Have a cigar is the best song on this album

>>127085880 (OP)
thank fuck Roger didnt sing it, as was the original plan and his later regret.
I fully expect the senile old git to release his version before he dies

>>127085880 (OP)
>shine on you crazy diamond parts I-V
>shine on you crazy diamond parts VI-IX
>9 part song
>2 songs
What did they mean by this

>>127085880 (OP)
Aye, that's some really nice phase 90 right there.

>>127085880 (OP)
not very controversial

>>127086234
Don't you dare address Daddy Roger in such an unkind fashion.

i was a novice floyd fan that mostly knew Dark Side and the Wall and was dipping into animals when my punk buddy who didn't even like floyd showed me Have a Cigar to praise it, from there it was album after album, now I'm mostly an Atom Heart Mother and Animals guy

>>127085880 (OP)
No

>>127086234
There is a version of Roger and David singing it together on the Immersion boxset (leaked years earlier on bootlegs) and it isn't very good. To be fair though they are scratch vocals.

>>127085880 (OP)
The whole album is shit

shine on > welcome to the machine > WYWH > Have a cigar

10/10 album

>>127087158
>Animals
If you haven't already then listen to the 8-track version of Pigs on the Wing with Snowy White playing a segue solo between both parts
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfjYV-E3mR8

>>127085880 (OP)
>welcome to the machine
I always skin that one.

>>127087538
same