Have a cigar is the best song on this album
>>127085880 (OP)
thank fuck Roger didnt sing it, as was the original plan and his later regret.
I fully expect the senile old git to release his version before he dies
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 7:28:33 PM
No.127086348
[Report]
>>127085880 (OP)
>shine on you crazy diamond parts I-V
>shine on you crazy diamond parts VI-IX
>9 part song
>2 songs
What did they mean by this
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 7:46:11 PM
No.127086495
[Report]
>>127085880 (OP)
Aye, that's some really nice phase 90 right there.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 8:43:23 PM
No.127087100
[Report]
>>127086234
Don't you dare address Daddy Roger in such an unkind fashion.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 8:47:44 PM
No.127087158
[Report]
>>127087468
i was a novice floyd fan that mostly knew Dark Side and the Wall and was dipping into animals when my punk buddy who didn't even like floyd showed me Have a Cigar to praise it, from there it was album after album, now I'm mostly an Atom Heart Mother and Animals guy
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 9:09:05 PM
No.127087423
[Report]
>>127086234
There is a version of Roger and David singing it together on the Immersion boxset (leaked years earlier on bootlegs) and it isn't very good. To be fair though they are scratch vocals.
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 9:11:21 PM
No.127087445
[Report]
shine on > welcome to the machine > WYWH > Have a cigar
10/10 album
Anonymous
7/18/2025, 9:14:25 PM
No.127087468
[Report]
>>127087158
>Animals
If you haven't already then listen to the 8-track version of Pigs on the Wing with Snowy White playing a segue solo between both parts
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfjYV-E3mR8
