Why are rock songs so stitched together? - /mu/ (#127284742) [Archived: 286 hours ago]

Anonymous
8/4/2025, 2:33:22 PM No.127284742
e5debddf83281d534c5e8d09681d6591
e5debddf83281d534c5e8d09681d6591
md5: 40e02c219538a54e23ee3d8b933790b9๐Ÿ”
More often than not the verse is completely compositionally disconnected from the chorus and both are completely disconnected from the bridge. Maybe an intro that just plays the melody from the chorus or the chord progression is shared between verse and chorus (even lazier). There is no building on established material or any real musical fabric holding it together, its just shit stitched together with no continuity. It doesn't go anywhere either, the end of the song often sounds completely identical to the beginning and it never feels like a complete expierence to listen to.

Like even old broadway hits still have more creative songwriting than most rock bands and those are in 32 bar form which is far simpler of a structure than verse chorus, why is rock music so incredibly lazy?

Mahler.
Replies: >>127284937 >>127285021 >>127285087 >>127285152 >>127287454
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:02:48 PM No.127284886
i like that cute dog, so bump
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:05:50 PM No.127284902
this is a good thread.
>why is rock music so incredibly lazy?
because its cemented on tribal african drum slapping. no matter how you try to embellish it, it is what it is. prog tried to give rock some semblance of narrative but you get circus shit like bohemian rhapsody or the abbey road medley.
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:14:35 PM No.127284937
>>127284742 (OP)
Don't care, sounds good and rocking
>inb4 pleb, retard or whatever insult you have
Replies: >>127285069
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:18:38 PM No.127284951
>More often than not the verse is completely compositionally disconnected from the chorus and both are completely disconnected from the bridge
why shouldnt they be? you write as if its a given or objective fact that thematic continuity and development is required or superior but thats a misconception, its a purely subjective opinion. one might ask the question why are you incapable of riding the changes between verse, chorus and bridge? such flexibility in composition, and crucially, in the appreciative abilities of the listener, must necessarily lead to freedom from rigid forms and greater expression in some regards. insisting that music always conform to pre-existing standard practices is limiting and backward-looking.
Replies: >>127287230
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:21:08 PM No.127284966
Life is stitched together. A life isn't a carefully plotted narrative with interwoven themes, it's a mess of semi-random events and longueurs that can only be understood in retrospect, if then. Rock was an efflorescence of culture that tried to capture that, a peek into every day lives that novels, plays, symphonies could never really depict. And that is exactly why it became so popular, it spoke to people and their messy, insufficient, momentary lives.
Replies: >>127285059 >>127287368
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:29:40 PM No.127285021
>>127284742 (OP)
Can you give an example of a rock song and a Broadway hit to illustrate your point?
Replies: >>127287244
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:31:45 PM No.127285038
fuck off tranny
Replies: >>127285119 >>127287304
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:33:52 PM No.127285059
>>127284966
>life has no meaning bro, just consume slop bro
spoken like a true hylic.
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:34:53 PM No.127285069
>>127284937
her insults are cute, shut up
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:37:31 PM No.127285087
>>127284742 (OP)
You'll love Black Sabbath or Stoner Rock in general
Replies: >>127287289
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:44:46 PM No.127285119
>>127285038
pretentious tranny or pretentious chud I can't tell
Replies: >>127287304
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:50:03 PM No.127285152
>>127284742 (OP)
i disagree with your premise.
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 3:52:00 PM No.127285163
This is why you ascend to the le high IQ realm and get into prog.
Replies: >>127287271
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 4:01:26 PM No.127285236
Because Broadway hits were written by academics and rock songs were written by and for teenagers
Replies: >>127285504
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 4:56:37 PM No.127285504
>>127285236
I wouldn't call Irving Berlin an academic but I agree with your general point
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:41:06 PM No.127287230
maxresdefault (2)
maxresdefault (2)
md5: f580707859d6d81747e59e86a7ad810c๐Ÿ”
>>127284951
This is like saying that story structure does not need characters or a consistent plot and can be just a bunch of moments stitched together. Just because music is a medium not taken seriously enough and is filled with relativist retards like you doesn't mean it's true. Hmpf!
Replies: >>127287328
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:42:31 PM No.127287244
pouting-senko-v0-xf57nbbvzcid1
pouting-senko-v0-xf57nbbvzcid1
md5: 5037bdd3be2a1de39b5c3dd91a732e20๐Ÿ”
>>127285021
Back in Black by ACDC

My Favorite Things from the Sound Of Music
Replies: >>127287379
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:44:30 PM No.127287271
ddy8ldn-75531c16-df3d-4516-b1c7-bbb81db8468f
ddy8ldn-75531c16-df3d-4516-b1c7-bbb81db8468f
md5: 2ad081437d2723f39668180deeb678b4๐Ÿ”
>>127285163
Prog is not good either and suffers from the same problem over a larger span of time. Tarkus is literally a bunch of disconnected shit stitched together. As are most long songs in pr*g rock
Replies: >>127287343
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:45:47 PM No.127287289
raf,360x360,075,t,fafafa_ca443f4786
raf,360x360,075,t,fafafa_ca443f4786
md5: 76c8d3512593d396252a67acf35ad969๐Ÿ”
>>127285087
Hmpf!

Absolutely and certainly hate everything in rock that I have heard. Even if I wanted to listen to lesser music I would prefer to spend that time listening to Mahler!
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:47:06 PM No.127287304
bread
bread
md5: 2f0ab10e7ceee95c35de2213b0825a67๐Ÿ”
>>127285038
>>127285119
I am not trans and my favorite composer is jewish so definitely not a chud either.

What I am is "correct"!
Replies: >>127287362 >>127287459
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:49:20 PM No.127287328
>>127287230
>does not need characters or a consistent plot and can be just a bunch of moments stitched together.
Isn't that just In Search of Lost Time, one of the most acclaimed works in literature?
Replies: >>127287404
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:50:15 PM No.127287343
>>127287271
Who cares. Shit that is predictable and the same stupid annoying formula like pop music is just so boring and uninteresting. I dont want to hear the same verse chorus verse nonsense. Zoomers like shit really gay and sounding exactly the same over and over and never get tired of it

Circus music is great too. You guys are just boring fucks with garbage taste. Id rather have you eat a bullet than listen to kpop
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:51:21 PM No.127287362
>>127287304
Only trannys make posts with these cute childish anime kind of characters that a 13 year old girl would use. Cringe.
Replies: >>127287415
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:51:55 PM No.127287368
0akb4tmpq6761
0akb4tmpq6761
md5: a6eaad38c42afd0c176962671dad47e0๐Ÿ”
>>127284966
Life is a series of reactions from the moment you step out of the womb. Causality dictates that everything you do is a product of that which happened before. Even if something supposedly random happens, the reason you expierenced it is the series of choices that lead to that particular point in time
Replies: >>127287459
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:52:56 PM No.127287379
>>127287244
Back in Black does not sound like a pastiche. And if you like The Sound of Music and Mahler maybe you just like Austria.
Replies: >>127287460
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:54:54 PM No.127287404
download
download
md5: 69b87b8400350b3f09c499c8956dd5d1๐Ÿ”
>>127287328
It still has a rhyme and reason. A rock song's musical structure often does not. Disgusting that you even compare rockslop to that! Hmpf!
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:55:56 PM No.127287415
senkooooo
senkooooo
md5: e2153773e542ece0b6f447990f4fa123๐Ÿ”
>>127287362
Dont know why cute girls annoy you so much
Replies: >>127287455
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:59:15 PM No.127287454
1725445117876888
1725445117876888
md5: 0672832637e1e64f221fe59ceaab7bd6๐Ÿ”
>>127284742 (OP)
You won't like my 2nd
Hnngph! :p
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:59:16 PM No.127287455
>>127287415
Its not a cute girl its a waifu cartoon character that losers jerk off to
Replies: >>127287503
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:59:44 PM No.127287459
>>127287368
>>127287304
Retard fat zoomer manlet larping as girl-breadโ€ฆ stop trying to drop gnawledge because you donโ€™t have any.

Musicals are significantly more repetitive because they have to actually create the sounds live sometimes only with the performers voices. Whereas on albums artists can use something called โ€œproductionโ€ to differentiate parts of the song.

https://youtu.be/i6-X5cZzrUw
The usual thing is to make the instruments more lush and layered as the song progresses.

https://youtu.be/KRXty8lDUW0
Lot of rock singers will put more effort into the vocals as the song progresses.
Replies: >>127287482
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 8:59:56 PM No.127287460
218150ed1952f9fd6eea3df8e9efe24513b9559014267070c56c14483c68b6b8_thumb
>>127287379
I do like austria! While I am ukranian, my family is part austrian nobility!
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 9:01:50 PM No.127287482
senko-the-upset-wife-800x450
senko-the-upset-wife-800x450
md5: 989f53b5b4bdc12473b6c72d98d0365a๐Ÿ”
>>127287459
>butthole survers
I am NOT listening to something with that undecent of a name, Hmpf!

Also there is nothing wrong with being brlow 5"7 shut up
Replies: >>127287546 >>127287555 >>127287559
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 9:03:34 PM No.127287503
senko-lol
senko-lol
md5: c3c895f56375a48106167f6ceba2321b๐Ÿ”
>>127287455
She's my wife!!!!!!!
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 9:07:29 PM No.127287546
>>127287482
>Also there is nothing wrong with being brlow 5"7 shut up
Rape
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 9:09:14 PM No.127287555
>>127287482
>5'7"
what's your number
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 9:09:38 PM No.127287559
>>127287482
"Indecent"
Why are zoomers worse than church lady's now? Wtf happened
Replies: >>127287659
Anonymous
8/4/2025, 9:20:37 PM No.127287659
wp4366692
wp4366692
md5: 71caa0f1c92f4d9b6eeb4b0512d7ae90๐Ÿ”
>>127287559
Why is it wrong if I dislike indecency?? "Butthole surfers" is just immature and insulting to whoever it speaks toward! Call your band a normal name dang it! Hmpf!