>>16764861 (OP)
Disregarding the religious aspect and just addressing the meme format in general:
Hyper fixation on rigor and nuance is just what people do when they are new to a topic. They are just now getting introduced to the complexities of the field and so good form takes priority over function.
Someone who has no knowledge of the field will point out the obvious, simple, conclusions that might seem "wrong" to a layman who's just having his intuitions challenged and has been trained to pull up a system if equations he has yet to fully grasp.
Someone who is properly familiarized with the field will know when to set the autistic rigor and formality aside in the face of an obvious, simple conclusion.