in a fit of rage over the mediocrity of his favorite popslop bands, he tries to drag the actually good ones down, he is too stupid to figure out his pathetic sperging out doesn't hit them, he will continue being a failure, and his shitty band will continue being garbage.

>>126880795
best post in this whole goddamn thread

>>126904872
samefagging again

>>126904895
I came in at the tailend of this whole shitshow, wanna talk about sikth with me babe?

>>126895595
I didn't make any of these threads, but go off, I guess.

>>126900154
>autist can't detect that the title is tongue in cheek and a recurring meme

>>126905000
One faggot making the same post over and over isn't a meme

>>126902779
>blink 182 is a copycat green day
shows bud doesn't know smack about this music. everyone and their momma knows they are screeching weasel and descendents worship

>>126903197
If you were there, you wouldn't need to trust his numbers, you'd already know, newfag.

>>126905313
I’ve been here forever and that’s why I know you are a newfag schizo like nicosperg was

>>126905465
job when?

>>126906102
fuck off newfag

Reminder that blink and mcr are friends and respect eachother. No need to fight mcrfags and blinkfags.

>>126881780
>>126900115
>they were very successful but you hear zero influence on anyone
MCR has influence across genres and it still echoes to this day with contemporary artists. Artists influenced or inspired by mcr include emo-pop contemporaries that debuted after them like Paramore and Panic at the Disco (there's pictures of Ryan Ross wearing mcr shirts before panic made it), the whole late 00s-10s metalcore scene, most of the three word metalcore bands like Black Veil Brides, Sleeping With Sirens, Bring Me the Horizon cite them as an influence.
The whole emo rap scene, Lil Peep sampled The Ghost of You in a song and said that he was a big fan growing up and dressed as Black Parade Gerard Way for Halloween when he was a kid, even bleached his hair for it, pop stars like Post Malone, Billie Eillish, has referenced MCR in her lyrics, copied her green roots black hair look from Gerard, there's multiple photos of her and her brother wearing MCR shirts and attended the reunion shows, Yungblud(obvious MCRfag), MGK, Halsey, Grimes, PinkPantheress said they are her favourite band and used to be in a MCR coverband, indie darlings like Phoebe Bridgers and Julien Baker.
Then there's more modern bands like Creeper, Palale Royale, Palaye Royale, Famous Last Words, 21 Pilots, New Years Day, Save Face, I'm sure there's more.
Most of these artists are dogshit, but the music industry took a huge dive after the 00s and that's a reflection of that. After the 2008 financial crisis the industry stopped funding big theatrical rock bands because they costed more and opted for more laid back lofi artists, so there were less obvious MCR inspired acts than there could be, but their influence can still be seen today.

>>126908156
Didn't read ChatGPT

>>126881780
>>126900115
>they were very successful but you hear zero influence on anyone
MCR has influence across genres and it still echoes to this day with contemporary artists. Artists influenced or inspired by mcr include emo-pop contemporaries that debuted after them like Paramore and Panic at the Disco (there's pictures of Ryan Ross wearing mcr shirts before panic made it), the whole late 00s-10s metalcore scene, most of the three word metalcore bands like Black Veil Brides, Sleeping With Sirens, Bring Me the Horizon cite them as an influence.
The whole emo rap scene, Lil Peep sampled The Ghost of You in a song and said that he was a big fan growing up and dressed as Black Parade Gerard Way for Halloween when he was a kid, even bleached his hair for it, pop stars like Post Malone, Billie Eillish, has referenced MCR in her lyrics, copied her green roots black hair look from Gerard, there's multiple photos of her and her brother wearing MCR shirts and attended the reunion shows, Yungblud(obvious MCRfag), MGK, Halsey, Grimes, PinkPantheress said they are her favourite band and used to be in a MCR coverband, indie darlings like Phoebe Bridgers and Julien Baker.
Then there's more modern bands like Creeper, Palaye Royale, Famous Last Words, 21 Pilots, New Years Day, Save Face, I'm sure there's more.
Most of these artists are dogshit, but the music industry took a huge dive after the 00s and that's a reflection of that. After the 2008 financial crisis the industry stopped funding big theatrical rock bands because they costed more and opted for more laid back lofi artists, so there were less obvious MCR inspired acts than there could be, but their influence can still be seen today.

>>126908171
Still didn't read ChatGPT

>>126908179
>citing an objective list of influenced acts is ChatGPT
I'm sorry that the school system failed you

>>126908193
Did you use an LLM for that little response too homo?

>>126880622 (OP)
The truth is pop punk is one of the worst genres of all time. The peak of 2000s rock is Songs For The Deaf, or one of the first 3 TMV albums, or The Moon Is A Cold Dead World. It surely isn't slop like MCR. I beg of you to listen to more music and stop letting nostalgia blind you.

>>126908218
Again, I'm sorry the school system failed you.

>>126908276
So the answer is yes

Be a man and listen to some Cheap Trick you mallshart loving homosexuals.

>>126908281
>a human couldn't have possibly written a well written, well researched and coherent response
You're pathetic, I genuinely feel sorry for you. I think you might be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HClZwFNNMKs

>>126908307
Didn't watch faggot. Maybe you can ask the LLM to write you an impassioned speech about its worth though

Oh wow, this thread's still going.

(also, yes)

>>126908179
>ChatGPT uses words like MCRfag.

>>126908164
>>126908179
>replies IMMEDIATELY
obsessed
Are you here all day waiting to get back to the MCRfags? LMAO

>>126908337
>obsessed
>generates paragraphs of text about something or other (I dunno, I didn't read it faggot lol)
Are you crying yet?

>>126908316
You didn't need to watch, I know that's too mentally demanding for you, you only need to read the title of the song.

>>126908348
You need to get a job friend. Your parents are worried.

>>126908348
Anon asked for artists influenced by MCR, I provided, what's so hard to understand? It's a long paragraph because they had a lot of influence.

https://kentamplinvocalacademy.com/artists-bands/lead/my-chemical-romance/ , https://www.kerrang.com/12-bands-who-wouldnt-have-been-possible-without-my-chemical-romance

>>126904127
These are two separate arguments about different things made by two different people. Learn to read.

>>126904062
>>126904141
Gerard has a more interesting and distinctive voice, while Patrick has a great standard voice that is not that memorable. Not a difficult concept to grasp. When something is unique it is more polarizing than something technically good.

https://kentamplinvocalacademy.com/artists-bands/lead/my-chemical-romance/ , https://www.grammy.com/news/my-chemical-romance-i-brought-you-bullets-you-brought-me-your-love-redefined-emo-anniversary , https://www.kerrang.com/12-bands-who-wouldnt-have-been-possible-without-my-chemical-romance, https://www.theringer.com/2022/07/26/music/my-chemical-romance-debut-anniversary-best-album-black-parade

>>126906204
you literally spent the whole day obsessing over this thread, it’s very sad. we can see the timestamps, you really need a hobby.

>>126908171
The list of people they influenced is grim. Holy shit.

>>126909453
Fall out boy didn't influence anyone, aside from making everyone think whatever garbage FOB played was utter shit, and should die out.

>>126909541
You're really upset over Fall Out Boy, huh?

no, but it is solid

>>126909453
Keep moving the goalposts, this was response to the claim that they had no influence whatsoever, I admitted that most of these are dogshit, but that's not the point.

>>126909600
Yes.