Thread 127646770

I remember being sheltered 16 year old listening to this album the first time.
I looked at the lyrics book first. Saw Not Now John and just from the "desert" vibe I got from PF at the time, with Wish You Were Here especially, and having listened to it on trips to western United States, I expected it to be this sort of lowly strumming guitar song like a bunch of sad old cowboys sitting on dusty front porches.

Instead I got rollicking rock n roll, with the ending sounding like a fascist rally, biting cynical lyrics (to me as a teenager it was at least). I must have listened to that song 10 times in a row. I was addicted to it. For years it was my favorite Pink Floyd song alongside Wish You Were Here. Now? I still like it desu.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=krUoy2-cMMs
Wish this cover had been around in 2010 when I was obsessed with the song.

Anonymous 9/5/2025, 10:40:08 PM No.127648009 [Report] >>127648324

>>127647266
David, please

Anonymous 9/5/2025, 10:40:58 PM No.127648025 [Report]

>>127646871
fpbp

TFC is a "highlights from the wall when you don't have time to listen to the Wall"

Anonymous 9/5/2025, 10:47:59 PM No.127648121 [Report]

Atom Heart Mother is the adult album

Anonymous 9/5/2025, 11:01:54 PM No.127648324 [Report] >>127649208

>>127648009
Did Roger pay you money to say this?

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 12:18:32 AM No.127649051 [Report] >>127649208 >>127649219 >>127649765

>>127646871
I don't particularly care for Pigs or Sheep -- I don't hate them, I just don't love them, Sheep especially. If it were just Pigs on the Wing & Dogs, Animals would be the greatest EP in music history. What does everyone think of "You've Got to Be Crazy" aka the demo for Dogs?

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 12:34:24 AM No.127649208 [Report]

>>127648324
Rent free>>127649051
Dogs is perfect

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 12:35:25 AM No.127649219 [Report] >>127649239

>>127649051
>You've Got to Be Crazy
Where does this song exist?

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 12:37:26 AM No.127649239 [Report] >>127649729

>>127649219
Concert bootlegs
https://youtu.be/jqULy8xQjZU?si=Of5h9-kWpgtfQ0OO

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:18:17 AM No.127649548 [Report] >>127649641

The Final Cut is a fine album, I don't get the hate just because Roger was an asshole about it

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:28:33 AM No.127649641 [Report]

>>127649548
His vocal delivery is nuts I love it

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:34:13 AM No.127649698 [Report]

>>127647266
based. this is real floyd

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:38:37 AM No.127649729 [Report]

>>127649239
This is my preferred version. Feels hazier, dreamier
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gEhqT_HXCyw

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:40:57 AM No.127649748 [Report]

>>127646770 (OP)
Everything I hate about Roger shines in this album. He's such an insufferable fag.

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:42:25 AM No.127649765 [Report] >>127649787

>>127649051
Sheep has arguably the best climax of their entire catalog. That guitar is explosive

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:42:33 AM No.127649766 [Report]

Adulthood is realizing Wish You Were Here is the best

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:45:02 AM No.127649787 [Report]

>>127649765
Now that bootlegs have come up, this does the guitar climax even better
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHmcrn3CNFw
and has an added keyboard bit to bask in the afterglow of the orgasm

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:54:03 AM No.127649885 [Report] >>127649926

OBJECTIVELY BEST PINK FLOYD ALBUMS
1. Piper at the Gates of Dawn
2. The Final Cut
3. Meddle

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 1:58:06 AM No.127649926 [Report]

>>127649885
>piper but no wish you were here
lol?

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 2:00:54 AM No.127649953 [Report]

IMG_5946.jpg md5: 6ca1f45a...

this is my favorite from pink floyd

Anonymous 9/6/2025, 2:05:09 AM No.127650004 [Report]

DSOTM
Meddle
SOS

It's something like that.Possibly Ummagumma comes into the game somewhere