Anyone else have a craft they REALLY like aesthetically, but hate their gameplay?
For me it's forestcraft.
When I was initially starting out in shadoba way back in the day Selwyn was a leader you could get for I think 1000 gold and I loved his looks.

Unfortunately forest never really clicked with me.
I hate the combo mechanic and the little fairies are lame. Old art especially so.
It just never lived up to the fantasy for me.

I wish forest was more along the lines of runecraft with kill orders and whatnot, makes a lot of sense for the hunter to be prepared too. Dirt is kinda like scavenging in a way.
On the flipside there was Mordekai too who was everything I expected him to be and then some. Stuck with me for many years.

What is your disappointment?