I met an idiot zoomer today who named her dog (poor dog) after this talentless hack. All her songs are noise, seriously they sound like an annoying noise coming from a machine that's about to fully break down any minute. Saw her hosting snl a few years ago and her personality is equally vapid as her 'music' is.

She was shilled to death back in 2018 in order to ensure her success.

Why? Because her handlers at Apple wanted to use her to prove that a "cutting edge" pop star could have a sustainable career due to music streaming.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2L-oNQWx48A

>>127115452
That thumbnail is all I needed to see to know you're a schizo retard and your opinions shouldn't be taken seriously

one hit wonder from last decade

>>127115433 (OP)
I wanna suck on her big veiny tits and then lick her anusse.

One hit wonder. There are many more benee songs that I like so Billie must have connections to keep the shilling going.

>>127115479
he's posting this in literally all Billie threads, usually as the first reply (kinda like >>127115518, could be the same schizo)

>>127115452
I will watch this later. Thanks.

>>127115452
I hate watching long Youtoob vids but this one was actually worth it when I found it a few months ago.

It really tells you a lot about how pop stars are fabricated today by megacorps

>>127115716
Payola has been a thing since the 1940s anon, you are really not as smart as you think you are, in fact you seem extremely dumb/underage considering you just found out about this a few months ago

>>127115716
How are corporations artificially creating hype with forced streaming numbers and spamming youtube/tiktok videos today any different than corporations artificially creating hype by filling tv airtime, paying off radios to spam their artists only and fabricating media stunts in the past before streaming?

>>127115518
>>127115671
One hit wonder? She has 7 top 10 hits, just last year she hit number 2 with Birds of a Feather. You could not escape that song.

The "they only got famous because of streams" argument is extremely retarded when you realize that if it were that easy then the conspiracy retards pushing this idea would've just done it themselves so they wouldn't have to resort to making slop that nobody gives a shit about. Buying views also wouldn't make sense from an business standpoint because it would cost more money than simply finding talent that draws in numbers anyways. It's basic fucking economics.

>>127115741
Trouble understanding plain English?
I said it really tells you about popstar conveyor-belt fabrication TODAY, you moron.

I don't care how the creaky boomer jews were doing it back when Bob Zimmerman was their product

>I’M DEPRESSED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>>127115756
That's the point: the astroturfing via the internet is the new payola.

>>127115859
That's great and all but I think you forgot that the point of running a business is to make money and when given the choice of wasting money buying views to inflate the fame of somebody nobody is going to give a shit about vs simply scouting for talent that people are going to give a shit about, it would make more economic sense to do the ladder would it not? Like even if your plan works you still sunk potentially millions of dollars in the process while competing record companies make more money than you by just not doing this. You do realize the fault in your logic right?

>>127115716
You can't really discuss Billie Eilish without discussing how she was incubated at Platoon, an agency which was run by the co-creator of iTunes and which functions like a label without being one.

What the guy behind the doc argues is, Apple and Spotify are trying to seize control of the music industry from the major labels and are using companies like Platoon in order to do it. Artist signs to Platoon, the artist signs their music away to streaming services without a label acting as a middle-man, and POOF labels become obsolete and artists are now the property of streaming services.

That's exactly why Billie was pushed so hard and relentlessly: she was supposed to be the flagship species for this entire ordeal. Promote her to the point where she inevitably becomes the biggest pop star in the world without much radio airplay but with loads and loads of streams.

>>127115899
Sounds better than being owned by a label.

>>127115917
It is, and I would argue it's why music is actually profitable again if any of this actualy played out like these retards are framing it as.

>>127115878
If you're Apple or Spotify you don't have to spend millions, you just artificially push up your protege's prominence in The Algorithm so everyone is listening to them. Then once you've created the fan base you don't even have to do that, your new pop star is a self-sustaining money printing machine. If it falters you can tweak the settings again, also for free, push them harder for a while and see if they can be resurrected. If not, there's always the next in line.
Meanwhile if you're a traditional record label without your own direct content delivery system you have to buy advertising, pay for radio slots, or pay your new streaming competitors for for a bit of Algorithmic favour, all with actual real money.

>>127115899
Yeah exactly, thanks for writing a summary for the unbelievers. I was too lazy to put time into that

>>127115917
It's not.
Despite being so criticised labels played their gatekeeper of tastes role very well until the 90s.
Those scouters actually had good taste and that's how we got those great bands that came from the underground being signed to more prominent labels.

Once big tech megacorps like Apple replaced labels, what you get is diversity-tier popstars pushed because they're women, brown, gay, nonbinary, latino etc, because Apple's corporate culture demands colourful gay content on their devices.

>this entire thread

>>127115479
He’s right though

>>127115917
Not really. It amounts to two groups of capitalists fighting each other. Lucian Grainge and the other old label heads vs. Daniel Ek and Tim Cook. Not really better for the artists especially given that streaming services have the ability to memory hole an artist's entire discography by simply removing them from their platforms. Big Tech isn't just about profit but about social control.

>>127116053
>you just artificially push up your protege's prominence in The Algorithm so everyone is listening to them.
Yes, back in 2018 Billie's music was always popping up on Spotify. Her songs were in multiple playlists and you couldn't escape her. That's how much she was being astroturfed.

>>127116167
What's weird about the Apple doc mentioned in picrel is how it was being filmed as Billie and Finneas were working on their debut album It was if Apple knew in advance how successful she was going to be.

>>127116086
Queers and blacks make great music though so idk if this is a huge problem, or even changes anything about the music industry.

>>127116221
Her debut album released in 2017 anon, the documentary began production in 2018, quick turnaround sure but don't be retarded, she was already well known by that point for songs like Ocean Eyes

>>127116059
One thing I forgot to mention is how a lot of this (and this is mentioned early on in the doc) was triggered by the crisis that happened in the music industry in the early-mid 2000s whereby album sales started becoming abysmal. Every time an industry (or the capitalist system itself) goes into crisis, you see rival groups of capitalists fight with each other in order to take control of said industry and stabilize it, and make the losing capitalists pay for the cleanup (so to say). That's exactly what Apple was doing here. So, come the early-2000s, illegal music downloading is still a thing even if Napster is in hot water, album sales are at an all-time low, music industry is in crisis mode. That guy Feigelson (or whatever his name is) comes up with iTunes and later proposes what ends up becoming the prototype for music streaming. Years later Apple decides to go all-in and Feigelson and his buddies establish Platoon.

>>127116263
>Her debut album released in 2017 anon,
That was an EP, not an album.

>she was already well known by that point for songs like Ocean Eyes
Ocean Eyes wasn't a Billboard hit until late 2018, like three years after it was posted to SoundCloud.

>>127116292
>That was an EP, not an album.
You're splitting hairs now you pedantic fuck, Don't Smile at Me had a proper release by a proper record label.

.

>>127115479
>schizo retard
and you're an ableist chud fuck off back to pol

>>127116292
Here’s before industry push and Apple Music
https://x.com/chartdata/status/991085624487591936?s=46
And here’s after industry push and Apple Music
https://x.com/chartdata/status/1115387025937575938
https://x.com/chartdata/status/1114982338528727042

>Record Labels....PROMOTE ARTISTS???
Isn't that literally their job? To promote their talent? I mean fuck man if I worked in the industry and my label wasn't promoting me I'd be pissed. How the fuck is this even a conspiracy theory? You're all retarded, go outside and touch grass

>>127116377
>You're all retarded, go outside and touch grass
so much ableism in this thread fuck off back to pol bigot

/mu/ now hates Billie but simps Shitlivia and Shitbrina, both of which are the same inorganic out-of-nowhere industry plant, but instead of Apple Music, it’s Disney. You’re all hypocritical retards who can go fuck yourselves. Thanks for reading.

>>127116341
I’m a diagnosed sperg and anyone who gets offended by the word retard in 2025 is retarded

https://strawpoll.com/poy9kzowQgJ/

>>127115841
Kek

>>127115433 (OP)
OHM novelty act and that's all.

>>127116086
>Once big tech megacorps like Apple replaced labels, what you get is diversity-tier popstars pushed because they're women, brown, gay, nonbinary, latino etc, because Apple's corporate culture demands colourful gay content on their devices.

That was more to do with them getting USAID bucks (now killed)

>>127116421
We hate Billie because she refuses to show off her tits, we don't hate the other two because they always show off their assets.

>>127115452
>cutting edge
>was absolutely generic and exactly like every other faux-2010s "bedroom pop" girl

>>127115899
>Promote her to the point where she inevitably becomes the biggest pop star in the world
...for six months in 2019

>>127115782
>She has 7 top 10 hits

And yet no one has heard them.

>>127117453
You mean YOU haven't heard them

>>127116853
and some jews joined the nazis whats your point?

I liken her to Gogi Grant or Brian Hyland or one of those people from the 50s-60s who had a meme novelty hit and a bunch of other chart filler "hits" nobody listened to and nobody remembers anymore;

>>127115433 (OP)
Say what you will, but you can't deny her brother was onto something on 2019 with their debut album. Shit was good.

>>127117493
Shouldn't you be throwing Molotov cocktails at ICE agents now, Finneas?

>>127117493
I hated it back then because it was all the same whispery ASMR crap. YSSMIAC was the only real stand-out song in that entire album. She proved she actually had range with Happier Than Ever.

>>127117551
I mean, technically Ariana Grande can sing too but after album one they just told her to do a fake blaccent.

>>127117530
Idk man, when it came out it was the first time I enjoyed pop since lady gaga. I still listen to bury a friend.

>>127116421
>so much ableism in this thread fuck off back to pol bigot
Kill yourself tranny, you are on the wrong website.

Bitch blatantly lied about her age, she's 32 and claims to be about 26.

>>127115433 (OP)
>>127117551
I find it funny how 90% of the Billie -stans from back then were boomers.

>>127117453
I heard Birds of a Feather like a billion times last year

>>127117464
i'm subjected to a lot of slop radio at my work and recognise a lot of new songs when discussed here. just about every new single gets played for a few months after release whether it's good or bad. maybe her hits aren't big where i am or i genuinely can't tell when it's her but literally the only song i know is the bad guy one.

>>127118063
I never hear that shit anywhere if I'm in a store or restaurant I mostly hear 70s-80s music.

>>127118067
>I mostly hear 70s-80s music.
same but with an equal amount of newslop mixed in

Daily reminder.

>>127118171
i have no idea what this means lol

>>127115790
so it just boils down to our education system has obliterated the majority of people's minds replacing once functional grey matter with garbage? Does lower IQ have to always result in lowering ability to appreciate good art/music?

>>127118227
It’s Billie and her bf Nath Wolf in Italy

>>127118227
She’s for white millennial cocks only despite the lesbian publicity stunt?

Reminder that she dated black guys until one beat the shit out of her and since then she only dates white guys.

>>127118324
That nig beating damaged her brain and now they call it non-verbal Tourette's syndrome: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21VxWSekvQE haha, so typical of the jews to do and say absolutely ANTYING but the truth about violent negros..

>>127115433 (OP)
Titties

>>127115452
Holy shit. Just finished watching the whole thing. I was not ready for that redpill.

>>127116306
Interesting. So they’re still pushing her hard.

>>127117530
Finneas is an AOC liberal. He’s attacked radical leftists for refusing to vote for Kamala.

>>127115452

>>127115433 (OP)

>what's her appeal exactly?


I PRESUME THAT IT IS HER «VIBE»(L O L); UNITEDSTATIAN Z00MERS BELIEVE THAT «BLACK» IS TANTAMOUNT TO «C00L», THEREFORE, «WIGGER» IDENTITY IS THEIR PROTOTYPE, AND SHE PERSONIFIES THAT PROTOTYPE THE BEST.

>>127115452
>only 245k views
This doc deserves 5 million views.

Everyone needs to know the dirty schemes of Big Tech.

>>127120661
Was that all caps spergout during the BLM riots due to her being scared, you think?

>>127115433 (OP)
industry plant
not very talented

It’s not that I deny she’s an industry plant. It’s just that I’m frustrated at the hypocrisy of /mu/ shitting on Billie for being an industry plant, but refusing to admit that the two talentless sluts from Disney that are constantly posted here are industry plants too, both with an even less organic rise to fame at that.

>>127123304
Of course they are. You're probably arguing with bots all day.

>>127123606
Point taken. Not sure why I keep coming back here desu.

Dead internet theory is particularly strong on 4chan.

>>127123304
At least they're kind of fuckable while Billie looks like Jabba the Hut.

>>127123648
No they're not

>>127123648
That’s irrelevant to their music, which is trash.

>>127123648
Billie can actually sing compared to them. Now she can't sing very well, but at least she tries. Those other whores can't carry a tune to save their lives.

>>127123721
None of them can sing to be honest. I don’t get why people think Billie has “range” when she still sounds like a little girl.

>>127115433 (OP)
The fact people compare this talentless count to Kate Bush and Diamanda Galas is a crime.