Why does the west not respect it's history in movies/television. - /pol/ (#507964862) [Archived: 1036 hours ago]

Anonymous ID: rYC4DQ5gUnited Kingdom
6/19/2025, 12:00:11 PM No.507964862
clear-inspiration-for-armor-design-of-nolans-odyssey-v0-phqbgnz5bioe1
>See Western media
>Pretty much no medieval european historical dramas at all
>Any time we get even a taste of European history, it's Pic related fucking awfulness or Leather biker daddy.
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/VRCliJk93xo
>See Chinese media
>Dominated by medieval historical dramas that actually are costume/armour accurate
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YejZbO3J2es
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9SWMx_a4I8
What gives? Why can China make historically accurate dramas and shows, yet the West can't even get the basics of the purpose of armor down right?
Replies: >>507965076 >>507965220 >>507965326 >>507965411 >>507965522 >>507965530 >>507965727 >>507966334 >>507966412 >>507966735 >>507967073 >>507967556 >>507967713 >>507967823 >>507968087 >>507968426 >>507968625 >>507969392 >>507969595 >>507969940 >>507970483 >>507970777 >>507971006 >>507971608 >>507972047 >>507972059 >>507972427
Anonymous ID: NhlCqPQqUnited States
6/19/2025, 12:01:50 PM No.507964945
This is a fantasy movie. It doesn't have to be historically accurate
Replies: >>507966148 >>507966430 >>507966482
Anonymous ID: hiSN/1I+France
6/19/2025, 12:04:03 PM No.507965076
>>507964862 (OP)
jews
Anonymous ID: W6vYKDIc
6/19/2025, 12:06:41 PM No.507965220
>>507964862 (OP)
The West in general was hijacked by the Financial class and they care more about abstract fashion rather than pomp to make the workers happy.
Anonymous ID: uGtqPjY7
6/19/2025, 12:08:41 PM No.507965326
>>507964862 (OP)
do you even own the Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo dvd punk?
Anonymous ID: 1qmDr07y
6/19/2025, 12:10:22 PM No.507965411
image_12959e-Dendra-Armor
image_12959e-Dendra-Armor
md5: 457d7f35ccd51a8cc57dcd922f8befd7๐Ÿ”
>>507964862 (OP)
a real armor set from Greek bronze age looked more like a picrel
Replies: >>507965714 >>507967484
Anonymous ID: VAIbRYFWSpain
6/19/2025, 12:12:22 PM No.507965522
>>507964862 (OP)
Jews
Anonymous ID: 4CHvtNdYPortugal
6/19/2025, 12:12:31 PM No.507965530
trying not to laugh
trying not to laugh
md5: ca1ab0c29f2d570d4cf7c74041de3b95๐Ÿ”
>>507964862 (OP)
>s that actually are costume/armour accurate
Anonymous ID: EodWniHqUnited Kingdom
6/19/2025, 12:13:13 PM No.507965578
>China
>historically accurate drams
Kek I've never seen even a single good (mainland) chinese movie. They're even worse than Bollywood for absurdity.
Replies: >>507966225 >>507968144
Anonymous ID: C661DM1hNetherlands
6/19/2025, 12:15:56 PM No.507965714
>>507965411
>everyone else still in loincloths and thatched shields kek
> niggers still doing this kek
Anonymous ID: 0loTNMIxUnited States
6/19/2025, 12:16:08 PM No.507965727
>>507964862 (OP)
>Dominated by medieval historical dramas that actually are costume/armour accurate
Are you sure about that?
>What gives? Why can China make historically accurate dramas and shows, yet the West can't even get the basics of the purpose of armor down right?
China pioneered the "Swords cutting through armor" trope. There has only ever been a handful of movies that got costumes AND tactics correct, and none of them have been done by the chinks. They are too brain broken by their Wushu superstitions.
Anonymous ID: zO7R6FblPoland
6/19/2025, 12:24:10 PM No.507966148
>>507964945
Ita not fantasy but mythology. Mythology explains the process of reincarnating in the kin. Niggers are not in the kin. Weapons and armour should be historically accurate because they carry memories
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 12:25:41 PM No.507966225
>>507965578
Kung fu Hustle was good. So was Shaolin Soccer.
Replies: >>507966335
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 12:27:37 PM No.507966334
>>507964862 (OP)
Oh yeah, Borgia was pretty good. Sharpe too, but that was a standalone historic fiction nocel before being made into TV.
Anonymous ID: 0loTNMIxUnited States
6/19/2025, 12:27:39 PM No.507966335
>>507966225
Hong Kong is not mainland China.
Replies: >>507966538
Anonymous ID: M+u2gtyRFinland
6/19/2025, 12:28:44 PM No.507966412
>>507964862 (OP)
(((western media))) is a propaganda tool. A constant stream of humiliation rituals. They destroy it on purpose. It's called "subverting expectations" I mean wtf, they are literally saying it's subversive loud and proud.
>hamburgers
Anonymous ID: zO7R6FblPoland
6/19/2025, 12:28:55 PM No.507966430
>>507964945
Its not fantasy but mythology. Mythology explains the process of reincarnating in the kin. Niggers are not the kin. Weapons and armour should be historically accurate because they carry memories and help to remember the past
Anonymous ID: ARJ/70kVSwitzerland
6/19/2025, 12:29:46 PM No.507966482
>>507964945
Might as well give them some machine guns then if it doesn't need to be historically accurate.
Replies: >>507966743
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 12:31:00 PM No.507966538
>>507966335
The director was Hong Kong Chinese, the production was a collaboration between him and mainland film schools. And also Columbia pictures actually.
Anonymous ID: vnCAudCvSouth Africa
6/19/2025, 12:34:25 PM No.507966735
>>507964862 (OP)
I'm not going to look at those links, but the Chinese movies I've seen are ridiculously ahistoric. The only good thing about them is that, unlike in the West, there is no mandatory PoCs (apart from the Chinese themselves, of course) shitting up the place.
Anonymous ID: 0loTNMIxUnited States
6/19/2025, 12:34:35 PM No.507966743
>>507966482
There is precedent for this in filmmaking. Romeo and Juliet story originally took place in 16th century Italy, but Romeo + Juliet(1996) worked in spite of the fact that they were shooting guns and not swinging swords. I think you could do an Odyssey film that takes place in "modern" times with modern weapons, in fact in a lot of ways I think that is probably preferable to having niggers pretending to be ancient greeks.
Anonymous ID: dmlxkkbAUnited Kingdom
6/19/2025, 12:40:22 PM No.507967073
>>507964862 (OP)
china only ever does historical
>we wuz
stuff because they are still reeling from the raw dog fucking we gave them during the time of the opium wars followed by their own period of cultural iconoclasm and they have no imagination to develop a better culture anyway which is why all their cities are wow pretty lights bug hive soulless emulations of the west
Replies: >>507967563
Anonymous ID: FcMAFmk+Australia
6/19/2025, 12:40:53 PM No.507967104
The West has a new mythology and its called Marvel. Sorry grandpa.
Anonymous ID: o1835a3vUnited States
6/19/2025, 12:46:50 PM No.507967484
>>507965411
>I'm a little teapo-ACK!
Anonymous ID: I0Ys3SDuItaly
6/19/2025, 12:48:01 PM No.507967556
>>507964862 (OP)
Obsolete and vestigial social engineering that has been completely substituted by far more efficient products meant to provoke existential dread and demoralization.

Is another series of Peplum movies going to be useful to the state or the expansion of control for the managerial class? Fuck no.
You get one "Adolescence" and the resulting fallout and echoing psychological operations through the media alone, can make you subservient as if you were ruled by omnipotent evil wizards.
Anonymous ID: vnCAudCvSouth Africa
6/19/2025, 12:48:08 PM No.507967563
MaryQueenofScotsandNogsandChinks
MaryQueenofScotsandNogsandChinks
md5: 7436abd56cfdf00a709c8f271286aa37๐Ÿ”
>>507967073
Pretty much this.
Their garbage is still better than the absolute clown world state of Western historical movies, though.
Anonymous ID: F9J3DL8TIreland
6/19/2025, 12:50:21 PM No.507967713
>>507964862 (OP)
You know why.
Anonymous ID: artoUMWfIndia
6/19/2025, 12:52:12 PM No.507967823
>>507964862 (OP)
Maybe becouse us and uk have decent film industry west .
uk had ugly inbreds royals ruling over them for forever and only interesting thing they did was killing own family memebers in different ways and colonization which they dont wanna associated anymore .

USA dont have their own history without slaves and other horrific shit.
Also they hate european history . Thats why they play basball and rugby instead of cricket and footbal
Replies: >>507968342
Anonymous ID: mGc+HuFaUnited States
6/19/2025, 12:56:11 PM No.507968087
>>507964862 (OP)
It goes back to the Renaissance itself.

Often times in Renaissance painting they would paint ancient historical figures in contemporary dress.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%27art_pompier
Replies: >>507968902
Anonymous ID: PwuJAtsNCzech Republic
6/19/2025, 12:57:04 PM No.507968144
>>507965578
watch chinese historical series retard
Replies: >>507968534
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 1:00:05 PM No.507968342
>>507967823
>and only interesting thing they did was
Bullshit, the Tudor and Edwardian periods are easily the most dramatized periods in English history.
Replies: >>507968704
Anonymous ID: 9i6mcyYTNetherlands
6/19/2025, 1:01:27 PM No.507968426
>>507964862 (OP)
Name a medieval book with a war story like this that doesn't involve ideas right people over in real life today.
Anonymous ID: 0loTNMIxUnited States
6/19/2025, 1:03:05 PM No.507968534
>>507968144
>Watch a 52 series melodrama with terrible acting, terrible costumes, terrible action, and some of the most awful sound mixing ever displayed in a tv series.
Anonymous ID: KX5siucp
6/19/2025, 1:03:34 PM No.507968565
they don't want you to glorify your roots

pre-jewish society
Anonymous ID: 9m+S3RLaUnited States
6/19/2025, 1:04:28 PM No.507968623
>import turd world
>have to create entertainment for turd world class
all this freaking out over hollyjew diversity has been the dumbest thing
who the fuck cares about your shitty movies and tv shows? there's no directorial talent working anyways, it's all jew'd shit
Anonymous ID: 0lRz3e5B
6/19/2025, 1:04:31 PM No.507968625
>>507964862 (OP)
Because intelligent people don't spend their day playing video games and watching movies.
Anonymous ID: artoUMWfIndia
6/19/2025, 1:05:38 PM No.507968704
>>507968342
Anon but they were ruled by inbreds and dont wanna glorify any off that .
Replies: >>507968925
Anonymous ID: vnCAudCvSouth Africa
6/19/2025, 1:08:36 PM No.507968902
>>507968087
>Often times in Renaissance painting they would paint ancient historical figures in contemporary dress.

I always assumed that was simply due to historical ignorance.
There's no excuse for it nowadays. But in contemporary historical dramas, they tend to get a lot of input from historians and experts, and the costumes are the one thing they get just right. Then they flush that effort down the crapper by casting a nignog as a White historical figure, making the accuracy of the costumes seem irrelevant.

L'art pompier has little to do with this matter, btw.
Replies: >>507969113
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 1:09:00 PM No.507968925
>>507968704
They already have, there's tons of British historical dramas. The Crown is still ongoing last I checked.
Replies: >>507969891
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 1:11:40 PM No.507969113
images (71)
images (71)
md5: bf2f9908fad6f40b907c80281fe7dcc3๐Ÿ”
>>507968902
>casting a nignog as a White historical figure
True, Queen Charlotte is possibly the worst example of this.
Anonymous ID: 3zO+wmh0United Kingdom
6/19/2025, 1:16:51 PM No.507969392
>>507964862 (OP)
>wearing metal armor without any kind of covering underneath it
Actual soldiers would never. There are usually so many layers when it comes to armor, even in hot countries.
Anonymous ID: s18Aj4y+Germany
6/19/2025, 1:19:43 PM No.507969595
>>507964862 (OP)
It might invoke some sense of nationalism, unity and respect for your ancestors. Can't have that in the west.
Anonymous ID: artoUMWfIndia
6/19/2025, 1:24:24 PM No.507969891
>>507968925
It dont have wars and killing it just water downed shit
Replies: >>507970621
Anonymous ID: xO5lCb3hUnited States
6/19/2025, 1:25:22 PM No.507969940
>>507964862 (OP)
Ayooo Theseus, You finna kill dat minatoor and raise da white flag. Dis nigga Minos tryna kill our white girls.
Replies: >>507970935
Anonymous ID: Xo4ppSFFUnited States
6/19/2025, 1:33:25 PM No.507970483
>>507964862 (OP)
Because woman are involved
Anonymous ID: cUYIJ03nNew Zealand
6/19/2025, 1:35:18 PM No.507970621
>>507969891
>It dont have wars
Yes it does.
Anonymous ID: 1DS6KktxBelgium
6/19/2025, 1:37:03 PM No.507970777
>>507964862 (OP)
itโ€™s all jewish run and they hate the west and white people especially their history
Anonymous ID: vnCAudCvSouth Africa
6/19/2025, 1:39:14 PM No.507970935
>>507969940
Ayo odisius dis syclops nigga finna eat our ass *crazyass yt muhfucka*
Anonymous ID: ZI25Dnu7Australia
6/19/2025, 1:40:17 PM No.507971006
1000015572
1000015572
md5: 71b72d5f90c62b3d8723e90f44178950๐Ÿ”
>>507964862 (OP)
No nigger hoplites
Replies: >>507971798
Anonymous ID: HrxMqeEiUnited States
6/19/2025, 1:48:48 PM No.507971608
IMG_7937
IMG_7937
md5: eec848323d863464d0c498a292b08967๐Ÿ”
>>507964862 (OP)
Why reinvent the wheel when the public are just expecting the same sword and sandle show they have always watched.
Anonymous ID: vnCAudCvSouth Africa
6/19/2025, 1:51:26 PM No.507971798
1749818876582813m
1749818876582813m
md5: d8999eef314ebd36f52de79230d4a407๐Ÿ”
>>507971006
>Hiphoplites
Anonymous ID: qd8/klO5United States
6/19/2025, 1:54:52 PM No.507972047
>>507964862 (OP)
the answer is always jews
Anonymous ID: NHt8y3Qy
6/19/2025, 1:55:02 PM No.507972059
>>507964862 (OP)
"Barbarians" first season was ok. Second season was complete shit
Anonymous ID: sUWQ4VW3Canada
6/19/2025, 2:00:08 PM No.507972427
1737524633619101
1737524633619101
md5: ddce2d6bfb609c70a2af007891e0d298๐Ÿ”
>>507964862 (OP)
>Why does the west not respect it's history in movies/television

You know the answer - Because Media is controlled by the Jews who are evil and wish to destroy White history so we Goy become Nigger mutts