Thread 128039893

"Echoes" is objectively the best song of all time.

>>128039893 (OP)
correct.

>>128039893 (OP)
Its akshually in my life by the beetles

>>128039936
thats not even a good song

I dont like the chromatic runs

>>128039893 (OP)
sexy basslines

>>128039893 (OP)
*Ping*
How did they do it?

Lol no. Not even the best pink floyd song.

>>128040178
which one
is it IVE GOT A BIKE
YOU CAN RIDE IT IF YOU LIKE

it's an elephant trunk

>>128040081
https://youtu.be/GUHrxuhXfHg

>>128039893 (OP)
I think every other song on that album is better actually

>>128039893 (OP)
not even the best song on the album
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhUW7A3qjY4

>>128041304
>slow blues song with a dog barking is better than the masterpiece of the epic
no

>>128039893 (OP)
It's not long island city here I come, so no

>formless pr*gslop by people who wish they could be classical composers
Hmpf! Listen to some Mahler if this impresses you! You'll see how CRAP this is!

www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZIDxZK8mnBg

>>128039893 (OP)
not even the best PF song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1OOQP1-wOE

>>128041609
Based

SYD mogs

>>128040178
Worthless post

>>128039893 (OP)
The last resolution with that "motorbike" sequence makes less and less sense the more I listen to it.

>>128039893 (OP)
When I was a kid I used to put myself into a state of hypnosis with this song

>>128039893 (OP)
Patrician
I also appreciate listening to rarer versions of the song. Gilmour's Live in Gdansk version has amazing bass for example https://youtu.be/EMneCi9F_UQ?si=xscLl_GFUKTUg8Hx

>>128042122
That's Dogs, you silly!

>>128039893 (OP)
I like the funky jam in the middle but you can shove the whale shit up your ass, hippy.

the sync to 2001 A Space Odyysey is perfect, maybe TOO perfect.
I'm sure they did it on purpose
https://youtu.be/rn7MmS3vazU?si=aCZhTpW44r2Y3-K4

>>128039893 (OP)
>>128039909
>>128040178
>>128041066
>>128041698
>>128042656
>>128042533
Listen to more music

I have an edit of Echoes that removes the weird whalsong section and replaces it with "One of These Days". its far superior to the original.

I put it on Soulseek

>>128039893 (OP)
Meddle [Harvest, 1971]
Not bad. "Echoes" moves through 23:21 of "Across the Universe" cop with the timeless calm of interstellar overdrive, and the acoustic-type folk songs boast their very own melodies (as well as a real dog, rather than electronic seagulls, for sound effect). The word "behold" should never cross their filters again, but this is definitely an improvement: one eensy-weensy step for humanity, one giant step for Pink Floyd. B-

I prefer dogs and atom heart mother as far as their long songs go

>>128041609
You will never be funny

>>128045206
He isn't trying to be funny, he is just speaking the truth

>>128040011
what's this? I know shit bout music theory

>>128045358
>truth

>>128041066
Contrarian

>>128042769
I know what I said niga.

>>128045184
AHM should have been replaced with granchester meadows

I like San Tropez

>>128039893 (OP)
>there are people that were so filtered, they edited the coliseum version down to the guitar solo only.
i mean it's great but please, I need the whole thing
>>128041609
where that tail poking from?

>>128039893 (OP)
>third best song on Pink Floyd's fifth best album is somehow the best song of all time
k

Worst on the album, I even like seamus and san tropez more

>>128039893 (OP)
The squeaking parts in the middle were kinda boring.

contrarianism used to be subtle

>>128045393
>nu/mu/cacas dont even know what "chromatic" means
Embarassing! Get a different hobby

>>128046973
>where that tail poking from?
Her back!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

>>128043847
Wow, rock "criticism" is the most retarded possible occupation possible, imagin3 being paid to be an easily impressed retard who doesnt understand music

>>128043169
Remove the entire song next! And listen to good music like Mahler and Bruckner instead of this crappy crap poopy dumb music!

>>128039893 (OP)
"objective" is really a good word to describe it. perhaps "impersonal" would do it as well. like it's not my personal favourite song of all time (The 15th by Wire), but i do think it's incredibly good, and anyone with some amount of taste for popular music should be able to see that. it takes every common element of song structure and takes every part of it to its logical extreme, in the best way possible.

I only recently discovered that the cover of this album is actually a photo of an ear. I always thought it was an aerial photo of some paradise island in the middle of the ocean. The green highlighted part would be the "main" island, the blue would be the water, obviously, and the brownish part would be coral or even the beach sand itself, which would be visible because of the crystal-clear water.

My life is an illusion.

>>128042656
>patrician
>rock music
You can only choose one.

>>128039893 (OP)
Cover by False Front and deaner with the golden jew

https://youtube.com/watch?v=xSDoV6KJ20k

>>128050412
>popular music
>taste
Pick one lmao

>>128050412
Objectively POOPY more like! Hmpf! Imagine liking this garbage

>>128039893 (OP)
>is objectively the best song of all time.
Yadayasa stfu

>>128050788
if you combine the front and the back cover it becomes clearer

Roger knew. all along.

>>128050788
Thanks, now I see it. I’m in my 40s and always thought it was some kind of bird embryo