Is corporal punishment based? - /pol/ (#511251245) [Archived: 38 hours ago]

Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:13:45 PM No.511251245
1753381868488985_thumb.jpg
1753381868488985_thumb.jpg
md5: 4ae275c7ee4d150aee77589dd26bc9a5🔍
Pliny the Elder said back in the day:
>"The centurion's vine staff is an excellent medicine for sluggish troops who don't want to advance."
Replies: >>511251422 >>511251457 >>511252733 >>511254418 >>511254483 >>511254524 >>511255221 >>511256149
Anonymous ID: eNCMgU+ePortugal
7/24/2025, 9:16:15 PM No.511251422
>>511251245 (OP)
I don't think it is. When reason is enough you should resort to that instead.
Replies: >>511251567
Anonymous ID: Jj8zx5D6Canada
7/24/2025, 9:16:41 PM No.511251457
>>511251245 (OP)
Ya he will for sure be more useful curled up closer to the explosions...
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:18:05 PM No.511251567
1751549141904215_thumb.jpg
1751549141904215_thumb.jpg
md5: 90021e2a84223593f550d47f2d31937b🔍
>>511251422
If reason was enough, punishment and laws themselves would be unnecessary.
Replies: >>511251945 >>511257356
Anonymous ID: eNCMgU+ePortugal
7/24/2025, 9:22:35 PM No.511251945
>>511251567
Laws are reason and the examples you're posting aren't convincing.
Replies: >>511252204
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:25:33 PM No.511252204
1695668952958999_thumb.jpg
1695668952958999_thumb.jpg
md5: c86a8657bf8f4b2716898ecf8080d79c🔍
>>511251945
What would be convincting?
Replies: >>511252529
Anonymous ID: znq3tRh7United States
7/24/2025, 9:27:28 PM No.511252354
Depends on the cause of the issue.
If there was misunderstanding then corporal punishment won't make the punished understand therefore there will be no improvement.
However if the punished was lazy, rebellious, or absentminded, then corporal punishment might be effective.

Either way I'd rather take a couple of belt hits and move on with my life than be forced to endure HR bureaucratic punishment.
Replies: >>511252640
Anonymous ID: eNCMgU+ePortugal
7/24/2025, 9:29:38 PM No.511252529
>>511252204
A serial killer getting slow cooked in a pot of boiling water for example. This just seems like cringe friendly fire, if you ain't got the morale to get something done, it's probably your ape brain telling you this is a stupid idea in the first place.
Anonymous ID: B03HEoFiUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:29:47 PM No.511252543
id cap him in the face whenever i got acces to my weapon back
Replies: >>511252640 >>511253457
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:31:06 PM No.511252640
1696951004348337_thumb.jpg
1696951004348337_thumb.jpg
md5: 9600e9a17e71832c5317605146edb4e9🔍
>>511252354
This is why the punishment must be administered immediately. If a dog shits in the house and you spank it 8 months later after a long court process, it will just think you're a mean asshole. It works the same with niggers.
>>511252543
doubtful
Replies: >>511254190
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 9:32:29 PM No.511252733
>>511251245 (OP)
Life is a corporeal punishment.
Replies: >>511253448
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:34:35 PM No.511253448
1697051163740812_thumb.jpg
1697051163740812_thumb.jpg
md5: a2480e9f69023855cdd72dbbb12a7dd7🔍
>>511252733
Then we are here because we deserve it.
Replies: >>511253780
Anonymous ID: nKjCAneASlovenia
7/24/2025, 9:34:43 PM No.511253457
>>511252543
Thats just the thing. By the time you get your weapon he will be far, far away and you will be in the ditch next to other comrades just trying to survive. Thats army.
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 9:37:23 PM No.511253780
>>511253448
I'm not looking at your gay webms but you deserve to be droned.
Replies: >>511254135
Anonymous ID: l1IAaR8YRomania
7/24/2025, 9:41:53 PM No.511254091
Stop russian-on-russian violence
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:42:33 PM No.511254135
1747518493980776_thumb.jpg
1747518493980776_thumb.jpg
md5: 3069d4636e4a98bedf91581910f77cf4🔍
>>511253780
That would only end my "corporeal punishment" anon...how do you not realize that?
Replies: >>511254248
Anonymous ID: B03HEoFiUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:43:14 PM No.511254190
>>511252640
honestly, if you jist sacrificed one of your arms as a shield, you could probably just run and snatch it from him or wrestle him down and you'd be at too close of range for it to be effective
Replies: >>511255457
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 9:44:04 PM No.511254248
>>511254135
The only thing that matters in the end is how your corporeal punishment comes to a close. And yours should end like that.
Replies: >>511254322 >>511254417 >>511254515
Anonymous ID: l1IAaR8YRomania
7/24/2025, 9:45:06 PM No.511254322
>>511254248
Did not care to read your posts.
Prepare to be unified with Romania.
Thank you for your attention.
Replies: >>511254404
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 9:46:06 PM No.511254404
>>511254322
Prepare to be unified with my dong.
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:46:12 PM No.511254417
1697579952264202_thumb.jpg
1697579952264202_thumb.jpg
md5: 78811ff0525bca43cfb5e73b19d971f0🔍
>>511254248
Punishment coming to a close is a good thing retard, and why are you so angry at me?
Replies: >>511254515 >>511255923
Anonymous ID: alt0My1yNew Zealand
7/24/2025, 9:46:17 PM No.511254418
>>511251245 (OP)
It's cowardly because he knows if the guy hits back he gets court marshalled etc
Anonymous ID: h60OXkXLUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:47:02 PM No.511254483
>>511251245 (OP)
If he were based, he'd be a sergeant by now.
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 9:47:29 PM No.511254515
>>511254417
See >>511254248
Replies: >>511255056
Anonymous ID: SYMIb8pK
7/24/2025, 9:47:39 PM No.511254524
>>511251245 (OP)
Wars between governments are never about fighting enemy governments, the real enemy in the war of a government is it's own people, if the government loses the war 90% of government officials simply defect to the enemy government, sometimes even still ruling the lands they used to rule.
Anonymous ID: NuvF4W5JUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:49:01 PM No.511254629
Scrawny peasant
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:54:09 PM No.511255056
1700933693406474_thumb.jpg
1700933693406474_thumb.jpg
md5: 1b1c6f1bccee1a51bfec71a7bbffff06🔍
>>511254515
Why are you so angry at me?
Replies: >>511255307 >>511255923
Anonymous ID: 0mspDYTkUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:55:52 PM No.511255221
>>511251245 (OP)
So are these videos of who the jews want us to call the "good guys" or videos of who the jews want us to call the "bad guys"
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 9:57:02 PM No.511255307
>>511255056
I'm not angry with you. I'm just mildly disgusted with you and I think you should die in a drone strike along with other goreposting trannies.
Replies: >>511255583
Anonymous ID: lUpX0phpUnited States
7/24/2025, 9:58:38 PM No.511255457
>>511254190
Yes and that's when you get shot. The point of corporal punishment is to demonstrate you can take your lumps and get back in line. If you can't do that and turn it into a fight, you're a mutineer and you get shot.
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 10:00:05 PM No.511255583
1697576910833781_thumb.jpg
1697576910833781_thumb.jpg
md5: 9b97ed3334e8c2d4e813e5ed2c6e5d4a🔍
>>511255307
I have posted no gore at all and you're seething in Transnistria.
Replies: >>511255682
Anonymous ID: m+3hahhjMoldova
7/24/2025, 10:01:10 PM No.511255682
>>511255583
I'm not watching your gay webms but I have no doubt that you're a goreposter and likely a tranny.
Replies: >>511255979
Anonymous ID: mOr90rP4United States
7/24/2025, 10:03:57 PM No.511255923
>>511254417
>>511255056
what the fuck is wrong with you NAFO pukes, why are you so fucking insane?
Replies: >>511255979
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 10:04:27 PM No.511255979
>>511255682
>>511255923
lmao
Anonymous ID: iUno/gNOUnited Kingdom
7/24/2025, 10:06:27 PM No.511256149
>>511251245 (OP)
In theory nobody was allowed to beat Roman citizens or force them to do manual labour. These things were huge taboos.
However Romans understood army life was different and exceptions had to be made there.
Replies: >>511256740
Anonymous ID: Uj03qBHHUnited States
7/24/2025, 10:13:34 PM No.511256740
>>511256149
>In theory
The Valerian and Porcian laws had to keep being re-instituted because they simply were not followed. And by the time they were, Roman citizens had long since stopped serving in the army.
Anonymous ID: ZRZzzJxHUnited States
7/24/2025, 10:21:12 PM No.511257356
>>511251567
This is from one of those alpha male training camps
Anonymous ID: tQlpHzXsUnited States
7/24/2025, 10:37:30 PM No.511258770
17527437528711_thumb.jpg
17527437528711_thumb.jpg
md5: f3f1fb43b20d224a997f6a98b881e9c3🔍
Do you think his dog will miss him? :(