← Home ← Back to /mu/

Thread 128291766

32 posts 12 images /mu/
Anonymous No.128291766 [Report] >>128291794 >>128291972 >>128292005 >>128292167 >>128292773 >>128292990 >>128293273
Is it possible to dislike this album?
Anonymous No.128291777 [Report] >>128291874
somebody post *that* user review
Anonymous No.128291794 [Report] >>128292185
>>128291766 (OP)
Disposable Heroes is one of my favorite Metallica songs. It takes a lot of stamina to play. I never found Thing that Should Not Be or Leper Messiah to be very interesting tho
Anonymous No.128291848 [Report] >>128291866
around 4 thousand people rated it under 3 stars on rym (me included)
Anonymous No.128291866 [Report] >>128291956
>>128291848
but why
Anonymous No.128291874 [Report] >>128291989 >>128293855
>>128291777

This album is the Nirvana "Smells like Teen Spirit" of heavy metal. It brought heavy metal to its knees, and castrated it mightily. It is, then, by definition, the most damaging, counterproductive, and overrated LP ever to be released. Even standing it up on its own, and not letting it poison the minds of those that came after it, I wouldn't even put it in the top 10 most influential thrash releases of 1986... it's easily killed by the unholy trinity of Darkness Descends, Reign in Blood, and Pleasure to Kill, which pushed the envelope of metal in three different, related directions. It's not anywhere nearly as enjoyable as expatriate Mustaine's Peace Sells, which was technically brilliant and a whole barrel of fun too, or as dark as Possessed's sophomore effort, or Sepultura and Sodom's full-length debuts. It's not nearly as punk-as-fun as Nuclear Assault's first. Then I could throw in fifteen, if not fifty, other backwash thrash LPs that did nothing for the genre as far as influence goes, but are still a whole fuckload more enjoyable than this one.
Anonymous No.128291956 [Report] >>128292286
>>128291866
because half of the tracks feels like a greatest hits collection and half of the tracks feel like filler
Anonymous No.128291972 [Report] >>128291980
>>128291766 (OP)
there could be a bit less reverb on the vocals
Anonymous No.128291980 [Report]
>>128291972
Came here to say that.
Anonymous No.128291989 [Report]
>>128291874
Anonymous No.128292005 [Report] >>128292158 >>128292206 >>128292211 >>128292235 >>128292247 >>128292396 >>128292847
>>128291766 (OP)
Anonymous No.128292158 [Report]
>>128292005
prog derangement syndrome
Anonymous No.128292167 [Report]
>>128291766 (OP)
RTL is better but Mop is 2nd best
Anonymous No.128292185 [Report]
>>128291794
That’s because Disposable is literally the best Metallica song. Damage Inc. is a close second, in my opinion.
Anonymous No.128292206 [Report]
>>128292005
Lmao. Either the biggest troll review ever or that guy is just not living in reality, whatsoever. The Archives are filled with some of the gayest metal heads ever.
Anonymous No.128292211 [Report]
>>128292005
Why are metalheads like this?
Anonymous No.128292235 [Report]
>>128292005
Anonymous No.128292247 [Report] >>128293940
>>128292005
>Cliff Burtons hippie tendencies
What did he mean by this
Anonymous No.128292268 [Report]
anyone who doesn't think this album is a 10 is thinking way too much into it
Anonymous No.128292286 [Report]
>>128291956
i wish people would understand that something not being a highlight makes it filler. or even thinking "song i don't like" is filler. the only true filler track on this album is the 3rd one, made last minute to literally 'fill' the album. it's not bad either, it serves as a nice slowdown.
Anonymous No.128292396 [Report]
>>128292005
He is, unfortunately, entirely correct.
Anonymous No.128292773 [Report] >>128293091 >>128293392
>>128291766 (OP)
MOP has everything, lyrics, themes, weight, it sounds fresh and original, it sounds modern I mean, it doesn't sound like an 80s record in the same of being relevant and modern even to this day.

Orion is my fav.
Anonymous No.128292847 [Report]
>>128292005
Holy fuck. I’ve seen some long ass reviews on metallum but never seen an essay of cope that bad
Anonymous No.128292990 [Report]
>>128291766 (OP)
This album is everything. I was listening to it today and was literally in tears over how iconic it is
Anonymous No.128293091 [Report]
>>128292773
>Orion is my fav.
Based
Anonymous No.128293273 [Report]
>>128291766 (OP)
nah. but I don't like Justice, personally. the band died with Cliff.
Anonymous No.128293313 [Report]
It’s very well produced. And justice which came after this is terrible sounding in comparison.
Anonymous No.128293392 [Report] >>128293408
>>128292773
exciter heavy metal maniac is superior
Anonymous No.128293397 [Report]
It's fine but the guitars sound like shit, Metallica's guitars sounded really bad in their "prime era"
they sound good on the Black Album though
Anonymous No.128293408 [Report]
>>128293392
I consider both albums good. I actually own an Exciter shirt.
Anonymous No.128293855 [Report]
>>128291874
actual genre tourist, that was AJFA
retard can't even meme with nuance
Anonymous No.128293940 [Report]
>>128292247
he was a stoner and composed about stoner crap